WHAT MAKES A WEED?

17%

Review and Herald Publishing Company · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 17, 1901

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 49, No. 3.

Read the full edition

WHAT MAKES A WEED?

WHAT is a weed? It seems a very simple question. Most young people would say, “Why, it’s just a — weed!” Or, if they knew about gardening, they might say, “Well, it’s something that you don’t plant, but it comes up just the same, and you have to pull it up.” I remember very well a splendid flower that was sent once to my mother — a great datura, white and fragrant, and of how she showed it to me, and explained that it was, after all, only a variety of the despised “Jamestown weed.” “It is a glorified weed,” she said, and I never forgot the phrase. And afterward I found out that the very word “weed” was not originally meant as a reproach to the plant that bore it, but came from the good Anglo-Saxon “weod,” which meant a shrub of any kind, or even a tree.
Then, when I visited a schoolmate who lived on a farm, I found that the beautiful white-and-yellow daisies that I loved so were nothing but weeds on a farm, and were rooted up wherever they showed their pretty heads. And as I grew older, and traveled, I began to find out that what was a flower in one place was a weed in another, and people weeded up in California what other people kept in conservatories in New York. So the question, “What is a weed?” seemed to get harder and harder to answer all the while.
But finally I got the clue. What do you suppose it is? Why, just this. It isn’t the plant that makes the weed, but the place the plant is in. If it is in a fit place, its own place, a place not set apart for anything else, it is simply a plant; and if it is beautiful, we call it a wild flower, and admire it and gather it. But when it takes a place that we need for other flowers, or for other plants, and crowds them out, then we are right to make war upon it; for it is a weed, useless and obnoxious.
And that clue has given me another clue. When I was a child, I often wondered whether some things I wanted to do were right or wrong — whether they were flowers or weeds in my soul garden. I couldn’t always tell: can you always tell, young people? But since I have settled in my mind what makes a weed, I have solved my question. Remember, I am not speaking of sinful things, but only of doubtful things. Sinful things are not just weeds; they are poison plants, to be rooted up at once. But the doubtful thing is not wrong in itself, any more than the ox-eye daisy or the goldenrod. As long as it does not grow in the wrong place, and crowd out better things, it does no harm.
But just there is where we must watch it. A farmer who had a field of goldenrod and no wheat — what a failure of a farmer he would be! A girl who had a garden bed, and only field daisies in it, with never a rose nor a heliotrope nor a geranium — what a mockery her garden would seem! Whatever interferes with the best we can make out of our lives; whatever makes us vain, or selfish, or lazy, or unloving; whatever crowds out, little by little, better things — that is a weed; and, if we are wise, we will root it up now, while we are young; for the best time to do weeding, as everybody knows, is early in the morning!—Priscilla Leonard.