The Indictment

5%

Review and Herald Publishing Assn. · Takoma Park Station, Washington, D. C. · Oct 17, 1916

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 64, No. 42.

Read the full edition

The Indictment

The Tragedy of the Theater — No. 3

The Indictment

(Continued)
THE theater is to be condemned for its unreal presentation of life. Dr. Brand said: “The theater’s appeal to the sensibilities and passions is uniformly exaggerated and extreme. Not only do its plots consist of assassinations, poisonings, and illicit loves and intrigues, but every passion is overdrawn. Anger is madness; ambition, frenzy; love, delirium. It does not hold the mirror up to Nature except in her very worst aspects and her most degraded moods. Nature is not always after money. Nature is not always in an agony of either horror or laughter. Nature is not always languishing with a great sorrow on her face and a bottle of laudanum in her pocket, weeping last tears over a false lover. Nature is not always nude, whirling around on one great toe, while the other is up in the air. Nature is not always armed with pistol and bowie knife. Nature is not always roaring through the streets with clenched fists, disheveled hair, and bloodshot eyes. She is not always cutting throats and playing the harlot. Nature never ridicules religion and morality, for an entrance fee. Nature is sane, rational, decently clad, patient, self-contained, not living for cash, even divinely beautiful at times, like her Maker.”
The theater thus presents a different world from that in which nine hundred and ninety-nine out of every thousand live. The majority of people do not live in the atmosphere of intrigue, illicit love, deception, murder, and other vile crimes. Most people have never seen a burglary or a murder except on the stage. If they have ever been forced to do so, it has been a shock from which they have been a long time recovering, nor is it an experience to be desired a second time. It cannot be said that its effect upon them was in any way beneficial. Then how, in any way, can its mimic reproduction on the stage be beneficial?
The costuming, the glitter, the tinsel, the unreal, coupled with the moral gloss, and the positive portrayal of crime, unfit the spectator for the humdrum life next morning. Nerves have been stretched to the breaking point; minds and senses have been dazzled and intoxicated so that neither body, mind, nor spirit is fitted for the new day’s work. People are made discontented, hence incapable of faithfully undertaking the responsibilities of the workaday world, which is so different from the mimic theater world. Instead of relaxing and recuperating tired minds and bodies, it stimulates and excites, with subsequent reaction and enervation.
The fourth harmful effect is the indecent display of nudity. The costuming in the average theater is positively immodest, indecent, and immoral. The theater’s appeal is to the sensuous and the sensual. This is a deliberate policy upon the part of the managers, who know the weakness of poor human nature. For many theatrical plays, actresses are chosen solely for their physical charms. In musical extravaganzas, for instance, it is vastly more important that an actress should have a pretty face and a beautiful form than that she should have a pleasing voice. A glimpse at many of the billboards substantiates this statement; for, as with Lady Waldemar, in Mrs. Browning’s Aurora Leigh,—
“They split the amaranth bodice down To the waist, or nearly, with the audacious press Of full-breathed beauty. If the heart within Were half as white! But if it were, perhaps The breast were closer covered, and the sight Less aspectable by half, too.”
I do not say by any means that all theater people are immoral. But I do say that if you will only stop to consider for a moment what it would mean to any woman to garb herself as these women are garbed and come out and stand on a platform before the gaze of a crowd of people, you will agree that no actress can get the consent of her conscience and her modesty so to do, unless at some previous time that modesty and delicacy have received a moral shock. There must have been a shrinking and embarrassment when the first costume was donned and when the first appearance was made, for no woman has stood behind the footlights, and looked down into the eyes of an audience, without reading in many of them the looks of lust and hearts of wickedness. To a refined and modest woman such consciousness once must have given excruciating moral agony,—to know that she was the object of such lust, feasting itself upon her physical charms.
People who know what is going to take place and who go deliberately to see are not excusable. The managers who furnish such plays, actresses who make themselves the objects of such moral lust, audiences who indulge their visual passions, are all equally culpable before God.
The next harmful effect is the breaking down of the moral barriers of the audience. How can a young man and a young woman who have come together to enjoy the play, and have looked upon and have listened to such things, fail to be contaminated? When they go home, they naturally are impelled to discuss what they have seen and heard. As one scene after another of the various acts is reviewed, and the oaths, curses, innuendoes, compromising positions, false morals, and vile costuming are discussed, they are bound to break down the barriers of modesty and reserve between them. Such conversation courts familiarity about topics that young people should never discuss together. The result is that each loses a certain respect for the other, making it more easy for them to talk about such things on other occasions and at least tempting them to do the same things, especially when the theater’s false morals are also adopted. If the theater be a means of culture and education, and yet such things as are seen there cannot be even safely discussed by young people, let alone practiced, then where is the moral value of the theater?
For instance, the intrigues and affinities and kindred immoralities portrayed upon the stage arouse suspicion in the audience. Here is a husband who perhaps has had a misunderstanding with his wife. The stage suggestion is almost identical with something he saw in his wife’s actions at home, and immediately arouses his suspicions of her; whereas the wife may have been perfectly innocent of any wrong-doing. Thus are jealousy and dissension bred in the home, frequently leading to divorce. Besides this, husbands and wives, perhaps, whose love has grown cold, here find suggestions by which they may deceive each other and lead double lives.
Much of the tragedy of the divorce court can be traced to the tragedy of the stage. When men lose their respect for womanhood, through displayed nudity, through the breaking down of moral barriers, and through the generating of lustful desires, marriage vows are lightly treated, and divorce becomes an easy method of ridding the contracting parties of their responsibilities, leaving them free to repeat their lusts elsewhere. With the dance, the theater is the chief feeder of the brothel, as divorced women make up the majority of professional prostitutes.
Another harmful effect is the “rotting of the will by the fomentation of the sensibilities,” to use the words of Dr. Washington Gladden. The sights, scenes, and sounds of the plays continually stir the emotions, play upon the affections, bringing the whole psychic nature into intense excitement. As they furnish no outlet or vent, the consequence is the gradual decaying of the fiber of the will.
For instance, the sympathies are stirred for the unfortunate, pitiable condition of the little orphan match seller, who, in the bitter cold, clad in mere rags, sinks down to freeze and starve on the city streets. Women will sit and weep over the pathos of the scene and have the deeper moral sensibilities of their hearts stirred, but they either do not know or do not care that children in the great city all round them are at that moment literally starving and freezing. Though they weep over the child in the mimic world, they never think of going forth into the real world to find real suffering children and to bring them needed comfort and relief.
“There may be a starving family in a neighborhood court, a sick and dying domestic in a garret, or a poor relative reduced from affluence to beggary. But what are all these to the theatergoing lady, who has been accustomed every night to see kings dethroned, imprisoned, murdered; princes wandering in beggary and starvation; nobles outlawed and put to death; mothers butchered in the presence of their children, and maidens betrayed and seeking revenge with a dagger or with poison? What are the real ills of life to one who lives amid such scenes as these? They are the unheeded sighings of the zephyr in ears filled by the roar of the tornado. They are the slightest murmurs of the rivulet to one who dwells under the voice of Niagara’s cataract.”
“Save me and mine from the tender mercies of such as have daily poured their sympathy on fictitious sorrow until the hackneyed hearts have now no deep affections. I would as soon trust the strength of a man who had kept an open vein for the daily waste of his own blood.”
Such toying and tampering with the emotions, the affections, and the sympathies, is absolutely dangerous. That they can look upon such scenes and not be impelled to go forth in holy service for humanity, means no less than that the will is in decay.
The psychological impressions of such plays gradually become stimulating, then intoxicating, so that people go to enjoy having their sensibilities stirred, as men drink stimulants. Life becomes to them hypocrisy, mockery, and a scoff at the real tragedies of sorrows and tears. The world goes on unrelieved by their love and sympathy, but is used as a means to entertain them by its misery. Characters have become flaccid and flabby and so fail to develop sympathy, sincerity, and heart earnestness in life. Dr. Gladden says, “I do not believe that any habitual or inveterate play-goer ever achieved conspicuous success in business, in statesmanship, or in professional life.”
Of the French Revolution, the celebrated Edmund Burke writes: “While courts of justice were thrust out by Jacobin tribunals, and silent churches were only funereal monuments of departed religion,” when Paris “was like a den of outlaws, a lewd tavern for revel and debaucheries”—there were in that city “no fewer than twenty-eight theaters crowded every night.” From debauchery, blasphemy, and butchery in the daytime to the theater at night,—from the theater at night back to butchery, blasphemy, and debauchery in the daytime!
And as at Rome when the bloody gladiatorial combats and fights with wild beasts, and persecutions of Christians were demanded at last to satisfy the craving for excitement, so in Paris the “fomentation of the sensibilities in the mimic world” at last demanded the real, the actual. Some of the darkest pages in history are to be traced to the theater’s demoralization of character.—“Across the Dead Line of Amusements,” Henry W. Stough.