AN IMPORTANT QUESTION

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 19, 1898

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 16.

Read the full edition

AN IMPORTANT QUESTION.

A BROTHER has sent us, for examination and review, a little pamphlet of twenty-five pages, entitled, “Are We Keeping the Right Sabbath?” This is an important question; for if God has given us a Sabbath, and the institution is confined to a particular day, it is important to know just what day that is, and keep that identical day; for God will not accept any man-devised substitute for his own arrangement. But if we are keeping the Sabbath at all, we are keeping the right one; for not to keep the right day is not to keep the Sabbath. The real question, therefore, is, Are we keeping the Sabbath?
The title-page of the pamphlet continues: “The Question Answered, by Rev. Wm. Cope.” But why does Mr. Cope take it upon himself to answer the question, when the Bible, the only competent authority to appeal to, has answered it so fully and explicitly? We have only to turn to its testimony; and when we appeal to its pages, we find clearly set forth these great facts: There is but one weekly Sabbath brought to view in the Bible. That was made in Eden, before sin entered the world, and was set apart for man. Mark 2: 27. It was made upon the first seventh day of time. The second seventh day was man’s first Sabbath.
Thus the week was established, and the right Sabbath designated. It was the seventh day of the week; for there was no other established period of time, except the day, then in existence. The week thus established has never fallen into confusion, nor been lost. There have been two great epochs in human history when it was recognized, and shown to be identical with the week of creation. One was when God spoke his law from Sinai, declaring his Sabbath, and fixing it to the seventh day, as in the beginning. The second was at the time when Christ was upon earth, who recognized the same week, and the Sabbath as the seventh day of that week.
The week of the New Testament was identically the same as the week of the present time. There has been no break nor confusion in this matter from that day to this. Therefore he who is keeping the seventh day is keeping the right Sabbath; and he who is keeping any other day is not keeping the Sabbath at all. So simple is this important question, and thus plainly is it answered by the unequivocal testimony of the Scriptures. But Mr. Cope undertakes to give a different answer; and there is where his trouble comes in.
We noticed last week the false claim, so often set up in these days, that the ten commandments, of which the Sabbath commandment is one, constituted the old covenant, and has been done away. This view is vehemently urged by Mr. Cope in the pamphlet before us; and he also, like the writer reviewed last week, totally ignores the distinction between the moral and ceremonial laws, putting, in many passages, the moral law in place of the ceremonial, and the ceremonial in place of the moral. Thus he reduces the plain testimony of the Scriptures to a tissue of falsehoods and confusion.
The proposition that the ten commandments have been abolished seems to appear, even to Mr. Cope himself, too outrageous a proposition to pass unchallenged; so he feels called upon to explain, as follows: “When I say the ten commandments were abolished, I mean to be understood they were abolished as the covenant between God and his people.” But since from the days of Adam until now they have never been such a covenant, they could not be abolished as such, and certainly in no other sense. The original obligation upon Adam was, Obey and live; but since the introduction of the plan of redemption, through Christ, the condition has been, Believe and live. And this shows in what sense only the ten commandments are ever called a covenant; for God can enter into no engagement to confer favors or blessings upon any man except on the condition, that he will obey him by keeping his commandments. He cannot bless disobedience, as that would be to bless sin, and put the seal of his approbation upon unrighteousness.
That the ten commandments ever constituted the first, or old, covenant, which has been done away, is in direct contradiction of the Scriptures, and as far from the truth as can be. Heaven and earth have not yet passed away, but until they do, on the express declaration of Christ, not one tittle of that law of which the Sabbath is a part can pass away. This is not saying that it will pass away then; but it places a limit this side of which every one ought to have enough regard for truth to know that the ten commandments cannot be abolished, or even changed in the least particular.
But, it may be asked, were not the ten commandments incorporated into the civil polity of the Jews, in which the penalty of death was attached to their violation? and has not that all been done away? To which the reply is at hand that whatever system the principles of the ten commandments may have been incorporated into, the abrogation of that system would not affect the ten commandments as such. They are to be contemplated apart, and by themselves, as God’s universal rule of moral conduct among men; and to speak of them as having been abolished is blasphemous. Think of God’s withdrawing from the world his prohibitions against idolatry, blasphemy, murder, lying, stealing, and adultery! Only the darkest moral obliquity could harbor the thought for a moment.
A few of Mr. Cope’s particular declarations, which he strangely offers for arguments, must be deferred to another paper. U. S.