1 Corinthians 3:4
For while one saith, I am of Paul; and another, I am of Apollos; are ye not carnal?
Translations
For while one says, I am of Paul; and another, I am of Apollos; are you not carnal?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
For while one saith, I am of Paul; and another, I am of Apollos; are ye not carnal?
Revised Version, American Standard Version
For when one saith, I am of Paul; and another, I am of Apollos; are ye not men?
for when one may say, 'I, indeed, am of Paul;' and another, 'I — of Apollos;' are ye not fleshly?
For when one says, I am of Paul, and another, I of Apollos, are ye not men?
For, as soon as one beginneth to say—I, indeed, am of Paul! and another—I, of Apollos! are ye not, men?
For when one of you says, “ I follow Paul,” and another, “ I follow Apollos,” are you not mere men?
For when one of you says, “ I follow Paul,” and another, “ I follow Apollos,” are you not of the flesh?
For when one says, “ I follow Paul,” and another, “ I follow Apollos,” aren’t you fleshly?
For when one says, I am of Paul; and another says, I am of Apollos; are you not talking like natural men?
For when one sayeth, I am Pauls, and another, I am Apollos, are yee not carnall?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
For while one saith, I indeed am of Paul; and another, I am of Apollo; are you not men? What then is Apollo, and what is Paul?
Cross-references
- 1 Corinthians 1:12
Now this I say, that every one of you saith, I am of Paul; and I of Apollos; and I of Cephas; and I of Christ.
Names rival groups claiming loyalty to Paul, Apollos, Cephas, or Christ.
- 1 Corinthians 3:8-9
Now he that planteth and he that watereth are one: and every man shall receive his own reward according to his own labour.
Planters and waterers are one, fellow workers with God.
- 1 Corinthians 1:10
Now I beseech you, brethren, by the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that ye all speak the same thing, and that there be no divisions among you; but that ye be perfectly joined together in the same mind and in the same judgment.
Calls believers to speak alike and avoid divisions.
- 1 Corinthians 3:11
For other foundation can no man lay than that is laid, which is Jesus Christ.
Christ alone is the church’s foundation, not human leaders.
- Acts 18:1-11
After these things Paul departed from Athens, and came to Corinth;
Paul preaches in Corinth and establishes the church addressed in the epistle.
- 1 Corinthians 3:22-23
Whether Paul, or Apollos, or Cephas, or the world, or life, or death, or things present, or things to come; all are yours;
Believers belong to Christ, not to competing human leaders.
- Acts 18:27-28
And when he was disposed to pass into Achaia, the brethren wrote, exhorting the disciples to receive him: who, when he was come, helped them much which had believed through grace:
Apollos strengthened believers and taught Christ, prompting comparisons with Paul.
- Ephesians 4:3-4
Endeavouring to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace.
Believers are called to preserve the unity of the one body.
- 1 Corinthians 1:13
Is Christ divided? was Paul crucified for you? or were ye baptized in the name of Paul?
both condemn party cries of Paul, Apollos, Cephas
- 1 Corinthians 3:8
Now he that planteth and he that watereth are one: and every man shall receive his own reward according to his own labour.
Different labors share one object and reward.
- 1 Corinthians 3:10
According to the grace of God which is given unto me, as a wise masterbuilder, I have laid the foundation, and another buildeth thereon. But let every man take heed how he buildeth thereupon.
Warns ministers to take care how they build.
- Romans 8:7
Because the carnal mind is enmity against God: for it is not subject to the law of God, neither indeed can be.
both blame divisions on the carnal mind
- Philippians 2:2
Fulfil ye my joy, that ye be like minded, having the same love, being of one accord, of one mind.
Harmony in thought and purpose is commended in contrast with division.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
45 sources
To say I am of Paul and I am of Apollos is to divide into rival parties around human leaders.RH Dec 11, 1900STB 197.6–198.1Lt 80, 1908, par. 4–5 That party spirit proves carnality, walking as men in envy, jealousy, strife and division instead of in the mind and Spirit of Christ.RH Dec 11, 19008RED 73.2–74.2AA 273.3–274.1Ms 130, 1899, par. 17Lt 66, 1908, par. 2–6 It shows believers are still babes in Christ, able to bear only milk and not yet solid spiritual food.Lt 231, 1903, par. 13–15Lt 66, 1908, par. 2–6Ms 74, 1899, par. 1–2 Paul, Apollos and their fellow workers are only servants by whom men believed, one planting and another watering while God alone gives the increase.8RED 73.2–74.2AA 273.3–274.1RH Aug 17, 1911Lt 231, 1903, par. 13–15SLP 126.1–3 Therefore glorying in men must cease, and all must humble the heart, glory in the Lord, and cleave together to Christ.Ms 130, 1901, par. 30–33Lt 56, 1893, par. 22–25Ms 99, 1902, par. 29–30
Factions at Corinth
The verse records a division in which one believer declared allegiance to Paul and another to Apollos, with some also claiming Peter or Cephas.RH Dec 11, 1900STB 197.6–198.1Lt 80, 1908, par. 4–5Ms 37, 1902, par. 15–16Ms 59, 1902, par. 7–9 Such taking of sides around different ministers in divisive comparison is the mark of a harmful party spirit.SLP 127.3–128.1
Paul had planted the church at Corinth by preaching Christ and His mission in plain, simple truth, unadorned with worldly wisdom, after disappointment with the result of using learning and eloquence at Athens.RH Aug 17, 1911SLP 120.1–2 Apollos later watered the seed that Paul had planted, teaching and helping it to grow, and his success in preaching through eloquent discourses and manifest learning led many hearers to contrast the two styles and exalt his labors above those of Paul.RH Aug 17, 1911AA 270.2SLP 120.1–2RH Aug 17, 1911 The differences between the ministers so contrasted were imaginary.SLP 120.1–2 Apollos had gone to Corinth to support Paul's labors among the Jews and worked in harmony with Paul for the advancement of the cause.SLP 120.1–2
Paul and Apollos were in harmony and did not encourage the rivalry or the preference shown.SLP 127.3–128.1AA 280.2 Because of the division raised over him, Apollos left Corinth and returned only after its spiritual condition improved.AA 280.2 Satan took advantage of the contrasting of the ministers to tempt the church to hold them in contrast.SLP 120.1–2 This rival, party spirit fostered by comparing the preachers and preferring the work of Apollos over that of Paul brought Paul conflict and trial inside the church as well as outside it, and threatened to greatly hinder the progress of the gospel and of truth.AA 270.2SLP 120.1–2RH Aug 17, 1911
Meaning of Carnal
To declare oneself for Paul and another for Apollos is carnality and walking as mere men.8RED 73.2–74.2AA 273.3–274.1RH Aug 17, 1911Ms 37, 1902, par. 15–16Lt 231, 1903, par. 13–15 It reflects the natural, self-centered heart and human ways rather than God's order.AA 273.3–274.1RH Aug 17, 1911Ms 37, 1902, par. 15–16 It means walking governed by human ways instead of wholehearted surrender to God.Ms 37, 1902, par. 15–16 The ministers themselves are only human servants commissioned to teach the truth, doing the same work marked out by the Father and dependent on Him for success, one planting and the other watering while God alone gives the increase and transforms character.8RED 73.2–74.2AA 273.3–274.1RH Aug 17, 1911
That carnal state is envying and strife and divisions over human leaders.RH Dec 11, 1900Ms 130, 1899, par. 17Lt 66, 1908, par. 2–6Ms 74, 1899, par. 1–29T 197.1 Such factions arise from jealousy, strife and division and prove the absence of the mind and Spirit of Christ.RH Dec 11, 1900Ms 130, 1899, par. 17Lt 66, 1908, par. 2–6 They leave the church in great weakness with dwarfed spiritual growth and are the plain cause of its difficulties.Ms 74, 1899, par. 1–2 In that condition even a plain message about self becomes an offense, and the one who speaks the truth is ranked as an accuser and faultfinder.Ms 74, 1899, par. 1–2 Erecting separating barriers by human invention is that same carnal party spirit.9T 197.1
It means believers are still babes in Christ who must be fed with milk because they are not yet able to bear meat.Lt 231, 1903, par. 13–15Lt 66, 1908, par. 2–6Ms 74, 1899, par. 1–220MR 335.1–3 Milk is the plainest, most simple truths suitable for converts young in the faith, while meat is solid, nourishing spiritual food suited to those who have made progress in knowledge of divine things.20MR 335.1–3 Remaining able to bear only milk and not meat or spiritual things shows failure to feed on Christ.Ms 74, 1899, par. 1–220MR 335.1–3
It shows they do not have the mind and Spirit of Christ but walk after narrow, conceited, selfish human wisdom, with views and feelings bound about by selfishness.RH Dec 11, 1900Ms 130, 1899, par. 17 It is life on a low level, dwelling on surface truth which calls for no thought and no deep research and no advance in spiritual knowledge.20MR 335.1–3Ms 70, 1901, par. 1–5 Such contending over human leaders does not show growth in grace but narrow, limited comprehension and defective, worthless experience.20MR 335.4–5Ms 70, 1901, par. 1–5 It is the opposite of feeding on Christ and partaking of the divine nature, for those who partake do not seek to stand at the head of a party but lead men to Christ and to the truth that makes all one in Him.20MR 335.1–320MR 335.4–5Ms 70, 1901, par. 1–5 Party loyalty reveals the absence of the liberality, generosity and tenderness that mark an abiding Christ.RH Dec 11, 1900Ms 130, 1899, par. 17
It means glorying in men and being puffed up for one minister against another.Ms 130, 1901, par. 30–33 It means showing and talking preferences by comparing one with another to the detriment of the one not preferred.Ms 130, 1901, par. 30–33 It means judging brethren because they do not regard one's own words and spirit and actions as perfection.Ms 130, 1901, par. 30–33 It means showing preference to men and leaning upon them as though eternal life depended upon them.Ms 111, 1909, par. 11–13 It means linking up with the one man under whose labors light was received, placing oneself on his side and refusing harmony with brethren, and tying up in separate bundles.Ms 130, 1901, par. 25–26 It means liking one speaker better and wanting to hear him rather than another, which is self and must be laid aside for oneness.Ms 82, 1886, par. 10
Ministers Are Servants
Paul and Apollos and those who followed them were only men commissioned of God to teach the truth, ministers and servants by whom men believed as the Lord gave to every man.8RED 73.2–74.2Lt 231, 1903, par. 13–15Lt 66, 1908, par. 2–6SLP 126.1–39T 197.1 They were individually engaged in the same work marked out by the Heavenly Father, each with his distinctive work, and wholly dependent on Him for the success attending their labors.8RED 73.2–74.2AA 273.3–274.1SLP 126.1–3 Though gifts differed, they served to the same object and were not the source of success.AA 273.3–274.1RH Aug 17, 1911Ms 67, 1900, par. 14–16
Paul planted and Apollos watered, for Paul first preached the gospel and planted the church at Corinth and Apollos later watered the seed by teaching and helping it grow.8RED 73.2–74.2RH Aug 17, 1911 Neither he that plants nor he that waters is anything, for neither causes growth nor deserves its glory.8RED 73.2–74.2RH Aug 17, 1911Lt 231, 1903, par. 13–15Lt 66, 1908, par. 2–69T 197.1 God alone gives the increase and transforms character through divine power.8RED 73.2–74.2RH Aug 17, 1911Lt 231, 1903, par. 13–15
He that plants and he that waters are one, laborers together with God, with diversity of gifts to blend harmoniously as only instruments of divine grace and power in carrying forward the great work of salvation.8RED 73.2–74.2Lt 231, 1903, par. 13–15SLP 126.1–39T 197.1 Every man shall receive his own reward according to his own labor, while believers are God's husbandry and God's building.8RED 73.2–74.2Lt 231, 1903, par. 13–15Lt 66, 1908, par. 2–69T 197.1 That building is on the only foundation that can be laid, which is Jesus Christ, whose building work will be made manifest and tried by fire, as the holy temple of God indwelt by the Spirit of God, which no man may defile without destruction.Lt 231, 1903, par. 13–15 Consciousness of being God's servants inspires energy and diligence to perseveringly discharge duty with an eye single to the Master's glory.8RED 73.2–74.2
Therefore the teacher of Christ's truth must stay near the cross himself in order to bring sinners to it, must preach Christ, and must studiously avoid calling attention to himself and attracting people to himself.8RED 73.2–74.2SLP 126.1–320MR 335.4–5Ms 70, 1901, par. 1–5 He is to preach the truth that makes all men one in Christ Jesus and to attract men not to himself but to Christ.8RED 73.2–74.2SLP 126.1–320MR 335.4–5Ms 70, 1901, par. 1–5 To draw attention to self encumbers sacred truth and hinders its saving power.8RED 73.2–74.2SLP 126.1–3
Unity and Humility Required
The cure begins with humbling the heart before God, refusing to think of men above what is written, and recognizing that Paul and Apollos and Cephas and all things belong to all believers alike because believers are Christ's and Christ is God's.Ms 130, 1901, par. 30–33 Glorying in men, being puffed up for one minister against another, showing and talking preferences by comparing one with another to the detriment of the one not preferred, and judging brethren because they do not regard one's words and spirit and actions as perfection, must be put away.Ms 130, 1901, par. 30–33 He that glories must glory in the Lord and not in men, for Christ Jesus is made unto believers wisdom and righteousness and sanctification and redemption.Lt 56, 1893, par. 22–25 Worldly-wise men count the preaching of the cross as foolishness, and men who have given their lives to worldly pursuits and cultivated sharp business traits after a worldly order do not come into the truth in large numbers, for not many wise men after the flesh, not many mighty, not many noble are called.Lt 56, 1893, par. 22–25 In the wisdom of God the world by wisdom knew not God, and it pleased God by the foolishness of preaching to save them that believe, choosing the foolish things of the world to confound the wise and the weak things to confound the mighty and base and despised things and things which are not to bring to nought things that are, that no flesh should glory in His presence.Lt 56, 1893, par. 22–25
Ministers are not to be idolized, and there are to be no religious pets and favorites, but the truths they bring from the Word of God are to be accepted and appreciated in meekness and humility.SLP 127.1–2 Seldom does one minister have all the qualifications necessary to perfect a church in all the requirements of Christianity, so God sends other ministers to follow one after another, each possessing some qualifications in which the others were deficient.SLP 127.1–2 The church should gratefully accept these servants of Christ even as the Master Himself and seek all possible benefit from their instruction, for God sends help as they need, not as they choose, since short-sighted mortals cannot discern what is for their highest good.SLP 127.1–2 Saying one likes one speaker better and would rather hear him than another is self and is carnal and unsanctified, and it must be laid aside for oneness, with workers presenting unity everywhere they go, studying early and late to defend their brethren, and laboring in harmony to fit men for immortality under God's mold instead of turning against fellow workers when their own way and will are crossed.Ms 82, 1886, par. 10
No one is to fasten the soul to a human leader or follow human devising, for Christ is the only Leader.Lt 37, 1899, par. 9–12Lt 37, 1899, par. 13–17Lt 233, 1899, par. 13–14 Believers are not to claim allegiance to one worker against another as though the work belonged to them, nor try to manage God's work by personal ideas, for ministers are servants through whom people believe while God gives the growth, and Christian workers have different parts in the work as fellow workers under God.Lt 37, 1899, par. 9–12Lt 37, 1899, par. 13–17 Believers must not act from an unconverted spirit to order, control, or dictate the work of God's servants, and human mistakes do not justify placing all workers under restrictive rules or the judgment of fallible people, for doing so brings confusion and dishonors God.Ms 128, 1908, par. 20–22 God gives each person a distinctive work and freedom to seek His instruction through prayer and the Holy Spirit and the Scriptures, rather than being ruled by another person's mind, and no ruling power should compel men to obey the dictates of the finite mind, for men must cease from man whose breath is in his nostrils.Ms 128, 1908, par. 20–22Ms 73, 1907, par. 13JIOKP 19.1 Relying on human wisdom instead of the Holy Spirit turns people from seeing God, for turning minds to lean on human wisdom places a veil between God and man so that there is no seeing of Him who is invisible.STB 498.1Ms 73, 1907, par. 13JIOKP 19.1
Workers in ministry and in medical missionary work must wear the yoke of Christ and walk in humility of mind before God, using their varied gifts to bless humanity.Ms 130, 1905, par. 12–13Lt 233, 1899, par. 13–1421MR 400.2–4 There is to be no jealousy of Paul or Apollos or Cephas, no friction, no quarreling, and no division between workers, but harmony in every action and in every part of the work controlled and guided by the wisdom God gives, drawing in even cords without friction as one united body under Christ.Ms 130, 1905, par. 12–13Lt 233, 1899, par. 13–1421MR 400.2–4 Ministers must give room to fellow laborers and not measure brethren by their own ideas, nor find fault with another person's work but improve their own.Lt 37, 1899, par. 9–12Lt 37, 1899, par. 13–17Lt 233, 1899, par. 13–14 Those in whom Christ abides will not quarrel but will stand under His standard, united by the desire to strengthen His work, following His directions for restoring the moral image of God in man in His name and for the glory of God and blessing humanity.Lt 233, 1899, par. 13–1421MR 400.2–4
The same carnal party spirit appears in erecting national barriers in the church, which is a plan of human invention that God can never endorse.9T 197.1 It is seen in withdrawing from some brethren for reasons existing only in the imagination and binding up with others, and in cherishing prejudice, envy, jealousy, evil surmising and discord against brethren.Ms 67, 1900, par. 14–16 It is seen in condemning a minister because he emphasizes a different phase of truth or presents the Word in a different way, or in fearing that brethren do not value his exposition of truth.Ms 67, 1900, par. 14–16 Such envying and strife and divisions make the church weak, separate brethren from one another and from God, and hinder the manifestation of the Spirit of God, for ministers are only servants by whom belief comes, working to the same object with one planting and another watering but God alone giving the increase.9T 197.1Ms 67, 1900, par. 14–16
Saying I am of Paul and I am of Apollos means linking up with the one man under whose labors the light of present truth was received, placing oneself on the side of the one who brought light and truth and refusing to be in harmony with brethren, ranging after human leaders and tying up in separate bundles.Ms 130, 1901, par. 25–2616MR 196.1–2 Such party loyalty proves want of meekness and humility and wholehearted kindness, making men independent atoms instead of sanctified channels and representatives of grace prepared and aided by one Agency from one great and powerful Source in love and harmonious action, each strengthening the other.Ms 130, 1901, par. 25–2616MR 196.1–2 It proves they are not being sanctified through the truth but are carnal babes in Christ fed with milk and not meat, walking as men with envying and strife and divisions among them, presenting division in place of unity to the world and to angels and to men.Ms 130, 1901, par. 25–2616MR 196.1–2 It is dangerous ground needing warning and education to a better understanding of the spirit that should control actions as believers in Christ Jesus, that each take diligent heed to his own course in presenting sanctifying truth to souls ready to die and make straight paths for their feet lest the lame be turned out of the way.Ms 130, 1901, par. 25–2616MR 196.1–2 Those cemented to the man who brought them the truth need reconversion as soon as possible, else their claimed conversion is a stumbling block to sinners.Ms 130, 1901, par. 25–26
Study and Present Application
The opening three chapters of First Corinthians, with the first and second as preparation for the third, are to be carefully read, studied, understood and practiced in every church as a special work and education for this time.Ms 74, 1899, par. 1–220MR 335.1–3 They are to be read with much prayer for correction, teaching that faith rests on God's power and that spiritual understanding comes through the Spirit.Lt 56, 1893, par. 22–25Lt 280, 1906, par. 20–25 Claiming to follow Paul or claiming to follow Apollos proves carnality and walking as men, the same as envying and strife and divisions over human leaders.Ms 74, 1899, par. 1–220MR 335.1–3 That carnal state left the church in great weakness with dwarfed spiritual growth, still babes in Christ able to bear only milk and not meat or spiritual things.Ms 74, 1899, par. 1–220MR 335.1–3 Milk is the plainest, most simple truths suitable for converts young in the faith, while meat is solid, nourishing spiritual food suited to those who have made progress in knowledge of divine things.20MR 335.1–3 Such party spirit shows life on a low level, dwelling on surface truth which calls for no thought and no deep research and no advance in spiritual knowledge, and not feeding on Christ.20MR 335.1–3 It is shown when a plain Thus saith the Lord about self is an offense and the one who speaks the truth is ranked as an accuser and faultfinder.Ms 74, 1899, par. 1–2 Worldly-wise men count the preaching of the cross as foolishness, so men who have given their lives to worldly pursuits and cultivated sharp business traits after a worldly order do not come into the truth in large numbers.Lt 56, 1893, par. 22–25 Not many wise men after the flesh, not many mighty, not many noble are called, because in the wisdom of God the world by wisdom knew not God, and it pleased God by the foolishness of preaching to save them that believe.Lt 56, 1893, par. 22–25 God has chosen the foolish things of the world to confound the wise, and the weak things to confound the mighty, and base and despised things, and things which are not, to bring to nought things that are, that no flesh should glory in His presence.Lt 56, 1893, par. 22–25 Christ Jesus is made unto believers wisdom and righteousness and sanctification and redemption, so he that glories must glory in the Lord and not in men.Lt 56, 1893, par. 22–25
The instruction and reproof of the third chapter is given to ministers of the gospel and to all churches wherever they are located and to be read in every church.Ms 58, 1911, par. 6–7 Ministers must receive its representation, humble their hearts before God, seek the truth for their souls' sake, and search the Scriptures, for unless they humble their hearts their names will not be placed in the book of life.Ms 58, 1911, par. 6–7 The verse is to be taken home, thought over, and personally applied as a test of readiness for the Lord's coming, because many who think they are prepared are not.Ms 111, 1909, par. 28–30 With prayer God will give understanding of it, and obeying it means separating from all hindrances, knowing the will of God and walking in that pathway, confessing Christ and coming out of darkness into His marvelous light, becoming free and all light in the Lord.Ms 111, 1909, par. 28–30 Dividing into parties around human leaders is carnal strife that must cease among God's people.Ms 99, 1902, par. 29–30 True believers will not range themselves under Paul or Apollos but will bear one testimony in cleaving to Christ.Ms 99, 1902, par. 29–30 In view of common peril and coming trouble, all strife must be put away, and when the storm of persecution comes the true sheep who know the Shepherd's voice will gather to Him.Ms 99, 1902, par. 29–30
Envy, strife, and divisions that form around human leaders reveal a carnal, unspiritual spirit and bring a dearth of the Spirit of God in the church.Lt 37, 1899, par. 9–12Lt 280, 1906, par. 4–5 Christians are not to claim allegiance to one worker against another or try to manage God's work by personal ideas, as though the work belonged to human preachers.Lt 37, 1899, par. 9–12Lt 37, 1899, par. 13–17 Ministers are servants through whom people believe, while God gives the growth, and Christian workers have different parts in the work but are fellow workers under God.Lt 37, 1899, par. 9–12Lt 37, 1899, par. 13–17 Believers should not find fault with another person's work, but improve their own and cooperate under God's direction.Lt 37, 1899, par. 9–12Lt 37, 1899, par. 13–17 The verse is so applied to divisions over the medical missionary work and to the need for workers to cooperate under God's direction.Lt 37, 1899, par. 9–12 Ranging after human leaders and making favorites is being carnal and not spiritual, marking those who are still babes in Christ, fed with milk, showing envy, strife and division, pomposity and grasping for supremacy.10MR 185.3–187.2 Applied to marriage it condemns giving first affection to another man's wife or to another woman, putting one's own wife second, and living in dangerous sentimental and spiritualistic impurity in mind and heart.10MR 185.3–187.2 Such favoritism dishonors God, spoils both persons, is a sign of the last days belonging to the wicked, and requires repentance, conversion, centering of the affections by Christ on proper objects, and being true as steel to marriage vows in thought, word and deed.10MR 185.3–187.2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
30 sources
The verse exposes the party cries at Corinth, with one claiming Paul and another Apollos, as sinful faction that Paul severely reproves.ST Nov 8, 1910RH Sep 19, 1871ST Oct 28, 1908 To be carnal there means to remain babes in Christ, able to bear only milk and not strong meat, showing spiritual immaturity instead of growth.RH Oct 31, 1907ST Oct 16, 1893ST Feb 19, 1894 Ministers are only servants and fellow workers through whom people believe, one planting and another watering while God alone gives the increase and transforms character.RH Aug 17, 1911ST Sep 23, 1886ST Jul 15, 1889 Ranging around human leaders and contending over personal preferences is carnality, springing from jealousy, envy and strife and showing lack of Christ's mind and Spirit.RH Dec 11, 1900ST Sep 23, 1886ST Nov 19, 1912 Christ, not any minister, is the one to follow, and believers must put carnal contention away and be joined in unity of mind and judgment as one solid building in Him.ST Sep 23, 1886RH Oct 3, 1907ST Feb 19, 1894ST May 16, 1878ST Dec 2, 1880
Words and Corinthian Setting
The cries of one for Paul and another for Apollos marked a sinful party division and faction among believers who were ranging themselves after different teachers.ST Nov 8, 1910RH Sep 19, 1871ST Oct 28, 1908 That divisive spirit was carnal, and the letter was written in part to correct it and severely reproves it.ST Nov 8, 1910RH Sep 19, 1871ST Oct 28, 1908 The church addressed stood not only in the city of Corinth but in the district of Achaia, a great commercial center on the overland route from Rome to the East between upper and lower Greece with the only good harbor in that section and a mostly foreign population including many Romans.ST Nov 8, 1910
Paul first preached the gospel and planted the church at Corinth, spending a year and six months teaching the word of God there.RH Aug 17, 1911ST Oct 16, 1893 Apollos later watered the seed by teaching and helping it grow.RH Aug 17, 1911 Yet five years afterward the Corinthians were still carnal after having had opportunity to gain an experience in divine things.ST Oct 16, 1893
To be carnal is the same as being babes in Christ, able to bear only milk and not strong meat, reflecting spiritual immaturity and lack of growth.ST Oct 16, 1893 Claiming allegiance to particular ministers rather than showing spiritual maturity proves that undue carnality remains.RH Aug 17, 1911RH Oct 31, 1907ST Oct 16, 1893ST Feb 19, 1894 Contending over individual preferences for ministers is the mark of an old babe who has not grown up in Christ, and those who argue and contend in this day over their preferences, either in the ministry or out of it, are no farther advanced in spiritual growth.ST Feb 19, 1894
The verse belongs to Paul's argument about the work of the gospel and building on Christ.ST Feb 14, 1884 That argument gives instruction especially for ministers, who are the builders in the figure.ST Feb 14, 1884 The third and fourth chapters teach that Jesus Christ is the only foundation upon which character and the church can be built.ST Aug 11, 1909 Believers are members of God's building and must work together, because separated from one another they cannot serve effectively.RH Oct 3, 1907
Carnality, Ministry, and Unity
Ministers are human servants commissioned to teach the truth, fellow laborers through whom people come to believe, doing the same work in the different roles God assigned by planting and watering.RH Aug 17, 1911ST Sep 23, 1886ST Jul 15, 1889RH Jul 23, 1914ST Nov 15, 1883 Paul first preached the gospel and planted the church, and Apollos afterward watered the seed by teaching and helping it grow.RH Aug 17, 1911 Neither the planter nor the waterer causes growth or is anything apart from God, so the work belongs to God rather than to any person or group, for God alone gives the increase and transforms character by divine power, and their work has value only through connection with Him.RH Aug 17, 1911ST Sep 23, 1886ST Jul 15, 1889RH Jul 23, 1914ST Nov 15, 1883 Christ, not any human minister, is the one to follow and imitate.ST Dec 2, 1880
Ranging around human leaders, worshiping men, and contending over individual preferences is carnality, revealing the natural self-centered heart and narrow conceited selfish judgments rather than the generosity and tenderness of an abiding Christ.RH Dec 11, 1900RH Aug 17, 1911ST Sep 23, 1886 It follows human earthly ways rather than godly wisdom, arising from jealousy, envy, strife, and division.RH Dec 11, 1900ST Sep 23, 1886ST Mar 27, 1884ST Aug 3, 1882 It shows lack of Christ's mind and Spirit, lack of conversion and forgetting Christ, and that the Holy Spirit has not been given His rightful place.RH Dec 11, 1900ST Nov 19, 1912ST Nov 19, 1912 Claiming allegiance to particular ministers such as Paul or Apollos is evidence of this carnal and worldly condition.ST Nov 19, 1912ST Mar 27, 1884ST Aug 3, 1882ST Nov 19, 1912
Favoritism toward favorite ministers, comparing their work, elevating one above another, condemning the other side, and boasting in a preacher as a superior orator tends to create dissension and factions.RH Aug 17, 1911RH Jul 23, 1914ST Nov 15, 1883RH Jul 5, 1864 This repeats the divisive spirit of the early church, and as when Apollos was elevated above Paul it created party divisions that threatened the progress of the gospel.RH Aug 17, 1911RH Jul 5, 1864 Association with Paul or Apollos, and even zealous labor and eloquent speech, does not by itself prove genuine Christianity.RH Jul 27, 1916 A person's true measure is the heart's relationship to God and the life lived in private as well as in public, so profession without a sincere personal life is pretense.RH Jul 27, 1916
Christians may rightly value those who first brought them the truth, but partiality toward particular workers replaces selfless Christian love.ST Sep 23, 1886 Contending over preferences for ministers, whether in the ministry or out of it, is the mark of an old babe who has not grown up in Christ, proving undue carnality remains.ST Feb 19, 1894 Belonging to Christ must become the one central thought and all-prevailing ambition that swallows up every other preference, putting carnal contention away as the bondwoman and her son, types of carnality, were cast out when Isaac was weaned.ST Feb 19, 1894
Such divisions prevent Christians from being joined into a solid unified body in Christ, for separated from one another they cannot serve effectively as members of God's building.RH Oct 3, 1907ST May 16, 1878 The opposite required is unity of mind and judgment with all speaking the same thing, and then the building will go up without the sound of a hammer with all parts fitly joined together growing up into a perfect building in Christ.RH Aug 5, 1873 To claim that one may be of Paul, another of Apollos, another of Cephas, and yet all be of Christ, so that denominational distinctions are not inconsistent with unity, keeps the carnality condemned.RH Oct 18, 1870 Such visible unity by open communion and interchange of pulpits, by agreeing on unscriptural dogmas while compromising revealed doctrines as non-essential and agreeing to disagree, and by boasted charity that still keeps sectarian prejudice, is false and cannot form a permanent solid structure.RH Oct 18, 1870RH Aug 5, 1873
Men's divisions and heresies, including churches divided into rival sects with strife, jealousy, and hostility, originate in and are perpetuated by the carnal mind and not by the Bible.RH Oct 22, 1872RH Oct 30, 1860 Their blame therefore cannot be laid upon God as Author of revelation nor used to justify an alliance that sets aside the word of God and compromises its truths.RH Oct 22, 1872 Believers must refuse assent to such a confederacy and sanctify the Lord and stand in word and deed for His word even when unpopular.RH Oct 22, 1872 The warning against divisions within God's people is not against their sharing a distinct name that sets them apart.
The wider chapter shows that the church contains people of different characters, represented by building materials of differing worth with some members unworthy.RH Aug 4, 1874 The church must therefore take care to preserve its purity while welcoming those who show repentance, faith in Christ, and a resolve to live holy lives.RH Aug 4, 1874 Identifying with Paul or Apollos instead of living in unity is evidence of a carnal mind, and the reference also supports understanding spirit in 1 Thessalonians 5:23 as the mind.RH Aug 2, 1864
Sources