THE test made on May 19, at the government proving-ground at Indian Head, of the heaviest armor-plate yet made in this country, was of great importance and interest.
The plate tested was made by the Bethlehem Iron Company. It is of the nickel-steel which our Navy Department has approved and adopted for armor, and was hardened on the surface by the Harvey process.
The results of the trial were very surprising. The first shot, a twelve-inch Carpenter steel projectile, fired from a gun 360 feet distant, with a muzzle velocity of only 1465 feet per second, not only penetrated the eighteen inches of steel but broke the plate in two directions for almost its entire width and length; while a second shot, with a velocity of 1926 feet, completed its destruction, breaking it into three pieces. It was, in fact, a complete victory for the projectile and a disastrous failure for the plate.
It would not, of course, be fair or just to decide from this single failure against the use of nickel-steel or of the Harvey process. The broken plate was taken for test as a fair sample, but some special cause for its failure may possibly have existed, and further trials will be needed. Previous trials in this country, Russia, and in France have seemed to show that nickel-steel is the best metal yet made for armor-plates, and the value of the Harvey process in hardening the surface has been generally accepted. It is, however, stated that recent experiments in England have decided the English government to adopt the Harvey treatment, while abandoning the nickel-steel.
The cause of the failure of the great plate is not understood. Its behavior seems to indicate great internal strains which may have come from the manner of tempering, of cooling, or from the temperature at which the plate was worked. Cases of such internal strains are very familiar to every one who works in iron and steel, and in some cases, perhaps in all, these strains are temporary, being greatest when the material is first turned out, and gradually diminishing as the molecules rearrange themselves, until they come to an equilibrium.
An example which occurred in our practice years ago was as follows: Certain wire-rods purchased for the best quality broke readily when they were being drawn into wire. The rods were condemned and thrown out in the yard, and lay under the snow and rain for the greater part of a year. They were then tried again, and drew without the least difficulty. Apparently in this case, the internal strains in the freshly-rolled rods were so great that the additional strain in drawing exceeded the strength of the material; but in time the particles rearranged themselves and left the entire strength of the material effective against external strains. So it very possibly may be in the case of this great armor-plate. If this is a correct hypothesis, the armor increases in resisting power the longer it is in use, up to such time as it loses its internal strains.—Literary Digest.