Laughter
THERE are two kinds of everything, and there are two kinds of laughter. I met a little boy in Moby Lane; he was an acknowledged son of A. Neil Lyons; he spoke with discriminating disapproval of a woman he met in a railway carriage, saying:—
“What’s the matter wif her? I laughed at her free times an’ she didn’t laugh back.” He meant the smiling kind of laughter.
It is the other laughter I have in mind—the kind that asserts a superiority to others. After my talks with the boy in Bavaria, I tried to think out a philosophy of laughter. I didn’t get very far. I know, as Lord Chesterfield knew, that sitting down where there is no chair produces more laughter than the wittiest remark you can make. When that happens, you laugh—you have let yourself be surprised by some apparent negligence in the laws of nature, at some apparent break in the cosmic mechanism, of which the Other Fellow is the victim. You do not laugh when you yourself sit down where there is no chair. Laughter is always aimed at a person or a thing; you smile with people and you laugh at them.
Mothers do not laugh; they smile.
The Little Boy in Bavaria
There was a street near my hotel in Munich, in ante-bellum days, where I used to walk and take the air. It was there I met the little boy in Bavaria. The first time I saw him he was a wet-eyed boy sitting on a stone ledge. I walked past him; then I turned back and said, “Good morning.” He was very polite. He bowed and said to me, “Good morning, sir.” I requested him not to call me sir, but doctor.
“Are you a doctor?” he asked, suspiciously.
“Certainly; I am a tear doctor,” I replied. It was the next day, or perhaps the day after, we agreed he should call me “Old Doctor Philo,” though I wasn’t keen on the adjective. However, I became his Old Doctor Philo, and we met nearly every day and discussed affairs in general, and I learned many things. One day we were walking near his house when he said abruptly—after emitting a long breath: “Well, I must go in and see my father.”
“Good,” I said, “so I will leave you here.”
“Oh, please,” said the little boy in Bavaria, “come with me, for I must go in and see my father.”
One of the dirty trinity was tugging at him, and it was not sentimentality; it was fear.
“Oh, please,” and he put his arm up round my waist, and led me into the house. He was a very young boy, slim and gentle, tall for his age, with a white face and serious eyes. I did not know his father then, though all the world knows him, for he is a very famous man, many times a doctor, omnifarian doctus, a scientist and scholar. That day—I see him as though in a picture—he sat in a big chair with a tall back, beside a little round table littered with books and papers. He was a long, thin man, with a studious face and a partly bald head; what hair he had was gray and yellow, and that was the color of his thick, straggling mustache; he was dressed in gray clothes, and his long legs—ending in gray slippers—stuck out straight before him. We entered the room softly, the boy in Bavaria pressing close to my side, with one arm round my waist. The learned man half turned his head, and eyed us over the back of the chair. What he said was: “Ah! I suppose this is your ‘Old Doctor Philo.’”
And with that, out of the gray-and-yellow man there came a blast of laughter, so merry, so hard and gay, so cold and hostile to humanity, that the boy in Bavaria wilted up against me in sheer physical chill.
Then I understood.
I understood why a boy sat wet-eyed on a stone ledge in Bavaria; I understood why he said: “Oh, please, I must go in and see my father.” That scientist, that portent of a man, had a sense of humor, which is an awful thing for a man of science to have. He laughed because childhood was not identically like his manhood; he laughed at childhood’s amusing ignorance of the cosmic system—its hopeful way of sitting down where there is no chair; and, laughing, he was gloriously aware that he was wiser than the childhood at which he laughed.
Have you ever been laughed at by a scientist?
Then you know the fierce, deep, and blighting power of laughter.
It is all very well to laugh and have the world laugh with you, as in the famous song, if you and thep. 4 world are not laughing at the Other Fellow—at his tragic endeavors to sit down where there is no chair.
Gayety of heart is charming; the joy of life that bubbles over is wholesome; but they have nothing to do with the laughter aimed at men and things. There is bitter cruelty in laughing at men, and to laugh at cosmic mechanism is sheer idiocy. Wherefore have a care of your laughter: if you are laughing because you are alive, it is all right; but if you are laughing because the Other Fellow has fallen on his nose, it is all wrong. There was once a man named Zeuxis; they showed him a portrait of an old woman—the poor old face fatigued by the years, the dim, watery eyes, the toothless mouth,—all the scantness and tremor of age were pictured there; and Zeuxis, looking at the portrait, laughed himself to death—and the world was better, cleaner, richer for his going. His was the bad kind of laughter. I have no words fierce enough to blast it with. The man who would laugh in an old woman’s home, would find something to laugh at in the nursery—and that is falling into the abyss of cynicism.
More and more, as I go through life, I try to wean myself from laughing at the Other Fellow—even when he is fat.
Even when—like the little boy in Bavaria—he is sentimental.
It is a lesson I learned from listening at nursery doors.—“Take It from Me,” by Vance Thompson.