AdventAI

THE “REVEREND” JOHN ALEXANDER DOWIE.

By F. A. Buzzell

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 49., December 3, 1895

BY F. A. BUZZELL.

(Chicago, Ill.)

On Sunday, Nov. 10, the Chicago Auditorium was again filled to its utmost seating capacity by a fine audience, to see, hear, and testify for “Dr. Dowie.” On that occasion thousands stood up in the vast audience at the request of Mr. Dowie, as witnesses that they knew that God had answered their prayers. A multitude of these, by request, remained standing for a moment or two, as witnesses to the answer of prayer in healing them. After they were seated, the doctor called upon many on the platform and in the audience to corroborate his statements, which they did, that they had, in the most providential and miraculous manner, been raised from a dying condition, and cured of terrible and malignant diseases through the prayers of Dr. Dowie. Many of these had been healed when they were at a distance from him.

That such immense audiences assemble to hear this man, that so many have been healed through him, and that the Auditorium is engaged for six months at a cost of $300 for one service, is remarkable; and when we consider the scriptures which describe the events of the days in which we are living, and consider the nature of these manifestations through Dr. Dowie and others, is it not as significant as remarkable? Probably many attend these meetings from curiosity, and because of the notoriety he obtained last summer through the action of some of the city officials who advertised him by persecution. However, he has an immense following of those who claim to have been healed and their friends. From whence is the power for these works of Dr. Dowie? The solution of this problem is perhaps upon the shoulders of Seventh-day Adventists as upon no others. Some believe in these works of Dowie, as from Heaven; others do not. They cannot be tested by the nature of the healing, neither by the fact of the healing, nor by the avowal that they are of Christ. Schlatter is healing, and if, as reported, he claims to be the Messiah, his healing is not of God.

Is there safety in passing judgment on Dr. Dowie's work from the instruction of Isaiah? “To the law and to the testimony; if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.” Placed with other New Testament scriptures, does it not form a correct criterion? There can be no certainty as to these manifestations as they rapidly and numerously appear, whether the gift is of heavenly origin or not, but through the character and spirit manifested by the medium of the power of healing.

The subject of this article gave an excellent opportunity, Sunday, Nov. 10, to learn of his religious standing and spirit. His discourse was to prove that Colonel Ingersoll’s theory that “God does not answer prayer,” is false. Dowie touched on the colonel’s “Foundations of Faith” theory, but the most of his discourse was to prove that Ingersoll was “a liar” when he said that God does not hear prayer. Dr. Dowie preluded his discourse with allusions to those city officials who, he said, were “led of the Devil” to persecute him. His language in reference to them was not the language of a Christian martyr, scripturally or historically considered. But he exemplified his spirit in its true light in his undertaking to deal with the Bible to dethrone Mr. Ingersoll. In trying to disarm him, he placed an armory at his disposal.p. 772 King David seemed to be very much in the speaker’s way. He said he had “no use for David, anyway.” He said that the prophet “ought to have been hanged,” although he did “not believe in hanging.” It is not necessary to repeat all that he said of David; some of it was not fit for print. Mr. Ingersoll himself would not offend an audience with allusions which Dowie made to the acts of David, which were wholly unnecessary to his subject or in any other place. There seemed to be a bitter, exulting spirit with the doctor while he dealt out blow after blow in his tirade against David, and he repeated and emphasized his words in a particularly unchristian manner; and tone and gesture were in keeping with it. There was not a word of extenuation for David as to his repentance. The Old Testament was of the past, and we did “not need it now;” but Mr. Dowie took the ten commandments along down into New Testament time, and “re-enacted them.” (This indicates that the true Sabbath has been in his way.)

In consideration of these incidents of Dowie’s work, can we bid him Godspeed? May we not expect that where the Lord works, there will be a manifestation of the Spirit of Christ and an agreement with the Bible, and not a disavowal of a part of it? I attended the meeting referred to, unprejudiced. I listened intently to get an understanding of the man. I came away enlightened. I believe that if we keep our ears and eyes open, and our understanding illuminated by the word of God, we need not walk in darkness as to the miraculous.