Government Monopolies

14%

Review and Herald Publishing Assn. · Takoma Park Station, Washington, D. C. · Jan 31, 1911

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 59, No. 5.

Read the full edition

Government Monopolies

The French government is confronted with a peculiar difficulty. Just now, when it needs all the money it can get for working men's pensions and other reforms it is threatened with the loss of one of its important revenues, that derived from the match monopoly. It might be supposed that tobacco and matches, in spite of their comparatively recent introduction as luxuries, had become necessities to so large a proportion of the population that a government which monopolized both was in possession of an assured income. Every cigar and pipeful involves the use of a match, probably more than one if they are of government manufacture, besides those that are used for the ignition of better things than tobacco, such as candles and kindling-wood. But the match is in danger of losing its own monopoly. The electric light, whether suspended from wires or carried in the pocket, requires no match, and self-lighting attachments of spongy platinum or some cheaper material are being put on gas-jets.
The most recent and dangerous rival of the match is, however, the new cerium alloy of iron, which, on being struck or even gently scratched, gives off a shower of brilliant sparks. The pocket cigar lighters now made in Germany for the use of the new metal are hardly larger than a match-box, and rarely require to be replenished. No poisonous phosphorus, no scratching on walls or trousers, no blowing out in the wind, no sulphurous odor, no danger of fire from matches thrown down. It is a curious reversion to the older form of striking a light, the use of flint and steel, except that the flint is replaced by cerium-iron. Such cases of atavism are not uncommon in the history of invention. The earliest bicycles had two wheels of equal size. These were abandoned for the high wheel with a little wheel trailing behind or running in front, but in a few years we restored them to their former equality. The first cars propelled by engines used the common highway, and now, after having run on rails for half a century, they come back to the road.
The match should celebrate its centenary in 1927, but it begins to look as if it would not live to see it. At any rate, the French government, alarmed at the threatened extinction of the match, is making violent efforts to prevent the invasion of this rival from over the Rhine. It is against the law to sell the cerium lighters or even to own them, and strangers who openly display the new playthings are liable to get into trouble. Nevertheless, it is impossible to keep them out altogether. They are surreptitiously slipped into one's hand on the boulevards like indecent post-cards.
The search for matches at the French frontier has long been one of the vexations of the tourist. Last summer the custom-house officers found a dozen matches in the pocket of an American tourist, and imposed a fine of a franc apiece for them, a rate of $2.40 a dozen. He tried to throw them away, but that was against the law. To give them to the inspectors, it seemed, was bribery; to burn them on the spot, arson. So he paid his fine, and then demanded the matches, saying that he had to have them in France. “Why?” asked the judge. “To light the French matches with,” was the reply.
The bather who wants to take a bottle of sea-water must first get a government permit. One would think that there was enough water left in the ocean. One might object that France does not own all the salt water of the world anyway. But there is the danger that the bottleful of water might be evaporated, and so salt obtained which had not paid the government tax. A French woman who kept a small tobacco shop was recently arrested and fined for selling cigarettes not made of tobacco. They were not sold with intent to deceive. They were presumably less injurious, being free from nicotine. But their use would cut down the government revenue. The raising of tobacco is restricted to certain localities in France; and in Spain, where it is also a government monopoly, it is almost all imported, notwithstanding there is an abundance of good tobacco land in Spain. But if it were grown freely somebody might roll up a leaf and smoke it on the sly.
In the United States the manufacture of matches and tobacco is also practically monopolized, but there is this difference, that the government does not get the profit of the business.—The Independent.