The Spirit of Criticism
By G. B. Thompson
If there were living in a community a man who, secretly yet deliberately, should poison a public drinking well, and through the contamination spread sickness and death in the neighborhood, such a dastardly act would not only subject the offender to the public execration of the people, but the hand of the civil law would be placed upon him to restrain him from further acts of the kind. Those who constantly criticize others, who handle the reputation of their neighbors, friends, or brethren in such a way as to arouse suspicion against them, suspicion calculated to damage their influence and rob them of their good name, are doing a work similar in spirit to the one who poisons the public drinking fountain. One destroys the physical body; the other, with poisonous words and innuendoes, destroys the reputation and influence of the individual. When this evil thing creeps into the church, and is clothed with a robe of false righteousness, it becomes all the more abhorrent and wicked. Such people usually attack their victim when he is absent, and cannot defend himself. By words and insinuations they sow among friends and acquaintances doubts concerning the honesty and integrity of the individual they criticize. That anything so extremely wicked and ungodly should be in the church, masquerading in the livery of heaven, would be almost beyond belief if it were not that its baneful work has actually been seen in the church, discouraging and darkening the souls of old and young, and extinguishing their hope of the life beyond. Warnings from the Spirit of Prophecy
“An earnest effort should be made in every church to put away evil speaking and a censorious spirit as among the sins productive of the greatest evils in the church. Severity and faultfinding must be rebuked as the workings of Satan. Mutual love and confidence must be encouraged and strengthened in the members of the church.”—“Testimonies for the Church,” Vol. V, p. 609. “Self-righteousness not only leads men to misrepresent God, but makes them cold-hearted and critical toward their brethren. The elder son, in his selfishness and jealousy, stood ready to watch his brother, to criticize every action, and to accuse him for the least deficiency. He would detect every mistake, and make the most of every wrong act. Thus he would seek to justify his own unforgiving spirit. Many today are doing the same thing.”—“Christ’s Object Lessons,” p. 210. “He who is guilty of wrong, is the first to suspect wrong. By condemning another he is trying to conceal or excuse the evil of his own heart. It was through sin that men gained the knowledge of evil; no sooner had the first pair sinned than they began to accuse each other; and this is what human nature will inevitably do, when uncontrolled by the grace of Christ.”—“Thoughts from the Mount of Blessing,” pp. 181, 182. From the biting, slanderous tongue of those in the bondage of this demon of darkness, none can be sure of escape. Their own ideas and opinions they consider as an infallible guide, and those who do not measure up to the standard which they have raised, are criticized, and in many cases held up to the scorn and ridicule of others. No matter what may be their standing in the community or in the church, their motives are judged and their apparent failures paraded before the people. A stream of poison is thus poured forth to contaminate the minds of old and young, and to befoul the spiritual atmosphere which they breathe. Usually no effort is made to visit the individual, to point out to him wherein he fails, but his delinquencies are paraded before a cold, unfeeling public, who have no knowledge of the situation, or the circumstances with which the individual is surrounded, or the struggles which are perchance straining the moral fiber of his soul. It would seem that a work so repugnant, so utterly contrary to every principle of righteousness, would of itself be sufficiently abhorrent to be shunned by all. That the work of censuring and judging the acts and motives of others is from Satan himself is quite clear. The Bible declares him to be the “accuser of our brethren.” Those who engage in the work of criticizing others are working hand in hand with Lucifer. If those who do this work are professed followers of him, who once bade only those who themselves had no sin to throw stones, it is all the more deplorable. It Is So Easy to Be Mistaken
A properly trained, refined, and cultured person will be exceedingly careful in his criticism of others. By being too free in ridiculing and criticizing others, we may advertise some weakness and failure of our own, and exhibit the fact that we are possessed of a small, narrow mind, incapable of weighing the work of others in unprejudiced scales. By being quick to call attention to something in the life of another which may not appear right to us, we may uncover to the gaze of others a cheapness in our own life that would4 be very embarrassing if we could but see it. Things are not always what they appear, and it is not always safe to trust even the evidence of our own eyes; we may be very far from having a correct understanding of things. “What looks to thy dim eyes a stain,
In God’s pure sight may only be
A scar brought from some well-won field,
Where thou wouldst only faint and yield.”
We should not criticize the actions of others, nor judge their motives, until we have made ourselves intelligent concerning all their circumstances and environment; and this we rarely if ever can do. Judging from appearances often leads to wrong conclusions. This is well illustrated by an incident which I heard recently. An exemplary and Christian lady one day picked up, in a large department store, an umbrella belonging to another. Discovering her mistake almost at once, she restored the umbrella to the woman, apologizing to her. The woman, however, indicated by her attitude that there was a serious question in her mind as to whether her umbrella had been taken by mistake or intentionally. A few hours later the lady who exchanged umbrellas by mistake, was in the street car returning home. She had with her three or four umbrellas belonging to some friends who had decided to remain in the city for the evening, and had asked her to take them home with her. Across the aisle sat the woman whose umbrella she had picked up a few hours before. This woman looked at her, and remembering her own experience, said, “Well, I see you have been quite successful.” She believed the evidence conclusive that the woman who picked up her umbrella was a thief; while as a matter of fact she was an honest woman, burdening herself with the umbrellas of others in order to be kind and accommodating. Yet circumstantial evidence was all against her. This incident should teach us not to criticize others, at least until we are familiar with all the facts in the case. And usually when we know the facts, we shall have no desire to criticize; for “to know all is to forgive all.” There is a form of criticism which is proper and helpful. It is that thoughtful investigation and candid criticism which is founded on an earnest longing to know what is right, and prompted by a desire to uncover truth. We may criticize ourselves, to see if we are holding up in the life the high and exalted standard that we should, and working consistently and faithfully toward achieving some noble work to which we have resolved that we would devote our life’s energies. It is proper to challenge that which comes before us claiming to be truth, and subject it to a searching, critical investigation. But candor is said to be the brightest gem of criticism; and as we apply the acid test of a critic, we should at all times keep the mind open for light, and be ready to accept the truth, even though it may overturn all our own preconceived ideas on the subject. No criticism is worth the name that is not governed by the law and the evidence. Then, too, we should keep in mind that we may be wrong. We should review our own limitations, and not be unmindful of the fact that intellectual insight and long experience are valuable assets in making one a good critic in any matter. Generally the riper our experience, the wider will be our range in our criticism, whether in our search after truth, correct principles by which to govern the life, or in reviewing the lives of those about us; and the more modest and reserved we shall be concerning our own attainment, and in our statements.