AdventAI

1 Corinthians 11:19

For there must be also heresies among you, that they which are approved may be made manifest among you.

King James Version

Translations

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

3 sources

Divisions, heresies, and false teachings must arise among church members and among believers.Ms 82, 1898, par. 31–33LS 86.2–88.3 These trials serve to make manifest those who are approved.Ms 82, 1898, par. 31–33LS 86.2–88.3Lt 64, 1874, par. 4–6 They are providential means to develop character, refining true Christians, removing their faults and producing Christlike meekness and purity.LS 86.2–88.3Lt 64, 1874, par. 4–6

When an influential man takes a wrong course, the resulting crisis exposes hidden disaffection.Lt 64, 1874, par. 4–6 Those who have had no harmony with reproof then feel excusable in speaking and acting out their unbelief.Lt 64, 1874, par. 4–6 It is better for all to let such a crisis come quickly.Lt 64, 1874, par. 4–6 Fear that churches will be endangered or ruined must not force a wrong step or a move in the dark.Lt 64, 1874, par. 4–6

Work that is not wrought in God will not stand the test but will come to nothing.Lt 64, 1874, par. 4–6 God's work moves forward with or without any particular laborer.Lt 64, 1874, par. 4–6 Arraying against those God is working with is arraying against God.Lt 64, 1874, par. 4–6 Church members should therefore walk humbly with God in obedience rather than let contention and division govern their gatherings.Ms 82, 1898, par. 31–33

Sources

  1. Ms 82, 1898, par. 31–33 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 13 (1898) — Ms 82, 1898 Ellen G. White, written June 26, 1898
  2. LS 86.2–88.3 Life Sketches — CHAPTER III. James White, 1880
  3. Lt 64, 1874, par. 4–6 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 2 (1869 - 1875) — Lt 64, 1874 Ellen G. White, written December 24, 1874

Pioneers and periodicals

35 sources

The word for heresies means sects and factions that divide believers, not simply holding a mistaken belief.ST May 19, 1881RH Oct 31, 1907RH Jan 24, 1865 Paul wrote this while correcting grievous disorder at the Lord's Supper at Corinth, where self-centered cliques feasted while poorer believers went hungry and were shamed.ST Nov 29, 1883RH Dec 3, 1867ST Jan 10, 1906ST Jul 8, 1889 Such divisions must occur among those who profess to be God's people, by God's permission, because people are free to choose their own way.RH Jan 24, 1865RH Jul 2, 1857ST Sep 11, 1884RH Feb 28, 1856 Their appointed purpose is that those who are approved by God may be made manifest, with the faithful revealed and others exposed in their true character.RH Oct 31, 1907RH Jan 24, 1865RH May 6, 1862 God permits and overrules these trials so that character is tested and purified and truth is valued more highly, yet creating division remains sin and does not excuse those who choose error.RH Jan 24, 1865RH Jul 2, 1857ST Sep 11, 1884RH Sep 22, 1874RH Dec 9, 1862

Words and Corinthian Setting

The word rendered heresies means sects, factions or schisms.ST May 19, 1881RH Oct 31, 1907RH Jan 24, 1865RH Sep 22, 1874RH Sep 2, 1873 It denotes faction-makers or sects who speak perverse things to draw disciples after themselves, not merely people who hold mistaken beliefs.RH Jan 24, 1865RH Jan 13, 1874 Heresy condemned as a work of the flesh lies not in mere choosing but in the motive of choosing and the thing chosen.ST Jun 26, 1901 Either a wrong motive or the choice of a wrong thing is the heresy condemned as a fruit of the flesh, namely the choice of what is contrary to the Gospel by preferring the way of man to the way of God, whether held by one person or by a body, and it belongs among last-day developments of apostasy.ST Jun 26, 1901

The verse belongs to Paul's correction of grievous errors and disorder in the observance of the Lord's Supper at Corinth.ST Nov 29, 1883ST Jan 10, 1906ST May 19, 1881ST Jun 21, 1905 Abuses brought in from a wicked heathen background treated the church of God like heathen temples, so that repeated instruction about the ordinance became necessary.ST Jun 21, 1905 The existence of the faults was reported to Paul by people from Corinth rather than revealed from heaven, and at least one sin was widely known.ST Nov 29, 1883

The divisions were parties and cliques meeting in a self-centered way, with some feasting while others suffered hunger.RH Dec 3, 1867ST Jan 10, 1906ST Jun 21, 1905 They treated poorer believers shamefully and failed to discern the Lord's body and to recognize the true import of the sacred ordinance.RH Dec 3, 1867ST Jan 10, 1906 The divisions were very wide, with part of the church commendable while another, not small, part had fallen into great depravity, including perversion of the Supper and the open practices rebuked in 1 Corinthians 5.ST Jul 8, 1889ST Aug 24, 1888 Paul faithfully and tenderly reproved these dissensions, lack of unity, worldliness, selfishness, indifference to the poor, and lack of spirituality as evils also found in the church now.ST Jan 7, 1897

The divided gathering showed the believers were not prepared to keep the ordinances and were not really celebrating that solemn rite.RH Aug 19, 1858ST Jan 10, 1906ST Jun 21, 1905 For such conduct Paul could not praise them.ST Jan 10, 1906 The same chapter furnishes the gospel memorials of the Lord's death, burial, and resurrection as plainly as the duty to keep the seventh-day Sabbath.ST Sep 9, 1880 Laying these memorials aside and substituting something of men's own, such as first-day observance to commemorate the resurrection, transgresses the law of God.ST Sep 9, 1880 The verse is cited among examples of apostolic teaching and discipline but offers no evidence that the apostles had authority to change the Sabbath or any part of God's moral law.RH Nov 14, 1871

The same chapter authorizes women to pray and prophesy.RH Jul 30, 1861 Specific instruction about the dress of women when they prophesy proves they are permitted to work and speak for God. This is distinguished from the instruction about women's silence in church courts, which addresses a different setting rather than ordinary public worship.RH Jul 30, 1861 The prohibitions correct abuse of a good thing rather than commanding total silence.

Why Divisions Must Be

Factions or sects must arise among believers and among those who profess to be God's people, by God's permission, for not all who profess will live in union and harmony, so divisions and false teachings are to occur.RH Jan 24, 1865RH Jul 2, 1857RH Feb 28, 1856RH Apr 13, 1911RH Jan 13, 1874 Such opposition tests integrity and can purify the ranks, giving the work fresh impetus rather than stopping it.ST Mar 27, 1884 Their appointed purpose is that those who are approved may be made manifest among believers, revealing who remains faithful and approved by God while exposing others in their true character.RH Oct 31, 1907RH Jan 24, 1865RH May 6, 1862RH Feb 28, 1856 Truth and holiness are thereby seen more clearly and valued more highly in contrast with error and sin.RH Dec 9, 1862

God permits and overrules these divisions so that good results from them, but their presence does not excuse those who choose error, does not mean God's work has failed or is defeated, and does not mean He advances it by joining rebels and disrupting its harmony, for creating divisions remains a sin.RH Jan 24, 1865RH Jul 2, 1857ST Sep 11, 1884RH Feb 28, 1856RH Apr 13, 1911 He permits sin and overrules it so that in its final results it brings good by making holiness conspicuous.RH Dec 9, 1862 Divisions and false teachings arise because people can choose their own way, and this freedom allows character to develop and righteousness to be shown.ST Sep 11, 1884

Divisions provide occasion for character to become clear and integrity to be tested, for those who resist reproof display pride, stubbornness, anger and strife, while those who accept it show meekness, patience, kindness and other graces of God's Spirit.RH Sep 22, 1874 Such trials refine true Christians, removing faults and producing Christlike meekness and purity, purify the ranks by separating the faithful from rebels, humble God's people and teach them to trust in Him, and can give the work fresh impetus rather than stopping it.LS 86.2–88.3ST Mar 27, 1884RH Feb 28, 1856 The contrast has helped even the unfallen angels recognize and prize their purity, and continues to reveal the beauty of holiness.RH Dec 9, 1862

The making manifest of the approved is connected with recognizing teachers and leaders fit to serve, chosen for proven ability to lead their households and preserve order, with suitability sought from God and set apart with the approval of the church and the Holy Spirit for service including baptizing and administering the Lord's Supper, whose emblems keep Christ's suffering and death in remembrance.RH Oct 31, 1907 Divisions and heresies were present right in the midst of the church in the days of the apostles and immediately following, caused by many vain talkers and deceivers, especially they of the circumcision, who were not sound in the faith, subverted whole houses and taught things they ought not for gain, speaking perverse things to draw away disciples.RH Nov 21, 1871 That such heresies had to occur so the true and faithful would be revealed by contrast means stepping outside the inspired books to prove doctrine leaves no sure foundation.RH Nov 21, 1871 Those who separate and go out from the church prove they are not truly of it, and God permits fanatical work and extremist and secessionist movements opposing the Sabbath truth so that those who are approved may be made manifest and allegiance revealed, which can correct some people.RH Jan 13, 1874RH Oct 24, 1885RH May 6, 1862

Ordinances and Faithful Endurance

Divisions and parties in the church break the fellowship that the Lord's Supper expresses, and when that fellowship is absent the celebration of communion is improper and loses an essential part of its meaning.RH May 27, 1873 The divisions at Corinth separated believers into parties and cliques whose disorderly meals connected with the Supper exposed the shameful way some treated poorer believers, and those divisions were to be put away so that all could gather together for the Lord's Supper in a sober and worthy manner.RH Dec 3, 1867

Divine ordinances must be kept as they were delivered and preserved pure according to their intention, with praise belonging to those who keep them so and deep blame to those who pervert one.ST Jul 8, 1880 Trifling with divine ordinances is no light thing, and both candidate and administrator must look well to the teachings of the gospel, with baptism in particular to be observed with carefulness according to its importance as the rite of union with Christ, and he who administers improperly does so at his peril.ST Jul 8, 1880 The Lord's Supper is free and no one is to be barred from partaking, yet communion involves obligations set forth in the Scriptures, and each person who eats and drinks bears his own responsibility for doing so and not those who administer the bread and wine.ST Mar 20, 1907

The mention of factions does not make Corinthian practice a guide for what is right or permissible, because serious and very wide divisions existed there, with some members commendable while another and not small part had fallen into great depravity and carried the greatest abuses under the Christian name, including perversion of the Lord's Supper and the shameful open practices rebuked in 1 Corinthians 5.ST Jul 8, 1889ST Aug 24, 1888 For this reason nothing concerning duty or what is permissible can be drawn from the practice of that church, but all duty must be learned from Scripture and the sacred word.ST Jul 8, 1889ST Aug 24, 1888 Paul reproved disorder involving spiritual gifts and the Lord's Supper, and the church has responsibility and authority to regulate such disorder.RH Jun 3, 1858

Trials, offenses, and apostasies are to be expected and should not discourage believers as though some strange thing had happened, since even the primitive church was not free from them.ST May 19, 1881RH Sep 2, 1873 A Judas among the chosen twelve, the disciples forsaking Jesus when he was betrayed and apprehended, Peter denying with cursing and swearing that he knew him, the sins of Ananias and Sapphira and the case in 1 Corinthians 5, the Corinthian divisions into Paulites, Apollosites, Cephasites and others, and the disorder over the Lord's Supper in 1 Corinthians 11:17-34 all show this necessity.RH Sep 2, 1873 Heresies meaning sects or factions must be among believers so that those who are approved may be made manifest, and such divisions, abuses, trials, and departures from the truth have to be rebuked, even sharply, so the church may be sound in the faith and it may be made clear who remains faithful and approved.ST May 19, 1881ST May 19, 1881RH Sep 2, 1873 Yet mercy converts and restores the fallen to favor.ST May 19, 1881

Sources

  1. ST May 19, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 19 — TRIALS WILL COME R. F. Cottrell, May 19, 1881
  2. RH Oct 31, 1907 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 84, No. 44 — Things that Differ John Norton Loughborough, Thursday, October 31, 1907
  3. RH Jan 24, 1865 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 25, No. 9 — Schism R. F. Cottrell, January 24, 1865
  4. ST Nov 29, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 45 — The Sabbath-School Ellet Joseph Waggoner, November 29, 1883
  5. RH Dec 3, 1867 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 30, No. 25 — A Question on the Communion Third-day, December 3, 1867
  6. ST Jan 10, 1906 Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 2 — SEARCH THE SCRIPTURES F. D. Starr, January 10, 1906
  7. ST Jul 8, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 26 — WINE, AND THE LORD'S SUPPER Joseph Harvey Waggoner, July 8, 1889
  8. RH Jul 2, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 10, No. 9 — OUR EXAMPLES July 2, 1857
  9. ST Sep 11, 1884 Signs of the Times, Vol. 10, No. 35 — Purified—When and How September 11, 1884
  10. RH Feb 28, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 7, No. 22 — OUR EXAMPLES R. F. C., February 28, 1856
  11. RH May 6, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 19, No. 23 — AND STILL THEY COME Editor, Third-Day, May 6, 1862.
  12. RH Sep 22, 1874 Review and Herald, Vol. 44, No. 14 — DUTY OF CHURCH MEMBERS TO EACH OTHER George I. Butler, Sept. 22, 1874
  13. RH Dec 9, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 21, No. 2 — The Beauty of Holiness December 9, 1862
  14. RH Sep 2, 1873 Review and Herald, Vol. 42, No. 12 — Trials Will Come R. F. Cottrell, September 2, 1873
  15. RH Jan 13, 1874 Review and Herald, Vol. 43, No. 5 — Christian Unity S. N. Haskell, January 13, 1874
  16. ST Jun 26, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 26 — Sectarianism June 26, 1901.
  17. ST May 19, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 19 — TRIALS WILL COME R. F. Cottrell, May 19, 1881
  18. ST Jun 21, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 25 — TWO PROMINENT ORDINANCES June 21, 1905
  19. ST Jun 21, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 25 — TWO PROMINENT ORDINANCES June 21, 1905
  20. ST Aug 24, 1888 Signs of the Times, Vol. 14, No. 33 — WINE, AND THE LORD'S SUPPER James White, August 24, 1888
  21. ST Jan 7, 1897 Signs of the Times, Vol. 23, No. 1 — SOME RELIGIOUS STRAWS January 7, 1897
  22. RH Aug 19, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 12, No. 14 — Did the Primitive Christians have a Specific Meeting to keep the Ordinances? D. Hewitt, August 19, 1858
  23. ST Sep 9, 1880 Signs of the Times, Vol. 6, No. 34 — UPON WHAT AUTHORITY? Dudley Marvin Canright, September 9, 1880
  24. RH Nov 14, 1871 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 38, No. 22 — EXAMINATION OF T. M. PREBLE'S FIRST-DAY SABBATH John Nevins Andrews, Third-day, November 14, 1871
  25. RH Jul 30, 1861 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 18, No. 9 — Women as Preachers and Lecturers J. A. Mowatt, Third-Day, July 30, 1861
  26. RH Apr 13, 1911 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 88, No. 15 — Editorial Editor, April 13, 1911
  27. ST Mar 27, 1884 Signs of the Times, Vol. 10, No. 13 — The Oneness of God's People Stephen Nelson Haskell, March 27, 1884
  28. RH Feb 28, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 7, No. 22 — OUR EXAMPLES R. F. C., February 28, 1856
  29. LS 86.2–88.3 Life Sketches — CHAPTER III. James White, 1880
  30. RH Nov 21, 1871 Review and Herald,, Vol. 38, No. 23 — The Testimonies of the Early Fathers S. N. Haskell, November 21, 1871
  31. RH Oct 24, 1885 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 26, No. 21 — Reformation vs. Fanaticism R. F. Cottrell, Third-Day, October 24, 1885
  32. RH May 27, 1873 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 41, No. 24 — OPEN AND CLOSE COMMUNION George Ide Butler, May 27, 1873
  33. ST Jul 8, 1880 Signs of the Times, Vol. 6, No. 26 — THOUGHTS ON BAPTISM—NO. 13. Editor, July 8, 1880
  34. ST Mar 20, 1907 Signs of the Times, Vol. 33, No. 12 — The Lord’s Supper Editor, March 20, 1907
  35. RH Jun 3, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 12, No. 3 — Prove all Things H. S. Gurney, June 3, 1858

Cross-references

  1. Acts 20:30

    Also of your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away disciples after them.

    Both warn that divisive people will arise within the church.

  2. 1 John 2:19

    They went out from us, but they were not of us; for if they had been of us, they would no doubt have continued with us: but they went out, that they might be made manifest that they were not all of us.

    Those who leave are shown not to belong to the church.

  3. 2 Peter 2:1

    But there were false prophets also among the people, even as there shall be false teachers among you, who privily shall bring in damnable heresies, even denying the Lord that bought them, and bring upon themselves swift destruction.

    Heresies arise among believers as apostasy develops.

  4. Galatians 5:20

    Idolatry, witchcraft, hatred, variance, emulations, wrath, strife, seditions, heresies,

    Both identify heresies as a work of the flesh.