AdventAI

Is a Horse a Horse?

By L. T. Curtis

From The Youth’s Instructor, Vol. LI, No. 1, January 1, 1903

If I were to point out a horse, and tell you confidently it is a cheval, you, as bright boys and girls, would tell me I was mistaken, and should I further insist that I was right in calling this commonplace quadruped by that queer name, and challenge you to prove the horse to be a horse indeed, the only reason you could possibly give would be that your father, and grandfather, and all your relations, as well as their relations, and in fact, all the people in the world who call themselves English, have called that particular animal a horse all their lives; and so you naturally conclude that the only one truly appropriate word by which to point out that animal, as you have before insisted, is “horse.”

But if, on the other hand, I should insist that my father, and grandfather, together with all my relations, and their relations, and, in fact, all the French nation have from remote times called that four-footed beast cheval, there is a possibility that your faith would be shaken in the idea that “horse” was the original name given that animal by Adam at the creation of the world, and that no other name than “horse” could with truth apply to that animal. And further, you might be led to wonder whether any one of the several hundred names by which the various peoples of the earth speak of a horse, was the one our first parent gave to that noble animal.

And what is true concerning this word is true also with reference to any other word, or letter used to spell that word. If I were asked to prove that a is a, the only proof that I or anybody else could give would be that the English-speaking people had agreed to adopt that character, and give it the name of a, and allow it to represent half a dozen elementary sounds of the language. They might just as appropriately have called it ah, or awe, or anything else. Or they might have made a vertical line to be a. For years I, together with a great army of stenographic writers, have been using a heavy dot for a instead of the ordinary character; and it can be demonstrated that the dot is as truly a as the more complicated figure.

Now by all this extended illustration, I wish to make emphatic this fact: that the truth of a thing is in the thing itself, and not in the name. Names of things come into being as fashions do, and differ in different localities as fashions differ. A word is but an arbitrary representation of an idea, and its only excuse for existing is that it may suggest an idea. The idea is the truth; and if the word is a strange one to me, it is, so far as I am concerned, but an empty sound,—a lifeless, useless, truthless thing.

The word of God is not a thing of life to me unless I can see God in it. And unless I get what is behind the words, I might as well be reading a fairy tale. Some of the commonest words of religious discourse—words which we all use, and think we know—prove, upon careful examination, to carry with them much that is deep and hard to understand. “Faith,” for example, we are apt to regard as a capacity to receive as truth anything hard to believe,—anything beyond the range of ordinary happenings. Yet many fail to get the deeper meaning of the word,—that of the reaching out of an empty hand after God, an inexpressible longing after him in whom we are complete.

Even God himself is to many a Christian but a miracle-working magician, a skilled architect, a great leader of armies, and an awful, uncompassionate judge. But when we come to study Christ’s interpretation of God; when we come to study the universe, in which space is as boundless as eternity; when we come to comprehend that the mightiest sun and the smallest atom obey with mathematical precision the laws that God has set and keeps in operation, he becomes a being altogether too awe-inspiring and sublime to liken to anything human, and yet a being so filled with the most heavenly attribute of humanity that we can joyfully say, with the apostle, “God is love!”

L. T. CURTIS.