One of the most thrilling of gospel stories certainly is that related by Luke, telling of the multitude of the heavenly host that “suddenly” was with the angel that had brought the glad tidings of the Saviour’s birth. They were there “saying.”
Suppose the record had been, “They were there, singing,” and continued thus: “They rendered one of the choicest selections from heaven’s own répertoire. The first soprano led off in a brilliant solo, running up with ease to high C, and sustaining her notes without the slightest quiver. The alto and tenor took up their successive parts with equal skill, the bass following, going down to the lowest depths with wonderful power. Then followed the full chorus, gliding through the most difficult mazes of harmony without one false note, while the shepherds looked one upon another, amazed.” Would such a record have come down through the ages, stirring successive generations to deepest adoration and highest worship?
The record is, “And suddenly there was with the angel a multitude of the heavenly host praising God, and saying, Glory to God in the highest.” We may well believe that these words were spoken in musical tones of richest and rarest quality; but we know they conveyed a sentiment, and there is no question as to the adoring worship of that sentiment.
We go to church to worship God. Our hearts, exultant in praise and joy, cry out, “Glory to God in the highest!” or in self-abasement, we cry, “Have mercy upon me, O God!” The organ prelude, it may be, harmonizes well with the feeling of the heart. It can be filled with sentiments of devotion or penitence. After it follows the artistic vocal rendering of some wonderful musical composition. Is it worship? Is it prayer? Is it praise?—Conjecture is vain; for not a word can be detected in the performance to which we are treated.
Music is grand and glorious. The more nearly perfect, the better. But music for the house of God should be the vehicle of some aspiration ascending from human hearts to a listening God. If it be an empty vehicle, however elaborately fashioned and skilfully adorned, what place has it in the house of prayer and praise? Adoring hearts, penitent hearts, aching hearts, longing to rise in communion with a loving and forgiving Father, feel its gorgeous emptiness, and wish for voices “saying” something to which they may respond, as did the hearts of the lowly shepherds on the hills of Bethlehem to the angelic anthem. — Selected.