AdventAI

THE HEAD OF THE CHURCH; IS IT CHRIST OR PETER?

By G. B. Thompson

From Review and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 28., July 9, 1895

BY ELDER G. B. THOMPSON.

(East London, South Africa.)

THE church is represented in the Scriptures as a body. Being a body, it must necessarily have a head. The same Bible which informs us that the church is a body, tells us that it is Christ’s body (Eph. 1:22, 23), and that he is its head. “For the husband is the head of the wife, even as Christ is the head of the church.” Chapter 5:23. “And he [Christ] is the head of the body, the church.” Col. 1:18. He is its foundation (1 Cor. 3:11) and “chief corner-stone.” Eph. 2:20. This is clear and easily understood. Opposed to this is antichrist,—that huge system of corruption and darkness, the papal hierarchy; that power which conducts the worship of the living God in a dead language; that claims that the true head of the church sits in the Vatican in Italy, and is called “His Holiness Leo XIII.” They maintain that this headship was derived in regular succession from the apostle Peter, who, they say, was the first pope.

This claim we wish to notice, not by investigating the scriptures on which they base this blasphemous dogma, but by calling attention to a few scriptures concerning Peter, which will demonstrate that he was not an infallible pope:—

1. Christ being the Scriptural head of the church, should they demonstrate Peter and his so-called successors to be another head, it would make the church of God a monstrosity—a thing having two heads and one body.

2. The church being the body of Christ, if the “Immortal Leo XIII.” is its present head, we have a divine body with a human head, which is quite a shocking though necessary conclusion.

3. “But,” say they, “Christ gave to Peter the keys of the kingdom.” Well, suppose he did? Where is the evidence which proves that this constituted him a pope, or that he retained these keys all his life, and then transmitted them to a second, and a second to a third, and so on, until Joachim Pecci, the present incumbent of the infallible chair, has them? At one time there were three contemporary popes. How was it ascertained which of them had the keys? We read nothing in the book of Acts concerning the keys, nor yet in the epistles of Peter. And it is worthy of remark that while Peter wrote his second epistle to put Christians in “remembrance” (chapter 3:1), he does not remind them that he has the keys, and is able to open and shut heaven at will, or that he was a pope. He took no such title as “Holy Father.” He simply said, I “am also an elder.” 1 Peter 5:1.

4. We learn from the record in Matthew that the disciples were all present when Jesus said to Peter, “Thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church.” But neither Peter nor any of the rest got the idea from this language that any supremacy was bestowed upon Peter; for up to the very night in which Jesus was betrayed, we find that there was a “strife among them, which of them should be accounted the greatest.” Luke 22:24. We read also that Peter, with nine other of the disciples, was “moved with indignation” against James and John because they had been able to present their request first for the highest places in the kingdom. Matt. 20:24. Had Peter understood that he was already appointed the corrector of heretics and “head of all the holy churches,” he would not have been worked up concerning the matter, seeing it was already settled in his favor.

5. The Romish Church is consistent in recognizing that the head of the church must possess infallibility. This dogma it claims for the self-constituted vicegerent of Christ, and, like the papal succession, it must have been handed down from the days of Peter. But was Peter infallible? How about the time when he said, “If I should die with thee, I will not deny thee in any wise”? Mark 14:31. Was he not mistaken?—Most assuredly. But infallibility admits of no mistakes. And was he infallible when “he began to curse and to swear, saying, I know not this man of whom ye speak”? And all this, mark you, occurred after the language recorded in Matt. 16:18.

6. Then if Peter was infallible, why did he not speak ex cathedra and settle the matter in dispute at the council in Jerusalem (Acts 15), instead of allowing them to debate the question in the presence of his infallibility? But he did not. He simply related his experience like the rest. And, furthermore, James seems to have been in the chair on this occasion; for he said, “Wherefore my sentence is,” etc. Verse 19. This would be very unparliamentary, to say the least, if Peter was the head. Imagine a priest presiding over a council where “His Holiness the pope” was present!

7. Again: Paul says concerning Peter, “I withstood him to the face, because he was to be blamed.” Gal. 2:11. Such conduct on the part of Paul would have been very unbecoming had he regarded Peter as infallible; for this attribute carries with it blamelessness. Should any functionary within the pale of the Catholic Church to-day withstand the so-called successor of Peter “to his face,” “His Holiness” would be so infuriated that the offender could never obtain absolution for his sin except by kneeling and kissing the old man’s toe, and begging like a serf for his forgiveness. A failure to do this would cost him his cowl. But Peter, after he was “withstood” to the face, speaks of Paul as his “beloved brother.” 2 Peter 3:15.

8. The apostle Peter did not claim the blasphemous prerogative of being able to forgive sins. When Simon Magus sinned, Peter said,p. 436 “Repent therefore of this thy wickedness; and pray God, if perhaps the thought of thine heart may be forgiven thee.” Acts 8:22. The “Holy Father” would have said, “I absolve thee,” imposing upon him a penance of some extra paternosters, abstinence from flesh meat for a time, or something of the kind.

9. Again: the papal church, directed by its infallible(?) head, teaches and practices the doctrine of the celibacy of the priests. But why so if St. Peter was the first pope, and they are his successors? The Scriptures teach us that Peter had a wife (Mark 1:30) who traveled with him. 1 Cor. 9:5. It would seem very peculiar, to say the least, to see the pope or any of his cardinals, archbishops, or priests traveling about with their wives. But why not, if the first pope did?

10. Again we ask, If Peter was the first pope, why are his epistles interdicted? why are they forbidden to be read by the people? why are the people not exhorted to read and study them if they are encyclicals of the first pope? No Catholics are forbidden to read the encyclicals of the “Immortal (?) Leo.” Are not the letters written by the so-called first pope, and addressed to “the strangers scattered throughout Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia, and Bithynia” (1 Peter 1:1), and “to them that have obtained like precious faith with us through the righteousness of God and our Saviour Jesus Christ” (2 Peter 1:1), of equal importance with an encyclical of Joachim Pecci, addressed, “To our venerable brethren, the archbishops and bishops of the United States of North America”? And why proscribe the one, and sanction the other? How clear it is that Peter was not a pope, on whom was built the church. He was only an erring, finite mortal, depending for salvation on faith in Jesus Christ. He was a part of the church which Jesus “loved” and “gave himself for.” He was not the foundation, but was himself built upon the foundation, which is Christ. “For other foundation can no man lay than that is laid, which is Jesus Christ.” 1 Cor. 3:11. He is both the foundation and the head, and we are “rooted and grounded” in him.