Acts 1:24
And they prayed, and said, Thou, Lord, which knowest the hearts of all men, shew whether of these two thou hast chosen,
Translations
And they prayed, and said, You, Lord, which know the hearts of all men, show whether of these two you have chosen,
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
And they prayed, and said, Thou, Lord, which knowest the hearts of all men, shew whether of these two thou hast chosen,
And they prayed, and said, Thou, Lord, who knowest the hearts of all men, show which of these two thou hast chosen,
And they prayed, and said, Thou, Lord, which knowest the hearts of all men, shew of these two the one whom thou hast chosen,
And they prayed, and said, Thou, Lord, who knowest the hearts of all men, show of these two the one whom thou hast chosen,
and having prayed, they said, 'Thou, Lord, who art knowing the heart of all, shew which one thou didst choose of these two
And they prayed, and said, Thou Lord, knower of the hearts of all, shew which one of these two thou hast chosen,
And, praying, they said—Thou Lord! observer of the hearts of all men! shew forth whom thou hast chosen,—of these two, one;—
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
And they prayed, “ Lord, You know everyone’ s heart. Show us which of these two You have chosen
They prayed and said, “ You, Lord, who know the hearts of all men, show which one of these two you have chosen
And they made prayers and said, Lord, having knowledge of the hearts of all men, make clear which of these two has been marked out by you,
And they praied, saying, Thou Lord, which knowest the hearts of all men, shewe whether of these two thou hast chosen,
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And praying, they said: Thou, Lord, who knowest the hearts of all men, shew whether of these two thou hast chosen,
Cross-references
- Acts 1:14
These all continued with one accord in prayer and supplication, with the women, and Mary the mother of Jesus, and with his brethren.
The disciples continued together in prayer before Pentecost.
- Luke 6:13
And when it was day, he called unto him his disciples: and of them he chose twelve, whom also he named apostles;
Both describe choosing men for the office of apostle.
- Mark 3:13-14
And he goeth up into a mountain, and calleth unto him whom he would: and they came unto him.
Both describe Jesus choosing and appointing men to the apostolic office.
- Acts 1:16-20
Men and brethren, this scripture must needs have been fulfilled, which the Holy Ghost by the mouth of David spake before concerning Judas, which was guide to them that took Jesus.
Describes the defection that created the vacancy.
- 1 Samuel 16:7
But the LORD said unto Samuel, Look not on his countenance, or on the height of his stature; because I have refused him: for the Lord seeth not as man seeth; for man looketh on the outward appearance, but the LORD looketh on the heart.
God sees what human judgment cannot see.
- John 6:70
Jesus answered them, Have not I chosen you twelve, and one of you is a devil?
Jesus chose the Twelve, though one was a betrayer.
- John 15:16
Ye have not chosen me, but I have chosen you, and ordained you, that ye should go and bring forth fruit, and that your fruit should remain: that whatsoever ye shall ask of the Father in my name, he may give it you.
Jesus says he chose and appointed his disciples.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
25 sources
The believers prayed to the Lord who knows the hearts of all people to show which of the two men He had chosen to take Judas's place in the ministry and apostleship.FE 530.19T 263.3–4Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–8 Although both candidates appeared worthy, the disciples recognized their own judgment was imperfect and could not discern hidden character and the secret motives of the heart.3SP 264.2–3ST Nov 7, 18787RED 3.3–4.1 In answer to the prayer the Spirit of God selected Matthias for the office.AC1 3.3ST Nov 7, 18787RED 3.3–4.1 Selection for responsibility is to be brought before God in united, earnest prayer, seeking His direction and choice rather than relying on human judgment, plans, or authority alone.FE 530.19T 263.3–4Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–8 He is the proper judge of fitness for service because His eyes read the hidden secrets of every heart and He knows who is willing to obey and serve, and He has certain men for certain positions who must be accepted and supported when He gives them.AC1 4.19T 264.1Ms 11, 1891, par. 22–23CT 511.3–512.2
Setting and Meaning
The prayer was offered by the believers to the Lord as the One who knows the hearts of all people, asking Him to show which of two men He had chosen to take the place left by Judas in the ministry and apostleship.FE 530.19T 263.3–4Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–8RH Oct 21, 1909Ms 88, 1893, par. 21 The two candidates were known and both appeared worthy, yet the choice was not settled by human judgment or authority but was brought to God for His direction.FE 530.19T 263.3–4RH Oct 21, 1909Ms 88, 1893, par. 21AC1 3.3 United earnest prayer together was the way the workers sought God in carrying the work forward, trusting His knowledge of every heart and His right to choose.FE 530.19T 263.3–4Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–8RH Oct 21, 1909Ms 88, 1893, par. 21
Their own judgment was recognized as imperfect, unable to discern hidden character and the secret motives of the heart.3SP 264.2–3ST Nov 7, 18787RED 3.3–4.1AC1 4.1Lt 72, 1878, par. 4–5 Although the disciples knew the men, they did not dare to risk their imperfect discernment but made the selection a solemn subject of prayer for God to indicate His choice by His Spirit.3SP 264.2–3ST Nov 7, 18787RED 3.3–4.1AC1 4.1Lt 72, 1878, par. 4–5 God’s eyes read the hidden secrets of every heart, so He alone was regarded as the proper judge of fitness for service.3SP 264.2–3ST Nov 7, 18787RED 3.3–4.1AC1 4.1 For that reason the matter of choosing ministers was treated as solemn, requiring much prayer and careful consideration of suitability rather than hasty or reckless advancement.3SP 264.2–3ST Nov 7, 18787RED 3.3–4.1AC1 4.1Lt 72, 1878, par. 4–5
In answer to that prayer the Spirit of God selected Matthias for the office as the one suited to fill Judas’s place as an apostle.AC1 3.3ST Nov 7, 18787RED 3.3–4.1 The decision was thus entrusted to God rather than to human preference, and Matthias was identified as the man chosen.AC1 3.3ST Nov 7, 18787RED 3.3–4.1
The verse belongs to the history of the early church in and just after the day of Pentecost, and careful study of that history refreshes the mind and instructs in the truth.Lt 170, 1907, par. 9Lt 177, 1899, par. 5 Its chapter is linked with Christ’s commission to His disciples, the promise of the Holy Spirit, and the angels’ message to the waiting disciples.Lt 170, 1907, par. 9Lt 177, 1899, par. 5 The experience recorded there, together with the experiences of Paul and the other apostles in Acts, is one God’s people in the present day must pass through in similar form.Lt 170, 1907, par. 9
As part of the book of Acts, the verse stands in a lesson book for believers, showing the disciples seeking God’s direction and recognizing that He knows every person’s heart and can reveal whom He has chosen.Lt 170, 1907, par. 9Ms 113, 1909, par. 4–8Lt 32, 1910, par. 8 The chapter teaches lessons about setting things in order, and those lessons apply to organizing special work and choosing workers.Lt 170, 1907, par. 910MR 17.2–3Ms 113, 1909, par. 4–8 The apostles’ example in putting matters in order and choosing a worker for the work ahead is therefore instruction for present order and selection.Lt 170, 1907, par. 910MR 17.2–3Ms 113, 1909, par. 4–8Lt 32, 1910, par. 8
Choosing Workers Prayerfully
Selection for responsibility is to be brought before God in united, earnest prayer, asking the Lord who knows every heart to reveal His direction and His choice between candidates to fill a vacant place in ministry and apostleship.FE 530.19T 263.3–4Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–8RH Oct 21, 1909Ms 88, 1893, par. 21 The prayer seeks God's knowledge and choice rather than leaning on human judgment, human plans, or human authority alone, trusting the decision to Him.FE 530.19T 263.3–4Ms 37a, 1909, par. 6–8RH Oct 21, 1909Ms 88, 1893, par. 21 God is the proper judge of fitness for service because His eyes read the hidden secrets of every heart and discern inner character and secret motives that human judgment cannot see.3SP 264.2–3ST Nov 7, 18787RED 3.3–4.1AC1 4.1 That heart-knowledge includes knowing who is willing to obey and serve.CT 511.3–512.2
God has certain men for certain positions, and His people must move carefully and make wise choice of men who will not betray sacred trusts.9T 264.1 Every case is to be presented before God in earnest prayer asking Him to choose and to provide the people best suited to help, and then those He gives are to be accepted and supported rather than chosen according to human plans.9T 264.1Ms 11, 1891, par. 22–23 Choosing people for important service requires careful consideration of suitability and must not be done hastily or recklessly.3SP 264.2–3ST Nov 7, 18787RED 3.3–4.1AC1 4.1Lt 72, 1878, par. 4–5 Putting forward those who are not capable or rushing unfitted men into ministry burdens the church and injures and harms God's work.3SP 264.2–3AC1 4.1Lt 72, 1878, par. 4–5
If believers in Christ's day needed to be guarded in choosing men for positions of responsibility, those living in this time need to move with even greater discretion, with greater care and much prayer in selecting ministers instead of advancing unfitted men recklessly.9T 264.1Lt 72, 1878, par. 4–5 The Lord who knows every heart and chooses whom He will appoint also trains and equips His ministers for the work.CT 511.3–512.2GW92 41.2–42.14T 315.2–316.1 He chose humble, faithful men and trained them rather than educated and respected people who lacked courage to confess Him, and He gives His chosen the words they should speak, at the right time and with power.CT 511.3–512.2GW92 41.2–42.14T 315.2–316.1
Trusting God's Heart Knowledge
God knows every person's heart, and He alone knows a sick person's past and future.2T 147.2 He alone can foresee whether recovery would lead that person to honor Him or to turn away from Him.2T 147.2 Prayer for healing should therefore ask Him to raise the sufferer up if it accords with His will, trusting His wisdom rather than demanding recovery.2T 147.2
The Lord knows every heart, including hidden selfish motives that others cannot see.1T 225.1–226.1 Circumstances can be allowed to test people so that their true character is revealed.1T 225.1–226.1 Because He knows the hearts of all, believers are to seek Him earnestly and be free from selfish purposes.STB 251.3 Those who faithfully represent the life and character of Christ will be blessed abundantly.STB 251.3
The Lord understands the working of every human heart and is to be trusted now and always.Ms 17, 1908, par. 31 Every soul is to be under His control, led and governed by His will.Ms 17, 1908, par. 31 This takes place through reconversion, reconsecration to His service, and the baptism of the Holy Spirit.Ms 17, 1908, par. 31 Because He is soon to come, workers are to arouse with energy to the work before them, letting truth go forth as a lamp that burns.Ms 17, 1908, par. 31
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
26 sources
After His ascension the believers united in prayer to the Lord who knows every heart to reveal which of the two men He had chosen to take Judas's place in the ministry and apostleship.ST Jun 17, 1897RH Feb 10, 1916RH Jan 9, 1855 The two set forward were Joseph called Barsabas and Matthias, both known and judged worthy, and the decision was then made by lot, with Matthias selected and numbered with the eleven among the twelve.RH Jan 9, 1855ST Mar 14, 1911ST Sep 15, 1887 The prayer confesses that God alone knows the hidden secrets, motives and circumstances of all, while human judgment is imperfect and cannot settle who is best suited.ST Nov 7, 1878ST Aug 29, 1895 It stands as the practical pattern for carrying forward the Master's work by placing appointments under divine direction through prayer rather than relying on human judgment alone.RH Oct 21, 1909RH Feb 12, 1901 That seeking of God's choice was the act of the church as an organized body, with the apostles in council with the believers appointing and ordaining a successor, not the act of Peter alone or of any single individual.ST Dec 3, 1894RH Apr 15, 1909
The Prayer And Choice
The believers gathered together prayed to the Lord who knows the hearts of all men to show which of the two men He had chosen to take the place left by Judas in the ministry and apostleship.RH Oct 21, 1909ST Jun 17, 1897RH Feb 10, 1916RH Jan 9, 1855ST Sep 15, 1887 The prayer sought the choice from God rather than resting on human judgment alone, and not as an act of Peter alone but of the disciples seeking God together before Pentecost.RH Oct 21, 1909RH Feb 10, 1916ST Dec 3, 1894 They then cast lots to learn the Lord's choice.RH Jan 9, 1855
The two men put forward were Joseph, called Barsabas, and Matthias.ST Jan 16, 1879 Although both men were known and judged worthy, the disciples recognized that their own judgment was imperfect and could not settle who was best suited for the apostleship, so they entrusted the decision to God who alone knew every heart.ST Nov 7, 1878 The choice was then made by lot between Matthias and Barsabas, and Matthias was selected and numbered with the eleven among the twelve.ST Nov 7, 1878RH Jan 9, 1855ST Mar 14, 1911ST Sep 15, 1887 That use of the lot was innocent and lawful, not gambling to get another person's money without earning it.ST Jan 16, 1879
God alone knows every person's heart, including its hidden secrets, motives and circumstances, while human beings may misunderstand another person's motives and circumstances.ST Aug 29, 1895 Human judgment is imperfect and cannot settle who is best suited, so the disciples trusted God's judgment of the heart rather than their own.ST Nov 7, 1878
The prayer belongs to the time after the ascension, following forty days with Christ after His resurrection and ten days of earnest united prayer while waiting for the Father's promise before Pentecost.RH Feb 10, 1916ST Aug 13, 1874RH Mar 31, 1874 Their unity and prayer preceded the outpouring of the Holy Spirit, and that united prayer and waiting prepared them for the Spirit's power to organize and energize their witness.RH Feb 10, 1916RH Oct 28, 1858RH Feb 12, 1901 Christ spent the forty days with His disciples ending with His ascension on Thursday, after which they continued in prayer and supplication until the day of Pentecost.RH Mar 31, 1874RH Feb 25, 1862
Their being together with one accord on the day of Pentecost was nothing materially different from what had been the case for the previous ten or more days.RH Feb 25, 1862 That ten-day period after the ascension included two first days of the week, and Pentecost came after the ascension, not on the first of the intervening first days of the week.ST Aug 13, 1874RH Mar 31, 1874 It therefore gives no evidence that they met to celebrate a first-day Sabbath or that the Spirit was poured out in honor of the first day.RH Feb 25, 1862 Christ's ascension was memorable, but it does not establish the day of the ascension as the Lord's day or as holy or as claimed by Christ.ST Apr 6, 1882
Matthias was selected under God to fill the place left by the apostasy of Judas.RH Aug 18, 1874 His not being mentioned later does not count against his apostleship, since several of the twelve are not mentioned after Acts 1. The twelve apostles were an important factor in the early church, and the number of the twelve was kept to correspond with the twelve tribes of Israel.ST Aug 9, 1905RH Aug 18, 1874 The eleven were still called the twelve, and the number twelve is not a limit on how many apostles God could send, for God continued to send apostles beyond the original twelve. An apostle is one sent with a mission and a message, given to the original twelve because they were selected in a special manner, and Matthias holds that office together with Barnabas, Paul, Epaphroditus, Silvanus and Timothy.RH Aug 18, 1874
Guidance For Church Order
The choosing of Matthias is the apostles carrying out the work their Master gave them, a practical pattern for the church's work and application of the Lord's doctrines. The believers prayed for the Lord who knows every heart to reveal which of the two men He had chosen, seeking God's direction through prayer rather than relying on human judgment alone.RH Oct 21, 1909RH Feb 12, 1901 Their prayer placed the appointment under divine direction, recognizing that He knows every person's heart.RH Feb 12, 1901
Choosing and ordaining church officers followed this practice of seeking God's choice, asking the Lord who knows every person's heart to reveal whom He had chosen for office.RH Aug 29, 1854 The disciples asked the Lord to choose between Joseph and Matthias because He alone knew every person's heart, including its hidden secrets. Although they knew both men and judged them worthy, their own judgment was imperfect and could not settle who was best suited for the apostleship to fill Judas's place, so they entrusted the choice to God and Matthias was selected for the office.ST Nov 7, 1878 Choosing people for important service should therefore be done cautiously and prayerfully, relying on God's knowledge of the heart rather than human judgment alone, and leaders should carefully consider people before placing them in positions of service, since appointing those unable to do the work can burden the church and harm its mission.ST Nov 7, 1878
The choice was sought from God rather than made by Peter alone, and it belonged to the church acting as an organized body, not to a single individual.ST Dec 3, 1894 After Christ's ascension the eleven apostles met in council with the believers and with earnest prayer for guidance appointed and ordained a successor to Judas in the office of apostle.RH Apr 15, 1909RH Aug 17, 1916 That office is general and not local, for the whole church, for the ministry of the Word and the general oversight of the work, unifying the churches as the gospel spreads.RH Apr 15, 1909 This action exemplifies the Spirit-filled church doing its work in a systematic manner and recognizing divine authority in the gifts and offices placed in the church for administering its affairs, demonstrating the Spirit's guidance and Christ's recognition of the organized church as a legitimate body.RH Aug 17, 1916ST Mar 6, 1884
An apostle is one sent with a mission and a message, given to the original twelve because they were selected in a special manner to do the work of God.RH Aug 18, 1874 The choosing of Matthias filled the place left by the apostasy of Judas, keeping the number of the twelve to correspond with the twelve tribes of Israel, while the eleven were still called the twelve and the number twelve is not a limit on how many apostles God could send.RH Aug 18, 1874 Matthias holds that office together with Barnabas, Paul, Epaphroditus, Silvanus, and Timothy, and God continued to send apostles beyond the original twelve.RH Aug 18, 1874 No further election to this office is recorded, and the church is not instructed to select apostles in succeeding ages, though when the providence of God makes manifest that He has raised up a man to do a special work the church should give him his proper degree of influence and position.RH Aug 18, 1874
The election of a successor to Judas by appeal to the lot between Matthias and Barsabas was innocent and lawful, not gambling to get another person's money without earning it.ST Jan 16, 1879 It gives no justification for using lots in church fairs to tempt children to trade pennies for gain.ST Jan 16, 1879 God knows every person's heart and knows whom He has chosen for His work, and though a person chosen among God's instruments may prove unfaithful, as Judas did, the work is not to be taken from the remaining apostles and handed to a new group, for God knows how to choose and carry forward His work.RH Dec 18, 1855
The Lord's knowledge of the hearts of all people is appealed to when asking whether one truly belongs to God and seeking to know one's standing before Him.RH Aug 6, 1857 That description of God applies to every act of speech, so people cannot truthfully excuse lying by thinking it is hidden from Him, even when He is invisible.RH Apr 27, 1916
Sources