What Business Men Have to Say of Boys

3%

Review and Herald Publishing Assn. · Takoma Park Station, Washington, D. C. · Jan 3, 1911

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 59, No. 1.

Read the full edition

What Business Men Have to Say of Boys

A RECENT number of Good Housekeeping devoted considerable space to a symposium on the boy problem. Leading business men and noted educators talked plainly and wisely of the faults of the average present-day boy, and pointed out some of the things that prevent the boy from measuring up to the business man’s standard for him as a factor in the business world.
The following paragraphs, taken from this symposium, will be of interest to all sensible, ambitious boys, as well as to those who have the responsibility of helping to prepare the boy for his place in the work of the world.

Need of Home Duties

Mr. William Orr, deputy commissioner of education, State of Massachusetts, says:—
From my observation there is serious danger because, through the increase of wealth and the artificial conditions of city life, many boys are not given the every-day tasks in connection with the home that develop a right sense of responsibility. The duties set for boys of an earlier generation had an educative value in putting a youth upon his own resources to accomplish results with the tools and means at his command. Out of such experience came initiative,—ability to meet new situations,—and a determination to accomplish one’s purpose. The virtue of thrift was inculcated, because the boy came to understand what it meant in the shape of time and labor to gain money.
The schools are, through various activities, undertaking to make up in some measure for the loss of such training and discipline; but at the best, the schools can do but little to take the place of the home and of parental oversight and authority.
It is highly important if boys are to grow into men, vigorous in body and resourceful in mind, that this home training should once more find a place in the education of our youth.

Hard Knocks Are Salutary

Mr. Herbert Myrick, president of Good Housekeeping, says:—
Necessity is the mother of effort. Experience is the great teacher. The poor boy or girl who is forced to struggle—not too hard, however—has a certain advantage over the children of well-to-do parents. Emerson uttered a great truth when he wrote, “Cast the bantling on the rocks.” The youth so reared as not to be obliged to work finds it difficult to get work if he really desires it. He goes to school and college until he is twenty or twenty-four, only to find that he has then to learn how to work. Under such conditions, this is not so easy as it would have been four or six years earlier. Such boys should have at least one year of hard work and varied effort between high school and college. The job, preferably, should be one that will put them up against all sorts of people. Except in a few sensory pursuits, a boy or a man must know human nature and how to handle it, if he is to “get along.”
A fond father brought his son of eighteen to consult with me about the boy’s preparation for the ministry. The father did all the talking until I asked him to keep still, and let the boy speak for himself. He was a guileless lad, had always been at school, had failed to get any experience to reveal his bent, and his only predilection for the sacred profession was that “pa wants me to be a preacher.”
“Young man,” I said, “go peddle papers in the slums and in the back country districts. Learn how people live, love, hate, hope, trust, and distrust, their joys and sorrows, ups and downs—how to get next; how to earn their confidence. If you learn how to sell a good periodical, you will find this knowledge of practical value when you undertake to sell them religion, law, or medicine, or bricks, beads, or brocades. Go direct from school to college and theological seminary, and seven years hence you will issue forth long on theology but short on common sense. Get some ‘ginger’ and ‘horse sense’ in your make-up now, by hard knocks among all sorts of people. This experience will be the ‘liberal education’ you need to supplement your book studies. It will so broaden your mind, expand your comprehension, quicken your sympathies, enlighten your soul, as to almost double the value of any college course that follows, and this whether you come out a preacher, farmer, or mechanic.”
Each boy is different, but all should get a variety of experiences sufficient to develop their natural bent, then train along the line of special capacity. How frequent the awful tragedy—the man who barely exists in some vocation only to find, when too late in life to change, that nature endowed him with talents that would have won recognition in another field! I do not refer to mere money-getting, which, while important to a degree, is by no means the measure of true success.
Youth deprived of the chance to overcome obstacles, who do not have to struggle, must be exceptional beings to make up in other ways for this lack in their evolution. The boy who earns his automobile, or builds it himself, is more likely to be a credit to himself, an honor to his parents, and an asset to the state, than the lad whose doting parents give him a gilded machine, with perhaps a too-much gilded chauffeur to go with it. Sugar-teats make babies, not men. The infant suckled by a virile mother, whose childhood is guided by a wise father, who learns to do by doing as well as by studying books, who gets some knocks from nature at eight to sixteen,—such a youth, boy or girl, has a tremendous advantage over the merely pampered.

No Sense of Obligation

The pointed words which follow are from the treasurer of a great manufacturing concern known to every reader:—
We have had hundreds of boys in our office, and have kept in close touch with them and their development; as a result, we have a pretty well-settled conviction that the average boy is not looking for an opportunity to succeed. He is looking for the largest immediate money return, rather than for an opportunity to get a training that will increase his earning power for the future. Unfortunately, he frequently assumes that attitude under parental guidance.
We have also noticed that the average boy has no sense of his obligation to his employer. It seems that only one out of every hundred has had any instructions or training at home as to what is due his employer when he enters a business office. He is lacking in application, in concentration, is jealous of his hours of work, and resents any necessity of remaining after hours as an encroachment upon his vested rights, so to speak. He seems to be controlled by one principle,—to give the least he can, and get the most.
We are sure there is room for improvement in many of the boys to-day who have recently entered business offices; and if they could be taught in their early years, while they are receiving their training, that there is a truer measure of success than the money compensation, we are sure their ultimate success would be greater, and their lives made richer and happier.
Of course there are exceptions. We do not wish to create the impression that all the boys fall short. We have had some very excellent ones who have measured up to their own opportunities and to our expectations in a most satisfactory way; but we regret to be compelled to state that our experience has not developed a very high regard for the great majority of boys who are found in business offices to-day.

Indolent, Insolent Town Boys

The following words from the treasurer of the Baird-North Company, of Providence, Rhode Island, are well worth considering by the boy who has a desire to make a real success of life:—
“What sort of boys do we like in our employ?” We like solid boys—boys who have at least a faint idea of what they are living for; boys who are frank and honest; boys who are not afraid of work; boys of high ideals, who are as anxious for promotion as we are anxious to see them succeed; boys who will accept responsibility; who can and will “deliver the goods.”
(Concluded on page nine)
  • (Concluded from page three)*
We certainly find in boys a lack of responsibility, a lack of reliability, a lack of stamina, a lack of any sense whatever of the rights of others. In short, the average town boy to-day is a mighty poor proposition. He is indolent, insolent, and hopelessly care free. He will not accept responsibility, and will not work unless he is strenuously supervised.
The reason is traceable, I believe, to the home. The town boy has nothing to do, and busies himself about it always. About all he accomplishes is to develop sharp practices and a disposition to avoid anything that resembles work or responsibility. He becomes an artist in the fineness of deceptive practices.
When we have work for boys, we hire men to do it, because it is cheaper and more satisfactory.
The only boy that we can employ with any satisfaction is the country-bred boy,—the boy who has had his chores to do, his responsibilities to carry from day to day. The country boy has health, strength, and courage. He has more manhood to the square inch than the city-bred boy has to the square acre. The very nature of his surroundings places upon him responsibilities. He must face situations and pass judgment upon propositions, and the responsibility, I believe, lies with the parents.
As a last word, take that from Mr. W. L. Park, vice-president of the Illinois Central Railroad, who says:—
The essentials to success necessary to inculcate in a boy by parents and teachers are not numerous or difficult,—honesty, neatness, punctuality, and reliability, with a training otherwise which impels involuntary submission to discipline. This, with a general ambition to succeed, is sufficient to carry a boy as high as his mental capacity and physical capabilities will permit.
He must make subservient to his own personal comfort the needs of the service he enters, go when and where he is sent, always cheerfully.
He will probably need to attract attention if he rises high, by a superabundance of loyalty and fidelity; a willingness to render more service than paid for; to do better work than others, and more of it. To bring himself to do that which is generally considered obnoxious by his fellow employees requires independence of character and self-denial.
Parents can well keep these things in mind in training their boys, as the difficulties they will encounter in this respect are becoming greater as our social conditions change.