“UNITED STATES” IS SINGULAR

20%

Review and Herald Publishing Company · Battle Creek, Mich. · January 16, 1902

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. L, No. 3

Read the full edition

“UNITED STATES” IS SINGULAR

In his recently published work on “A Century of American Diplomacy,” General John W. Foster, former Secretary of State, uses the singular verb in connection with the United States, and is called to account therefor by a prominent critic, who admonishes him that “to make United States a singular noun would require an amendment to the Federal Constitution.”
Mr. Foster has spent considerable time and labor in making an investigation of this subject, and concludes from all the testimony he has been able to gather that the point is not well taken.
“I have found,” said Mr. Foster, recently, “that in the early days of the republic the prevailing practice was the use of the plural, but even then many public men employed the singular, and of late years the latter has become the rule. Among statesmen who have habitually used the singular verb are: Hamilton, Jefferson, Seward, Blaine, Edmunds, E. J. Phelps, Webster, Benton, Fish, Frelinghuysen, Motley, Reid, Gresham, Silas Wright, Marcy, Evarts, Bayard, Charles Francis Adams, Depew, Olney.
“Of living professors of international law, Woolsey, of Yale; Moore, of Columbia; Huffcut, of Cornell; and James C. Carter, of New York, use the singular. Andrew Jackson was the first president to adopt the singular verb in his official papers. In the earlier messages of the presidents the plural form is usually found; but since Lincoln, all of them, including Grant, Cleveland, Harrison, and McKinley, have invariably used the singular. In the decisions of the Supreme Court during the first half-century the plural form is generally used, but the singular appears occasionally. In later years the court has used the singular. The same remark applies to treaties with foreign nations.”— Chicago Record-Herald.