AdventAI

IMMORTALITY NOT A BIRTHRIGHT, BUT A GIFT FROM GOD.

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 2., January 9, 1894

BY ELDER W. H. LITTLEJOHN.

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

(Continued.)

The distinguished commentator, Albert Barnes, strange as it may appear, was a believer in the endless suffering of the wicked. The torture which this conception inflicted upon his great intellect is fittingly set forth in the subjoined extract from his writings:—

“I confess, when I look upon a world of sinners and of sufferers, upon deathbeds and graveyards, upon the world of woe filled with hosts to suffer forever; when I see my friends, my parents, my family, my people, my fellow-citizens; when I look upon a whole race, all involved in this sin and danger; and when I see the great mass of them wholly unconcerned, and when I feel that God only can save them, and yet he does not do it, I am struck dumb. It is all dark, dark, dark, to my soul, and I cannot disguise it.”—“Sermons,” pp. 124, 125.

The eloquent Saurin closes one of his sermons on this subject, with these words:—

“I sink, I sink, under the awful weight of my subject; and I declare, when I see my friends, my relations, the people of my charge,—this whole congregation; when I think that I, that you, that we all are exposed to these torments; when I see, in the lukewarmness of my devotions, in the languor of my love, in the levity of my resolutions and designs, the least evidence, though it be only possible or presumptive, of my future misery, I find in the thought a mortal poison, that diffuseth itself through every period of my existence, rendering society tiresome, nourishment insipid, pleasure disgustful, and life itself a cruel bitter. I cease to wonder that the fear of hell hath made some melancholy, others mad; that it hath disposed some to expose themselves to a living martyrdom, by fleeing from all commerce with the rest of mankind, and others to suffer the most terrible, violent torments.”

Pitable indeed is the condition of a man whose faith chains him, as did that of Barnes and Saurin, to a dogma against which every sensibility of his noble nature revolts with shame and horror. Such men think that they believe in the doctrine of eternal conscious misery, but in reality they neither do nor can. The distinguished Bishop Newton, in the subjoined extract, states the matter correctly:—

“Imagine a creature, nay, imagine numberless creatures produced out of nothing, . . . delivered over to torments of endless ages, without the least hope or possibility of relaxation or redemption. Imagine it you may, but you can never seriously believe it, nor reconcile it to God and goodness.”

The writer remembers having heard, years ago, an incident narrated, which, whether true or false, will serve to illustrate the situation. A worm had worked his way through the ear, or otherwise, to the brain of an unfortunate man. The suffering of the latter was intense, and his life was despaired of. At length the physician trepanned the skull, and endeavored to remove the worm, which was partially visible. Their efforts were unavailing. Whenever they undertook to grasp the creature with their instruments, he would dart back under the covering of the brain, and the patient would go into terrible convulsions. The experiment was repeated again and again, with the same result. At length a medical student who was present, left the room, but speedily returned bearing between his thumb and finger a green leaf. Stepping forward, he deposited it by the side of the worm, and to the astonishment of all except the student, the worm left his hiding-place, and crawled out upon the leaf, which was instantly removed with the worm upon it. The life of the sufferer was saved. Let the worm represent the malign doctrine of eternal conscious misery, and the green leaf the doctrine of conditional immortality, and you have a fitting representation of the condition of the church at this time, and the perfect relief which is offered in the view defended in this paper.

A law without a penalty is a dead letter. The timidity which the preachers feel in the matter of pressing upon their congregations the doctrine of endless misery, results in their failure to rein sinners up to the judgment bar of God. As a substitute, they undertake to present the love of God for sinners, hoping in this way to convert men without resort to the terrors of the law. This plan will not work successfully, for two reasons: First, it is not the gospel method. Paul says: “Knowing therefore the terror of the Lord, we persuade men.” 2 Cor. 5:11. Secondly, as long as the masses are aware that the churches really believe in the doctrine of endless misery, it is idle for the ministry to talk to them of the infinite love of a God who would torment a finite creature eternally for the commission of a finite sin. As a result, the church is being honeycombed with infidelity. Thousands whose names are on the church books have gone over to Spiritualism and Restorationism. This tendency, instead of decreasing, will steadily increase. The only remedy will be found in a return to the gospel view, that “the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.” That doctrine is consonant with reason. By a punishment exactly commensurate with the deserts of the offender, it presents the terrors of the law rationally, and in a manner to impress and restrain evil-doers. In destroying the incorrigibly wicked, it presents the best and most merciful disposition of them which could possibly be made, since it would not be consistent with their interests or those of the universe, that their lives should be prolonged eternally, while they live only to sin against and insult the God who made them.

In the promise of immortality to the saints, it places before them an infinite motive for perseverance in well-doing until the victory is won. Resting, as it does, the salvation of the sinner upon the atonement of Christ, the only begotten and well-beloved Son of the Father, it illustrates the infinite love of the latter in the gift of that Son to secure the salvation of rebels against his moral government. By showing that Christ, through his suffering and death, purchased eternal life for all who would accept it at his hands, the Saviour is exalted to a position equal to that of the Father in point of dignity and power, and enthroned forever in the affectionate regard of the saved. By substituting a rational punishment for the lost, in the place of one too terrific for contemplation, it gives to the believer a theory of the divine plan in dealing with both the saved and the unsaved, which can be defended upon logical grounds, and which removes once and forever the doctrine of eternal conscious misery, which has so long spread its dark wings over the church, and brooded like a terrible nightmare over the spirits of good men, torturing their hearts and benumbing their intellects by visions of the divine wrath utterly irreconcilable with either justice or mercy.

It does not fall within the scope of this article to enter into an extended examination of the texts which are supposed to teach the endless torture of the wicked. Nevertheless, the writer will give a passing notice to the most prominent of them at this point, lest the really conscientious reader, while anxious to adopt the view presented in this connection, should feel that he was prevented from so doing by positive Scripture statements.* Knowing, as the writer does, that preconceived notions go a great way in determining the impression which a given textp. 20 makes upon the mind, the reader is requested to look at each passage which will be brought forward for examination, from the standpoint of one who is seeking to build up a Scriptural theory of the state of the dead, rather than from that of one whose views on that question are already formulated.

(Concluded in book form.)

Notes

  1. *For an exhaustive and critical examination of all of the texts usually employed for and against the natural immortality of the soul and the endless suffering of the wicked, the reader is referred to “Here and Hereafter,” by Elder U. Smith. This book is published by the REVIEW AND HERALD, and will be sent post-paid to any address for $1. ↩