1 John 2:19
They went out from us, but they were not of us; for if they had been of us, they would no doubt have continued with us: but they went out, that they might be made manifest that they were not all of us.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
They went out from us, but they were not of us; for if they had been of us, they would no doubt have continued with us: but they went out, that they might be made manifest that they were not all of us.
They went out from us, but they were not of us; for if they had been of us, they would have continued with us: but they went out, that they might be made manifest how that they all are not of us.
They went out from us, but they were not of us; for if they had been of us, they would have continued with us: but they went out, that they might be made manifest that they all are not of us.
out of us they went forth, but they were not of us, for if they had been of us, they would have remained with us; but — that they might be manifested that they are not all of us.
They went out from among us, but they were not of us; for if they had been of us, they would have surely remained with us, but that they might be made manifest that none are of us.
From among us, they went out, but they were not of us; for, if, of us, they had been, they would in that case have abode with us; but [it came to pass] in order that they might be made manifest, because, all, are not of us.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
They went out from us, but they did not belong to us. For if they had belonged to us, they would have remained with us. But their departure made it clear that none of them belonged to us.
They went out from us, but they didn’t belong to us; for if they had belonged to us, they would have continued with us. But they left, that they might be revealed that none of them belong to us.
They went out from us but they were not of us; if they had been of us they would still be with us: but they went out from us so that it might be made clear that they were not of us.
They went out from vs, but they were not of vs: for if they had bene of vs, they should haue continued with vs. But this cometh to passe, that it might appeare, that they are not all of vs.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
They went out from us, but they were not of us. For if they had been of us, they would no doubt have remained with us; but that they may be manifest, that they are not all of us.
Cross-references
- John 6:66
From that time many of his disciples went back, and walked no more with him.
Many disciples turn back and no longer follow Jesus.
- John 15:5-6
I am the vine, ye are the branches: He that abideth in me, and I in him, the same bringeth forth much fruit: for without me ye can do nothing.
Those without vital union with Christ do not remain and are cast off.
- Matthew 13:21
Yet hath he not root in himself, but dureth for a while: for when tribulation or persecution ariseth because of the word, by and by he is offended.
Tribulation or persecution reveals those who do not endure.
- 1 John 2:24
Let that therefore abide in you, which ye have heard from the beginning. If that which ye have heard from the beginning shall remain in you, ye also shall continue in the Son, and in the Father.
Remaining in the original teaching means continuing in the Son and the Father.
- 1 Corinthians 11:19
For there must be also heresies among you, that they which are approved may be made manifest among you.
Divisions reveal who is approved and who truly belongs.
- 1 Timothy 4:1
Now the Spirit speaketh expressly, that in the latter times some shall depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits, and doctrines of devils;
Departure from the faith is linked to heeding seducing spirits.
- 1 John 4:1
Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world.
Believers are told to test spirits to see whether they are from God.
- 1 John 2:23
Whosoever denieth the Son, the same hath not the Father: [but] he that acknowledgeth the Son hath the Father also.
Denying the Son means not having the Father.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
39 sources
Those who went out from the fellowship had never truly belonged to it, and their departure made that lack of belonging manifest, for those who truly belonged would have continued with the believers.RH Mar 8, 1906Lt 72, 1906, par. 34–36Lt 28, 1898, par. 7–8 Being with the people is not the same as being of them, since a person can be present and even trusted and valued as a helper yet not truly be of them.5MR 169.1–2Lt 155, 1910, par. 1–3 Many leave because they are offended when truth in reproof and warning cuts across their practice and cherished ideas, and because truth demands death to self which they refuse, wanting instead to control others and gratify ambition.Lt 28, 1898, par. 7–8Lt 17, 1897, par. 6–813MR 10.3–11.1Ms 78, 1897, par. 42–43RCOC 38.4 Those who thus go out are apostate antichrists who war against the truth they once built up and pass to the enemy's side, and the appearance of many such antichrists is the evidence that it is the last time.Lt 72, 1906, par. 34–36Lt 28, 1898, par. 7–8Lt 38, 1894, par. 15Ms 52, 1904, par. 33–38Lt 242, 1906, par. 4–15 The same departure will happen again in a shaking that separates the untrue from the true, yet the Lord works through it to separate the disaffected from the loyal, truth bears away the victory, and the vacancies are taken by others who receive the truth.Lt 17, 1897, par. 6–8Lt 311b, 1906, par. 10–1113MR 10.3–11.114MR 286.2Ms 97, 1898, par. 13–15
Meaning of Departure
Those who went out from the fellowship had never truly belonged to it, and their going out made that lack of belonging manifest.RH Mar 8, 1906Lt 72, 1906, par. 34–36RH Jul 20, 1905Lt 38, 1894, par. 15 If they had truly been of the believers they would no doubt have continued with them, for continuance is the mark of genuine belonging.RH Mar 8, 1906Lt 72, 1906, par. 34–36RH Jul 20, 1905Lt 38, 1894, par. 15Ms 15, 1886, par. 17 Their departure therefore discloses that they were not all of the company they left, even though they had once been with the believers in the faith and once been loved in it.Lt 72, 1906, par. 34–36Lt 28, 1898, par. 7–8Ms 15, 1886, par. 17 Some became offended at something said or done, withdrew themselves, went over to the ranks of the enemy, and war against the truth they had once built up.Lt 28, 1898, par. 7–8 In turning they give heed to seducing spirits, and as apostates they are called antichrists who do the work of Satan, whose sharp working and the rise of many antichrists prove that it is the last time.Lt 72, 1906, par. 34–36Lt 28, 1898, par. 7–8Lt 38, 1894, par. 15Ms 15, 1886, par. 17
The verse distinguishes being with the people from being of them.5MR 169.1–2Lt 155, 1910, par. 1–3 A person can be present among the church and even be trusted and valued as a helper, and yet not truly be of it.Lt 155, 1910, par. 1–3 That difference is revealed when one holds strange opinions with perfect confidence that one's own opinion is supreme, fails to view things in a correct light, and holds ideas not in harmony with the mind and working of the Holy Spirit.Lt 155, 1910, par. 1–3 Such a course mars the cause, brings confusion into the ranks by carrying others along, and disqualifies a person from presiding over a conference unless convicted and converted from those opinions.Lt 155, 1910, par. 1–3 The same going out applies to former members who left and to those involved in contention, while special efforts are still to be made by visiting them for their return.5MR 169.1–2
Reasons for Leaving
Many go out because they become offended when truth is spoken in reproof and warning irrespective of consequences, having once been with the believers in the faith but withdrawing when something said or done crosses them and passing over to the ranks of the enemy to war against the truth they once built up.Lt 28, 1898, par. 7–813MR 10.3–11.1Ms 97, 1898, par. 13–15 Their hearts are not in harmony with the truth as it is in Jesus, for they cherish ideas, theories and sentiments of their own that do not harmonize with truth and refuse to give up their own ideas when truth conflicts with them.13MR 10.3–11.1Ms 97, 1898, par. 13–15 On every occasion of persecution many who profess to love the truth are offended because its principles cut directly across their practice and income, and they stumble and fall and apostatize from the faith they once advocated.Lt 28, 1898, par. 7–8Ms 78, 1897, par. 42–43 Their going out in this way, just as many of Christ's disciples were offended and walked no more with Him, makes manifest that they were not all of the believers, and their appearance as many antichrists is evidence of sharp working by which it is known that it is the last time.Lt 28, 1898, par. 7–813MR 10.3–11.1Ms 78, 1897, par. 42–43
They go out because truth demands death to self and the practice of self-denial, which they refuse.Lt 17, 1897, par. 6–8RCOC 38.4 They want instead to handle the consciences of fellow men and to control minds and talents, gratifying an ambitious desire to rule other men rather than submit to truth, and in this their true characters are revealed.Lt 17, 1897, par. 6–8RCOC 38.4 Some make total shipwreck of the faith, and the same departure will happen again and should cause no surprise.Lt 17, 1897, par. 6–8RCOC 38.4
They turn aside by giving heed to seducing spirits, yielding to temptation and following deceptive teachings after having shared and been loved in the faith community, which shows they did not truly belong to it since those truly of it would have continued with it.Ms 15, 1886, par. 1711MR 86.2–87.16T 400.3 Those who have received great light but have rejected the love of truth depart from the faith under trial, having no vital union with the true vine.Ms 78, 1897, par. 42–436T 400.3 Those who refuse to be taught of God and hold instead the traditions of men take the side of the enemy against God and are written as antichrist, while those who feed on the Word of God show it by their practice and are on the Lord's side, seeking by precept and example to reform the world.STMW9 55.1–220MR 113.3–114.1 God's people press together in unity, one with Christ, while those who will not practice His lessons find in antichrist the center of their union, and the two opposing parties stand in collision until the Lord appears and sets up a kingdom that shall stand forever.STMW9 55.1–220MR 113.3–114.1
Their condition is revealed by persistency in having their own way and by perfect confidence that their own opinion is supreme, unerring and infallible, holding a once-taken position as never to be changed and treating all they do as infallible, which proves a great error.Lt 19d, 1874, par. 4–620MR 225.3Lt 155, 1910, par. 1–3 They are marked by long murmuring and complaining, by claiming that no one but themselves is competent to lead, by accusing responsible men and presenting them and their work in a false light, and by seeking to gain the confidence of the church to follow their ideas, becoming burdens for the church to carry.Lt 19d, 1874, par. 4–620MR 225.3 When the light of truth comes to bring reformation, those who receive it come into harmonious sentiments, but those who continue in opposition create disunion not over the faith received but over the expression of the faith.20MR 225.3Lt 155, 1910, par. 1–3 Holding strange opinions, failing to view things in a correct light, and holding ideas not in harmony with the mind and working of the Holy Spirit mars the cause, brings confusion into the ranks by carrying others along, and disqualifies a person from presiding over others unless convicted and converted from those opinions.Lt 19d, 1874, par. 4–6Lt 155, 1910, par. 1–3 A contentious, envious and fault-finding spirit likewise exposes that a person who leaves is not truly in harmony, and while unchanged such a one should not be encouraged to rejoin, for that spirit would bring conflict even among angels and cannot enter heaven.4T 237.2–238.1Lt 19d, 1874, par. 4–6Lt 155, 1910, par. 1–3
Some depart over temporal and practical interests, like those who came to Christ only for temporal advantage after the miracle of the loaves and then left Him.Lt 17, 1897, par. 6–8 Men entrusted with business management who practice robbery and deception, act unjustly and strengthen others in wrongdoing, go out from among the people because they are not truly of them.Ms 78, 1897, par. 42–43Lt 219, 1897, par. 2 Those who profess belief while refusing to practice health-reform truth hinder the work, and the standard is to remain uplifted until they reform or depart, their departure revealing that they were not truly part of the community.Lt 95, 1898, par. 7–8Lt 219, 1897, par. 2 Those cut away as branches that bear no fruit are bound up with unbelievers, scoffers and mockers, and to secure their own safety they will bear false witness and betray their brethren, telling where they are concealed and putting persecutors on their track.Ms 78, 1897, par. 42–43Lt 219, 1897, par. 2 If their dishonesty is not searched out, clearly discerned, repented of with a rent heart and not merely outward form, and made right by restitution, they will never see the kingdom, for those who do not fall on the Rock and be broken are uncircumcised in heart and not true in character, and while unchanged they only stir up the worst passions and confirm others in a wrong spirit.Lt 95, 1898, par. 7–8Lt 219, 1897, par. 2
Antichrists and Last Time
The coming of many antichrists, just as it was heard that antichrist shall come, is the evidence by which it is known that it is the last time.Lt 72, 1906, par. 34–36Ms 52, 1904, par. 33–38Lt 164, 1910, par. 5–7Ms 56, 1905, par. 30–31 Those who went out from among believers had once been with them in the faith, but they became offended at something said or done, withdrew themselves, and their going out made manifest that they were not all true believers, for if they had belonged they would have continued with them.Lt 72, 1906, par. 34–36Lt 28, 1898, par. 7–8Ms 52, 1904, par. 33–38Lt 164, 1910, par. 5–7 Their appearance as many antichrists is evidence of Satan's sharp working in the last time, in contrast to truly sanctified souls in the family who live the Word of God and are educated and taught of God.Lt 28, 1898, par. 7–8Lt 164, 1910, par. 5–7 On every occasion of persecution many who profess to love the truth are offended because the principles of truth cut directly across their practice and income, and they stumble and fall and apostatize from the faith they once advocated.Ms 78, 1897, par. 42–43 Having no vital union with the true vine, they are cut away as branches that bear no fruit and are bound up with unbelievers, scoffers and mockers, and to secure their own safety they will bear false witness and betray their brethren, telling where they are concealed and putting persecutors on their track.Ms 78, 1897, par. 42–43
Those who go out are apostates whom the verse calls antichrists, and they are doing the work of Satan.Lt 28, 1898, par. 7–8Lt 38, 1894, par. 15Lt 242, 1906, par. 4–15 Having been once with believers, they go over to the ranks of the enemy and war against the truth they had once built up, and their departure makes their true allegiance manifest.Lt 28, 1898, par. 7–8Lt 38, 1894, par. 15Lt 242, 1906, par. 4–15 Men's choices and practice reveal whether they belong to Christ's people, for those who feed on the Word of God show it by their practice and are on the Lord's side, seeking by precept and example to reform the world.STMW9 55.1–220MR 113.3–114.1 Those who refuse to be taught of God hold the traditions of men and at last pass over to the side of the enemy against God and are written Antichrist, while God's people press together in unity, one with Jesus Christ, and those who will not practice the lessons of Christ find in Antichrist the center of their union.STMW9 55.1–220MR 113.3–114.1Ms 10, 1900, par. 19–22 Those who in the crisis allow themselves to be more on the side of the world than of God will eventually place themselves wholly on the side of the world, and those who become confused in their understanding of the Word and fail to see the meaning of antichrist will surely place themselves on the side of antichrist, making manifest that they were not of God's people.Ms 10, 1900, par. 19–22 Every true child of God fights bravely on the side of Christ, becoming more and more distinct from the world by openly conforming to the law and observing the Sabbath as the visible sign and mark of distinction between God's chosen people and the world, a separation witnessed and explained by the fulfillment of the prophecies of Daniel and John in these last days, with the two opposing parties standing in collision until the Lord appears and sets up a kingdom that shall stand forever.20MR 113.3–114.1Ms 10, 1900, par. 19–22
After leaving the fellowship, men whom Satan inspires unite with evil angels to retard the work over unimportant questions and bring confusion into the ranks, causing rejoicing in the camp of the enemy.20MR 18.1–2 Their going out describes apostasy in a time of crisis when men who have preached the truth to others go out from among believers by giving heed to Satan's temptations.Lt 9, 1897, par. 2 Their going out puts souls on the very brink of ruin, ready to perish, and calls those who remain to humiliation, to seeking the Lord, and to pleading with God to save the perishing and to break the infatuation.Lt 9, 1897, par. 2
Final Separation Foretold
The same going out will happen again and should cause no surprise, for apostasies and a shaking are to be expected in the last conflict while heaven works to prepare a people to stand.Lt 17, 1897, par. 6–8Lt 311b, 1906, par. 10–1114MR 286.2Lt 112, 1890, par. 10–116T 400.3 Their departure makes manifest that they were not truly of the believers, since those who truly belonged would have continued with them, and it reveals true character by separating the untrue from the true as tares are separated from wheat and dross from metal.Lt 17, 1897, par. 6–8Lt 311b, 1906, par. 10–114T 89.2–90.1 Trials and persecution expose who is steadfast, for some who profess to belong fall away when tribulation comes because they were not firmly grounded, and the refining process leaves them as dross while the shaking blows them away.14MR 286.24T 89.2–90.16T 400.3
Their going out parallels the many disciples of Christ who were offended and walked no more with Him when truth was spoken in reproof and warning irrespective of consequences.Lt 17, 1897, par. 6–813MR 10.3–11.1 Those who leave have no vital union with the true vine and are cut away as branches bearing no fruit, to be bound up with unbelievers, scoffers and mockers, like every plant the Father has not planted being rooted up.Ms 78, 1897, par. 42–4314MR 286.24T 89.2–90.1 On every occasion of persecution many who professed to love the truth stumble and fall and apostatize because its principles cut across their practice and income, and to secure their own safety they will bear false witness and betray their brethren, telling where they are concealed and putting persecutors on their track.Ms 78, 1897, par. 42–43
In the last great conflict between the powers of darkness and the powers of light there will be a complete separation of Christ's true children from the world, with no time to assimilate with the world.20MR 113.3–114.1Ms 10, 1900, par. 19–22 Every true child will fight bravely on the side of Christ, becoming more and more openly distinct by conforming to the law and observing the Sabbath as the visible sign and mark of distinction between God's chosen people and the world, a separation witnessed and explained by the fulfillment of the prophecies of Daniel and John in these last days.Ms 10, 1900, par. 19–22 Those who feed on the Word show it by practice and press together in unity, one with Jesus Christ, while those who refuse to be taught of God hold human traditions and at last pass over to the side of the enemy, so that the two opposing parties stand in collision until the Lord appears and sets up a kingdom that shall stand forever.20MR 113.3–114.1Ms 10, 1900, par. 19–22
The Lord works through the departure to separate the disaffected from the true and loyal, and truth bears away the victory.13MR 10.3–11.1 The vacancies they make will be taken by others who receive the truth and will not leave the ranks diminished, men of true Christian principle who fear God and glorify Him and become faithful, trustworthy upholders of God's Word in its true bearings and simplicity.13MR 10.3–11.1Ms 97, 1898, par. 13–15 Those who leave because the truth conflicts with their own ideas thereby make their disaffection evident, while faithful people take the places they leave and continue the work.13MR 10.3–11.1Ms 97, 1898, par. 13–15
Faithful Response Required
The departure calls for holding the truth fast at all hazards, standing firm on the platform of eternal truth with courage and hope in the precious promises, since it is not yet too late for wrongs to be righted.Ms 56, 1905, par. 30–31 In contrast to those who go out, truly sanctified souls in the family who live the Word of God are educated and taught of God.Lt 164, 1910, par. 5–7 The chapter is to be read to be sure of walking in the knowledge of the truth and being a partaker of the divine nature, holding singleness of purpose and obtaining the genuine experience of walking humbly with God.Lt 116, 1910, par. 2–6 It gives practical instruction for steadfast faith in God and warns against being led astray by human judgment.Ms 237, 1902, par. 6 It gives instruction from Christ to be studied and obeyed to be ready for the Lord's appearing, forbidding exalting self and disparaging others and commanding each soul to criticize self, confess and forsake personal sin, make diligent work for repentance, and set the heart in order without a moment to lose, because souls are in peril in the great day of atonement but can be cleansed from sin.Lt 368, 1904, par. 14–15
The standard is not to be lowered for those who profess belief while refusing to practice the truth, as with health reform, but is to remain uplifted until they reform or depart, and their departure reveals they were not truly part of the community.Lt 95, 1898, par. 7–8 Those who have gone out were not of the fellowship, and therefore no means should be drawn away to help them, but means entrusted by the Lord should be placed where it will build up the cause in the earth, meeting the immediate necessities of faithful work and carrying the message of present truth to needy missionary fields and to those who have never heard it.Ms 13, 1908, par. 87MR 195.3 When rebellious elements separated, their departure made plain they were not truly part of it, while those who remained met peacefully and in harmony with God's work.ST Jan 12, 1882 A departure can expose a contentious, envious, and fault-finding spirit showing lack of harmony, and while unchanged such a person should not be encouraged to rejoin, because that spirit would bring conflict even among angels and cannot enter heaven.4T 237.2–238.1 Yet former members who left and those involved in contention are to be visited and given special efforts for their return.5MR 169.1–2
Their going out in a time of crisis, when men who have preached the truth to others go out by giving heed to temptation, puts souls on the very brink of ruin ready to perish, and calls those who remain to humiliation, to seeking the Lord, and to pleading with God to save the perishing and to break the infatuation.Lt 9, 1897, par. 2 Men entrusted with business management who practice robbery and deception, act unjustly, and strengthen others in wrongdoing will go out because they are not truly of the people, and if their dishonesty is not searched out, clearly discerned, repented of with a rent heart and not merely outward form, and made right by restitution, they will never see the kingdom of heaven.Lt 219, 1897, par. 2 Being with yet not of the people is revealed by holding strange opinions, having perfect confidence in one's own opinion and treating it as supreme, failing to view things in a correct light, and holding ideas not in harmony with the mind and working of the Holy Spirit, which mars the cause, brings confusion into the ranks by carrying others along, and disqualifies a person from presiding over others unless convicted and converted from those opinions.Lt 155, 1910, par. 1–3 Those who do not fall on the Rock and be broken are uncircumcised in heart and not true in character, and while unchanged they only stir up the worst passions and confirm others in a wrong spirit.Lt 219, 1897, par. 2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
54 sources
Those who went out from the fellowship were outwardly joined to it but never truly belonged to it, for if they had truly belonged they would have continued with it, and their going out made plain that they were not all of it.RH Mar 8, 1906ST Oct 16, 1893ST Oct 16, 1893 Their departure is a mark that it is the last time, in which many antichrists have appeared and the spirit of antichrist is more fully developed.ST Oct 16, 1893RH Sep 30, 1852RH Sep 17, 1857 These antichrists deny the Father and the Son and transgress and abide not in the doctrine of Christ, professing to know God while in works they deny Him and saying they have fellowship with Him while they walk in darkness and keep not His commandments.RH Sep 30, 1852RH Sep 17, 1857ST May 7, 1894 Their going out is a sifting of chaff from wheat that purifies the church, and it tests and strengthens the unity of those who remain, teaching them to trust God rather than people and freeing them to advance with greater success and blessing.ST Oct 16, 1893RH Feb 26, 1867RH Dec 16, 1858RH Jul 23, 1857ST Feb 27, 1907 Trials and persecution therefore expose false profession and cause those whose faith is not steadfast to fall away, in contrast with the perseverance of those who belong in truth.RH Jun 3, 1858ST Jun 5, 1879
Words and Departure Meaning
Those who went out from the fellowship had been outwardly connected with it but never truly belonged to it in heart and faith.RH Mar 8, 1906RH Jul 20, 1905ST Oct 16, 1893ST Oct 16, 1893 If they had truly belonged they would no doubt have continued with it, for genuine belonging holds fast and remains.RH Mar 8, 1906RH Jul 20, 1905ST Oct 16, 1893RH Jan 6, 1863RH Jul 13, 1905 Their going out made this manifest, laying open the separation and showing plainly that they were not all of it.RH Mar 8, 1906ST Oct 16, 1893ST Oct 16, 1893RH Jan 6, 1863RH Jul 13, 1905 Lack of loyalty to the faith is thus revealed by departure, while faithfulness is shown by abiding with the believers.RH Mar 8, 1906RH Jul 20, 1905RH Jan 6, 1863RH Jul 13, 1905
The going out was of those in Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia, and Bithynia who had been Christians but left the body. Some had left three years before, some longer, and some above twenty years. After leaving they worshiped images, repeated invocations to the gods, and reviled Christ, thereby making manifest that they were not all of the church.
In the setting of this departure, the phrase rendered born of God is to be understood as begotten of God.RH May 8, 1856 Born and begotten are used synonymously in the New Testament.RH May 8, 1856 That synonymous use governs the sense of the begetting spoken of in connection with those who continue and those who go out.RH May 8, 1856
Antichrists and Last Time
The going out from the fellowship makes plain that those who left never truly belonged to it, for genuine belonging would have kept them continuing with it, and this departure is a mark that it is the last time.ST Oct 16, 1893RH Sep 30, 1852RH Sep 17, 1857 Many antichrists have appeared as proof that it is the last hour, and the spirit of antichrist was already more fully developed among the early believers.RH Sep 30, 1852RH Sep 17, 1857ST May 7, 1894 False teachers and antichrists were already active among them, and the first epistle of John was written as a special warning against them.ST May 7, 1894ST Aug 24, 1904
These antichrists are dissidents who deny the Father and the Son, expressed in saying to let God and Jesus go.RH Sep 30, 1852RH Sep 17, 1857ST May 7, 1894 They are not open infidels but hypocritical professors who transgress and abide not in the doctrine of Christ.ST May 7, 1894 They profess to know God but in works deny Him, say they have fellowship with God but walk in darkness, profess to know Him but keep not His commandments, and claim to be in the light but hate their brethren.ST May 7, 1894 They oppose Christ not necessarily by profession but by actions.RH Aug 5, 1909ST May 7, 1894 They are the same class denounced as murmurers and complainers walking after their own lusts, speaking great swelling words, seducing the brethren, promising liberty, and alluring through lusts of the flesh and wantonness those clean escaped from error, as wells without water and spots and blemishes.ST May 7, 1894
Claiming to save oneself and atone for one's own sin is antichrist, because it puts self in God's place and dishonors His law.ST Nov 1, 1899 Spiritualists are antichrist under the teaching of chapters 2:18-22, for their works are forbidden by the word of God.RH Jun 13, 1871 They deny God, deify man, justify sin, and deny the Bible, proving they are not the spirits of the dead but spirits of devils or fallen angels leading men captive.RH Jun 13, 1871 The development of antichrist culminated in papal power and persecution during the 1,260 years, when millions are said to have died for their faith.RH Nov 20, 1900
Abandoning the Bible is a sign of Protestant decline that opens the way to Romanism, lost liberty, and antichrist.ST Mar 11, 1903 The verse is associated with the church's final struggle against paganism and antichrist, in which missionary self-sacrifice and martyrdom are needed to inspire the church.ST Dec 5, 1892 The world will to the very end hate and oppose Christ and His true church, and God's method is not evolution but revolution and not natural growth but supernatural birth.ST Aug 7, 1901 This dispensation results not in conversion of the world but in out-gathering a people for His name by separation rather than assimilation, its great danger is accommodation, and its final state as a whole is apostasy with formalists, hypocrites, and nearly undetectable counterfeits to the end.ST Aug 7, 1901 The hope of church and world is the coming of the Lord when the Gospel's worldwide triumphs will begin, and believers must perpetually watch against worldliness and heresy while waiting for the Son of man.ST Aug 7, 1901
Church Unity and Discipline
The going out makes plain a sifting of chaff from wheat that purifies the church, and divine power at work in the church serves to remove unworthy members.ST Oct 16, 1893RH Feb 26, 1867 While believers possess the Spirit of Christ and are led by it they belong to one undivided body, and departure reveals lack of true union in that Spirit.RH Mar 17, 1853 Those who remain connected to Christ receive life from Him and stand together in unity of the Spirit.RH Jan 15, 1857
The departure of false brethren serves as a test that strengthens the unity of those who remain committed to the message rather than their own wills.RH Dec 16, 1858 Their leaving draws out a clear testimony and teaches believers to trust God rather than people.RH Jul 23, 1857 It relieves the faithful of burdens and allows those determined to advance to speak more freely.RH Feb 3, 1859 It is followed by greater success and blessing, so that such departures do not by themselves show that a movement has failed, since they occurred even among Christ's and the apostles' followers without destroying the work.ST Feb 27, 1907 The hypocrisy of those who leave is no reason for the faithful to distrust one another; brotherly love and confidence should increase.RH Dec 16, 1858
Those who walk with the church awhile and then go out from it, or wish to withdraw when no charge has been brought against them, make manifest that they were not all of it, for if they had been of it they would have continued with it.RH Jan 9, 1855 Therefore the church has nothing to do in formally disfellowshipping such persons but should grant their request and let them go.RH Jan 9, 1855 Fellowship was withdrawn from one who left because his departure showed he was not one of them, and this was made known so that the inexperienced would not mistake his standing or be harmed by his influence.RH Jan 28, 1858 Those whose lives showed they were not of the church were dropped from its rolls.RH May 14, 1914
One who has thus gone out or been disfellowshipped and wishes to return should be restored in meekness upon good evidence of divine forgiveness.RH Jan 9, 1855 Until then such a one must not occupy time in meetings as though nothing had happened, nor be admitted to the ordinances or as a witness for or against the saints any more than an unbeliever outside the church.RH Jan 9, 1855 The honest among those who left later come back to the remnant, recognizing where the Lord's work is.RH Jul 23, 1857
Those who have gone out endeavor to divide and distract the flock, and after leaving become bitter enemies working against truth and order.RH Dec 26, 1854RH Jul 18, 1854 They are disorderly spirits to receive no fellowship.RH Dec 26, 1854RH Jul 18, 1854 Those who remain must not be affected by them but must uphold those who stand for truth and order, and must mark such divisive persons so the flock will shun them.RH Jul 18, 1854 Standing by the organization while trusting God to defend His truth answers those who leave and now work against the church's organization and its work.RH Dec 26, 1907 To follow those who went out would be to leave the last message of mercy and go down to a low and degraded work of the enemy in perilous last days, while those who remain are God's called and faithful ones who have borne the burden and heat of the day firm on present truth.RH Dec 26, 1854
Separations in Advent History
Those who separated from the Seventh-day Adventist group and denomination to establish another meeting showed by going out that they were not in union with its work, for those truly belonging would have continued with it, and theological errors and departures leave the main body standing firm as God's spiritual church with Jesus as head joined together and growing into a holy temple.RH Jan 6, 1863RH Jul 22, 1915 In dispute over who separated from whom, those who held to the Adventist experience, fundamental principles, and prophetic course associated with 1844 remained, while the others gave these up and adopted a different course and thus departed.RH Nov 22, 1864 Responsibility for division rests with those who depart from the truth rather than those who uphold it, when people replace the church's original gospel with new teachings and persist in them while the church remains faithful.RH Jul 13, 1905
A spirit prompting separation from God's people entrusted with the Third Angel's Message is not from God, and the leaving of false brethren has served as a test strengthening the unity of those who remain committed to that message rather than their own wills.RH Oct 30, 1856RH Dec 16, 1858 Resistance to gospel order exposes a rebellious spirit leading to discord and slander, with some followers also abandoning the Sabbath, and those who left over obedience to the commandments revealed they were not of the faithful group while those who remained continued meeting to observe the sanctified day and study the Bible.RH Jul 31, 1856ST Jan 8, 1880 Those who reject the visions and separate show by going out that they were not of the body, for rejecting pure instruction and shutting the eyes to plain light soon leads to surrendering the main pillars of present truth and brings judicial blindness, while those who love and rejoice in the great Bible truths for this time continue and feel no disposition to quarrel with the visions.RH Aug 17, 1876
The same is manifest in individuals who left because they were ill at ease where the gift of prophecy and discernment exposed bad habits and then opposed the visions, and in those who left and tried to turn a reader against those writings while the reader judged them by their fruit.RH Dec 15, 1863 Departures connected with defense of tobacco use and intoxication by a preacher and a few adherents, leaving to practice free love which the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus give no place or nourishment so that it is a credit to commandment-keeping people that such ones must go outside to do it, and native students leaving those who trained them to seek higher wages, all reveal that those who left were not truly part of the fellowship.RH Sep 2, 1858ST Jul 20, 1904RH Aug 24, 1905 The principle applies to those who claim fellowship while circulating material that condemns and accuses former brethren and undermines confidence in workers, to those who work against the church's organization and work, and to men who stirred others against the community, whose departure made plain their lack of belonging and calls for standing by the organization while trusting God to defend His truth.RH Jun 10, 1909RH Dec 26, 1907RH Nov 16, 1916
One who left and boasted he would take many members with him failed among resident enrolled members in Salem, and in Lapeer one who had gone out circulated reports that caused a severe trial yet the brethren remained firm in the truth.ST Jul 31, 1884RH Jan 13, 1859 Those who go out to wreck the good work succeed only in confusing a few, for man cannot destroy God's work, since this message is a prophetic movement fulfilling the vision given on Patmos and must go forward, and its advance cannot be stopped any more than Pharaoh could stop Israel from leaving Egypt after God declared the seed of Abraham would come out with great substance after four hundred years of affliction, or than men could stop the sun from shining or the light of the threefold message of Revelation 14 from bringing hope.RH Mar 20, 1913 People leaving a church does not by itself disprove the truth or integrity of God's church, for at times God calls a faithful remnant out of a corrupt church, and those who answer have resisted corruption while still connected to the larger body, remain faithful to God's word, go forward in His work, and do not make faultfinding their chief concern.ST Aug 4, 1909
Warning and Faithful Living
The warning about antichrists belongs among the persons to be avoided by those who walk in the light, for their going out from the believers makes clear that they did not truly belong to them.ST Sep 25, 1893 Genuine belonging would have led them to remain, so their departure makes the separation plain, and this apostasy is a mark of the last time.ST Oct 16, 1893 The incarnation is the testing truth, involving the union of divinity and humanity in the believer, and to accept this experience means dying to self and giving up temporal things, a test which some fail to endure.ST Oct 16, 1893 God's power in the church serves to remove such unworthy members.ST Oct 16, 1893
Trials and persecution expose professors whose faith is not steadfast, so that those who abandon the Christian community under trial reveal that they were not truly of it, for had they belonged to it they would have remained.RH Jun 3, 1858ST Jun 5, 1879 Their falling away makes their false profession manifest, in contrast with the perseverance of those who belong to the community in truth.RH Jun 3, 1858ST Jun 5, 1879
Some go out from among believers by giving up one point of truth after another until they are probably gone forever.RH May 14, 1861 The first wrong discoverable in them is a disposition to find fault with those God is especially using to advance His cause, which is contrary to brotherly love that lays down life for the brethren.RH May 14, 1861 Their going out manifests that they were not all of the body, and warns that many more will have to be sifted out unless they humble themselves, confess all faults, and seek righteousness and meekness to be hid in the day of the Lord's fierce anger.RH May 14, 1861
Those who leave the church after efforts to reclaim them have failed reveal by their departure that they were not truly of the church, for those who left the believers had not truly belonged with them and their departure made this plain.RH Jul 23, 1857RH Mar 5, 1857 Their leaving became a blessing by drawing out a clear testimony and teaching believers to trust God rather than people.RH Jul 23, 1857 It also warns against murmuring against God's work or those He employs.RH Jul 23, 1857 The honest among those who left later came back to the remnant, recognizing where the Lord's work was.RH Jul 23, 1857
Professed beliefs should be matched by consistent conduct, so those who hold opposing teachings should not be treated as though they share the same faith, and Christians should not compromise truth to win their favor.RH Sep 22, 1910 Judas was outwardly among Christ's disciples but was not truly one of them, having no fellowship or shared purpose with Christ and the loyal disciples because he was walking in darkness.ST Nov 22, 1883 His departure made plain that he did not belong to them.ST Nov 22, 1883
Sources