AdventAI

WILL THEY UNITE?

From Review and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 30., July 28, 1896

The late appeal of the pope to the Eastern Church for reunion has brought forth a very vigorous reply from the prelates of that church, in which they reject all the overtures of the pope and of the Latin Church for union. They accuse the pope and his church of going away from the true church, and of setting up standards of their own. The Eastern Church certainly has the best of the argument upon this point. There were several centuries when the bishops of Rome possessed no more authority than did the bishops of the other metropolitan cities of the Roman empire. The division of the Roman empire, and some other causes, opened the way for the bishop of Rome to become the head of the churches in the West, and as the West for some centuries has been the growing part of the world, it has gained a great following. But the East is beginning to feel a new life, and the Eastern Church is apparently much stronger than it has been before for centuries and it is as bitterly opposed as ever against a union with, which would mean a surrender to, its historic enemy, the Latin Church, and its self-assertive head and representative the pope.

Of more interest to us, however, is the action of the Church of England in regard to reunion. There is no doubt that there is a small faction of that church which would enjoy a reunion with Rome. Like many other small factions, it makes so great an outcry that its size and importance is much overestimated. A few crickets in a field will make more noise than a whole herd of cattle; but the cattle will not vacate the field on account of the crickets. So the English Church feels in regard to the faction that desires to unite with Rome. Probably no one is better prepared to speak for that church upon this point than the archbishop of York. He has lately made the following declaration before the synod of his diocese upon this subject. This statement is so important that it cannot fail to interest the readers of the REVIEW. If he has any authority to speak for his church, and no one can dispute that he has, the gulf between the English Church and Rome is still very wide:—

In speaking to you of the church, its office, its work, and its needs, you will not be surprised if, before I close, I make response to a letter—another letter—from the head of the Roman Church, published a few days ago, and addressed, apparently, to the whole of Christendom. No one can fail to recognize in it the loving spirit and unfailing courage which are characteristic of the eminent prelate from whom it comes; but, none the less, it is impossible for English churchmen not to see how it mingles truths universally accepted with claims which must be disallowed.

We, too, believe most truly in the unity of the church. We, too, may share the earnest longing of the pope that this underlying unity may, in God’s good time, be made manifest in a more visible union. If such a blessed end could be obtained without the sacrifice of truth or the acceptance of error, the words of the Master himself would leave us without excuse if such a desire did not find a place in our hearts and in our prayers; but when this union is represented to us as a union not only with our blessed Lord and with one another, but as a union with Peter, and, still more, with the successors of Peter, or, in plain terms, an unquestioned submission to the Roman pontiff, we are bound to reject a claim so entirely unsupported by the teaching of Holy Scripture or by the voice of the universal church.

Until we are, per impossibile, convinced that St. Peter himself held this position of supreme authority; still more, that such a position and such authority were transmitted to those who followed him in his office, whatever that office may have been,—until it has been proved to us that the bishops of Rome do hold, and have held, this position and authority by the direct appointment of our blessed Lord himself, it is impossible that on any terms we can acknowledge such a claim or yield ourselves to this obedience. There can be but one answer to such a demand.

Nor is our difficulty less as regards the unity of the faith. If the faith be that which, once for all, was delivered to the saints, the faith contained in the Holy Scriptures and in the creeds of the undivided church, we are already at one alike with the Church of Rome and the churches of the East. But if by the faith is meant the acceptance of doctrines which have accumulated during successive centuries, or the decisions of councils in no way ecumenical, or the utterances of individual popes by no means infallible; if this faith is to include such worship of the ever-blessed mother of our Lord as is bound in devotional manuals sanctioned and recommended by the authorities of the Roman Church; if it is to include the doctrine of indulgences, whatever that may practically mean, or that Romish doctrine of purgatory which our church condemns as the perverted substitute for the true idea of the intermediate state,—then, indeed, in loyalty to our Master, we must decline to take this yoke upon us, or to yield our assent to what our church has rightfully characterized as fond things vainly invented, and repugnant to the word of God.

The pope will not be surprised, and still less can he be offended, if, on matters of such vital importance, we speak with the same courage and faithfulness that he himself has shown. It is difficult, indeed, for us to understand how intelligent and godly men can accept such doctrines and uphold such usages. But large allowance must be made for those who have inherited such beliefs through a long course of centuries, and have been familiar with them from their earliest years.

We may humbly trust that better things are yet in store for a church which has occupied so prominent a position in the history of Christendom, and has done so much to extend the knowledge of Christ to the distant ends of the earth. The appeal to history, with its ever-growing influence upon the intelligence of mankind; the study of the Holy Scriptures, so strongly encouraged by the present pope; the increasing interest in theology on the part of the layman as well as the priest; the general spread of knowledge, and the extension of religious education—all these are full of hope and promise for the welfare of the church of Christ in all its branches, and for the gradual gathering together of the children of God.

In such a hope we may gladly unite our prayers with those of the pope and his people for the final reunion of Christendom. We may well believe that these prayers will not be in vain. In ways which we little expect, and under conditions which we and he alike might believe to be impossible, there may come to us, in the providence of God, the fulfilment of our common desire and prayer. The words of our Lord have not lost their truth or their power. “The things which are impossible with men are possible with God.” For such consummation we may devoutly and earnestly pray.

It may not be amiss for us to consider for a moment how matters now stand. It is the merest newspaper gossip to say that any overtures have been made on the part of the Church of England to the See of Rome. Whatever overtures have been made have come from Rome itself, in the form of such encyclical letters as that which was published a few days ago—letters prompted by a motive with which all may sympathize, and written in a spirit which all must admire, but burdened with conditions impossible of acceptance by those who are blessed with spiritual freedom, and have been brought out of error into the clear light and knowledge of the truth.

There is something almost pathetic in the thought of the aged and venerable prelate’s issuing from time to time these persuasive appeals to East and to West, to be met only by renewed rejection or by significant silence.

Nor is it more true that there has been any application to the pope from the side of the Church of England, with a view to obtain the recognition of our own position in the church of Christ. The inquiry now being held respecting our Anglican orders owes its first impulse to the writings of Roman Catholics themselves. On our own part there is not, and never has been, a shadow of doubt; nor should we be one whit the better, or one whit the worse, as regards our holy orders, whatever the opinion of the Church of Rome might be. It is true that it might greatly affect the prospect of Christian reunion, but it is this, and this alone, which gives to the question its interest and importance.