A Defective Illustration

20%

Review and Herald Publishing Assn. · Takoma Park Station, Washington, D. C. · Jan 25, 1916

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 64, No. 4.

Read the full edition

A Defective Illustration

When I was a boy, I was very fond of stories, and that fondness followed me into my ministerial experience, and today there is scarcely a boy who is more fond of illustration and story than I. When I began to preach, I ransacked everything I could find for stories that would enable me to convey the truth that I gathered out of the Bible. At one time I stumbled upon an illustration used by the greatest man in illustration that I knew of—Henry Ward Beecher. It was an illustration of his own, depicting the fall of man in the garden of Eden, and the work of regeneration. I thought it was excellent. I was not sufficiently matured in theology to be able to dissect the story and see wherein it was defective. Today I should not think of using it.
Mr. Beecher’s illustration was drawn from a picture which he imagined hanging in his room. It had been hanging there for a number of years. At first it was a beautiful picture; but years passed, and dust and dirt accumulated until the picture was disfigured; it was ruined. No one could tell what it was intended to portray. Finally the housekeeper came along, saw the imperfections of the picture, how it was marred and blurred. She took it down, and with a cloth washed all the dust and dirt away, then dried it and hung it up again; and there was the original image as perfect and as beautiful as before, and the only thing needed to keep it in that condition was an occasional visit from the housekeeper with her cloth, water, and soap. “Now,” said Mr. Beecher, “that picture was at first illustrative of the garden of Eden—perfect, without a flaw. That framework was the original man, also perfect and without a flaw. For a time it remained perfect, but somehow the devil came in and marred the picture until it was no longer pure and beautiful. That,” said he, “is the fall of man—man in his original perfection and purity marred and blurred by sin. Now, the housekeeper washes it and restores the original, and that is the work of regeneration, in that the original perfect picture is restored,—all sin washed away,—man standing before God as he originally made him, perfect, without flaw and blemish.”
I thought that was a good illustration of regeneration. I used it one Sunday morning in my pulpit. I had a deacon who was a very acute old brother. After the service was over and I was leaving, he said to me: “I want to speak to you a minute. You may be very fond of Mr. Beecher’s illustrations, and you may tell a story ever so well, but there never was a greater bundling together of mistakes than in that one you told this morning.” I was very quick to defend my illustration, and said, “Wherein is it false?” He said, “Do you think that regeneration goes no deeper than the washing off of the accumulated sin of a man’s life? If it goes no deeper than that, it is no more than the work of reformation. And if that is the case, what is to become of the sin with which the man is born? If the mere washing off of an accumulated sin is all, what becomes of this inherited sin?” I began to see his point, and I said, “I will think about it.” I did think about it—I did some serious thinking. I got my Bible, and studied on the subject, and the next time I saw that man I said, “You were right; I ought to have looked into that story before I told it.”
Regeneration is in no sense a washing away of sins. Christianity is in no sense a washed-over Adam. Regeneration and the Christianity that follows, is a work beginning in the heart and working to the surface, and not an external work working to the heart. To make that a true illustration, regeneration would be the housekeeper taking that picture down, and with a pair of scissors cutting the canvas right out with all its dirt, the framework only remaining, and then putting in its stead a new canvas. And the new canvas, instead of being a picture of Adam, would contain a picture of Jesus Christ, the Son of God. It is Christ in you, the hope of glory, that saves; not Adam. The man who today is a saved man is saved because God, through the work of regeneration, took out of him his sin, and in its place put Christ. It is Christ enthroned that produces the life that characterizes a true child of God.—Dr. Len G. Broughton.