ABELARD

8%

S. D. A. Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 12, 1895

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 43, No. 37.

Read the full edition

ABELARD

(Conclusion.)
After his triumph over William of Champeaux, Abelard had not an obstacle in his path to glory. The straws which his rival cast before him were swept idly away. His star was in its zenith; its decline was soon to begin.
He was now nearly forty years old. His life had been ardently devoted to study and work. It seems that his zeal to reach the highest pinnacle of learning had left no leisure and no inclination for the pursuit of any other of the objects which attract mankind. But now he was drawn aside into an attachment for that woman whose devotion has made his name more famous than all his learning could have done,—Heloise. She was a woman, or rather a girl, of rare attainments for that age. Hers was not only beauty, but superior intelligence. She was an orphan, related to the noble house of Montmorency, and was the niece of a canon named Fulbert, who had educated her so well that, when Abelard met her, she read not only Latin, but Greek and Hebrew. Abelard was a churchman,—a canon if not a priest,—and churchmen were forbidden to wed. He married in secret. Fearing to ruin her husband, Heloise denied the marriage. This made trouble between her and her uncle, and she fled to the convent of Argenteuil. Fulbert then began to plot revenge against Abelard. He had assisted in the flight, and Fulbert believed that he intended to desert his wife. Through the machinations of the enraged uncle, Abelard was soon overwhelmed with shame and ruin, and, seeking only to hide from the world, he entered the monastery of St. Denis. Before he took his vows, however, he insisted that Heloise should first enter the monastic life, and, amid a crowd of weeping friends, she took the black veil, being only twenty.
Abelard did not long remain at St. Denis. The calls to teach became too pressing to be refused. It was urged upon him, perhaps he felt, that his misfortune had been sent by God to humble and refine him, that he might do a greater work. “You have taught the philosophy of man,” said Abbé Adam of St. Denis; “perhaps Providence has been preparing you, and now calls you, to teach the new and higher philosophy,—the philosophy of God.” Leaving the monastery, the humbled dialectician went to his friend Foulke, at Compiègne, and there, in the abbey of Maisoncelle, began to teach. The history of former days repeated itself. He was soon surrounded, according to the original authorities, with four thousand pupils. But his enemies were no longer helpless. His ruin had weakened his cause forever. It was not long till he was summoned before a council of the church at Soissons; his teaching was condemned, and he himself was sent back to his own monastery.
Perhaps it was in no submissive spirit that he returned to St. Denis. At any rate, he soon made enemies of his brother monks. The discipline in that monastery was very lax. It had been founded and was sustained by the royal favor, and thus it had come to be “rather a monastery devoted to Cæsar than to God.” Abelard could not endure the abuses which he witnessed daily, and it was doubtless his protests that brought upon him the dislike of his fellows. An incident soon occurred which brought this dislike to a focus. The monastery was said to have been founded by St. Denis, or Dionysius, of Athens. The monks of St. Denis believed that this was the same whom Paul had converted by his speech at the Areopagus. One day Abelard, coming across a passage in the writings of the Venerable Bede which states that Dionysius the Areopagite afterward became bishop of Corinth, pointed it out, smiling, to some of his brethren. An angry protest arose at once. The abbot was called, who proved from the writings of a former abbot of the monastery that its founder was indeed Dionysius the Areopagite, bishop of Athens. Abelard ridiculed the authority, and made invidious comparisons between his fame and that of Bede. Abbé Adam threatened to send him to the king for an insult so unheard of to the dignity of the place. Apology and entreaty were alike vain; to the king he must go. The king, fortunately, cared little for the honor of St. Denis, and Abelard was not only acquitted, but released from his obligations to the monastery.
He now repaired to Troyes, and built himself a hut of straw in the midst of a wilderness, where he hoped to find the peace and quiet his soul longed for. Not so. How quickly a thing could be blazed abroad in those days when all established communication was very slow, is marvelous; no sooner was Abelard’s whereabouts known, than students began to gather about him as before, and to build their huts beside his. He could not but teach; they would have nothing else. They built him an oratory of stubble, which he called by the name of the Paraclete, the Comforter, because he had found rest after his troubles and afflictions. But even this selection of a name brought forth criticism, because no one could remember that ever before a church or convent had been called by the name of the Holy Spirit. In this oratory he lectured to greater crowds than ever before. His fame had spread throughout Europe, and from every land pupils came to hear him. His tone of lecturing had changed, too; his lectures were more devotional, and appealed more to the heart and life.
At this time there was a man rising into influence in the church, who represented the very opposite in religious character from the nature of Abelard. Abelard was a keen and deep reasoner, who sought to prove all things. This man was a man of faith, devoted with fanatical and unquestioning zeal to what he did believe, and untiring in his endeavors to translate his beliefs into facts in all that he came into contact with. This man was St. Bernard. He was determined to reform monastic life, and earnest to advance the power of the papacy. His plan was to take a number of followers off into the wilderness, establish a monastery upon principles of the strictest asceticism, and then to send these monks into other monasteries as missionaries of reform. This monastery he established within a few miles of the oratory of the Paraclete.
Bernard was the natural enemy of philosophy and of Abelard. He could see more keenly than any one else in his times the real outcome of Abelard’s teaching. He looked forward with the eye of a seer, and saw, as the result of this kind of teaching, a Luther and a reformation. He had the penetration to see that a spirit of inquiry was the subtlest foe of the church.
Abelard knew what to expect. He felt that such a neighbor was dangerous, and he fled to Brittany. The abbot of the monastery of St. Gildas-de-Rhuys had just died, and Abelard was asked to take his place. The abbey overlooked the sea, on a wild and rocky promontory, in a wild and barbarous region, inhabited by the same race which Cæsar had found so unmanageable, when, centuries before, he accomplished the conquest of Gaul. Abelard labored long and faithfully to bring his lawless and half-savage monks to some sort of orderly and decent living, but in vain. After almost ten years of effort, he was at last compelled to flee for his life from his infuriated charges. He continued to live in Brittany for some time after this event, and at length came to Paris, and once more engaged in teaching.
But the relentless opposition of Bernard met him again as soon as he took up his old profession. He was summoned before a council at Sens, condemned, and forced to burn some of his books. He appealed to Rome, and was condemned at Rome. He then determined to go thither to seek justice in person; but got no farther than the monastery of Cluny, in eastern France. Entirely broken in health and spirit, he gave up the struggle at last. Curious crowds gazed at the monks as they passed through the streets, to catch a glimpse of the great professor, and pointed out, with pity and wonder, the bowed head and dejected figure of the man who had stirred Europe with his teaching, now the humblest and saddest of all that forlorn procession. From Cluny he was shortly removed to a neighboring monastery, where he died in April of 1142, being about sixty-three years old. After his burial, his body was taken up secretly by his friends, and carried to the abbey of the Paraclete, of which Heloise had been abbess since shortly after its abandonment by Abelard; and there it was buried beneath the chancel by Heloise and her nuns; and there, too, after many years, she came to rest beside him.
Abelard was an acute reasoner, but was not a great philosopher. He brought forth nothing new or lasting. He was too fond of action, too much in love with controversy, to produce those fruits of the mind which ripen only in quiet study. He must have been a great orator, for only the power of oratory could have drawn the multitudes which followed him. He was also a poet; and, strange to say, it is in this least of his capacities alone that he was remembered, till the restless historical investigation of the last century brought forth the details of his life. His love-songs, written in the native tongue, are among the earliest treasures of French literature. But while he has left nothing more worthy which is distinctly his own, he had yet a great influence upon his own and later times; for he started a form of thinking which was not to die out till it ended in the revival of learning and the great Reformation, and which was most visibly embodied, during the intervening centuries, in the University of Paris.
C. B. MORRILL.