AdventAI

A POOR EXCUSE.

By M. E. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 26., June 26, 1894

A DOCTOR of divinity, writing in the United Presbyterian of Dr. Schaff’s latest work, “The History of the Reformation in Switzerland,” pays special attention to that part of the book which speaks of Calvin’s treatment of Servetus. He tries to shield Calvin from blame in the following manner:—

“The Servetus episode of course comes in for an extended notice—100 pages. There are many who know nothing of this incident save the phrase so familiar in the mouth of the enemies of Calvinism, ‘Calvin burned Servetus.’ One would suppose Calvin had pounced upon him and thrown him into the fire. The facts are that Servetus was condemned by a civil tribunal, the council of Geneva, for heresy and blasphemy, in denying the doctrines of the Trinity and the divinity of Christ. Not Calvin only, but all the Reformers approved of the verdict. They held that the civil power had a right to punish heretics with death; nay, more; that it was as much bound to inflict punishment for the violation of the first table of the law as of the second. We do not agree with them. Calvin would not agree with them if he looked at the matter from our viewpoint. Too many make no allowance for the influence of centuries of Protestant teaching and toleration.

“But too much has been made of Servetus, living and dead. He was an erratic egotist, who sought notoriety, and good men were possessed of enough folly and fanaticism to give it to him. The council of Bern, thirteen years later, Calvin being dead, punished with death a less aggravated and dangerous heretic, yet we never hear him named nor lamented.”

There are two points in this remarkable quotation that are worthy of notice. First, is the claim that Calvin did not actually burn Servetus, because he did not pounce upon him himself and throw him into the fire! Such an argument is both ridiculous and misleading. Calvin entered the complaint against Servetus, knowing well what the final result would be, even doing it on Sunday, for fear that, should he wait another day, he would escape! He stood back of the whole proceeding; and if he had actually lighted the fire with his own hand, he could not possibly have been more guilty.

Then, again, look at the pleading in his case. He was “condemned by a civil tribunal,” etc. This is precisely the same argument that the Catholic Church uses to justify the wholesale religious persecutions and murders that Protestants charge to her account. We all know how those civil tribunals were controlled, and we know also that the plea that what we call persecutions were done by the civil authority is a miserable subterfuge of the Catholic Church. And it is no less the same on the part of this Presbyterian divine. The fact that another man was judicially and civilly murdered a few years later, by the council of Bern, and that not much attention was given to the matter, is a poor excuse for the murder of Servetus.

The second point we wish to notice is his acknowledgment that the civil law had no right to inflict punishment “for the violation of the first table of the law, as of the second.” In this we fully agree with him. But we wonder if it has escaped the notice of this minister, as well as of the paper which prints his article, that the fourth commandment is one of the precepts of the first table? It hardly seems possible that he is so obtuse as not to know this; yet the church with which he is connected and the paper from which we quote, are very forward to enforce the observance of the fourth commandment, as they are pleased to construe it, with pains and penalties, although it is a command of the first table, which this writer acknowledges they have no right to enforce by civil law. Calvin was wrong in both principle and practice. The doctor is right in principle but wrong in practice. He offers an excuse for Calvin, which, poor as it is, he cannot offer for the church to which he belongs; for the United Presbyterian Church is as eager to enforce an obedience of the first table of the decalogue by the authority of the civil law as ever Calvin was to enforce his ideas of the trinity by the same power.

No doubt the “centuries of Protestant teaching and toleration” have done much for liberty of conscience; but judging from what we see every day of the same spirit of Catholicism and of Calvin, in the matter of an enforced Sunday-keeping, there is much yet to be done before professed Protestants will learn the folly of trying to establish the religion of Christ by an appeal to Cæsar.

M. E. K.