WAS HE THE SON OF A KING?

8%

Review and Herald Publishing Company · Battle Creek, Mich. · February 27, 1902

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. L, No. 9

Read the full edition

WAS HE THE SON OF A KING?

Among the victims of the Reign of Terror in France,—that “Red Terror” which proclaimed that there was no God in heaven, and which set up the dripping guillotine as the emblem of liberty, and made earth a bloody shamble,—it is hard to decide who was the most innocent and helpless sufferer of all. Yet in the end all readers agree, I think, upon the supreme pathos of the little dauphin’s fate. Born a mighty prince, surrounded by homage and luxury from infancy, nurtured tenderly by a passionately loving mother, and endowed with unusual intelligence and sweetness of character, this loving and lovable child, only seven years old, was taken away, after his father’s execution, from his mother and his little sister (afterward the Duchesse d’Angoulême), never to see them again. From the despair and terror of this last parting, little Louis was brought to conditions more miserable still. His keeper, a brutal Jacobin cobbler, named Simon, beat and ill-treated him, made him drunk, taught him blasphemous oaths and bad language, and sought to corrupt his mind and disease his body.
At night, when the exhausted child fell asleep, the cruel cobbler would cry out in his ear, and wake him with a start, until at last his nerves gave way, and he gradually fell into an imbecile condition. Simon beat him upon the face in such a way as to leave two noticeable scars. For the last six months of the captive child’s life he was silent, stupefied, dying by inches of scrofula. His keepers had been changed at the time of the fall of Robespierre, and the new ones were kinder than Simon had been; but the boy never revived, and died, a physical and moral wreck, not quite two years after Marie Antoinette had clasped him, in that despairing parting, in her arms.
I must confess that, at first, when I thought the dauphin had died thus in his prison, I never could bear to read his story. It was too terrible, too hopeless,—this anguish of a little, tender child. But soon I learned that there was a strange sequel, which put a different aspect upon it all. This story is, briefly, that the child who lived those last sad months in the prison was not killed by ill-treatment, but suffered from a disease of long standing, which would have brought him to the grave in spite of any care; that it was not the dauphin at all; and that little Louis—though Simon’s treatment had indeed made his mind a blank for a while—was rescued by the substitution of this sick child, and taken safely to America, where he soon recovered his reason, and lived a long, useful, and happy life.
Now, at first sight this seems impossible. Would Robespierre, having sent the king and queen of France to the guillotine, allow the heir to the throne to escape? Why should he go to America if he did escape? Why did not his uncle, Louis the Eighteenth, when he came to the throne, hunt up the true heir? and so on, through many other natural questions. But the story, as it goes on, answers each question so well that we can not help being impressed by it.
In the first place, it was the fall of Robespierre that opened the way for the child’s escape. It is a fact that the very night of his triumph over Robespierre, the republican leader, Barras, went to the prison to see the child, and that the next day he changed the keepers. Suddenly, just after this, no one but the new keeper was allowed to see the boy for some time, and all the attendants in that part of the prison were also changed. A friend of Barras, it is proved, went to America on a secret mission about this time. A doctor who had seen the dauphin before this, was called in to attend the sick child, and did not recognize him; he imprudently said so, and died very suddenly and mysteriously just afterward. The child’s death, in 1795, was at first kept a secret, and the body was buried hurriedly with no one about who could identify it. The young Duchesse d’Angoulême, the only surviving member of the family of Louis the Sixteenth, never believed that her brother had died in the Temple; and it is said on good authority that Josephine, Napoleon’s queen, who had known Barras intimately in Revolutionary days, asserted in 1814 that the dauphin had escaped, and was living in obscurity. So much for the French side of the story.
The American side is even more interesting. In 1794, in the times when New England was struggling with the Indian wars, a band of savages attacked the town of Deerfield, in Massachusetts, and carried away captive the Reverend John Williams and his family to Canada. All the family were ransomed and brought back in the end, except one daughter, Eunice, who married an Indian chief. Her daughter, Mary, married an English surgeon; but their son, Thomas Williams, cast in his lot with his grandfather’s tribe, married an Indian woman, and brought up his large family in Indian fashion. In his wigwam, however, there was one strange inmate,—a fair-haired boy, entirely unlike the other children, whom report said had been brought to the little Indian village by a Frenchman, and given into Thomas Williams’s care. It is certain that every six months a sum of money was sent from some source to Williams for this child.
The boys of this Indian family were an object of interest to the Williams family in Deerfield, and they offered to help in their education. Thomas accordingly sent two of them—his eldest son, John, and the fair-haired boy, who was known as Eleazer—to Massachusetts to be educated. John’s bills were paid by the relatives, but a remittance came half-yearly to Eleazer through an agent unknown. John would not study, and had to be sent home; Eleazer was very intelligent, and became a great favorite. He told his friends in New England that the first years of his life were a blank to him; and that the Indians said he was an idiot when brought to them, but that he had recovered his reason by diving from a high rock, at thirteen years of age, and striking his head so violently as to become insensible. When he again became conscious, his mind was restored.
Still, he had a few mysterious memories. He said he had been in great pain in his childhood, only he could not remember how it came. He had two scars on his face, which were connected in his mind with something painful that had happened to him. By all accounts, he was a most truthful and high-minded lad, and it astonished no one when he decided to study for the ministry. The Indians of the tribe were all Roman Catholics, but Eleazer became an earnest Protestant. He studied for his chosen work until the war of 1812 broke out. Then he became superintendent-general of the Northern Indian Department, in the service of the United States. He fought on the American side at Plattsburg, and was wounded. General Lewis Cass became very friendly to him, and wrote of him to the Secretary of War: “He is a gentleman of education and talents, and can render important services to the government and the Indians.”
But Eleazer Williams had no political ambitions. His services to the Indians were to be of a higher kind. After the war he finished his studies, and, after ten years of missionary work among his people, he was ordained in 1826, and took up the work at Green Bay, on the Indian reservation. He had married a beautiful and amiable French girl, who was related to the French general, Jourdan. In his little home, bare and plain, he also welcomed his aged Indian foster-mother, and cared for her until her death.
In 1841, when Louis Philippe was on the throne of France (a king elected by the people, and therefore apparently secure of his title aside from the fact that he descended from the Bourbons), he sent his son, the Prince de Joinville, to America. To the surprise of everybody, as soon as the ship reached America, the prince, with only a small retinue, went to western New York. It was given out that he was on a hunting trip. He sought out the Protestant missionary, Eleazer Williams, and invited him to a private interview at his rooms in the hotel at Green Bay. At that interview, so the clergyman asserted, the prince informed him that he was not an Indian, but a Frenchman, and the son of a king. He then asked him to sign a document, which Williams read over, written in parallel columns of French and English; it was an act of abdication, with this condition: that a large amount of property should be made over to the signer as a compensation for the loss of the throne. Although dazed and wondering, the clergyman utterly refused to sign. The next day the prince sought him out again, but received another refusal. Then they parted, de Joinville showing unusual respect, as to one of equal or superior rank, and saying, “Though we part, I trust we part friends.”
The Indian missionary had no thought whatever of claiming a kingdom. He did not even tell his wife about it at first, but from that moment he became anxious to find out his true history. No further light came to him, however, until 1848, when a letter came from Baton Rouge, stating that a Frenchman, named Bellenger, had made a deathbed confession of having brought the dauphin, son of Louis the Sixteenth, from France years before, and placed him among the Indians at the north. This seemed to complete the chain of evidence, and Eleazer Williams, from that day, firmly believed himself to be the dauphin. He realized entirely, however, that as a Protestant and an obscure missionary in a far-away land, he had no possibility of ever getting his royal rights; and he never attempted to press them. He went on with patient zeal in his work of the ministry, and lived and died a consistent Christian missionary, content among many privations, and useful and beloved among his people. The testimony of all who knew him is conclusive that he was not one who would have made any claim he did not thoroughly believe to be true, or describe in detail an interview such as the one with de Joinville, which had never taken place. He died in 1858, aged seventy-three.
Was he, then, Louis the Seventeenth, the Dauphin of the Temple prison? The question is one of those puzzles which history sets forth, but does not solve. For my part, I believe that the dauphin escaped, and did not die in his dreary captivity; and I like to think that, far from that royalty which had been so fatal a possession to his parents, the lovely boy whom Marie Antoinette had so loved became a noble man, lived a useful, consecrated life, untroubled by storms of state, and died in peace and honor.—Priscilla Leonard, in the Well Spring.