THE HORR AND HARVEY DEBATE

14%

S. D. A. Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 15, 1895

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 48, No. 33.

Read the full edition

THE HORR AND HARVEY DEBATE.

The numerous discussions and debates in the public press and in other ways upon the subject of finance, which have been a leading feature of the present political outlook, have at last led to a set debate between the chosen champions of those who may be called the gold and silver men. The publication of a little book called “Coin’s Financial School,” by W. H. Harvey, of Chicago, is the cause of this discussion. The debaters are Roswell G. Horr, formerly United States senator from this State, and now of New York City, and the author of the aforesaid book. The discussion involves the merits of the book, but it is not confined to that. It was opened July 16 in Chicago, in the presence of a large number of invited guests. The whole debate is being reported and published more or less fully all over the United States.
The difference of opinion between the debaters and those whom they represent may be briefly stated. Mr. Horr is a bimetalist,—that is, he believes in the use of both gold and silver for money,—but he believes in a single standard for money, and that that standard should be gold, as it now is. So as far as the standard of money is concerned, he is a monometalist. With him silver serves a good purpose as subsidiary coin, the same as copper. He holds that the demonetization of silver in 1873 was a wise action, to place the monetary system of this country in harmony with the systems which obtain in other countries, and that our monetary system should be regulated by the customs of other nations. Mr. Harvey is also a bimetalist, but he holds that silver as well as gold should be primary money, as it was before 1873; that the act of 1873, by which silver was demonetized, and lost its character as money, was a “crime”; that it was passed in a surreptitious manner, the majority of those who voted for it and favored it not knowing what the result would be; that this demonetization of silver has worked incalculable injury to the people of the United States; and that to remedy what has been done, this country should immediately remonetize silver, and open the United States mints to the free coinage of silver and gold at the old rate of sixteen to one. (By “sixteen to one” is meant that a fixed weight of gold shall be equal in value to sixteen times that weight in silver.) Great interest is being awakened by this debate, and the disputants are cheered by the unstinted applause of their friends.
Three points have been made very clear by this discussion,—that the silver dollar was the only standard of our system of money from the time of the establishment of our system of currency until 1873, that in 1873 silver was demonetized by act of Congress, and that since that time we have been upon a gold basis.
Mr. Harvey charges that the act of 1873 was a conspiracy of capitalists against the interests of the common people. The proof of this position is not clear. Still, he is able to show that many distinguished men who voted for and favored this measure, did not know that their action would result as it did.
Mr. Harvey thinks that the United States is controlled by the money power of England, and that there should be a second declaration of independence. He holds that with free and unlimited coinage of silver, New York and not London would be the commercial center of the world, and that France and many other nations would follow our example. Mr. Horr denies all this, believing that the return to the condition which existed before 1873 would cause a financial revolution ruinous to the country. No discussion in this country since the Lincoln and Douglas debates has attracted more general attention.
Both men are able disputants. Mr. Horr has long been known as an able orator and skilful debater. Mr. Harvey is not so well known, his publication of “Coin’s Financial School” first bringing him to public notice; but Mr. Horr is learning that the unknown quantity is a sharp lawyer, who has thoroughly studied the question of finance, and is perfectly at home in the arena of debate. The American people have the right to know the whole truth of this matter, and it is to be hoped that this debate will tend to that result.