AdventAI

SOME OBJECTIONS AGAINST THE SABBATH CONSIDERED.

By Philip Giddings

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 33., August 17, 1897

BY PHILIP GIDDINGS,

(Georgetown, British Guiana.)

Objection.— We keep Sunday, the Christian Sabbath.

Reply.— Whatever is Christian must first be Christ’s. When we find the Sabbath that Christ kept, we find Christ’s Sabbath, and if Christ’s, then it is the Christian Sabbath. We all agree that it was his custom to keep holy the seventh day (Saturday). Luke 4:16. “He that saith he abideth in him ought himself also so to walk, even as he walked.” 1 John 2:6.

Ob.— The seventh-day Sabbath was to commemorate creation; but the first-day Sabbath is to commemorate redemption.

R.— Now we know that the seventh day is to commemorate creation, because the Bible says so. Where do you find an equal authority for what you say concerning Sunday?

Ob.— God finished his work and rested; so Christ, on the cross, said of his work, “It is finished.” “He also hath ceased from his own works, as God did from his.”

R.— God (by the Son) finished his work on Friday. Christ on the cross, speaking of his own work, said, “It is finished.” You will remember that that day, too, was Friday. Here are two analogies: God finished his work on Friday, and rested on the seventh day; Christ finished his own work on Friday; when would you have him rest?—Why, on the seventh day.

Ob.— But we commemorate the day on which he broke the chains of death and the grave. We are begotten “again unto a lively hope by the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead.” Our hope anchors on the resurrection. For, “If Christ be not raised, your faith is vain; ye are yet in your sins. Then they also which are fallen asleep in Christ are perished.” 1 Cor. 15:17, 18. Therefore we celebrate this birthday of the Christian’s lively hope.

R.— The quotations are strong and beautiful, but the “therefore” does not follow. When we endeavor to form a couplet with Scripture and the unauthorized version of our deduction, we make but an iambus; it comes short of the glory of a plain, “Thus saith the Lord.” Who hath required this at our hands? Is this the commemoration that Christ has chosen—to make of none effect his commandment by our deduction? or is it to “walk in newness of life” (see Romans 6)—to live a life of righteousness? And what is righteousness? “All thy commandments are righteousness.” Ps. 119:172. Therefore, “Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled.” Matt. 5:18.

Ob.— It is the Jews’ Sabbath.

R.— Mr. William Scott, if that house over there is the house of William Scott, it is William Scott’s house. It is needless to say that “of” is the genitive particle, equivalent to the possessive ’s. Now, sir, the commandment reads: “The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God,” etc.; therefore, the seventh day is the Lord’s Sabbath. The question, then, to be settled, is: Whose God is he? If he is the Jews’ God only, then Gentiles have no part nor lot in anything that is his. If he is the Gentiles’ God only, the Jews have no portion with the Gentiles. But Paul says: “Is he the God of the Jews only? is he not also of the Gentiles? Yes, of the Gentiles also.” Rom. 3:29. Now, Mr. William Scott, if you have two sons, John and James, will not both have a right in what is yours? Wherefore, since the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord, and since he is the God, not of the Jews only, but also of the Gentiles, the seventh-day Sabbath belongs to both Jews and Gentiles. That there were some ceremonial sabbaths is agreed. Leviticus 23 speaks of seven ceremonial sabbaths “besides the Sabbath of the Lord.” When Christ, the great Antitype, became the Passover for us, these sabbaths passed away with the typical system to which they belonged. But the Sabbath of the Lord belongs to that law of which its Author said: “It is easier for heaven and earth to pass, than for one tittle of the law to fail.” Luke 16:17.

Ob.— But it seems most fitting that Sunday should thus be commemorated.

R.— Why every Sunday? Why more resurrection-Sundays than crucifixion-Fridays? He rose, not every Sunday in the year, but one Sunday in the year, and the same reason that allows you but one Friday—“Good Friday”—would allow you but one Sunday—“Easter Sunday.” There is no reason in Scripture or in consistency that the Sunday come oftener or be holier than the Friday. Your own position would allow you one Sunday, while the Scriptures would allow you none.

Ob.— If we err, we err in good company.

R.— ’T were better to be right in bad company. We shall be judged, not as a “company,” but as individuals. “So then every one of us shall give account of himself to God.” Rom. 14:12. Your Christian duty is not indicated by what good people did, or do, or leave undone, but by what the present knowledge of God’s word, appealing to your conscience, convinces you that you ought to do. We are to follow good men only as they follow Christ. If we do otherwise, we err.

Ob.— Do you think that if it were wrong to keep Sunday, the Lord would have permitted it so long?

R.— Do you think that if idolatry, covetousness,—in short, the devil, and sin,—were wrong, the Lord would have permitted them to exist so long?

Ob.— It seems a design of the Spirit that Christ should rise on Sunday, thus indicating the new Sabbath. It would have been just as easy for him who “is able even to subdue all things unto himself” to arrange the resurrection to come on some other day, if divine wisdom had not chosen Sunday. Again, if Sunday were not the proper day for Christians to keep, the Reformers, such as Luther and his fellows, in their diligent study of the Bible, would have found out and exposed that error as they did other errors.

R.— Your argument amounts to this,—what others have not seen, we must not see. Let usp. 516 not forget that Luther did not believe in infallibility, either in the pope or in himself. An illustration of how even the great Reformer could be wrong in things Biblical is his hasty rejection of the book of James as “the trashy epistle.” You believe that he was wrong in this. Nor was this his only error. You know that the Romanists teach that the bread and wine used in celebrating the Lord’s Supper are actually changed into the body and blood of Christ. This error Luther also maintained. Nor were these all, but they are enough to show that he was liable to errors. Carlstadt, a man of Luther’s time, did expose the Sunday-Sabbath error. The Reformers were not faultless. Says Dr. Cummings, of London: “The great Reformers of the sixteenth century [were] great with all the faults that clave to them, and it would have been strange if they had been faultless, having come out of a church so corrupt and a superstition so contaminating. The earlier Christians were wont to worship God and his Son only, but in this age, they who were called Christians worshiped the wooden cross, the images of saints, and the bones of men, they knew not whom.” In the year 604, the Pantheon of Rome was dedicated to the Virgin Mary and the saints; and the niches which had been filled by heathen gods were refilled with the glorified saints of Christendom, which were put in the same niches, or more probably, the former images had different names bestowed upon them, just as was done with Jupiter Tonans, who has a key in his hand for his thunderbolt, and is kissed as St. Peter by the great vicar of Christendom.

In fact, “Paganism was simply baptized,—heathen gods were called Christian saints,—and so it exists to-day.” So likewise the pagan Sunday, bearing on its very face its idolatrous meaning (the day of the sun),—this heathen Sunday, simply baptized, is called the “Christian Sabbath,” and so it exists to-day. But the light of Scripture and history, more penetrative than the X-rays of Roentgen’s new photographic discovery, brings out the heathenish fact, stripped of its dense covering of hoary age and baptismal “unavail.” A word about the deduction of the Spirit’s design: Theological deductions are not always Scripturally correct. At best they are well-meant guesses, which may hit or miss the truth. Sometimes they miss, even when tried by well-meaning men. Our Saviour once said to his disciples: “Take heed and beware of the leaven of the Pharisees and of the Sadducees. And they reasoned among themselves, saying, It is because we have taken no bread” (Matt. 16:6); but he did not mean such bread as they supposed he meant. He once said: “If I will that he tarry till I come, what is that to thee? . . . Then went this saying abroad among the brethren, that that disciple should not die: yet Jesus said not unto him, He shall not die; but, If I will that he tarry till I come, what is that to thee?” John 20:22, 23. Now the Scriptures say that Jesus rose again the first day of the week, and some men say that because of that fact, Sunday is the “Christian Sabbath;” yet the Scriptures say not that it is the “Christian Sabbath,” but only that Christ rose on the first day of the week; and this deduction, plausible as it may seem, is as wrong as the others. “Add thou not unto his words, lest he reprove thee, and thou be found a liar.”