The Mystery of the False Joan of Arc

6%

Review and Herald Publishing Assn. · Washington, D. C. · September 29, 1903

FromThe Youth's Instructor, Vol. LI, No. 39

Read the full edition

The Mystery of the False Joan of Arc

“A FALSE Joan of Arc!” I hear the reader exclaim, “How could there be one, when every detail of the short life of the Maid of Orleans is known, from her earliest childhood to the moment of her martyrdom at the stake in Rouen?”
Yet a false Joan of Arc there was, and her brothers, Jean and Pierre du Lys, believed in her for six years and more, and so did the whole city of Orleans. Many books have been written in France about this strange personage, and grave French historians have tried to “pluck out the heart of her mystery;” but, as a matter of fact, nobody to-day knows who she was, any more than in 1436, when she first appeared, and convinced the brothers of the Maid that she was their sister, the “Pucelle of France.”
Yet if any fact in history is certain, beyond all doubt, it is that Joan of Arc was burned at the stake in the public square of Rouen on the thirtieth of May, 1431. There is a splendid painting in the Pantheon of Paris of the tragical scene. Bound to the towering stake with iron chains, a white-robed, girlish figure, the heroic Maid stands clasping the cross with both hands, and with her face raised to heaven, rapt and beautiful, as if forgetting the dreadful piles of fagots at her feet, and the rough men at arms who are heaping them higher about her, and waving the torch that is to fire them. Every detail of this painting is attested by history, and thousands of eyes witnessed the martyrdom of this nineteen-year-old peasant maiden of Domremy, whose only crime was that she had saved France. The whole city of Rouen saw her led forth from prison to trial, from trial to stake; and so deep was the sympathy she excited, even in this stronghold of the English power, in France, that as she passed to her death, the multitudes, kneeling and weeping, repeated incessantly the invocation for the dying.
In one short year, Joan of Arc had saved France from the yoke that had crushed the nation for a century of wars; she had raised the siege of Orleans, and crowned the king at the Cathedral of Rheims; and then, for one more year, she had lain in the prison of Rouen, brought to trial after trial, but so clearly innocent that it took the cruelest tricks, at last, to make her even seem guilty enough for her sworn enemies to sentence her. In these trials, every year of her girlish life was gone over, so that we have the most complete biography of her (and all under oath) that exists of any human being.
We know her earliest childhood in Domremy; the forests where she wandered, the fields where she kept the sheep, her spinning wheel, her household tasks, her playmates; we see her listening to her “Voices,” and praying that she might not have to go to the wars, poor little maid! We see her sent at last to the dauphin, in 1429, and telling him a secret revealed by her visions, which was a sign, and after which he put her in command; we see her leading French armies to their first victories in a score of years, relieving Orleans, and crowning the king, in 1429, while thousands crowded to kiss her very feet, or kneel in the path where she had passed. We learn that she was beautiful, and had a wonderful magnetism about her personality, so that the English called her a “witch.” Simple and humble as the Maid of Orleans always was, the people believed her capable of working miracles—which, indeed, her marvelous victories appeared to be. So, when the tidings of her cruel death came to the king and the people of France, there was a great popular hope that in some miraculous way the Maid would come back—that she was not really dead after all. It was the same old belief that has clung about every beloved national deliverer, and it was the firm belief of half of France concerning Joan of Arc.
Besides, the Maid had died in the midst of enemies, and in the English dominions in France, up in the north. There were no telegraphs, no newspapers and special correspondents, in those days. It was only by hearsay that her friends knew of her death,—and why should the traitor English be believed? The miraculous Maid had ways of saving herself from them that none could guess. She might easily have escaped, and be lying in hiding while the English, unwilling to acknowledge her deliverance, burned some other woman in her place—and so on. We need not be surprised, therefore, that when, five years later, a “false Pucelle” appeared in the French domains, she was received with apparently no doubts at all.
But who was this second Maid of Orleans, and where did she learn to counterfeit the true heroine so marvelously? There is where the mystery comes in. In May, 1436, the “Pucelle Jehanne,” as she styled herself, arrived at La Grange aux Ormes, near St. Privay. She was at once taken to see some gentlemen of the town of Metz, near by, and, by chance, next day, the two brothers of Joan of Arc came to Metz, and were naturally anxious to meet her. “They thought that their sister had been burned, but, so soon as they saw her, they recognized her, and she them,” says the old Metz chronicle.
These brothers of the Maid had been ennobled by King Charles in honor of their sister’s deeds, had fought by her side in the wars, and were men of proved bravery and integrity. No ordinary impostor could have so deceived them as did the false Joan. The people of Metz, when the “Pucelle Jehanne” was recognized by these members of her family, were convinced that the Maid of Orleans was among them again, and went wild with joy. Arms, horses, and jewels were given to her, more than she could use, and she was invited into Luxembourg, where nobles and people alike crowded to welcome her. Orleans, when it heard the joyful news, which Joan du Lys, the younger brother, rode home to tell, “bringing letters from La Pucelle,” gave him rich presents, and sent a pursuivant to Luxembourg, to bring the false Joan at once to the city she had saved.
Meanwhile, the “Pucelle” had been sought in marriage by a knight of Metz, Robert des Armoises by name, and had accepted him. On account of this marriage, the false Pucelle did not leave Metz for Orleans, but remained there in quiet domestic life for three years, during which two children were born to her.
But in 1439 she accepted the repeated invitation of Orleans, and seemed to have been received in state, as became the Maid of France. She was “royally entertained” from July the eighteenth to August the first by the town. It must be remembered that every one in Orleans over twelve years of age had seen and known the true Joan of Arc; yet none doubted that it was she. All this while she had corresponded with the King of France, too, and had met several of the generals who had served under the real Maid of Orleans, and still no one had any suspicion of her imposture, so far as we can find out. In this same year, 1439, she was given command of troops at Maus, and took part in a raid, which shows she had some knowledge of military life, enough to deceive her soldiers. Here she was in company with an old companion in war, the Marshal de Rais, who had followed the white banner of Joan of Arc, nine years before; yet he had no doubts of her identity with the Maid.
Two persons, however, the false Pucelle had carefully avoided—the mother of Joan of Arc and King Charles himself. Joan of Arc, indeed, had never revisited her native village of Domremy from the day she first left it for the dauphin’s court; but she had endeavored to do so, and had only been prevented by the necessities of her campaigns. The false Pucelle took care not to go to Domremy, either, contenting herself with seeing her brothers in Metz and Orleans. But the time came when she had to have audience before the king.
As we have learned, the proof that had convinced Charles, the dauphin, of Joan of Arc’s divine mission to save France was a certain secret “sign” made known by her at their first interview. This “sign” Charles had never revealed afterward to any one, and the Maid of Orleans had utterly refused, at her trials, to make it known, even when threatened with torture. It was quite natural, therefore, that when Madame Jehanne came before him at his court, he should salute her courteously with the words, “Pucelle, my dear friend, you are welcome back, in the name of God, who knows the secret that is between us.” These searching words were too much for the false Pucelle. She saw he expected the “sign,” which she could not give, and, falling on her knees, she acknowledged that she was not the Maid of France, and asked pardon.
So runs the story of her unmasking, told by an aged tutor of the king’s son long afterward to a youth, Pierre Sala, who in his old age, in turn, wrote it down in a book of the Deeds of Kings. It is the only explanation we have as to why the false Pucelle suddenly dropped out of sight in public affairs henceforth; and it seems to bear truth with it. But there is no doubt, nevertheless, that years after this King Charles himself appointed Nicholas de Vouthon (in 1452) as chaplain to “Jehanne la Pucelle,” which seems strange in view of all this; and that Pierre d’Arc still recognized her as his sister to the end of his life.
The last we hear of her is in 1457, when, in Angers, the officers of King René of Anjou (father of Margaret, the wife of Henry the Sixth of England, and so, presumably, English in his sympathies), arrested “Jehanne des Ermoises” for “having long called herself Jehanne la Pucelle, and deceived many persons who had seen Jehanne at the siege of Orleans.” The record goes on to show that the false Pucelle maintained that “no other charge had ever been brought against her,” and that King René, having been “addressed by others in her favor,” granted her full liberty, on condition “that she bear herself honestly in dress.” This doubtless refers to her habit of wearing man’s dress and armor, as the true Joan of Arc had done.
From this court of Angers, the false Pucelle passes on into the same obscurity and mystery whence she came. No explanation of her imposture has ever been found; but it is certain that this unknown girl deceived every eye and every heart that had ever known the Maid of Orleans, excepting only the mother, whom she was clever enough to keep away from, and the king, whose secret “sign” she had no possible way of learning. Her success is one of the astonishing facts of French history.—Priscilla Leonard, in the Well Spring.