The relation of the law and the gospel is a subject that has been very much discussed, and very much misunderstood. By some they are regarded as being so incompatible as not to be able to exist together. These think the gospel to be an antidote for the law, neutralizing it by its action and releasing all who receive it from any obligation to the law. It must be admitted by all that both proceed from the same Source. The Author of the law laid the plan of the gospel; and how a perfect being could produce in one age a set of principles to be destroyed by another set of principles introduced at another time, has never been made clear. Indeed, such a thing could not be.
We believe the relation between the law and the gospel to be much closer than is generally supposed, even by those who acknowledge the divine authenticity and office of each. Not only are they intended to work the same purpose in bringing men to a knowledge of God, but they are inseparable and to a great extent identical. The most important object in existence, next to God, is the will of God. This will is expressed in the laws he has established. The most important consideration in connection with the will of God is to have it regarded and obeyed by his creatures. The gospel consists of those provisions made by infinite goodness, by which men are assisted in their efforts and desires to be conformed to the will of God.
This being so, it is evident that the gospel must embrace all the will of God as its fundamental consideration. The Saviour came into the world proclaiming, “I delight to do thy will, O my God: yea, thy law is within my heart.” And every effort of his life was to carry out that will, and establish it in the hearts and lives of men.
With wonderful love and wisdom and patience God has sought to teach his will to mankind, and to induce as many as possible to accept it. But the tendency of the human mind has been in a contrary direction. As a race, we have been fools and slow of heart to receive what God has sent us. But with patient and persistent compassion God has never abandoned his purpose of saving all whom a God of infinite grace and mercy could save.
The ten commandments, which in the most concise form set forth the great principles of the divine will, are for the most part given in negative form. “Thou shalt not,” is the most rudimental form of instruction. Parents begin with their children by telling them what they must not do. By wise management this same power that at first restrains from wrong, becomes a power impelling the child to do well. It is love all the time. It is the work of love to awaken and incite love. Back of every restraint that love imposes, there is an impulse of loving devotion; and the ultimate and grand object of the restraint is to arouse the impulse. Unless this object be gained, the real end, obedience, is lost. He who goes no farther in obeying God than simply to heed the “thou shalt not,” gains no more than the merest rudiments of morality. Obedience in the highest sense consists not in refraining from an evil act, but in the performance of a good one. Over against every vice is a corresponding virtue. To refrain from the vice is the smallest part of morality, the full measure of which requires nothing less than the full practise of the virtue.
Consequently the actual force of the ten commandments is a positive rather than a negative one, and this fact is stated by our Saviour when he said that on the two commandments, “Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart,” and, “Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself,” hung all the law. It might not at first glance appear absolutely necessary that, in order to refrain from injury to our neighbor, we must love him; but such is the case.
Take one of the commandments, for instance the eighth. Stealing is to deprive another of that which belongs to him, without rendering an equivalent, and embraces various forms of dishonesty. To deprive our neighbor of one of his rights, either of property, reputation, or any other right, is to steal from him. The only way to avoid depriving him of his rights is to give to him his rights. His rights are equal to our rights. Therefore, in order to obey the eighth commandment, it is necessary for us to love our neighbor as ourselves. The same method of exegesis will apply to each of the commandments. He that hates his brother, violates the sixth commandment; he is a murderer. Not only so, indifference is murder also. He who could deliver his neighbor from a calamity and fails to do so, is morally responsible for the calamity. Love is a positive principle. It is not passive; it does not content itself with having nothing against its object; it always has something for it. Indifference would permit the whole world to perish. Indifference asks, “Am I my brother’s keeper?” Indifference, we repeat, is murder. Hence nothing short of love to our neighbor will enable us to keep the sixth commandment. In those commandments, and beneath them as their eternal foundation, is the great principle of love. Love is also the essential element of the gospel.
But all men are not lovable. Some will not reciprocate love and goodness. Some men are unkind and untrue; yet they are our neighbors, and we should love them. The commandments do not say, Thou shalt not steal from the good, Thou shalt not kill thy friends; but they do say, “Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself,” and that means all classes. But to love our enemies; to be patient and meek with those who misuse us; to be forgiving and compassionatep. 473 toward those who would injure us, is more than human. Such a spirit is only from above. It is the spirit of Christ. It is the sum and substance of the gospel. It is also the end, or object, of the law. No one can obey the law of God without the spirit of Christ; for the spirit of Christ is perfect obedience to the law of God, and the spirit of Christ is the genius of the gospel.
What, then, is the relation which the law and the gospel sustain to each other? Is it not evident that they both proceed from the same Source? that they have the same object? and that they embrace precisely the same principles? When we speak of the gospel distinctively, we perhaps have in mind special reference to the system of divine grace; but the purpose of that grace is to assist men to conform to the will of God; or, in other words, to become spiritually and perfectly obedient to the law of God. It presents to every man the perfect will of God, and all the help he needs to obey that will. The law of God itself embraces nothing less than that; for God never placed a requirement upon his children without providing all the help necessary to enable them to observe that requirement; so that the gospel of divine grace is a necessary part of the law of God, and the law of God forms the basis of the gospel system.
Why, then, spend our time in drawing vain distinctions between two things which are the very counterpart of each other, which exist for each other, and neither of which could be complete without the other? Vain are all attempts to contrast the two, and worse than vain are all efforts to array them in antagonism.
G. C. T.