WHEN the chemist speaks of a “test,” he means “a procedure or reaction employed to recognize or distinguish any particular substance or constituent of a compound.” Thus there is, for instance, the iodine test for starch, and the acid test for gold.
This latter phrase, “the acid test,” is frequently employed in a figurative sense in connection with character.
“Yes, he is all right,” the remark may be heard; “the acid test was applied to him, and he came out pure gold.”
A merchant determined to apply an acid test to the young men in his employ. For some time it had been known in the establishment that there was to be a promotion to a position of unusual responsibility. A dozen employees thought longingly of the tempting position; half as many felt they had a good chance to win. It was generally agreed, however, that there were but two real possibilities. One of these, Lawton, was a quiet, unassuming young man who for more than five years had been doing good work for his employer.
“But I fear he doesn’t stand as much of a show as Nelson,” an interested bystander said; “he isn’t self-assertive enough. He is conscientious, capable, and dependable, but he doesn’t take pains to impress himself on the rest of us as he should. Nelson never allows us to forget his presence and his worth. Lawton needs to be more like him. To tell the truth, though, there isn’t much choice between them. I am glad I don’t have to make the difficult decision.”
The merchant, also, found the choice difficult. At length he realized that the two were so evenly matched that he must have additional light before he could decide between them. He resolved to make a character test. He wondered how he was to do this, until he learned that Lawton and Nelson, who had been good friends, were growing apart. After a time, he decided that the fault was Nelson’s, for Nelson was saying bitter things about Lawton, and Lawton was saying nothing about Nelson. So far, he thought, Lawton was proving himself the better man. But here was an opportunity for a further testing of both men.
One day the merchant went to Nelson.
“What do you think of Lawton’s fitness for more responsible service, Nelson?” he asked.
The reply came instantly:
“I fear he could not give satisfaction; he is good as far as he goes, but he cannot go far.”
Next, Lawton was approached, and to him was put the same question as to Nelson’s fitness for promotion. After a moment’s hesitation, the answer was made:
“I think well of him. I feel sure he has ability for many things for which he has not been tested.”
Why was this an acid test? Why did the merchant choose Lawton for the position? Why was he right?
It is told of President Hayes that he once recommended for a position a man who had talked outrageously about him.
“How could you do it?” asked a friend. “Do you know what that man thinks about you?”
“Oh, yes,” answered Hayes, “but they asked me what I thought of him, not his opinion of me.”
Of course it is difficult to be fair in expressing our opinion of one who has seemed to be unfair to us. But can we afford to be unfair simply because we have been treated unfairly? Are we willing to take a place beside the young man of whom the author of a recent story told, the man who “couldn’t for the life of him understand that his personal feeling toward a man should not under any circumstances make any difference in his judgment of the man”?
But a critical world expects just this of a man. Can we demand less of ourselves?—Selected.