AdventAI

ANOTHER REBUKE.

By T.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 51., December 17, 1895

The Argument Summed Up.— Two weeks ago there was an article in this department concerning the rebuke of M. O’Keefe, a Catholic priest of Maryland, for the action of a ministerial association that sought to enlist him in a movement for enforcing Sunday laws. A reply to this rebuke appeared in the Baltimore Methodist, and this was followed by a rejoinder in the Catholic Mirror. We do not indorse the style of Mr. O’Keefe, though the inconsistent course of the ministers exposes them to ridicule and invective according to the human standard. But the Saviour has taught us not to deal thus with those who hate us or despitefully use us.

But Mr. O’Keefe pokes the unwelcome truth of their real situation at them in a very uncomfortable way. He thus replies to their answer to his arguments:—

“Putting your argument and mine in the form of a colloquy as above, I beg leave to formulate it for the benefit of my readers. Addressing myself to the Rev. Messrs. Heisse, Cassard, and Guthrie, I invite their attention thus:—

“‘Rev. Sirs: Your teacher, the Bible, which you hold to be inspired, and which you cherish with great apparent reverence, is most explicit in requiring the Sabbath (Saturday) to be kept holy; but I find you flatly contradicting your teacher in practice, and keeping another day nowhere referred to “to be kept holy;” viz., Sunday.’

“‘Answer delivered by Rev. Mr. Heisse, spokesman for the trinity: “Mr. O’Keefe, I find you laboring under much poverty of thought; ergo, the Sunday, not Saturday, is our day.”’

“‘But, gentlemen, let me direct your attention to the consistent course pursued by the Jewish race relative to this question. The Hebrews, from the days of Moses to this Saturday, have ever kept the Saturday, instructed by the same teacher, the Bible, as yourselves.’

“‘Answer: “Mr. O’Keefe, your “absurdity of logic” is intolerable; ergo, our Sabbath is Sunday.”’

“‘But, gentlemen, your Redeemer and his apostles kept the Saturday, and no other day, as your New Testament teaches from Matthew to Revelation.’

“‘It matters not, Mr. O’Keefe, what arguments you advance for Saturday; your redundancy of language and limitless display of egotism are utterly abhorrent to us; ergo, we keep Sunday.’

“‘Let me, Rev. Sirs, remonstrate still further: are you not aware that you have, by keeping Sunday, apostatized from the uniform and consistent teachings of your own and only avowed and cherished teacher, the Bible, and enrolled yourselves beneath the polluted banner of “the scarlet lady”—the mother of abominations?’

“‘Answer: “Mr. O’Keefe, our spokesman, Rev. Mr. Heisse, has well said of you, “He has our sympathy because of his intense blindness in moral perceptions, and his amazing lack of sound judgment on the leading questions of the hour;” ergo, we are prepared to acknowledge our indebtedness to the Church of Rome by keeping her day, Sunday, the earnest remonstrances of the Old and New Testaments to the contrary notwithstanding.”’

The Facts Restated.— The gentlemen in controversy with Mr. O’Keefe presented a more favorable letter from another priest, the authenticity of which O’Keefe questions. That letter said: “I hope you gentlemen cannot succeed in inducing all non-Catholics throughout this country to change Saturday into Sunday. We Catholics in that event must eventually have the worst of the mix-up.”

To this remark Mr. O’Keefe replies:—

“What living Catholic priest is there who does not know that Protestantism has, contrary to its fundamental principles, abandoned its sole acknowledged teacher, the Bible, on the Sabbath question, and, guilty of a double apostasy, gone over, bag and baggage, to the teaching and practice of the Catholic Church? In putting the question I must make honorable exception. I refer to the Seventh-day Adventists. They are the only consistent Protestants on earth. They follow the teachings of their Bible by keeping the Sabbath enjoined by God and their acknowledged guide, only to be fined, punished, and imprisoned by their fellow-Protestants even in the State of Maryland, for their consistency, while their persecutors have shamefully abandoned the very principles for which they punish them. And what would your bogus priest recommend, Rev. Sir?—Remain wallowing in the mire of a double apostasy!”

It is with no spirit of exultation that we would call attention to these statements. We hold no common ground with Catholics on the question; and as before stated, we disown the style and language in which much of the article is couched. But the facts alluded to are obvious, and ought to have great weight with Protestants. We do not make any plea for Seventh-day Adventists. There is no credit to be given to us; but why will not our fellow-Protestants see the inconsistency of their course, and stand for the defense of the truth rather than rush to its persecution?

T.