Evolution
“We have come now to earth’s topmost round,” remarked President Merriam at the next meeting of the club.
“I wish to ask our naturalists if they have ever found in their researches anything that favors the theory of ‘development;’ that is, higher forms being evolved from lower ones. Such a thing would contradict Moses’ history of creation.”
“On the contrary, Mr. President,” replied the geologist, “my science proves the degeneration of species. Petrifactions show much larger specimens of both plants and animals than are now found in the same localities; men have been exhumed of much larger stature than any now living.”
“And we may reasonably infer that with larger physical frames, their greater vigor produced intellectual and spiritual natures correspondingly superior,” added the president. “Does our chemist know anything that proves development?”
“Nothing whatever, sir,” was the emphatic reply. “There is no way to account for chemical affinities; but there is one thing certain about them, they are immovably fixed. Well is it for us that they are; for if they were subject to change, we could never know what to depend upon. When the cook adds soda to his acid, he might get a bitter; and when he puts his bread into the oven, it would as likely as any other way separate into its original ingredients, instead of baking; and so on, ad infinitum. We should have a ‘chance world’ in earnest.
“New affinities may be discovered, but there is no progression in the fundamental constituents of things, nor has there ever been. The integrity of the world depends on this fact.”
“What about the vegetable kingdom, Miss Ford? Do the grasses ever step up into what we call a higher class?”
“Oh, no, sir. We have progress which makes variety possible, but a species never loses its family characteristics. Cultivation improves the grasses, but never changes them into wheat; an apple-tree never becomes a pear-tree, and no pomologist ever attempts the change. The way is open for endless improvement, but never a change of species.”
“From this standpoint what can the physiologist say of Charles Darwin’s evolution of the human body? Was he right when he taught that at first animals of the lowest type lived in the ocean, having neither heads nor tails; that after a time one crawled on to the land, where he needed a head, so a head grew for him; the other decided he needed a tail, so a tail grew for him? What evidence do you find for such a belief?”
“I call it retrogression. That theory supposes that more wisdom and ability inhered in the creature which had no brain, than is now to be found in any human being. I have personally known men who were greatly dissatisfied with a short stature; so they ‘took thought’ and exerted all their powers; but they could not ‘add to their stature one cubit.’” — Mrs. M. E. Steward.