A Step toward a New Papacy.
A FEW days ago the Lambeth Conference (held in Lambeth palace, Canterbury, England) ended its work, after a month of sessions. There were present one hundred and ninety-four bishops of the Anglican, or Episcopal, Church, representative bishops from every branch of that church being present. The sessions of the conference were held in secret, and while we may know the final decisions of the conference, as far as they are published, we cannot know of the diversity of opinions presented and the discussions that preceded the final agreement.
At the close of the conference, a kind of encyclical was issued. The most important topic discussed in the encyclical is that relating to the organization and government of the church by which we may conclude that that topic furnished important matter for discussion. It is apparent that many of the Anglican clergy, particularly those of England, are envious of what they denominate the “majestic organization of the papacy,” and are desirous of imitating it. They would like to see a great universal Anglican Church, with a primate; and there was evidently much discussion upon this point. A Romanist would say that such an organization is not practicable, since anything Anglican cannot be universal, as England is not universal; and the Anglican could retort by saying that the same objection could be urged against Rome. Indeed, if all the churches that have the Anglican form of worship—the lineal and literal descendants of the Anglican, or English, Church—would consent, there would be nothing in the way of an English pope; and if a pope is a necessary feature in the government of the church, an English pope would surely be as good as an Italian pope.
But the Lambeth Conference did not take kindly to the idea even of an English pope. The American bishops have strong notions of American liberty. They evidently hold, what is a fact of history, that when the civil bonds which united the American colonies to England were severed, the spiritual connection of the American Episcopal Church to its fostering mother, the English Church, was also broken;p. 602 and they do not propose, at this late day, after a century of independence, to unite the American branch of the Episcopal Church to its English mother other than in voluntary, kindly, and Christian relations. An English pope is not at all to their liking.
The same feeling evidently prevailed among the bishops of the Anglican Church in the British colonies. These colonies have attained almost complete civil independence, and the Anglican Church’s spiritual independence in these colonies, of the mother church of England, is even greater. The Canadian bishops living so near the bishops of the United States, enjoying fraternal relations with them, and seeing the measure of their independence, could not accept of any less measure of liberty. The sentiment and feeling of Canadian independence as expressed by Kipling in his poem of “Our Lady of the Snows,” in the lines—
“Daughter am I in my mother’s house, But mistress in my own,”
well expresses the feeling of the Canadian Anglican Church toward its mother, the English Church . The same feeling prevailed generally, and the hopes of all those who desired to see an English papacy were at once cut off.
The conference, however, did take a step in the direction of a closer union, by forming what is denominated a “central consultative body for supplying information and advice.” This is a distinct step toward a papacy, and is no doubt a compromise between the two opposing ideas and forces in the Episcopal Church. This committee is to be appointed by the Archbishop of Canterbury, the chief primate of England. It may be seen that with this power of appointment in his hands, it will be an easy matter for him to appoint those who are in accord with his views. Then if any measure of authority is given to this “consultative committee,” a central authority is at once established, which, from custom and precedent, may finally claim an authority and power which at the first were not dreamed of by many who consented to give it being.
The papacy grew up in a similar way, and it is a well-known axiom that like causes produce similar results. Whether there will ever be an Anglican papacy, then, depends upon two considerations: (1) Will there be time enough for its development? and (2) Will the spirit of supremacy subdue the spirit of liberty in the Anglican Church? The New York Tribune thinks it can never be. It says:—
It [the Anglican Church] may, and probably will, maintain communion between its various national branches, but there will never be an Anglican patriarchate. That conception of church polity may continue to receive the academic recognition of the theologians, but as a working principle, it is dead beyond the hope of a resurrection.
It is to be hoped that the Tribune is a true prophet; but an evil thing, once started, rarely goes backward. M. E. K.