The Red Triangle Work

7%

Review and Herald Publishing Assn. · Takoma Park Station, Washington, D. C. · May 27, 1919

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 67, No. 21.

Read the full edition

The Red Triangle Work

It is so easy to find fault that anybody can do it if given half a chance, and many if given no chance at all. It is so easy that even if the occasion offers some opportunity for dissatisfaction people do not stop to consider the circumstances that are responsible for the unsatisfactory condition. They do not consider whether those apparently at fault are battling with conditions they are powerless to remedy, and so need the faultfinder’s sympathy rather than his criticism in their efforts to serve him.
The war experience of the Young Men’s Christian Association is perhaps as pertinent a general illustration of this fact as can be cited. Of course everything was not altogether satisfactory at the triangle huts, but the Y. M. C. A. made an honest and heroic effort to serve the soldier boys. The boys are free to tell their side of the story whenever they find occasion to do so, why not hear the Y. M. C. A. version of this stupendous phase of the great war service?
The transportation and distribution of 100,000,000 pounds of supplies at a cost of nearly $25,000,000, the providing of pianos, Victrolas, books, and movies for entertainment at many places, was no small task. Mr. Frank W. Ober summarizes this great work, given over by the Government to the Y. M. C. A., in the following words:
“With high purpose the association took on the canteen service in France. It had always been a sore spot and an embarrassment to the army. We did not fully know what we were undertaking nor the difficulty of service in the whirlwind of war—the cataleptic fury of war, the 4,000 miles of transport, the mêlée of camps, the mutations of personnel, the insatiable and unreasonable demands of soldiers, and the knowledge that the post exchange was always the popular grouch of men to whom grouching was a habit. Think of running a thousand Butler stores, or following circus tents from town to town with lemonade stands and chocolate bars, or of rivaling all of the United cigar stores, or of marketing the output of five chocolate factories! Or of setting up grocery stores in the face of mobs under martial law in a mining camp—all to be supplied by trucks over shell-swept roads!

Two Thousand Cups of Chocolate on Call

“Quite a task for a noncommercial, nonmilitary organization to innocently undertake overnight! A Jim Hill or a McAdoo might have hesitated. That the association has come out of it fifty per cent creditably is a miracle, yet 22,000 to 100,000 men have been served every week over single counters, and still men keep coming. The first call on arriving in town has been for the Y. M. C. A. canteen. We saw a queue of 600 men in one place waiting to be served when the supplies arrived. Sometimes when the army stores gave out, 2,000 cups of chocolate were furnished on call. Men and women have broken under the attempt to do the impossible 4,000 miles away from home.
Yesterday we viewed the wrecks of huts conducted by the British in Ypres and Dickebush—that most awful cataclysm of the war. Here 87 huts where men had ministered in the acme of frenzied devotion to their fellows were completely destroyed. On every side were gaping shell holes. They had lived amidst the diabolism and carnage, and thought the service fully worth the risk of their lives. True, they had been so occupied that there was scant time for preaching, yet their acts spoke a Christ-kindness. Impotent to get the goods up despite the Herculean efforts of the transport drivers, our men smarted under the criticism of failure to meet the wants of men to the full.
“And feeling that the canteen has supplanted the higher purposes of maintaining morale, it may not be strange that the Regional Association secretaries in France raised the question if the canteen service was worth while and if it could not be abandoned. Yet they stayed to see it through. As we write, enough transportation cannot be secured, even in armistice days, to half meet the demands. Our men were misunderstood by soldiers who could not be assured that the association had not taken on the business to make money. They have been charged with graft, although the prices were usually less than in the home cities. This sacrificial work may have been mistakenly undertaken and in cases inefficiently conducted, but in the end it will be found a credit to the enterprise and devotion of those who took it on.

Dissatisfaction at Home—to Be Expected Abroad

“Can any man run a hotel at home without dissatisfaction on the part of some? The association at Coblenz, operating as the headquarters of the Army of Occupation, runs ten hotels and restaurants serving thousands of meals a day—every meal offering a chance for complaint because of a cold plate, a hair in the soup, or the discourtesy of a servant. And how about clean sheets and towels for 2,000 men a day? Or finding fault with the ‘shows’ every night for 36,000 men in this town, or the continuous movies at one of its commandeered theaters, or picking flaws in the running of the 36 canteens conducted for the insatiable, restless troops about this city? Or finding a chance for comment in the scores of games of baseball or basketball; or the educational program, already serving 2,000 men? Yet these men seemed happy. The streets were empty and the buildings were crowded. These ten hotels, and the restaurants, theaters, and 36 canteens were commandeered by the Government and given over to the association for army service. The association equipped and manned them.
“Business began when the troops entered Coblenz. We found the vast building, the ‘Festehalle,’ which we visited the other night, seething with 4,000 vigorous men. An orchestra played constantly in one hall seating 1,000 men, a show was on in the big hall seating 2,500 more. The American Library Association gave out 300 books a day, some 100,000 francs were deposited for sending home. In another building 2,100 meals were served, with ‘pie à la mode’ galore! The 36 association centers had more than 15,000 guests every day in Coblenz alone. Think of the task of calling together 400 secretaries, thirteen groups of entertainers from overseas, and rushing them to the Rhine within a few days, not to speak of engaging and organizing this force of capable secretaries and a force of 300 local foreign-speaking helpers.
“Coblenz is also the center for association service with the 300,000 troops of occupation located in over 300 points and towns. Think of the supplies needed for the canteens alone! In ten days 78 carloads were received and sent out by the 100 automobiles. In the equipment were 100 pianos, 350 Victrolas, and 400 musical instruments. There have been sent out 50,000 books and 20,000 magazines, and 4,500,000 sheets of writing paper. The program offered was so full and compact that a lecturer could not be squeezed in for two weeks!”
In view of the almost incomprehensible work that the Y. M. C. A. attempted for the soldier boys, surely it is hardly praiseworthy for those for whom the service was undertaken and maintained, much less for those who were allowed to remain at home, amid plenty and comfort, to find fault because of inadequacies of service at certain points. Should we not the rather express appreciation for the miracle accomplished and forget the small inefficiencies that all regretted but none could prevent? F. D. C.