1 Thessalonians 4:16
For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God: and the dead in Christ shall rise first:
For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God: and the dead in Christ shall rise first:
Commentary part 2 of 3
Pioneers and periodicals (continued)
Public Audible Descent
His coming is one future, certain, real, open, public, visible, audible, glorious, unmistakable and dramatic event with shout, archangel voice, trumpet, clouds, angels and lightning brightness from east to west, witnessed by all the earth and reaching even the dead, seen by every eye including those who pierced him.ST Mar 11, 1886RH May 18, 1869RH May 16, 1907ST Aug 7, 1884RH Dec 8, 1915 The Lord himself descends personally from heaven at his second coming, and at his coming the dead in Christ rise first before the living who remain are caught up together to meet him in the air to be ever with him, which comforts those mourning fellow believers and proves the righteous receive no reward until he comes.ST Mar 11, 1886RH May 18, 1869RH May 16, 1907ST Aug 7, 1884RH Dec 9, 1902 The trumpet blast shakes the earth and opens the graves, awakening those who sleep in death, and the gathering is carried out by angels at his command.ST Aug 7, 1884ST Jan 6, 1887RH Jun 9, 1910
It is not secret, quiet, hidden, mystical, spiritual, confined to desert, room or movement, seen only by a few, or a series of gradual comings; any christ who does not come publicly in this manner is false, and this openness guards against false christs, false prophets and deceptive signs.ST Mar 11, 1886RH May 18, 1869RH May 16, 1907ST Aug 7, 1884RH Dec 8, 1915 He returns openly, not secretly, and the promise is a certain reality to be considered, not a matter of speculation about timing which remains unrevealed.ST Aug 7, 1884RH Dec 9, 1902 The descent with shout, archangel voice and trump is a public alarming manifestation like Sinai with rolling thunder after solemn preparation, unparalleled until then, heard throughout the earth as sweet music to friends and threatening thunder to foes, effecting resurrection and gathering that cannot be counterfeited.ST Aug 7, 1884ST Jan 6, 1887RH Jun 10, 1858RH Aug 2, 1864 The shout is a commanding roll-call as the King calls each faithful person by name from the Book of Life, and the call reaches everywhere from wave-hidden caves, desert sands, battlefields, dungeons, mountains and ocean depths, sending forth thousands and millions and awakening the echoes of heaven and hell.RH Jun 9, 1910RH Aug 2, 1864
He comes with all his holy angels until heaven is emptied and silent at the seventh seal for about seven days, angels sent to graves, gathering the elect from the four winds from every age, nation, race and walk of life, reuniting friends and carrying saints aloft to his presence.ST Aug 7, 1884ST Apr 2, 1912ST Nov 11, 1913ST Sep 16, 1930 Each person's guardian angel receives them as they rise from the long sleep of death, and the trumpet signals the angels to descend from Christ, the saints being changed to immortality in an instant at its sounding before the angels carry them from the earth in a separation of righteous from wicked by a judgment already decided.RH Feb 22, 1870 Christ does not touch the earth or set foot on the sin-cursed earth at this meeting but remains in mid-heaven in the air, calling his people to himself in clouds to take them to heaven, distinct from his later coming at the end of the thousand years when the New Jerusalem descends and his feet stand on the Mount of Olives.ST Apr 2, 1912ST May 5, 1914ST Feb 24, 1914ST Oct 20, 1914ST Nov 11, 1913 This resurrection begins the thousand years, and the resurrected saints with the living righteous go with him to heaven to remain with him during the millennium and to the mansions in the Father's house until the curse is removed.ST May 5, 1914ST Oct 20, 1914
Together with the next verse the passage describes two bodily classes in God's kingdom, the dead who are raised and those alive who are translated, shown in miniature at the transfiguration where Moses who died represents those raised and Elijah taken without dying represents those translated, with Enoch also typing the living.ST Oct 12, 1876ST May 14, 1894ST Dec 8, 1914ST Jan 11, 1905RH Jul 31, 1866 When Jesus comes in his kingdom in glory the dead in Christ rise first made immortal, and the living saints are changed to immortality without tasting death, and together with Christ as King in glory these groups make up the saints in the kingdom of God.ST Dec 8, 1914ST Apr 1, 1886RH Jul 31, 1866 The living righteous who remain until the coming, including the sealed 144,000, are changed in a moment in the twinkling of an eye without dying or tasting death, as Enoch and Elijah were, redeemed from among the living after conflict with the beast, his image, mark and number.CO 95.5ST May 13, 1908ST Mar 20, 1884ST Aug 21, 1884ST Aug 14, 1884 That change is the same as dying and being raised with a new body that cannot decay, putting them on an equality with those raised from death, so those asleep suffer no loss and the living have no precedence but both are glorified together at his coming and neither before he comes.ST May 13, 1908ST Mar 20, 1884ST Aug 21, 1884ST Aug 14, 1884ST Apr 1, 1886
Saints means holy ones, including both holy angels with whom he comes and holy people for whom he comes to gather them, so there is no discrepancy between coming with ten thousand saints and coming for his people.ST Apr 23, 1896ST Apr 5, 1899RH May 6, 1852ST Aug 21, 1884RH Sep 30, 1915 He descends in the glory of his Father with thronging shining angels to gather his ransomed home, the sleeping saints long mingled with dust and myriads in the ocean's bed waking immortal, and with the living made immortal rising to meet him in the air to stand enraptured thereafter always with the Lord.RH May 6, 1852RH Sep 30, 1915RH Apr 18, 1871 Christ's public coming is distinct from his coming as a thief to close human probation and receive his kingdom; it is literal and glorious in the clouds of heaven and not an unexpected secret event for the faithful.ST Oct 19, 1888 The future catching-up with Christ's descent from heaven with angels is wondrous beyond human description and will come true as promised.RH Mar 15, 1906
The shout is glad and gives sweet surprise to those waiting for it, and those ready will be found without blemish.ST Nov 22, 1883ST Nov 6, 1893RH Mar 10, 1863 To the righteous dead the Lord's voice and last trumpet bring delight and sweet release, ending sorrow, toil and tears as the heavenly shore draws near and the Christian's watch and armor are laid down forever.ST Nov 6, 1893RH Mar 10, 1863 Some saints will still be living on earth when Christ comes, so they could not have come with him from heaven.RH Aug 13, 1861 The passage to glory comes either through death and the grave or through Christ's return in the clouds.ST Feb 3, 1914RH May 8, 1866 The Lord's return with archangel voice and trumpet will awaken even those deeply hardened and spiritually asleep.RH Sep 26, 1865
First Resurrection Order
First means the righteous dead are raised before the righteous living who remain are changed and caught up together with them in clouds to meet the Lord in the air to ever be with him.CO 95.5ST May 13, 1908ST Mar 20, 1884ST Aug 21, 1884ST Aug 14, 1884 The living have no precedence over those asleep and suffer no disadvantage in sleeping, but both groups are glorified together at the same time when he comes, and neither is glorified before he comes.ST Aug 21, 1907ST Mar 20, 1884ST Aug 21, 1884ST Aug 14, 1884 The living righteous are changed in a moment in the twinkling of an eye at the last trump, and that change is the same as dying and being raised with a new body that cannot decay, which puts them on an equality with those raised from death.CO 95.5ST May 13, 1908 First is set against the living who remain until the coming of the Lord, not against the wicked dead, and the fate of unbelievers must be learned elsewhere.ST Mar 20, 1884ST Aug 21, 1884
This is the first resurrection, the resurrection of life, of the just, of the blessed and holy overcomers only, at the beginning of the millennium when Satan is bound.RH Dec 8, 1915ST Jul 29, 1913ST May 13, 1908ST Sep 19, 1911 It takes place at the second coming when the Lord himself personally descends from heaven with a shout, the archangel's voice, and God's trumpet, and the righteous of all ages who have died are therefore one class of the subjects of his heavenly kingdom while the righteous living at his return are the other.RH Dec 8, 1915ST Jul 29, 1913RH May 1, 1913 It occurs one thousand years before the resurrection of the wicked, the unjust and the rest of the dead to corruption and second death, proving all are not raised together.ST May 13, 1908ST Sep 19, 1911 Those who share in it are freed from sin's hold and will be with Christ.RH Dec 8, 1915
Their raising is bodily, literal and recognizable, with mortal corruptible weak dust waking immortal incorruptible powerful glorious in his image like Christ's resurrection body which had flesh and bones.ST Jan 6, 1887ST May 6, 1880ST Jan 28, 1886 Asleep means physically dead, not morally or spiritually dead, and identity is retained, even the deformed and diseased rising glorified with shining faces, reorganized from dust though not necessarily from the very same particles.ST May 6, 1880ST Jan 28, 1886 The trumpet's sound shakes the earth and opens the graves, and the dead who sleep in Jesus rise first clothed in immortality before the living saints are caught up and glorified.ST Jan 6, 1887ST Jan 28, 1886 The archangel's voice has not yet been heard, and the resurrection and catching up have not yet occurred but remain prophetic for believers living at his coming.ST May 6, 1880
The dead in Christ are the pious dead of all ages from Abel onward, patriarchs, prophets, apostles, martyrs, infants, children, aged, those lost at sea, in battle or persecution, from every nation and tongue, a multitude no one can number.ST May 29, 1901RH Apr 23, 1908RH Jun 7, 1915RH Apr 16, 1867 There is no distinction of rich or poor, free or bond, white or black, and no wide contrast between God's method of saving men under the old dispensation and under the new, but one Father, one Saviour, one law, one gospel, and one means of salvation for all.RH Apr 23, 1908 They are not brought from the courts of heaven but from the dust of the ground where they wait, since even David has not ascended, and the Life-giver's voice pierces the grave to earth's remotest bounds to call them forth.ST May 29, 1901 At that hour the silent cities of the dead are peopled with living souls, as the redeemed come from valley, slope, mountainside, caverns, and ocean depths, no longer pale with suffering and disease but radiant with the bloom of immortality, ransomed from the power of the grave.ST May 29, 1901ST Oct 22, 1874RH Jun 7, 1915 The angel who watched over each saint in life stands by the grave and carries the risen believer in triumph to the Lord, and all meet together upon the sea of glass and receive the crown of glory from his hand.ST Oct 22, 1874RH Apr 23, 1908
Their resurrection follows the pattern of Jesus' own resurrection and is grounded in it; as surely as he died and rose God will bring them up, Christ the firstfruits and afterward they that are Christ's at his coming.ST May 15, 1907RH Feb 19, 1901ST Feb 27, 1879ST Feb 20, 1907ST Sep 4, 1907 It is by the same Spirit that raised Christ and the same creative power that now changes hearts, and Christ's resurrection is the assurance that the redeemed will be raised to everlasting life with mortal bodies made immortal.ST Feb 20, 1907ST Sep 7, 1904 They will rise with the vigor of youth, clothed with immortality, and then join the living believers to meet the Lord, which gives hope and comfort to those who grieve and courage to dying believers.RH Feb 19, 1901ST Feb 27, 1879ST Sep 7, 1904
The call reaches everywhere to enfranchise its prisoners, from the wave-hidden caves of the ocean and the shifting desert sands to fountain, battlefield, garden, mountain, marble sarcophagus, wild wood, dungeon, and valley, sending forth thousands and millions.RH Aug 2, 1864 Its sounding awakens the echoes of heaven and hell, to the saints life-given and glorious music but to the wicked a final farewell.RH Aug 2, 1864 Even long-forgotten graves and sea yield saints whom angels guard and gather, none forgotten, with Palestine's dust stirred earliest.RH Aug 2, 1864ST Mar 26, 1896RH Jun 2, 1874RH May 14, 1872ST Jul 22, 1897 The living saints are then caught up together with them in the clouds to meet him in the air to be with him forever, a comfort for mourners and light beyond the dark prison-house of the dead.ST Mar 26, 1896RH May 14, 1872ST Sep 11, 1901
There is also a special partial resurrection before the voice of God announces the day and hour, when many of both righteous and wicked rise, distinct from the general first resurrection.ST Jan 11, 1916ST May 7, 1912ST Sep 11, 1901 Those who pierced Christ and those who died in faith under the third angel's message rise glorified to hear God's covenant of peace and see him come, the righteous to everlasting life and the wicked to shame and death.ST May 7, 1912ST Sep 11, 1901 Only the righteous are raised in the first resurrection at his coming, while the wicked are not raised until a thousand years later.ST Jan 11, 1916 At that same time the living righteous, identified as the 144,000 including those raised in the special resurrection, are glorified at the voice of God and changed in a moment in the twinkling of an eye and made immortal, then caught up together with the risen saints into the cloudy chariot to meet the Lord in the air.RH Aug 3, 1905
The resurrection and catching up fulfill the prophetic gathering of Israel and the elect with the great trumpet, uniting Isaiah 27, Ezekiel 37 and Matthew 24:31.RH Apr 17, 1900ST Jan 13, 1888RH Oct 22, 1861ST Feb 18, 1886ST Feb 22, 1883 This is the day of the great trumpet when Israel is gathered, the graves of the whole house of Israel are opened, and the outcasts are gathered one by one from every side to the new earth.RH Apr 17, 1900ST Feb 22, 1883ST Feb 2, 1882 The gathering takes place at the resurrection when Christ comes with power and great glory, not when joining the church or at death, and fulfills the promise to Abraham of the land as the world.ST Jan 13, 1888RH Oct 22, 1861 The trumpet and gathering parallel the Son of man coming in the clouds with power and glory, when angels gather his elect.ST Feb 18, 1886
At the same instant the living are changed from corruption to incorruption and mortality to immortality, and with the risen are caught up to mansions in the Father's house, the Holy City New Jerusalem.RH Oct 27, 1874RH Apr 14, 1874RH Mar 20, 1856ST Mar 27, 1893ST Jan 14, 1886 This is the last-trump resurrection when this corruptible must put on incorruption and this mortal must put on immortality, reflecting Christ's image, which is the birth of the Spirit into new and eternal life necessary for entrance into God's kingdom.RH Apr 14, 1874RH Mar 20, 1856 Flesh and blood in a corruptible, mortal state cannot inherit the incorruptible, everlasting kingdom, so the resurrection to immortality makes the inheritance possible for the first time; saints are now only heirs and become inheritors when the Son of man comes in his glory to sit on the throne of his glory.RH Apr 14, 1874ST Jan 14, 1886ST Nov 16, 1882 Then they live and reign with Christ a thousand years and then live on the new earth forever.RH Oct 27, 1874
The verse distinguishes the first death of the faithful from the second death which those who keep Christ's sayings will escape.ST Aug 12, 1875RH Dec 27, 1855 The first death is the result of mortality inherited from Adam, and the dead have no knowledge; the second death is the penalty for personal sin and can occur only after a resurrection from the first death.RH Dec 27, 1855 The saints who died in faith will truly rise from the dead, not merely undergo a moral or spiritual change, for the resurrection has not yet happened but is future at his coming.LS 321.3–322.1ST Oct 3, 1878ST Nov 18, 1889RH Apr 7, 1904RH Feb 9, 1864 When the Saviour comes his voice will awaken the righteous dead from their graves to health and immortality and eternal life, and death will no longer hold them.ST Oct 3, 1878RH Apr 7, 1904RH Feb 9, 1864RH Aug 19, 1909
The raising of the dead and the changing of the living for reunion is only a preliminary step to a higher and holier bliss, the manifested union of the church with her Lord in the marriage of the Lamb, when the Bridegroom comes to claim his bride and take her to share his glory and his throne as a glorious church without spot or wrinkle.RH Jun 7, 1915 The resurrection is the birth of Zion's children and the new birth into immortality awakened by trumpet and God's voice; until then believers may be begotten through the gospel by faith shown in obedience, with baptism as the first action expressing faith in the risen Saviour and a prospect of rising in the first resurrection.RH Apr 7, 1859 Bringing sleeping believers with Jesus means bringing them from the dead as God brought Jesus from the dead, where with expresses likeness, so they are raised like Jesus, not necessarily brought from heaven at the same time as he comes.RH Mar 15, 1864 Together with the second resurrection this means all people including the long-dead wicked will ultimately see Christ.RH Jan 9, 1900 The saints rise through God's forgiveness made possible by Christ's death as their sacrifice.ST Sep 16, 1875
Sleep Until Coming
The dead in Christ lie asleep unconscious in the dust in the grave, without consciousness, knowledge of passing time or activity, as in deep sleep, with no immortal part surviving to live on apart from the body.RH May 16, 1907ST Aug 7, 1884RH Sep 17, 1857ST Nov 18, 1886 They receive no reward, crown, heaven, Paradise, hell or purgatory at death, and have not ascended, even as David and the apostles have not ascended.RH May 16, 1907ST Aug 7, 1884RH Sep 17, 1857ST Nov 18, 1886RH Dec 22, 1868 The resurrection is the awakening of those who sleep in death, not the bringing down of the dead already living consciously in heaven.RH May 16, 1907ST Aug 7, 1884ST May 29, 1901ST Oct 22, 1874 Their hope of being with the Lord depends wholly on this resurrection at Christ's return from heaven with shout, archangel voice and trumpet, when the risen saints and the changed living meet Him together and from then are always with Him.ST Aug 7, 1884RH Sep 17, 1857ST Nov 18, 1886RH Dec 22, 1868
A year or a thousand or six thousand years is to them as the wink of an eye or a night's sleep, for the dead know nothing of time.ST Mar 9, 1876RH May 16, 1907ST Aug 7, 1884RH Jun 9, 1874ST Feb 1, 1905 Death is followed at once in their awareness by hearing His voice, so the interval passes like a night's sleep seeming no longer than from death to resurrection.RH May 16, 1907ST Aug 7, 1884RH Sep 17, 1857RH Jun 9, 1874ST Feb 1, 1905 Paul's desire to depart and be with Christ is therefore met at the coming and resurrection, not at death, when "so" or "in this manner" they are caught up together to meet the Lord in the air.ST Aug 7, 1884RH Sep 17, 1857ST Nov 18, 1886RH Dec 22, 1868 Those raised come up no older than when they died.RH May 16, 1907ST Aug 7, 1884RH Sep 17, 1857ST Nov 18, 1886
Being with the Lord, appearing with Him in glory, beholding His glory, receiving the redemption of the body and the house from heaven follow resurrection and translation at the second coming, not death while at home in the earthly body nor in the naked unclothed state.ST Aug 7, 1884CO 95.5RH Sep 17, 1857RH Nov 7, 1854ST Dec 5, 1916 As Christ lay in the tomb until His resurrection, so no one is promoted in death.ST Aug 7, 1884RH Sep 17, 1857RH Nov 7, 1854ST Dec 5, 1916ST Jan 6, 1887 The trumpet's sound shakes the earth and opens the graves, the dead who sleep in Jesus rise first clothed in immortality, the living righteous are changed instantly, and together they are caught up to be forever with the Lord.ST Aug 7, 1884CO 95.5RH Sep 17, 1857ST Dec 5, 1916ST Jan 6, 1887
Life, immortality, incorruption and eternal life are not possessed by nature or at death but are bestowed and put on at the last trump in a moment when mortal puts on immortality, as surely as Jesus died and rose.ST Jun 24, 1889ST Jul 27, 1915ST Apr 12, 1899RH Dec 24, 1872RH Dec 26, 1907 Mortals do not possess immortality before then and no part of reward is received at death.ST Jun 24, 1889ST Apr 12, 1899RH Dec 24, 1872RH Dec 26, 1907ST Sep 20, 1905 At the voice of the archangel and the last trump the righteous dead are raised and the living righteous are then changed to immortality, giving all who receive eternal life triumph and victory over death and the grave.ST Apr 12, 1899RH Dec 24, 1872ST Sep 20, 1905ST Oct 22, 1874RH Dec 14, 1869 Death will then have no further power over them because through faith they have conquered sin, whose sting brings death.ST Jul 27, 1915ST Apr 12, 1899RH Dec 24, 1872RH Dec 26, 1907ST Sep 20, 1905
The faithful receive reward, crowns of immortal glory and eternal life at the coming, not at death.ST Apr 12, 1899RH Dec 24, 1872RH Dec 26, 1907ST Sep 20, 1905ST Oct 22, 1874 The apostles sleep until called, the penitent thief is then remembered for Paradise, and Abraham who died without receiving the promised inheritance cannot be made perfect without the children of faith but all enter together.ST Apr 12, 1899RH Dec 24, 1872RH Dec 26, 1907ST Sep 20, 1905RH Dec 14, 1869 The saved dead and the living enter their eternal joy together, are caught up together to meet the Lord, remain with Him forever, and all receive the crown of glory from the hand of Jesus upon the sea of glass.ST Apr 12, 1899RH Dec 24, 1872ST Oct 22, 1874RH Dec 14, 1869RH Apr 23, 1908
Without His return and resurrection the dead in Christ would not rise, would have perished and have no future existence, life, salvation or kingdom, making His advent and their resurrection inseparable.ST Jun 24, 1889ST Jul 27, 1915ST Apr 12, 1899ST Jan 28, 1913ST May 12, 1898 Without resurrection there is no immortality, and without immortality the hope of the kingdom would fail and redemption would not be complete.ST Jun 24, 1889ST Jul 27, 1915ST Jan 28, 1913ST May 12, 1898ST Nov 10, 1909 The resurrection and Christ's return occur together, placing the resurrection of the dead in Christ at Christ's return, not at each believer's death.ST Jun 24, 1889ST Jul 27, 1915ST Jan 28, 1913ST May 12, 1898ST Nov 10, 1909
This truth that the dead sleep until the coming exposes Spiritism and communion with supposed spirits as delusion and doctrine of demons.ST Feb 25, 1875ST Jul 24, 1907ST Jun 20, 1900RH May 1, 1855ST Sep 18, 1901 Appearances of the dead are evil angels impersonating them, not spirits returned, but tormenting deceptions of the spirits of devils, and the dead are asleep until then, not active spirits who can appear as departed friends or return to communicate with the living.ST Sep 20, 1905ST Feb 25, 1875ST Jul 24, 1907ST Jun 20, 1900RH May 1, 1855 Safety is to seek God, judge by law and testimony, hold this truth from the Word against the wave of last-day Spiritist deception, and not seek messages through spirit mediums.ST Feb 25, 1875ST Jul 24, 1907ST Jun 20, 1900ST Sep 18, 1901ST May 28, 1902
The spirit is the breath God gave, the life itself, which at death returns to His keeping and at the resurrection comes again into the dead in Christ so they rise and live.ST Mar 9, 1876ST Feb 6, 1896ST Feb 6, 1896RH Jun 9, 1874ST Feb 1, 1905 God preserves identity and raises them as the same persons, though how He preserves it is not specified, and personal identity will be preserved.ST Mar 9, 1876ST Feb 6, 1896RH Jun 9, 1874RH Mar 10, 1863ST Feb 1, 1905 Death does not give a new character and people rise with the character formed in life.ST Mar 9, 1876ST Feb 6, 1896RH Jun 9, 1874RH Mar 10, 1863ST Feb 1, 1905 Death is a dreamless sleep with no conscious thoughts which only Christ the Life-giver can awaken, bringing them back from death and the grave at His coming, restoring the whole person then clothed with immortal life.ST Mar 9, 1876ST Feb 6, 1896ST Feb 6, 1896RH Mar 10, 1863ST Feb 1, 1905
Job will see his Redeemer at the latter day upon the earth in his flesh in the resurrection when the dead rise, not at death in a disembodied state.ST May 29, 1901ST Oct 22, 1874RH Apr 23, 1908RH Jun 7, 1915 This is the call Job waited for in the grave through his appointed time, and he will answer changed into a glorious immortal being.ST May 29, 1901ST Oct 22, 1874RH Apr 23, 1908RH Apr 16, 1867 The dead who sleep in Jesus are not brought from the courts of heaven but from the dust of the ground where they wait, since even David has not ascended into the heavens, and the Life-giver's voice pierces the grave to earth's remotest bounds to call them forth from valley, slope, mountainside, caverns and ocean depths.ST May 29, 1901RH Apr 23, 1908RH Jun 7, 1915RH Apr 16, 1867 At that hour the silent cities of the dead are peopled with living souls, ransomed from the power of the grave to meet their Redeemer.ST May 29, 1901RH Apr 23, 1908RH Jun 7, 1915RH Apr 16, 1867
The verse shows the time when the dead condition that followed Adam's sin will end.RH Apr 23, 1908RH Jun 7, 1915RH Apr 16, 1867RH Sep 26, 1854 Adam entered a dying condition in the day he ate and after nine hundred and thirty years entered a dead condition, and the dead remain in that dead condition until the trump sounds and they are raised as the verse describes.ST May 29, 1901RH Apr 23, 1908RH Jun 7, 1915RH Apr 16, 1867RH Sep 26, 1854
Prophetic Time Sequence
The words are still prophetic and unfulfilled, for the archangel's voice has not yet been heard and the resurrection and catching up have not yet occurred.ST Oct 18, 1883ST May 6, 1880ST Feb 4, 1913ST May 27, 1875RH Oct 4, 1906 The coming they foretell is still future, literal and personal, not the destruction of Jerusalem, not Pentecost, not conversion, not death, and claims that Christ already came in 1874 or otherwise are false.ST May 6, 1880ST May 27, 1875RH Oct 4, 1906RH Apr 12, 1915 Paul's placing of himself among those alive is prospective identification with the last generation, not a prediction for his own day.ST May 6, 1880ST Feb 4, 1913ST Jun 30, 1909ST His second letter clarified that the coming would follow the falling away and revelation of the man of sin, identified with Daniel's little horn which arose after the fourth empire was divided and persecuted saints for 1260 prophetic years.ST Jun 30, 1909ST
The verse was written about A.D. 54 repeating the plan Jesus told his disciples, to remove ignorance about those asleep so believers do not sorrow as those with no hope.ST Mar 11, 1886RH Sep 17, 1857ST Jul 25, 1911ST Apr 29, 1908ST Jan 3, 1905 The Thessalonians feared the dead would miss the coming and some imagined a soon coming in their lifetime, which did not excuse them from diligent work.ST Oct 18, 1883ST Aug 13, 1874 Because at his coming each person's standing has already been determined, the investigative judgment of the righteous precedes his coming during probation while Revelation 14 is given.RH May 18, 1869RH Dec 31, 1908RH Apr 2, 1914RH Sep 7, 1916RH Nov 5, 1908 It answers to the cleansing of the sanctuary on the tenth day of the seventh month, beginning at the close of the 2300 days in the autumn of 1844 and proceeding from ancient cases onward.RH May 18, 1869RH Dec 31, 1908RH Apr 2, 1914RH Nov 8, 1915
The trumpet sounds only after cases are investigated and decided, after intercession is finished and probation closes.RH May 18, 1869RH Dec 31, 1908RH Apr 2, 1914RH Sep 7, 1916RH Nov 8, 1915 There is no time at the sudden descent for examination, no later probation after death or after the trumpet, and the resurrection itself executes judgment separating saints for life from the wicked left for the second resurrection.RH May 18, 1869RH Dec 31, 1908RH Apr 2, 1914RH Nov 5, 1908 The resurrection begins the thousand years.ST May 5, 1914ST Jan 16, 1901RH Jul 21, 1874 At his coming the living wicked are consumed by the brightness of his presence while the righteous are taken to heaven to the mansions in the Father's house to reign as kings and priests in judgment during the thousand years while the earth lies desolate without inhabitant as Satan's prison fulfilling the scapegoat type.ST May 5, 1914ST Feb 24, 1914ST Oct 20, 1914ST Nov 11, 1913
The great day of the Lord begins with the close of probation, followed by the seven last plagues, Armageddon, earthquake, then the second coming and this resurrection, then the millennium with saints in heaven, then the second resurrection and destruction in the lake of fire, resulting in a clean universe and new heavens and new earth.ST Mar 17, 1887ST Mar 11, 1875ST May 1, 1884ST Mar 24, 1909 Only at the end will his feet stand on the Mount of Olives, the city descend adorned as a bride to the renewed earth and he receive his kingdom, after which they inherit the new earth with Eden's beauty to fulfill the promise to Abraham, with fire destroying the wicked and purifying the earth.ST May 5, 1914ST Feb 24, 1914ST Oct 20, 1914ST Nov 11, 1913 Children who died in infancy grow up during that time.ST May 5, 1914ST Feb 24, 1914 Its nearness is shown by fulfilled waymarks from Jerusalem's destruction through the Papacy, earthquake, darkened sun and moon, falling stars in 1833, wars, crime, plagues and distress of nations.ST Sep 19, 1900ST Jan 20, 1909ST Mar 5, 1896ST Jun 29, 1882 The generation that saw the 1833 stars will not pass, and the coming is even at the doors though day and hour are unrevealed.ST Sep 19, 1900ST Jun 30, 1909ST Jan 20, 1909ST Mar 5, 1896
Believers in 1844 expected the descent with archangel voice and trump on the tenth day of the seventh month, October 22, 1844, ordering affairs and assembling in breathless anxiety.GSAM 183.2–184.1RH Aug 19, 1851RH Dec 1850 When the sun set their sadness matched the disciples after the crucifixion, for the date reckoned from B.C. 457 for the 2300 days was right but the event was the cleansing of the sanctuary and coming to the Ancient of Days, not the advent.RH Aug 19, 1851RH Dec 1850 There must have been space for the proclamation of the wedding and the shut and open door before Jesus comes, fulfilled in the seventh month of 1844.RH Aug 19, 1851RH Dec 1850 The awakening occurs at the appointed time when Christ comes and the heavens pass away. After entering the Father's presence the saints have a work of judgment committed to them during the period between the two resurrections, entering God's Paradise in the third heaven within the heavenly Jerusalem and eating the marriage supper before judging the wicked dead from their recorded deeds.ST Jan 16, 1901RH Mar 8, 1870ST Oct 10, 1878
Those who held a nearer reckoning taught that the gathering of the saints with the dead in Christ rising first had to be done before this generation closed, bringing fulfillment into the third day by near the close of 1859 and before May 19, 1860. When an earthquake was accompanied by a blood-red moon, people cried out that the trumpet would sound, the dead would rise, and judgment had arrived.ST Mar 31, 1881 He comes when world wickedness again reaches the stage of Noah and Lot, then resurrecting the righteous and destroying evil permanently, unlike the flood and fire on the cities of the plain which only temporarily dethroned evil as an object-lesson.ST May 8, 1901ST Mar 24, 1914 Deliverance by translation comes soon after the image to the beast is formed, marking the end of the prophetic period in which the United States appears.RH Oct 27, 1874RH Oct 27, 1874RH Jan 6, 1874 The coming is connected with when the angels are made immortal, but the timing is not known.ST Sep 5, 1911 The second coming and resurrection were expected not far into the newly opened century after victory over the beast and his mark, within the days of the voice of the seventh angel whose sounding began over fifty-six years before and extends a thousand years beyond the second coming.RH Jan 8, 1901
False Views Refuted
The verse does not describe death, a death-bed scene, conversion, giving the heart to God, comfort in general, the Spirit's coming, Pentecost, Titus at Jerusalem's destruction, the Roman army, a spiritual influence, or the coming at each death.RH Feb 18, 1875ST Apr 14, 1887ST Mar 2, 1882RH Apr 24, 1913ST Death brings no descent from heaven, no shout, no archangel voice, no trumpet, and no joint catching up of living with risen dead, and to make death the event so announced would place the resurrection at death.RH Feb 18, 1875ST Apr 14, 1887RH Apr 24, 1913STST Dec 8, 1881 It describes the same event as the promise to come again and receive believers so they may be with him, with coming again fulfilled in the Lord's descent, receiving fulfilled in being caught up in clouds to meet him, and being with him fulfilled in ever being with him, so referring the coming to death is impossible.ST Apr 14, 1887ST Mar 2, 1882ST The language is clear and plain, foretelling not quiet conversion but a literal personal revelation in awful grandeur.RH Feb 18, 1875ST Apr 14, 1887ST Dec 8, 1881
The shout is not a symbolic public shout of encouragement fulfilled by fifteen years of worldwide restlessness and dissatisfaction, quarrels of labor and capital, trusts, the cry of the socialist, and the growl of the nihilist and anarchist.ST Feb 6, 1896 Nor are the shout, voice, and trump the progress of Christian civilization, the overthrow of false religions, the extension of missions, and the suppression of slavery, though some held the beginning of a glorious spiritual coming was even then being lived.ST Feb 6, 1896 The language of trumpet and opening graves must stand in plain sense, not as figure for the soul standing before God in an immaterial body whose manner is unknowable.ST Dec 8, 1881ST Feb 5, 1880 It means exactly what it says: Christ comes a second time to earth and awakes his sleeping people and brings them forth from their graves.ST Dec 8, 1881ST Feb 5, 1880
Denial of this personal coming is a special mark of antichrist, opposed to the claim that the second coming is only the coming of the spirit in Spiritualism.RH Mar 20, 1866RH Mar 20, 1866 Against the claim that there is no resurrection, the verse proves bodily resurrection of the dead at Christ's coming to be a central plainly taught doctrine learned from prophets, Christ, and apostles, and teaching contrary to the order of dead rising first and living caught up together causes divisions to be avoided.RH Jan 15, 1857RH Mar 20, 1866 There are not two future comings or two stages of one coming, a secret coming without warning to take the ready to secret chambers followed after judgments and revivals by a visible manifestation to establish the kingdom; there is but one coming, and parousia and epiphaneia are simultaneous and open, so secret rapture views are a last-day delusion.ST Jan 7, 1913ST Sep 22, 1909 At the great day angels gather saints from graves and sea raised immortal.ST Dec 1, 1909
This disproves purgatory and a presently burning hell, for immortality is put on and glory appears when Christ appears, with immortal life until then hidden with Christ in God.RH Dec 28, 1911ST Apr 9, 1896 The dead are awakened at the resurrection when Christ returns and the trumpet sounds, and do not immediately appear before God in judgment at death.RH Oct 23, 1866ST Aug 19, 1886 The carrying of Lazarus into Abraham's bosom takes place at the yet future descent and gathering, when the archangel voice rings through hades and angels gather the elect from the four winds upward to be forever with the Lord, not at the moment of death.RH Mar 4, 1862RH Sep 3, 1872 The rich man seeing Lazarus in Abraham's bosom therefore belongs to that future time after probation is past, and their conversing is allegory, not revelation of life after death, with final rewards not given at death.RH Mar 4, 1862RH Sep 3, 1872ST Apr 9, 1896 That gathering belongs to the first resurrection, one thousand years before the second resurrection when the wicked come forth to death in the lake of fire.ST Apr 9, 1896ST Aug 19, 1886
Teaching inherent immortality makes the second coming vain and does away with the resurrection.RH May 16, 1907ST Aug 7, 1884RH Sep 17, 1857 Belief in succession of incarnations or release of an immortal person at death is needless, for the resurrection is the awakening of those asleep unconscious in the grave, not the description of dead already living consciously in heaven.RH May 16, 1907ST Nov 18, 1886 The righteous receive no reward until Jesus comes, and being with Christ does not happen at death but only in this manner at his coming, when dead in Christ rise before living believers are caught up together with them in clouds to meet him in the air.ST Aug 7, 1884RH Sep 17, 1857ST Nov 18, 1886RH Dec 22, 1868 Without it faith would be vain, for hope of being with him depends on this resurrection and translation.ST Aug 7, 1884RH Sep 17, 1857RH Dec 22, 1868
The verse says nothing about unbelievers then and is not a general resurrection of righteous and wicked together; it teaches a resurrection of the just alone.ST Aug 21, 1907ST May 13, 1908ST Mar 20, 1884ST Aug 21, 1884ST Aug 14, 1884 Its first is set against the living who remain until the coming, teaching that those asleep suffer no loss and the living have no precedence, but both are glorified together when he comes and neither before he comes.ST Mar 20, 1884ST Aug 21, 1884ST Aug 14, 1884 The righteous dead are raised first, before the righteous still living are changed in a moment and caught up, which change is as dying and being raised with an undecaying body putting them on equality with those raised.CO 95.5ST Aug 21, 1907ST May 13, 1908 While some hold both righteous and wicked rise then in separate resurrections of life and damnation, the weight holds the verse addresses the faithful dead, not the fate of the wicked.ST Mar 20, 1884ST Aug 21, 1884ST Aug 14, 1884
The coming does not begin a second probation to convert the world, bring blessing to nations, or set up an earthly era of peace.ST May 5, 1914ST Feb 24, 1914 The whole world will not be converted before he comes, and the millennium does not begin until after the advent, beginning with this resurrection of the righteous dead.ST May 5, 1914ST Feb 24, 1914 At his descent he does not set foot on the sin-cursed earth but calls his people to himself in clouds in the air, gathering risen and living as the harvest of the righteous to take them to heavenly mansions in the New Jerusalem during the millennium until the curse is removed.ST May 5, 1914ST Feb 24, 1914ST Oct 20, 1914ST Nov 11, 1913
The second coming cannot be the time for proclaiming the wedding and the shut and open door in the heavenly sanctuary, for that coming leaves no scriptural time or place for such proclamation.RH Aug 19, 1851RH Jan 19, 1869RH Oct 4, 1864 There must positively be space for that proclamation before Jesus comes, fulfilled in the seventh month of 1844.RH Aug 19, 1851 The marriage of the Lamb takes place beforehand while he finishes work as High Priest pleading his blood in the true temple and enters the most holy place, having already received dominion, glory, and kingdom to come as King of kings to raise the dead, change the living, and destroy those left of the plagues.RH Jan 19, 1869RH Oct 4, 1864RH Feb 21, 1856RH Jun 9, 1851 He does not come to be married but returns from the wedding to the New Jerusalem, the Lamb's wife, leaving no foolish virgins then to seek admittance.RH Jan 19, 1869RH Jun 9, 1851
After the Advent no saints remain on earth or in Babylon to be called out, for all God's people are caught up to meet him in the air to ever be with him and begin reign with him in his kingdom.RH May 6, 1852ST Jun 15, 1882RH Dec 9, 1851RH Aug 14, 1856RH Aug 14, 1856 Therefore the three messages of Revelation 14 and the call to come out of Babylon lest they partake of her sins and receive her plagues cannot be proclaimed after the Advent when Babylon is fallen and utterly burned.RH May 6, 1852ST Jun 15, 1882RH Dec 9, 1851 They cannot afterward still be in Babylon once already caught up forever with the Lord.RH Dec 9, 1851RH Aug 14, 1856RH Aug 14, 1856 The visible coming in glory with resurrection and catching up is distinguished from the bridegroom's coming in the parable, which may refer to an event preceding it.RH The resurrection, transformation, and catching up occur at his descent before entering the New Jerusalem with him, so a door shut only after they enter cannot represent mercy closing before the Advent.RHRH Apr 14, 1853
Sources