BY ELDER W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
SOMETHING over twenty years ago, the author of this communication published in the REVIEW AND HERALD a series of articles on the parable of the rich man and Lazarus. In those articles he took the position that the parable in question was employed by the Saviour as an argumentum ad hominem to the Pharisees, whose peculiar views respecting the state of the dead were exactly set forth therein. An argumentum ad hominem is an argument based upon the conviction of the one to whom it is addressed, and does not necessarily express the conviction of the one by whom it is employed. To be brief, the writer argued that, according to the connection, Christ had come into collision with the Pharisees, who were covetous, on the question of the uses and the abuses of riches. The Pharisees, as is well known and as the connection proves, esteemed riches very highly. Luke 16 : 13–15. They even went so far as to teach that the possession of riches furnished a presumption of the divine favor, while poverty was an indication of the divine wrath.
To disprove the soundness of this theory, the Master employed the parable of the rich man and Lazarus, in which the rich man was represented as lifting up his eyes in hell after death, while the beggar went direct to the bosom of Abraham, or the place of the blessed. Luke 16 : 19–31. The reader will observe that if the parable which Christ employed was correctly framed, and expressed a condition of things which either had been realized in the past or might possibly be realized in the future, the Pharisaic idea of riches must have been unsound; since, otherwise, it would have been impossible for a rich man to be lost or for a beggar to be saved. The Pharisees evidently saw the point of Christ’s argument, and were so completely dumbfounded that they made no reply, a fact which proves that the parable employed by Christ expressed nothing which was not in harmony with their views of the state of the dead. Had there been anything in the statements of the parable contrary to their conceptions of the facts, they would immediately have seized upon such a point, and with it parried the thrusts which Christ had made at their conception of riches. Their failure to do so furnished prima facie evidence that they were completely paralyzed by the logic of Christ. They believed in Abraham’s bosom, in hell, and in the gulf, and they dared not deny that a rich man could be lost and a beggar be saved, so they were completely silenced.
In the articles in question, as before indicated, the writer repudiated the theory that the parable of the rich man and Lazarus was either true as a matter of history or that there ever were in the bowels of this earth such places as Abraham’s bosom and hell, separated only by a gulf, one being the abode of the blessed and the other that of the damned spirits. To justify the Saviour in using a parable whose teachings were in many respects unsound, the writer argued that such a course on his part was admissible; since, by the law of parables, it was not required that all of their auxiliary statements should be historically or theoretically correct; and since, as the parable of the rich man and Lazarus did exactly express the views of the Pharisees, it was perfectly legitimate for Christ to use it against the latter, showing that they had stultified themselves by holding and teaching certain views which contradicted each other.
Since the appearance in the REVIEW of the articles mentioned, the theory there advocated, though entirely new at that time, has been slowly but steadily coming into favor. Of its ultimate triumph, there can be but little, if any, doubt. The only thing necessary at any time to make its success assured, has been conclusive evidencep. 435 that the Pharisees did actually hold to the views set forth in the parable. On that point, the essay of Josephus on “Hades,” it would seem, should satisfy the most fastidious. Fortunately, however, the writer has recently come into possession of facts going to show, not only that the Pharisees believed in the doctrines set forth in the parable of the rich man and Lazarus, but also that the parable was one which they had constructed for themselves, and did not, in any sense, originate with Christ. The intelligent reader needs not to be informed that the Babylonian Talmud contained a collection of wise sayings, comments, parables, etc., etc., which had been handed down for centuries by tradition, and which were finally recorded for convenience and security in the Talmud mentioned above.
Dr. Daniel Whitby, of England, more than two hundred years ago, when discussing the nature of the parable of the rich man and Lazarus, made the following remarks: “There was a rich man, etc. That this is only a parable, and not a real history of what was actually done, is evident, (1) Because we find this very parable in the Gemara Babylonicum, whence it is cited by Mr. Sherringham in his Joma.”—Whitby’s Commentary on Luke 16 : 19.
Dr. Lightfoot, who is high authority on all questions relating to rabbinical lore, is referred to on this question by Doddridge in the following manner: “Dr. Lightfoot and others have shown that the Jews in their Gemara have a parable much to the same purpose.” (Doddridge as quoted in Emphatic Diaglott in note on Luke 16 : 19.)
It is difficult to see how additional testimony could be required in support of the proposition that the parable of the rich man and Lazarus was employed by Christ against the Pharisees as an argumentum ad hominem. That it was so employed must be true for the following reasons: (1) The parable could not have been true historically speaking; since, according to the Scriptures, the dead are unconscious (Eccl. 9 : 5; Ps. 146 : 3); and (2) Since it is ridiculously absurd to suppose, that, as the parable teaches, the spirits of the dead are confined in the center of this earth; either in a place of torment, styled “hell,” or in a place of blessedness known as “Abraham’s bosom;” (3) Inasmuch as the parable did exactly set forth the views of the Pharisees concerning the state of the dead, and inasmuch as it was perfectly legitimate for Christ to confound his opponents by turning against them their own weapons, it is fair to presume that on this, as on other occasions, he did resort to the argumentum ad hominem (Matt. 12 : 27; Luke 14 : 5); (4) When, as by the quotations given above, it has been rendered certain that the parable of the rich man and Lazarus was current among the Pharisees, it is certain that the Saviour quoted the parable as he did, not for the purpose of indorsing these absurd utterances, but for the purpose of confounding the men, who, while employing such a parable, could at the same time be guilty of contradicting its most manifest teachings by placing upon riches an estimation, which, if justifiable, would prove that the salvation of the beggar was impossible, and the damnation of the rich man out of the question; inasmuch as the possession of riches on his part furnished a credential of the divine favor.
Here this article must close. Adopt the view of the parable of the rich man and Lazarus which it advocates, and the use of that parable by the Saviour in the manner in which he did use it, is perfectly justifiable. Reject the view herein advocated, and you make the Lord Jesus responsible for the wild vagaries of a Pharisaic conception which was constructed out of the myths and fogs of a pagan theology, the materials of which had been gathered largely during the time of the Babylonian captivity.