AdventAI

The Young Man Who Resigned

By George Horace Latimer

From The Youth’s Instructor, Vol. LI, No. 21, May 28, 1903

A merchant pointed out to a new stenographer the other day several serious and wholly inexcusable mistakes which he had made. The stenographer colored at the first word of the lecture, and waited impatiently—and without listening—until it was ended. Then he resigned.

“Why do you resign?” asked the merchant.

“Because I won’t let any man take advantage of his power as an employer, and speak harshly to me.”

“What did I say?” asked the merchant.

“I don’t know just what it was. I only know you were jumping on me about my work.”

“Why did you leave the position you had before you came to us?” asked the merchant.

“For the same reason that I’m leaving here. The man thought he could jump on me just because I was an employee,” was the reply.

“But didn’t you make any mistakes? Was your work perfect?”

“Of course I made mistakes. Nobody is perfect.”

“Then you don’t permit any one to speak to you of your mistakes?”

“I don’t think harshness is the way to help a man to get along.”

“And you regard any form of reproof as harshness?”

The stenographer was silent.

“The only talk about your work that you will listen to is praise?”

The stenographer was silent.

“You can’t see that praise is not of the slightest value to you, that criticism is invaluable?”

The stenographer was silent.

“You can’t see that by speaking to you of your mistakes, I was showing myself to be your friend; that if I had passed over your mistakes, I should have been doing you an injury?”p. 2

The stenographer was silent.

“Don’t you think you’d better give me another trial?” asked the merchant.

“Yes,” said the stenographer. But he resigned again within a week, and was let go.

At first blush every employee who reads this story will scoff at this stenographer as an unusual example of inordinate vanity. But—isn’t the story worth thinking about? Is this stenographer so unusual, after all? Is such vanity rare, or is it only his courage of it that is rare?

It was by ambition that the angels fell. It is by self-excuse that men fall.

A very great man once said that no man had ever yet lifted his head so much as an inch above the mass of his fellows who had not the power of self-criticism—the ability to see his own faults either on his own initiative, or when some friend or foe pointed them out. The smaller kinds of superior men close their ears against their enemies, but learn when their friends are venturesome enough to criticise them. The larger kinds of superior men learn much from the frankness of friends, more from the fierce and scorching criticism of their unintentionally friendly foes. And on the day that a man ceases to be capable of self-criticism, ceases to be tolerant and eager for criticism from without, on that day his undoing begins.

Again and again you hear it said of a man, “He has reached his limit.” What does that mean? In every case, close study of the man and his career will show that he has reached that stage at which self-exaltation has succeeded in silencing self-criticism.

Study the man who works beside you. Study the man who was promoted the first of the year. Study the man who wasn’t—especially if he happens to be yourself. This is not a world of chance, but of causation. There was a “why” for the one man’s promotion, another “why” for the other man’s dismissal or failure to advance.

What the world most needs is not alms or crutches, but more friendly criticism, more self-criticism.

The place to begin to correct the evils in the social system is with the one member of it who is wholly under your control. Other corrections can wait. That one can’t. —George Horace Latimer, in Saturday Evening Post.