Translations
American King James Version, King James Version
And the pelican, and the gier eagle, and the cormorant,
and the pelican, and the gier eagle, and the cormorant,
And the pelican, and the gier-eagle, and the cormorant,
and the pelican, and the vulture, and the cormorant;
and the pelican, and the vulture, and the cormorant,
and the pelican, and the gier-eagle, and the cormorant,
and the pelican, and the carrion vulture, and the gannet,
and the vomiting pelican and the little vulture and the gannet;
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
the desert owl, the osprey, the cormorant,
the pelican, the vulture, the cormorant,
And the pelican and the vulture and the cormorant;
Nor the pellicane, nor the swanne, nor the cormorant:
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And the cormorant, the porphyrion, and the night crow,
Cross-references
- Leviticus 11:13-19
And these are they which ye shall have in abomination among the fowls; they shall not be eaten, they are an abomination: the eagle, and the ossifrage, and the ospray,
Both texts list birds forbidden as food under the dietary laws.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
2 sources
Deuteronomy 14:17 belongs to the directions forbidding the eating of unclean animals and creatures.DA 617.2ST Mar 21, 1878 Its prohibition was not arbitrary authority but was given to guard health and to preserve the life and health of the people.DA 617.2ST Mar 21, 1878 Eating the flesh of certain animals could pollute the blood and shorten life.DA 617.2 To retain the faculties of mind and body the blood must be kept pure by simple, healthful food, so the animals least objectionable for food were specified.ST Mar 21, 1878
Its teaching was distorted when its prohibitions were carried to unreasonable lengths, making life a burden of ceremonies and restrictions about eating and drinking and keeping the mind on a continual strain to discriminate between clean and unclean.ST Mar 21, 1878 It was further distorted by requiring people to strain drinking water to remove even the smallest insect, treating such minute concerns as more important than serious sins.DA 617.2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
44 sources
The verse names the pelican, the gier eagle and the cormorant among the unclean birds forbidden as food, whose eating would defile one under that law.ST Jul 3, 1907ST It stands within the nineteen-verse list of Deuteronomy 14:3-21 in which Moses sets out with decisive precision which beasts, fishes and fowls may be eaten and which may not, rehearsing the distinctions given in Leviticus 11.ST Dec 17, 1894 That definite instruction limits the permission to eat whatsoever in Deuteronomy 12:15 and to buy and eat whatsoever the soul desireth in Deuteronomy 14:26, so those permissions allow only clean flesh and never set aside the specific prohibitions.ST May 24, 1905ST Apr 21, 1914ST Apr 1, 1889 The distinction is not arbitrary decree nor first made for Israel, for the unclean are unclean and unwholesome in their very nature and habits and were already known in Noah's day when seven pairs of each clean kind but only a pair of each unclean kind entered the ark.ST Jan 2, 1912ST Aug 13, 1912ST Feb 11, 1889 It was given to preserve life and health by purest blood through least objectionable foods and to keep Israel holy and separate from the world, and what was better for ancient Israel to refuse is better to refuse now as a lasting principle, though those who held the ceremonial enforcement ended at Christ's death taught it no longer applies apart from its health principle.ST Apr 25, 1906ST May 23, 1911RH Jan 6, 1910ST Feb 13, 1896
Verse Wording and Context
The pelican, the gier eagle, and the cormorant stand among the birds classed as unclean, unfit for food, and forbidden to eat, so that eating them would defile one who observed that law.ST Jul 3, 1907STST Apr 29, 1913ST Jan 30, 1901 They are unclean by their very nature and habits rather than made unclean by decree, for the instruction tells what they are and designates what may be eaten.STST Jul 3, 1907ST Feb 13, 1907ST Apr 29, 1913 The prohibition rests on sound principle because their nature has not changed, and it guards physical health and cleanliness as well as moral soundness and purity, since what a person eats is frequently accountable for how a person acts.ST Jul 3, 1907STST May 23, 1911ST Apr 29, 1913 Together with Leviticus 11 the chapter gives the limits on the kinds of flesh permitted, and these food restrictions concern which animals are fit to eat rather than whether meat offered to idols may be eaten.ST Jul 15, 1908
The verse belongs to the specific nineteen-verse list in Deuteronomy 14:1-21, especially 14:3-21, in which Moses sets out with decisive precision which animals, fowls, fishes, and birds may be eaten and which may not be eaten.ST Dec 17, 1894ST Feb 11, 1889ST May 23, 1911 With Leviticus 11 it records the law distinguishing permitted from forbidden living creatures and rehearses the distinctions given in Leviticus 11.STST Feb 11, 1889ST Feb 13, 1907 That specific law of what may be eaten and what may not be eaten limits broader permission to eat living creatures and to buy and eat whatever is desired, keeping desire inside God's express prohibitions so as not to set aside or overthrow the specific prohibition.ST Dec 17, 1894 Clean and unclean kinds already existed in their nature at the Deluge, when only a pair of each unclean kind was preserved in the ark but seven pairs of each clean kind, which science confirms as unwholesome for food.ST Feb 11, 1889
The chapter's prohibitions also include swine's flesh, shellfish, and rabbits, and the division into clean and unclean pronounces both hogs and dogs unclean.RH Nov 5, 1872ST Jan 30, 1901 The fuller code in Leviticus 11 and Deuteronomy 14 regulating clean and unclean foods was given with instruction about blood and fat to help man select his diet, purify the blood because bodies are made of what is eaten, and make a holy, happy people after the call out of Egypt.RH Jan 6, 1910 Even on clean meats there are further restrictions, including the forbidding of fat and blood and the rule that meat must be used only on the first and second day after killing and not eaten at all on the third day.RH Aug 4, 1903 Animals found diseased are likewise prohibited from being eaten.ST Jul 29, 1889
The list of forbidden fowls does not mention geese or ducks, and those birds are not mentioned elsewhere in the Bible either.ST Mar 25, 1897
Broader Permissions Limited
The definite instruction about clean and unclean animal foods limits the whatsoever that may be eaten in Deuteronomy 12:15 and Deuteronomy 14:26, so no permission is given there to eat unclean animals.ST May 24, 1905ST Apr 21, 1914ST Apr 1, 1889 Deuteronomy 12 did not permit eating unclean meats, and the permission to eat flesh applied only to clean animals, not to every kind of animal.ST Apr 21, 1914ST Apr 1, 1889 The same limit is given in Leviticus 11, and the unclean and the clean mentioned in connection with eating refer not to the food eaten but to the eaters, both Israelites and strangers.ST May 24, 1905
The specific instructions in Deuteronomy 14:1-21 about what may be eaten and what may not be eaten, including the pelican and gier eagle and cormorant, are not set aside or overthrown by the general permission in Deuteronomy 14:26 to eat whatsoever the soul desireth when coming up to the great feasts.ST Dec 17, 1894ST May 24, 1905 The permission to spend second-tithe money for whatsoever the soul desires or lusteth after at the place God chose for the great yearly gatherings does not include any of these prohibited foods or every kind of meat desired, but stays inside God's express prohibitions and allows only what the chapter allows.ST Dec 17, 1894ST May 24, 1905ST Jul 18, 1911ST Apr 15, 1897 What the soul desires does not allow transgression of the specific laws God Himself gave distinguishing animals He permits His people to eat from those He forbids, and its application now is to be studied in the light of God's love to His children and such scriptures as 1 Corinthians 10:31.ST Dec 17, 1894ST Apr 15, 1897
God's own separation between the clean and the unclean shows that not every creature is fit or best for food, for God has told plainly which things He has given and sanctified or set apart for food as good for food, and which things He has not so given.ST Apr 25, 1906ST Jun 11, 1912ST Aug 26, 1913 Only what He created to be received with thanksgiving by those who believe and know the truth may be asked His blessing upon and received with thanksgiving, and only the food God commands to be received with thanksgiving is sanctified through the Word of God.ST Apr 25, 1906ST Jun 11, 1912 The listed birds fall within the limits on what may be treated as food in 1 Timothy 4:4, and the distinction is presented as more than a ceremonial rule.ST Dec 5, 1895ST Aug 26, 1913 These food restrictions concern which animals are fit to eat, not whether meat offered to idols may be eaten, and a vegetarian diet is not commanded by Scripture, though it is presented as a better choice.ST Jul 15, 1908
The classification was made by heavenly wisdom because of the very nature of the creatures themselves, resting on sound principles, and since their nature and habits have not changed they are unclean still.ST Apr 25, 1906ST Jul 3, 1907 The truthfulness of God's classification is demonstrated by science in absolutely forbidding the things God prohibited, as swine's flesh when one is sick or convalescent, and many on purely scientific grounds abjure these altogether.ST Jun 11, 1912 Deuteronomy 14:3-20 records God's Old Testament binding written law distinguishing clean and unclean animals that Peter had never violated and appealed to when commanded to eat in the vision of Acts 10:9-16.ST Jul 12, 1883 That vision did not abolish that distinction so that everything is lawful to eat, but showed that no man is to be called common or unclean.ST Jul 12, 1883
Nature and Origin of Distinction
The pelican, the gier eagle, and the cormorant are named as unclean because they are unclean in their very nature and habits, unfit and unwholesome for food and an abomination, while the creatures called clean are much more favorable for food.ST Jan 2, 1912ST Aug 13, 1912ST Jun 17, 1903ST Apr 25, 1906 The law does not make them so by decree, but tells what they already are and designates what may be eaten on that ground.ST Aug 13, 1912ST Oct 11, 1899 The classification was made by heavenly wisdom for that reason, not as an arbitrary setting aside of some equally wholesome animals and not as an arbitrary ceremonial separation to divide Jews from Gentiles.ST Jan 2, 1912ST Apr 25, 1906ST Jul 12, 1883
Clean and unclean kinds already existed from the beginning in the nature of the animals themselves and were already known in Noah's day at the Deluge.ST Feb 11, 1889ST Jul 12, 1883 Only a pair of each unclean kind was preserved in the ark, but seven pairs of each clean kind went in. That was several hundred years before the Jews existed as a nation and more than a thousand years before God's people were known as Jews, so the distinction was not first created when the laws were given to Israel.RH Nov 5, 1872ST Aug 10, 1915ST Jul 12, 1883 The list given after the Exodus from Egypt, where every wrong practice prevailed, does not bring about a new order of things.ST Jul 12, 1883
Since the nature and habits of the creatures have not changed they are unclean still.ST Apr 25, 1906ST Jul 3, 1907 Science confirms the truthfulness of the classification and absolutely demonstrates it by forbidding on purely scientific grounds the things God prohibited.ST Jun 11, 1912 In the nature of the foods eaten and rejected by Israel there could be no change even when all sacrifice of beasts in God's plan ended at Christ's death on the cross.ST Oct 11, 1899
These food laws were not part of God's perfect laws from the beginning, but were provided for Israel with better kinds of flesh foods to preserve the holy seed and to improve existing conditions.ST Oct 11, 1899
Purpose and Lessons Taught
The laws in Leviticus 11 and Deuteronomy 14 regulating clean and unclean foods, with instruction about blood and fat, were given to help man select his diet and to preserve life and health.ST Mar 21, 1878RH Jan 6, 1910ST Feb 13, 1896 By simple diet and manna apart from the flesh-pots of Egypt God sought to purify the blood, because bodies are made of what is eaten and the purest food makes the purest blood, and to keep the faculties of mind and body the blood must be kept pure by simple, healthful food, so He specified the animals least objectionable for food.ST Mar 21, 1878RH Jan 6, 1910 The rule guards physical health and cleanliness and also moral soundness and purity, because what a person eats is frequently accountable for how a person acts.ST May 23, 1911 Diseased animals were likewise prohibited from being eaten, and while some restrictions also had ceremonial or symbolic purposes, the restrictions are presented as wise safeguards whose observance benefits health and preserves the people.ST Feb 13, 1896ST Jul 29, 1889ST Dec 17, 1894
The instruction about diet in Deuteronomy 14:3-21 separated Israel from the world as God's holy people, directing dietary choices consistent with holiness and worship.STRH Apr 17, 1879ST Apr 28, 1909 The food distinctions were intended to protect them from corruption in blood.ST Keeping that diet kept them holy and peculiar, while breaking it was lusting to live and eat like the world and like Egypt, with complaining and murmuring against the Lord.RH Apr 17, 1879 That disobedience caused the Lord to withdraw His protecting care, so the disobedient wandered in the wilderness until all but Caleb and Joshua and the children perished and never entered the promised land.RH Apr 17, 1879
The code was given after the call out of Egypt to prepare a people not ready to enter the land flowing with milk and honey, beginning with health reform, diet and the law of God as the entering wedge and right arm of the message.RH Jan 6, 1910 The statutes regulating flesh eating would never have been necessary if Israel had submitted to God's plan to wean them from flesh food and establish them a healthy and holy people by food most conducive to health and righteous character.RH Dec 21, 1905 They were given as a concession after Israel refused God's manna diet and freedom from disease and lusted after flesh and were determined to have it at any cost, because God could lead them no faster than they were willing to follow.ST Feb 17, 1904RH Dec 21, 1905 God granted their desire in part but left them to bear sickness as the consequence, so they could differentiate between the more harmful and the less harmful, which is the difference between clean and unclean animals.ST Feb 17, 1904RH Dec 21, 1905 Within that law eating the permitted clean flesh is not sinful, but it is not an absolute necessity.ST Feb 17, 1904 The granted desire brought sickness, disease and leanness of soul, and stands as an example not to lust after evil things.ST Feb 17, 1904RH Dec 21, 1905 These principles originated in the mind of God and were revealed to man, not from the science of that day.RH Jan 6, 1910
The unclean were an abomination to offer to the Lord, while the clean could be offered for sacrifice.ST Jan 2, 1912 Every animal life taken for food kept continually before Israel the lesson of sin and its consequence death, telling of the sinful condition in which they were and of the death on their behalf of the One to come.ST Oct 11, 1899 The Pharisees carried these prohibitions to unreasonable lengths, making life a burden of ceremonies and restrictions over eating and drinking and keeping the mind on a continual strain to discriminate between clean and unclean.ST Mar 21, 1878
Lasting Authority Disputed
The classification of the pelican, gier eagle and cormorant as unclean and an abomination not to be eaten was made by heavenly wisdom because of the very nature of the creatures themselves, and since their nature has not changed they are unclean still.ST Apr 25, 1906ST The law did not make them clean or unclean, for clean and unclean kinds already existed at the Deluge when only a pair of each unclean kind was preserved in the ark but seven pairs of each clean kind, and the distinction was recognized before the Flood more than a thousand years before God's people were known as Jews, so it is a lasting principle and not a Jewish rule.ST Feb 11, 1889RH Nov 5, 1872 They are unclean by their very nature and unwholesome for food, which science confirms, and God declares them so because they were so, not arbitrarily.STST Oct 11, 1899 The same principles used to distinguish clean and unclean in ancient times still apply, and the clean food given to Israel would still be better than a general flesh diet if followed by all the world to the present.ST Feb 11, 1889ST Oct 11, 1899 What was better for ancient Israel to refuse is better to refuse now, and only the food God commands to be received with thanksgiving is sanctified through the Word of God.ST Apr 25, 1906 Though unclean, both hogs and dogs pronounced unclean in Deuteronomy 14 are still used as food, dogs by the heathen Chinese and swine by Christians, and raising swine for market to sell their flesh for money is wrong.RH Nov 5, 1872 When Jesus Christ died upon the cross all sacrifice of beasts in God's plan ended, but in the nature of the foods eaten and rejected by Israel there could be no change, and eating unclean beasts brings disease such as scrofula and cancer.ST Oct 11, 1899
Those who held that the binding force had passed away taught that the ceremonial enforcement given to the Jewish nation alone passed away at the death of Christ and was not imposed on Gentile converts living among nations where clean and unclean were eaten at all times, apart from the restrictions in Acts 15.ST Dec 17, 1894ST Aug 13, 1912 In that teaching the distinction served a purpose under Jewish ceremonial law which was abolished as a law when the gospel went to the Gentiles, and the restrictions served a purpose among Israel but were lifted as a binding law when the gospel went to Gentiles who could not initially keep them.ST Aug 13, 1912ST Aug 13, 1912 The specific law therefore no longer applies, although its underlying health principle remains and people should follow it as far as possible, choosing food not by appetite but by what glorifies God and gives best health and service.ST Dec 17, 1894 The verse remains part of Scripture through which people can learn that God distinguished among animals for food, and in light of Scripture and knowledge of health people should choose the best diet they can and follow God's original provision of fruits, grains, nuts, and vegetables, bringing glory to God.ST Aug 13, 1912ST Aug 13, 1912
In the same line it was taught that Israel's dietary laws including this list of unclean birds are not binding on Gentile believers, while the principles behind them and the differences in the nature of animals remain true.ST Aug 11, 1909 The prohibition on unclean foods was later lifted, but the principle of choosing food that honors God remains, and the swine is unclean and should be excluded from the diet.ST Jul 29, 1913
Healthful Living and Application
Heeding the clear instruction brings health, while the animals used for food are becoming more and more diseased and vegetables, grains, and fruits are much cleaner and more wholesome almost universally.ST Jan 2, 1912ST Jun 17, 1903 Fruits, grains, nuts, and vegetables are identified as better, purer foods and as God's original provision, to be chosen as the best diet possible in times when disease affects animals as well as people and to bring glory to God.ST Aug 13, 1912 A vegetarian diet is presented as a better choice though it is not commanded by Scripture, and these food restrictions concern which animals are fit to eat, not whether meat offered to idols may be eaten.ST Jul 15, 1908 Even clean flesh is not the best food, as shown by God giving manna instead of flesh and by giving no flesh at all in the beginning of man's life on earth, since the statutes regulating flesh eating would never have been necessary if Israel had submitted to God's plan to wean them from flesh food toward health and righteous character when He brought them out of Egypt toward Canaan.ST Jan 2, 1912RH Dec 21, 1905 They were given as a concession when Israel lusted after flesh and was determined to have it at any cost, because God could lead them no faster than they were willing to follow, so they could differentiate between the more harmful and the less harmful, which is the difference between clean and unclean animals, and the granted desire brought disease and leanness of soul and stands as an example not to lust after evil things.RH Dec 21, 1905
Pork is hard to digest, does not assimilate readily, and carries potencies of disease and especially scrofula, with eating unclean beasts bringing disease such as scrofula and cancer.ST Jan 2, 1912ST Oct 11, 1899 The ban still binds in sickness, so a doctor's claim that bacon is good for tuberculosis does not make it right to eat.ST Jan 2, 1912 Giving up pork removes outbreaking humors from the blood and lets wounds and bruises heal by first intention without suppuration, while legumes such as beans, peas, and lentils, or plenty of fresh cow's milk, with rest, abundance of fresh air night and day, and superabundance of food, are proper treatment for consumption.ST Jan 2, 1912
As far as possible, food should be chosen not by appetite but by what glorifies God and gives best health and service and for fitness for health and service to God. The distinction rests on the nature of the animals and their suitability as food, not an arbitrary rule, and the principle that some foods are unsuitable for health and service to God remains valid, so what was better for ancient Israel to refuse is better to refuse now.ST Apr 29, 1913 Its application now is to be studied in the light of God's love to His children and such scriptures as 1 Corinthians 10:31.ST Apr 15, 1897 God's gift of freedom to choose and to rejoice in what is good is bounded by His other commands, and taking His permission as license to indulge is wrongdoing.ST Aug 27, 1902
Changing from a flesh diet to a vegetarian diet requires wisdom and good common sense in cooking and combinations of food.ST Jun 17, 1903
Sources