Thou shalt not kill forbids every person from taking another person's human life under any circumstances or provocation, for human life is sacred as God's gift continually dependent on Him, only the Giver has right and knowledge to withhold it, and no human power can restore it once taken by one rash act, so the command guards each neighbor's natural right to live and makes every person's life inviolate.ST Dec 16, 1908RH Jul 7, 1874RH May 23, 1907RH Sep 18, 1860 It stands in the numbered sequence as the sixth commandment, placed fifth in the Catholic list which omits the command against graven images and divides coveting into two, and knowing it makes the wrong clearer and increases responsibility because sin darkens the mind against rights.RH May 23, 1907RH Jul 9, 1857 It simply forbids murder and killing as the deliberate wanton taking of innocent human life, plainly wrong and needing no proof as violation of moral law, a crime and high crime belonging to the second table summed in love to man, distinct from local temporary legislation, unchangeable by legislation or civilization, not abolished by Christianity but continually quoted by Christ and the apostles.RH Oct 10, 1907ST Dec 6, 1883ST Feb 5, 1902RH Jul 15, 1875RH Mar 12, 1908 In Christ it is not only prohibition but enabling word giving power to obey, becoming law of liberty in which the obedient delight, and faithful obedience to it with the other precepts would end sin; it is no yoke to the honest and pure in heart.RH Oct 10, 1907RH Jul 15, 1875
It guards life, personal safety and right to life for all including wife, parent, child, the small and insignificant and all dear ones against the stronger, as moral foundation of civilization and first condition of society, revealing God as protector of life and requiring severe punishment for such murder as invading a dwelling to kill.ST Dec 16, 1908RH Jul 7, 1874RH May 23, 1907RH Sep 18, 1860 The word kill in itself includes taking life generally, but the verse does not forbid killing animals, birds, reptiles, insects or plants when necessary, nor killing an ox for market, nor destroying pests such as bedbugs, fleas and potato beetles, for its circumstances show it concerns duties toward other people.RH Mar 11, 1909ST May 20, 1908RH Apr 12, 1864ST Feb 5, 1902 Those who held otherwise taught that the sixth precept forbids slaughter of animals for food and requires abstinence from flesh meat, allowing destruction of inferior animals only in dire necessity where one's own life is at stake, because man's life is worth more than lower animals and life is more than meat.ST Oct 8, 1894
It forbids lying in wait to kill unsuspecting inoffensive persons with deadly weapons, assassination and revolution for pleasure, riches and honors, shooting others, dueling, killing an enemy in revenge even when the victim killed one's father, and everyday murders such as shooting a wife, stabbing a father or killing over opinion, and hearing it convicts the murderer with terror to confession and pardon while calling it obsolete leaves shooting, beating and swearing uncondemned.ST Jul 17, 1907ST Jan 1, 1894ST Aug 16, 1910ST Jan 13, 1887ST May 13, 1886 Its restraint removed would leave life unrespected, the strongest to take by violence and become richest, children to kill parents for corrupt desires, and the world a horde of robbers and assassins without peace, rest or happiness, with disobedience sowing disobedience and teaching release from it opening flood-gates of lawlessness, murder, fraud and robbery; the law is not to be reduced but men changed to meet it.ST Jul 17, 1907 It forbids not only killing with poison, pistol or knife but killing as surely if more slowly by conduct, as when a disobedient son kills parents by vileness of life or a husband kills his wife by coldness, brutality, unfaithfulness and intemperance, who are in every sense murderers, and it forbids conduct hastening another's death such as repeatedly serving harmful food even without ill will.ST Sep 17, 1902ST Oct 28, 1930 It forbids destroying the person made in God's image whether just begun and yet unborn or in full maturity, whether suddenly or gradually by act or intention, since human life as breath of God quickening His image is sacred from conception, condemning abortion by poison or instruments among educated rich as well as heathen drowning of newborns for birds and reptiles, deserving civil prison punishment and church reprimand without partiality to the respectable.ST Aug 25, 1887RH Jun 25, 1867ST Sep 10, 1885
It forbids eating blood and things strangled because blood is life, binding from the beginning and now, inconsistent with Christ's life as law in perfection.ST Dec 12, 1892 Withholding the gospel so people die for want of spiritual knowledge, leaving a wounded person to die when one can care for him even if an enemy, and excusing failure to make effort to keep someone alive, also transgress it, for it requires love seeking another's good beyond refraining from injury.RH Jan 8, 1867RH Feb 20, 1900ST May 12, 1881 It guards the joy of living, given by the Father as absolutely necessary to happiness and life in His family, whose disregard would be fatal to all intelligent beings in heaven and earth, unchangeable everywhere and abolished only by writing its love inwardly so one pleases to do only what it requires, Christ thus its end for righteousness to believers for perfect liberty.ST Sep 13, 1899 It forbids taking human life including ending a patient's life on mercy grounds, since men cannot know incurability or greater good nor restore life, and assuming authority to kill under circumstances usurps God.ST Nov 8, 1899
Even an accidental blow nearly causing death can make one fear becoming a murderer despite lack of intent, showing its gravity for conscience.ST Nov 13, 1893 It is no obstacle or contrary to an innocent person but applies against one who has murder in heart or is actually a murderer, remaining binding when anger tempts as with hand on revolver, where calling it bondage resists it and love brings willing obedience; its requirements are safe rule for the narrow way, not opposed to gospel salvation but expected with looking to Jesus.ST Feb 4, 1886RH Jun 10, 1852ST Feb 4, 1886ST Nov 20, 1893 Refraining from killing is part of perfect conformity under moral government, while killing violates moral law.ST Feb 4, 1886ST Mar 17, 1914 It is one of eight prohibitions, the other two requiring honor to Sabbath and parents, meant for all time and classes; breaking it is sin as transgression of law, a grave sin of commission like theft, adultery and perjury justly met by civil and church penalties, and included among sins bringing curse for withholding the Lord's due.ST Jun 19, 1884RH Apr 27, 1905
It forbids taking lives for differences of belief as murder bringing guilt, awakening individual accountability to God and questioning secular killing for faith, pressing full claims against religious coercion, church-state union, enforcing worship by sovereign or majority, silencing dissent, and wars of religion as continued medieval intolerance, since faith has value only when free and others' opinions must be borne.ST May 28, 1912ST Aug 18, 1909 It is one of only three Decalogue precepts repeated word for word in the New Testament, though lack of verbatim repetition does not release from keeping any precept.ST Apr 19, 1877 It establishes murder and adultery as morally wrong so that claiming a right to them corrupts judgment, presenting absolute standards not changeable conventions, with covetousness as grave as murder and right and wrong as real distinctions.RH May 9, 1871ST Aug 16, 1910RH Oct 19, 1916ST Jul 17, 1879 Following Scripture literally does not lead to violating it, for the Pocasset murder came from personal impressions in disregard of its plain precept, not from obeying the Bible.ST Jun 19, 1879
Urging stoning of those who teach obedience to God's commandments contradicts it and conflicts with its prohibition, while blaming others or claiming beguilement does not excuse transgression.ST Mar 4, 1875RH Feb 18, 1875ST Jun 10, 1889 Killing is moral wrong unjustifiable by pressure or circumstances, as harvesting on Sabbath cannot be so excused.RH Jul 2, 1861 It addresses each person as individual duty, not merely rule for society.ST Aug 5, 1913 Murder is prohibited totally every day, not only Sunday or holidays, so limiting prohibition weakens law; likewise liquor traffic making criminals like murder and theft must be totally prohibited all days rather than merely closed Sunday which legalizes evil other days, for destroying life remains wrong every day not only on sacred day.RH Jan 27, 1910ST Oct 17, 1900 Violating it in hope of gaining the victim's property is crime for illusory reward with no lasting gain, since sin earns death.RH Feb 24, 1874ST Mar 11, 1880
Taking a neighbor's life violates God's law and is a form of theft depriving him of what is rightfully his, coming under the law's cutting-off penalty for willful transgression requiring strict obedience.ST May 31, 1910ST Oct 22, 1902 It rules out killing to gain mastery, condemning rulership by crushing others and war as toll of ambition for dominion, against God's purpose shown in Christ's service, with eternal victory for those awaiting God's restoration. It forbids taking another's life for perishable or imperishable gain, vengeance belonging to God and enemies to be fed not revenged.ST Mar 31, 1898 Its prohibition rules out taking life even claiming death brings heavenly bliss, for treating death as call to Jesus cannot make killing children or righteous right, and the Ten are not abolished.ST Nov 16, 1882 Avoiding harm outweighs social etiquette, so regard for comfort and dignity must not yield to custom, and breaking it is far graver than table breach like lifting knife instead of fork to lips.ST Nov 26, 1912ST Dec 13, 1883
Heart Motive and Spirit
Thou shalt not kill reaches beyond the outward deed of taking life to the desire, thoughts, principles and motives that lead to it, condemning anger, hatred, malice, envy, pride and revenge and requiring a right heart conformed to love after the example of Jesus.ST May 13, 1897ST Dec 15, 1898ST Nov 13, 1893 Right desires would keep a person from killing, while uncontrolled temper and desire to kill make guilty before God whether or not the act was planned.ST Nov 13, 1893 The command uproots sin to its innermost cause, condemning the desire to harm that precedes the act and judging, condemning and speaking evil of others, for all death is contrary to God's will.ST Dec 15, 1898 It forbids murder in outward deed and in heart motive and requires love to neighbor as self, doing to others as one would have them do, as one precept of Exodus 20:1-17 to be kept whole and enshrined in the heart.
Anger without cause is subject to judgment, hatred of a brother is murder, and malice and revenge are murder in source, while righteous indignation at God's dishonor or oppression is not sinful.ST May 13, 1897ST Dec 15, 1898ST Nov 13, 1893 Those who keep this with the rest of the commandments are pure in heart to see God and have right to the tree of life and entrance through the gates into the city to immortal life, while murderers are left without. It always forbade hatred even in Old Testament times and was just as broad then as now, for Cain was already a murderer before he shed his brother's blood.ST Sep 27, 1883 To say hatred was once allowed would leave unconverted haters fit for heaven, which cannot be, for the law was perfect for converting the soul and demanded a heart cleansed from every sinful desire.ST Sep 27, 1883
Jesus in Matthew 5 did not make the command more or less than it ever had been, did not enlarge or diminish it, but magnified it and made it honorable by making its spiritual depth clear and giving it broad spiritual application to the thoughts and intents of the heart.RH May 17, 1864RH Apr 3, 1879ST Sep 27, 1883 Anger is related to murder as its root, must precede murder, and cherishing anger must be broken before murder can follow.RH Apr 3, 1879 His teaching on murder raises the standard rather than repealing or weakening it, for the gospel spiritualizes and perfects the moral law, strengthening obligation as a rule of life revealing duty and forbidding sin.RH Mar 10, 1859RH Jan 1, 1861 Narrowing the command to the outward act is an evasion to defend the change of the Sabbath and of times and laws by Rome.ST Sep 27, 1883 Nor can Matthew 5 be a new code replacing it, since that would place the new enactment three and a half years before the abolition of the old and would refer to at most three of the ten and therefore be incomplete.RH May 17, 1864
Keeping the letter without the spirit is not keeping it, for outward conformity alone is not obedience, and the command must be kept spiritually in both letter and spirit.RH Jan 27, 1916RH Feb 17, 1859ST Jun 9, 1890ST Sep 18, 1893 Its spirit forbids hating a brother, so one who hates without killing breaks it in spirit and is a murderer in spirit.ST May 9, 1878 Yet keeping the spirit never excuses breaking the letter, so one who willingly kills cannot claim still to keep it in spirit, and letter obedience is needed for its spirit.ST May 9, 1878 The law governs the heart as well as outward conduct, directing the spirit in its outward actions, for human life is sacred and must be treated with due regard.ST Jun 9, 1890 The question about keeping the spirit as well as the letter therefore calls for obedience to the intent, not merely the wording.RH Jan 27, 1916
Evil-speaking, judging, condemning, hateful words, reproachful names, variance, strife, quarrel, envy, unkind words and selfishness violate it, and reconciliation must precede worship.ST Dec 15, 1898ST Jul 1, 1889 Hatred, envy, unkind words, reproachful names, and thoughts or desires leading toward the crime also violate it, as one of the Ten expressing love toward others and reaching into thoughts and purposes of the heart.ST Jul 1, 1889 Its positive meaning is to do good, preserve life, value and guard a neighbor's life as one's own, using opportunities to increase one another's comfort and happiness rather than merely refraining from harm.ST Oct 6, 1887ST Aug 24, 1882 God protects every person's life by expressly forbidding killing, safeguarding not only one's own life but the lives of loved ones, with serious punishment rightly following murder.ST Oct 6, 1887ST Aug 24, 1882 Fulfilled by love it requires active unselfish concern illustrated by Jesus' life of doing good, and is fulfilled not merely by outward obedience but by love established in the heart.ST Jan 30, 1901RH Jan 26, 1905
The prohibition reflects the presence of sin, while teaching the enduring principle of protecting life, and obedience would prevent crimes with their imprisonment and executions and help preserve peace and happiness.ST May 13, 1897ST Feb 8, 1905 Those who held the narrower view taught that it requires only refraining from killing as one of eight negative duties, with Sabbath-keeping and honoring parents as the only two positive duties, meaning not doing the act but not commanding positive love.RH Jan 31, 1854 On that view a person could refrain from killing, idolatry, profanity, stealing, adultery, false witness and covetousness while keeping the Sabbath and honoring parents, and still knowingly leave a next-door neighbor to starve and freeze while having plenty, so keeping it would not fulfill the royal law of loving neighbor as self.RH Jan 31, 1854 On that same view Adam could have obeyed this and every other one of the ten and still have become a sinner by breaking God's earlier law in Eden, showing sin and death entered not by transgressing this code two thousand years before it was given.RH Jan 31, 1854
Every premeditated taking of life is rooted in coveting, for no forethought murder happens without coveting money, wealth, place, reputation or power to inflict vengeance, so violation begins with a covetous heart longing for what it does not have.ST Aug 2, 1905ST Feb 5, 1902 The tenth commandment thus interlinks with this, secret unlawful desire leading to murder.ST Aug 2, 1905ST Feb 5, 1902 The verse also reaches beyond physical death, as shown when Adam and Eve broke it in Eden by eating and thereby killed themselves and the whole family, by whose trespass the many died.RH May 16, 1907 Unrepented sin causes the sinner to die the second death and drags down to perdition some soul whom he might have influenced to eternal life, for none lives or dies to himself.RH May 16, 1907
By implication it requires the opposite positive duty and forbids lesser faults of the same kind, calling for avoiding occasions and temptations to kill, not encouraging others to do so, and restraining them when possible.RH Feb 20, 1872 It forbids helping another break it, as lending a weapon to a murderer would provide the means for violation. Keeping it means more than refraining from taking life; it means not to hate, because to hate is to kill, requiring humane conduct and freedom from hatred through submission to God by faith.RH Mar 14, 1907RH Feb 26, 1914ST Jan 21, 1886 Cherishing envy, hatred and enmity breaks it as truly as actual murder, so it must be obeyed outwardly and from the heart.ST Jan 21, 1886 Read through the life of Jesus Christ and the principle of love as God's purpose for life, it becomes true by saying to God to make it true while cooperating with Him, through whose grace He keeps from hate by keeping in perfect peace, making the holy law life in character by faith which thus establishes the law.RH Mar 14, 1907
It covers a variety of sins and wrongs beyond open killing, magnified with the seventh in Matthew 5:17-37 to show breaches that would never have been discovered without inspiration.RH Sep 27, 1864 This magnifying makes the law honorable and provides the pattern for understanding His teaching on swearing as magnification of the third commandment.RH Sep 27, 1864
Health Self and Neighbor
Thou shalt not kill forbids taking one's own life, for suicide is murder that despises God's gift of life and rebels directly against His authority, whether driven by despair, fear of suffering or disgrace, or any other cause, whether by shooting, poisoning, drowning, starving, or by a prisoner seeking to avoid a certain death sentence, and to permit it or to teach that suicide is no sin annuls a commandment that is eternal and unchangeable.RH Jun 23, 1868RH Dec 20, 1853ST Sep 24, 1912 The same prohibition reaches drinking whisky as murdering oneself and wilfully starving oneself as self-murder, binding across all ages as Cain's act and these acts violate the same unchanging law.ST Dec 15, 1898ST Sep 24, 1912 It also forbids defeating the law of nature, which men commit without knowing it while conscience is scarcely stirred because fashion has made the sin common and sophistry has filed off its sharp edges, so the sin must be plainly named as murder with commandment and breach laid side by side until conscience is torn and smitten and the humbled soul looks to Christ as Saviour from sin and not as minister of sin.RH Feb 21, 1871 Obedience includes living in harmony with the natural laws God established, and violating those laws through depraved appetite and lustful passions is disobedience to God and contributes to the disease afflicting the world.RH Mar 6, 1913
Destroying health and shortening life by unnecessary indulgence is killing and is sin against God, including drinking intoxicating drinks, smoking and chewing tobacco, using opium, tea, coffee and other stimulants, tight dressing, unwholesome food, intemperate eating, overeating, overwork, sexual excess and other harmful habits and excesses that weaken body and mind, impair health, rapidly destroy life, shorten the average length of human life, impair the vitality of children born, and cause unhappiness, suffering, poverty and discomfort.ST May 6, 1889RH Nov 3, 1874RH Mar 17, 1863RH Mar 13, 1866RH Dec 2, 1873 Knowingly using tea or tobacco when they are known to injure health violates the commandment, for harming one's own health is contrary to not killing, and those professing respect for all of God's commandments must lay aside what harms the body.RH Mar 17, 1863RH Mar 13, 1866ST Oct 29, 1885 Tobacco is a powerful poison destroying vital force and the functions needed for healthy life, whose temporary stimulation and soothing comes at the cost of life and health, and using it so as to weaken health and shorten life amounts to suicide in a constructive sense.RH Nov 3, 1874ST Oct 29, 1885 Using stimulants, poisons, or things contrary to nature that tear down rather than build up the body violates the commandment, especially when a person has learned the truth about their effects.RH Jul 2, 1867
The prohibition also forbids harming others by those habits, including bringing wretchedness and sorrow on wife, children and neighbor through drink, polluting the air that wife, child, friends, neighbors and strangers must breathe with tobacco smoke that can even destroy the life of infants, and by tight dressing preventing development of the body, displacing organs, producing deformity, and making women unable to bear well-developed healthy children and nurse them successfully.ST May 6, 1889 The liquor traffic deliberately brings death through accidents, disease and ruin, and belongs under the same condemnation of destroying life.ST May 6, 1889
The commandment requires preserving health and prolonging life by every proper means, for knowingly and carelessly causing sickness by violating health laws is sinful, and habits of eating, drinking, and laboring that damage the body and bring disease or premature death, including overeating and overwork causing premature death, are forbidden.RH Jul 2, 1867RH Feb 26, 1867ST Dec 15, 1898 Natural and physical laws are God's laws as truly as the Decalogue, so violating them is sin and disobedience to God.RH Feb 26, 1867RH Mar 6, 1913 Taking into the body what injures it transgresses whether the harm comes from a dose of poison that kills quickly or from smaller doses repeatedly taken, as with moderate drinking.ST Jun 10, 1908 To defile the body, to make it strengthless and diseased by indulgence of appetite and passion for tobacco, liquor, or any hurtful thing, to enfeeble body, nerves, brain and judgment and become a health-destroyer and self-made invalid, is to break the commandment, for the body is God's property by creation and by redemption and is His temple to be consecrated to His service.ST Apr 4, 1900 Those who keep themselves from the defilement of appetite and passion keep the commandment, become partakers of the divine nature, keep clear perceptions, preserve every faculty in health to present to God in service, and can be used by Him.ST Apr 4, 1900
Its principle also requires preventing preventable death as far as lies in human power, so failing to prevent tuberculosis when it is a preventable disease violates it.RH Apr 7, 1910 It forbids drunkenness and all other sins against bodily life and welfare, so no added commandment against drunkenness is needed, and drunkenness is also a fruitful source of sins that break this commandment and the seventh commandment.RH Mar 31, 1910 God may show mercy to people who break His law without understanding its true character, but growing light about the law calls people to prepare characters fit for citizenship in His kingdom.RH Jul 2, 1867ST Dec 15, 1898 Keeping the commandment also fulfills duty to self, securing self-support, self-defense, self-control, and self-culture, because failing to support oneself takes support wrongfully from others, failing to control oneself leads to sin against others, and failing to train body, mind, and heart prevents proper service in society.ST Jun 23, 1887
Government War and Exceptions
The general prohibition is not broken by carrying out a judicial sentence at God's command when Israel was a theocracy under God as King, where people acted only as God's agents and executors of His will with responsibility assumed by Him through prophet or priest, as in putting to death one who entices to other gods under Deuteronomy 13:6-9, executing the Sabbath-breaker under Numbers 15:32-36, and destroying the Canaanites, which was obedience not murder, so that sparing what God commanded to destroy brought rebuke and punishment, and such actions must be weighed by motives, circumstances and instruction given rather than taken as permission for murder.ST Apr 9, 1912RH Aug 27, 1857RH Oct 21, 1862RH Oct 21, 1862 God as King could order the death of persons or nations as judgment directly or through human agents without violating an immutable precept, when wickedness was complete and nations had rejected saving truth and become identified with sin, receiving the wages of sin, with mercy still open to the truly repentant.ST Mar 20, 1901RH Apr 6, 1916 Such judgments could warn future generations that sin leads to death, protect those who might otherwise be led into deeper depravity, bring recognition to God, and in the case of deeply corrupt nations like the Canaanites act in mercy to prevent further crime and vice, carried out in the wisest and most loving way consistent with character, needs and free will, though human agents might limit or distort the work without their sins being charged to Him.ST Mar 20, 1901RH Apr 6, 1916 All life comes from God as a trust for humanity's eternal good, so His taking of life is not violation of His own law against wrongful taking of human life.RH Apr 6, 1916
The prescribed penalty for wilful premeditated murder distinct from accident is death, shown by the cities of refuge, and government ordained by God to punish wrongdoing in executing a murderer convicted beyond question inflicts the penalty for violating the commandment rather than violating it, and restrains future crime.RH Mar 7, 1871 Every person's life is made inviolate, guarding wife, parent, child and all dear lives, so that invading a dwelling to murder ought to receive severe punishment, revealing God as protector of life, and wanton violators who fear neither God nor punishment beyond the grave when the command is enacted as civil statute are hanged by the neck until dead.RH Sep 18, 1860ST Apr 1, 1897 Human governments do not make murder wrong but punish it because it is wrong, and the commandment incorporated into Israel's civil law assigned death as civil penalty punishing the offender as violator of the commonwealth, leaving him still to answer to God at judgment, with the precept binding Gentiles as well as Jews and enduring after special local laws ended.ST Jun 12, 1879RH Mar 7, 1871 The sacredness of human life as God's breath quickening His image is not set aside by death as penalty under Moses, by civil statutes taking the lives of wanton destroyers of life, or by self-protection even when it requires taking life, for rights and duties do not conflict, though limits must be jealously guarded in true reverence for man.ST Aug 25, 1887
Civil law addresses only the outward deed to repress incivility, repress crime, conserve civil rights and protect rights, and would be recognized as necessary even where God is not known, while the commandment is wholly spiritual belonging to the inner life and forbidding motive, thought, hatred and unrighteous anger, so that one who hates his brother is a murderer in God's sight even without taking life.ST Dec 24, 1912ST Jul 18, 1900 A civil law may use the same words and forbid the same outward act without making the command merely civil, and civil law cannot remove inward guilt or make people moral but can only suppress and punish the outward act.ST Mar 17, 1887ST Aug 6, 1912 The civil penalty attached in Israel's theocratic government ceased with that government without abolishing the moral commandment, and violations not recognized or punished by human law remain forbidden as interpreted in the New Testament.RH Mar 26, 1872
War is murder even when only one is killed, and no glossing or disguising changes that, for war is right only if murder is right and wrong if murder is wrong, defying the command through national slaughter repeated generation to generation, killing even those bound by family, as the bitter end of contentious tempers begun in childhood for which instigators bear responsibility.RH Aug 28, 1900RH Feb 27, 1900ST Jan 9, 1901 Firing on an enemy in war is disobedience to the command, patriotism can deceive people into violating it by encouraging killing, and the command stands as infinite standard thundering unmodified down the ages as long as time lasts, calling to follow the Prince of Peace toward the coming age when war and hate cease rather than Mars and Moloch for greed, conquest, wrong and butchery.RH Apr 14, 1903ST Apr 9, 1902 Those who hold this therefore teach that Christians must refuse arms, seek service that saves life such as the medical corps rather than deliberately destroying life, refuse to support soldiers and warfare by voluntary offerings while teaching the commandment, and accept martyrdom rather than kill when drafted.RH Aug 28, 1900RH Oct 2, 1900
Those who held otherwise teach that the verse does not forbid all killing in war, does not by itself rule out taking life in a just war, and is consistent with God's commands to Israel to wage war, inflict capital punishment, and the magistrate's bearing the sword as God's minister to punish wrongdoing.RH Oct 21, 1862RH Oct 14, 1862 Defensive war to protect government and people's rights and lawful government against rebellion or invasion is held not to be murder, as shown by Abraham who kept God's commandments yet fought to rescue Lot and defend allies and was blessed as God's servant, and by Michael the Prince of Peace leading holy angels to protect God's government against rebels without violating the commandment kept by Christ and by angels that do His commandments.RH Oct 14, 1862RH Oct 28, 1862 Paid military service is held to remain open, since soldiers told to be content with wages are still soldiers and soldiers refusing to fight when required would earn no pay, with no command to drafted soldiers to resist authorities, risk death or prison and go home, though volunteering for an unjust war like Herod's war to keep his brother's wife or a war to maintain slavery is wrong, and killing enemies who began hostilities and first shed blood was not regarded as violation under the rule that shed blood requires blood.RH Sep 30, 1862RH Dec 16, 1862
Military service requires implicit unquestioning obedience to the commanding officer regardless of the commandment, putting the officer in God's place between soldier and God, so one unwilling to let man come between must stay out of the army. The holy ten lay binding duty above commanders' orders, to be obeyed even when disobedience brings punishment and imprisonment, as faithfulness to One higher in the patience of the saints and ground for witness by word, deed and publications before officers and fellow soldiers.RH Sep 26, 1907 Being drafted places a person under government's responsibility for violating the command, while resisting military law until shot takes responsibility for suicide.RH Aug 12, 1862
A civil statute commanding murder is unjust, binds no one, and should be repealed rather than enforced, for God's law is higher than human law, and the express command must not be disregarded or violated under compulsion of national law.ST Jun 10, 1886RH Jun 8, 1916 Civil laws protecting life may exist independently of religion or knowledge of the Decalogue, and enforcing them is distinct from compelling love or religious observance, with authority over religious questions remaining between soul and God rather than civil government.ST Sep 24, 1894ST Oct 16, 1893 Killing was understood to be forbidden, so that Abraham at first doubted the command to slay Isaac as possible deception since God would not command what He had forbidden, before conviction that the command was genuine and trust that God could raise Isaac and fulfill promises through him, while the prohibition was also used to tempt him to doubt on the ground God would not require what He had once forbidden.ST Apr 1, 1875ST Apr 3, 1879AUST Jun 14, 1920
The commandment was claimed to support the civil magistrate as preserver of both tables entitled to punish all breaches of both, compelling subjects by penalty to hear for instruction and conversion and punishing further refusal to join the church, joining Bible with sword to preserve uniformity by violent repression.RH Jul 2, 1908 Exodus 20:1-17 was made supreme law and cornerstone of government in Massachusetts Bay with the Bible as statute-book and church dominating civil power, making breaches concerning parents, false worship, adultery and covetousness alike capital, while the command not to kill did not protect Indians identified as Canaan, Amalekites, Amorites and Philistines worthy only of death.ST Jul 26, 1899 By contrast the command belongs to the second table of the last six defining duties and rights between people which people may require of one another and which belong to the proper field of civil legislation over outward acts, distinguished from duties owed to God which no person may enforce or use civil power to compel.ST Jan 6, 1887ST Feb 17, 1914ST Nov 11, 1889 Disagreement over the binding prohibition against murder does not remove the state's duty to legislate against it, and claimed religious duty does not make murder lawful or exempt, for government must uphold the second table.RH May 17, 1870ST Jan 5, 1882
The destruction of the enemy fleet and deaths of hundreds at Manila Bay raise the question whether killing in a claimed victory is more wicked and dishonoring to God than fleeing to save life.ST Aug 25, 1898 Civil governments may regulate murder, theft, adultery and injury to reputation for safety and protection even without following God, without thereby becoming agents enforcing spiritual law, and belief in the ten does not mean every commandment should be civilly enforced, stealing being properly legislated in contrast to Sunday observance.ST Oct 23, 1893ST Sep 2, 1889 The state has no authority to exempt anyone from obeying the command against murder as God's command, nor did God submit what He spoke to popular vote or hand authority over it to people or civil power to enforce or change without bringing doom.RH Mar 1, 1906ST Nov 28, 1895 It stands on record as ethical commandment remaining in force until repealed by record, and no record of repeal exists, so it is still binding.RH Nov 24, 1910
Unity Sabbath and Wholeness
The prohibition of killing belongs to a single unbroken chain of ten, so that to violate it is to become a transgressor of the whole law and guilty of all, because offense against one precept is offense against the authority that gave them all.ST Oct 22, 1874ST Jun 12, 1907ST Nov 3, 1914RH Jun 2, 1851ST Nov 7, 1878 Keeping it therefore requires keeping all ten together, and keeping all but this one still leaves guilt, since the law remains whole only as each distinct point remains binding.RH Oct 27, 1868ST Nov 3, 1914RH Jun 2, 1874 It is the sixth commandment of the Decalogue spoken by Jehovah alongside the Sabbath, defining duty to neighbor within the same royal law and law of liberty by which Christians are judged.ST Oct 22, 1874ST Jun 12, 1907RH Jun 2, 1851 That law is unalterable and perpetuated to the end of the gospel dispensation, coeval and coextensive with eternity, giving right to the tree of life and entrance through the gates into the city when Jesus comes to those who keep the whole duty of man.RH Oct 27, 1868RH May 7, 1872
It is inseparably bound with the fourth commandment and the Sabbath, so that an argument against the Sabbath strikes with equal force against it and against the Decalogue itself.ST Jul 29, 1913ST Jul 27, 1882ST Mar 18, 1875 To admit continuing obligation not to kill while denying continuing obligation to observe the Sabbath day of the Decalogue is faulty logic, for its principle still exists and still binds now exactly as when the law was in force, and setting aside the set form of the ten did not release from the duty it enjoins.ST Nov 13, 1879ST Mar 10, 1881 Denying the continuing authority of the fourth commandment undermines the claim that the Ten as a whole have supreme authority, and keeping this precept while rejecting the Sabbath is partial handling that makes appeal powerless.ST Jun 8, 1904ST Mar 10, 1881 Together they are the sum of all morality and the reflection of God's character, perfect and unchangeable, so that it is easier for heaven and earth to pass than for one tittle to fail, and they stand as the test of all voices and teachings.ST Jun 8, 1904
It stands on the same authority and permanence as the commands against adultery and for the Sabbath, spoken by the same God, so that breaking the Sabbath is sin just as killing is sin.RH May 23, 1854ST Nov 7, 1878ST Sep 27, 1883 God is as earnest about the command not to kill as about the fourth commandment, and all ten are fundamental law, the constitution of the moral world, binding on all people in every age and never abolished nor needing re-enactment after the resurrection.ST Sep 13, 1905ST Sep 27, 1883 The Sabbath command stands among the same enduring laws, and Sabbath-breaking could open the way to grave crimes including murder, though the death penalty once imposed on Sabbath-breakers belonged to Israel's temporary civil regulations, not to the permanent moral law.RH May 23, 1854
The papacy was permitted to control and alter the law for the prophetic period of 1260 years, and in its catechism the second commandment was struck out and the tenth divided to make a ninth repeating the seventh, while power was claimed to change the Sabbath from Saturday the seventh day to Sunday the first day without Scriptural authority.ST Jul 13, 1915RH Oct 30, 1856RH May 7, 1872RH Sep 29, 1863 This command remains unchanged in papal editions and is held in common by the biblical Decalogue and the papal version, yet the law as a whole was trampled by the little horn and is to be restored with high reverence by the remnant in the last days.RH Oct 30, 1856RH Jun 14, 1867RH Jan 8, 1857RH Apr 21, 1874 That restoration is associated with Sabbath reform, for the remnant keeps the unchangeable precepts spoken at Sinai and written on stone by God.RH Jun 14, 1867RH Jan 8, 1857
Narrowing the prohibition to the outward act of killing only is an evasion to defend Rome's change of times and laws by the man of sin.ST Sep 27, 1883 It always forbade hatred even in Old Testament times and was just as broad then as now, perfect for converting the soul and demanding a heart cleansed from every sinful desire, with Cain already a murderer before shedding blood.ST Sep 27, 1883 Jesus in Matthew 5 did not enlarge or diminish it or make it more or less than it ever had been, and to say hatred was once allowed would leave unconverted haters fit for heaven, which cannot be.ST Sep 27, 1883
Keeping this precept alone cannot distinguish whether a person intends to obey God or the papacy, since both laws contain this prohibition alike.ST Apr 22, 1880RH Jun 2, 1851ST Sep 17, 1874RH Apr 21, 1874 None of the precepts held in common can distinguish the two classes of worshipers; only action on a precept that has been changed distinguishes the worshiper of God who keeps it as God gave it from the follower of the changing power who keeps it as changed.RH Apr 21, 1874 The errors of interpretation in leaving out the second and dividing the tenth are distinct from the intentional change of thinking to change times and laws, which is found in the fourth commandment alone where change is expressly claimed.ST Sep 17, 1874RH Nov 6, 1913 The command therefore proves that the mark concerns the change made in the law of God.RH Apr 21, 1874
If the Sabbath could be changed every command could be changed, for treating the Sabbath command as changeable would give license to remove not from the command against killing and thereby permit murder, since God's law is not to be mutilated.RH Mar 7, 1854RH Nov 27, 1866ST Feb 13, 1901 Removing not would reverse its requirement, and to declare God does not mean what He says in the fourth commandment is to tell the hater of men that God does not mean what He says in the sixth, thus breaking down all moral restraint.RH Nov 27, 1866ST Feb 13, 1901 Its absence from the four prohibitions in Acts 15:24-29 does not set it aside, for not one of the ten is named there, and to argue that what the apostles did not repeat is abolished would make murder, swearing, lying, stealing and coveting lawful.ST Aug 30, 1877RH Oct 26, 1911ST Jun 3, 1875 The council rejected circumcision and the law of Moses as conditions of salvation, not the commandment against killing or other moral duties.ST Aug 30, 1877
Christ's warning about breaking even a least commandment and teaching others to do so applies to this commandment, showing it remains binding and must not be rejected as abolished.ST May 13, 1886RH Apr 7, 1851ST Mar 25, 1889 Those who teach the law abolished and keeping it a fall from grace logically teach that keeping this commandment is also wrong, that killing is no sin, and even that people must kill to secure favor, though professing abhorrence of murder, for contempt for law comes from hatred of the Sabbath and of all restraint.ST May 13, 1886 If the commandment were abolished without being given again by God there would be no law against that sin.RH Apr 7, 1851 Refraining from killing was obligatory from creation upon Adam and his descendants as inferred from Cain and Abel, so giving the law again on Sinai does not mean it was not binding before, and if moral obligation still endures and those commandments stand, the Sabbath stands with them.RH Sep 20, 1853RH Jun 28, 1864RH Oct 11, 1864
It stands among the Sinai commands in which the Sabbath is grounded on God's work of creation, a different reason and work from Israel's rest from bondage in Egypt.RH Aug 6, 1872ST Nov 25, 1880RH Feb 25, 1875 It belongs to the last six precepts on the second table teaching duty to neighbor, and its binding authority like that of the other moral precepts rests on God being Creator and Maker of heaven and earth as set forth in the fourth commandment and commemorated by the seventh-day Sabbath.RH Feb 25, 1875 What gives the Lord right to forbid killing is that He made all things, and the weekly Sabbath after six days labor is the appointed reminder of that creation work and of human obligation to the Maker, whose distinguishing attribute is creative power proving existence, power, authority and distinction from false gods.RH Feb 25, 1875ST Feb 11, 1875 The Sabbath precept is the seal to God's law without which the law would have no authority, so all other moral precepts depend for authority on the creation fact the Sabbath preserves.ST Feb 11, 1875
The written Decalogue containing it does not command Sunday-keeping, so the claim that disregarding Sunday tramples the Decalogue cannot be supported by the commandments' text, and pleading for Sunday observance as religious law is ruled out by God's constitution.ST Jul 3, 1884ST Jul 4, 1905 Teaching only a short selection of four commandments instead of the whole original law sets aside the authority of God's law, makes human beliefs and practices the standard of morality, and substitutes commandments of men under pretended divine sanction.RH Mar 30, 1905 It is part of the ten as God gave them and part of the principles of morality for staying lawlessness, and it cannot be omitted or amended to conform to human teachings.RH Mar 30, 1905
It belongs to the unchangeable Sinai precepts to be restored by the remnant in the last days after trampling, with Sabbath reform, and in the last generation a people arise who observe all ten and recognize the revival of the spirit of prophecy, as the remnant seed who keep the commandments and have the testimony of Jesus against whom the dragon makes war.RH Jun 14, 1867RH Jan 8, 1857RH Mar 8, 1870RH Aug 14, 1856 The predicted end-time controversy concerns restoring what was trodden underfoot, and those approved keep God's commandments and therefore do not claim the law abolished, with the Sabbath question discussed among believers after separation from the churches as preparation for the third angel's message calling to keep them all.RH Mar 8, 1870RH Aug 14, 1856RH Dec 18, 1855 Obeying it with the other commands is doing the Father's revealed will embodied in the one perfect moral code, still binding neither changed nor abolished, so that entering the kingdom requires doing and not merely saying Lord, Lord.ST Feb 24, 1887RH Jun 23, 1863RH Aug 18, 1863 Keeping this prohibition is part of keeping covenant and remembering commandments to do them, on which fulfillment of promises depends, that days may be prolonged and believers abide in God's tabernacle, holy hill, Christ's love and full joy, as Jesus kept His Father's commandments and calls to the same obedience.ST Oct 29, 1912
Denying it as part of denying God's law leaves men free to set up their own standard or accept public opinion, bearing fruit in teaching nothing fundamentally true or sacred and no commandments from God.RH Aug 26, 1909 The desire to escape seventh-day Sabbath obligation led to teaching the law abolished and men under grace not law, then to abolishing ten and re-enacting nine omitting the fourth.RH Aug 26, 1909 Attempts to discredit, change or set aside the Ten promote lawlessness toward destruction, and disregard for the Sabbath weakens respect for the whole law, inclining people to break any commandment conflicting with interest, while weakening authority encourages removal of restraint.RH Mar 9, 1905RH May 18, 1911ST Jul 22, 1886ST Mar 13, 1879ST Dec 29, 1887 Its observance urged under the Spirit's convicting power would help hold back lawlessness, to be taught in church and home not by the state, as the only sound basis for genuine morality in God's eternal unchangeable law.RH Mar 9, 1905
God's people remain faithful to its principles even when threatened with death for refusing to abandon the seventh-day Sabbath.RH Dec 3, 1901 Outward refraining from killing, lying and stealing from human and worldly motives does not mark obedience to God as Sabbath observance does, for many who care nothing for God or religion still will not openly kill to evade the law of the land and live in good society.ST Feb 27, 1893ST Sep 4, 1901ST Sep 6, 1899 Constant conscientious refraining from worldly work and amusements on the Sabbath does mark one who recognizes God's authority and seeks humbly to obey, while the law against killing, like the Sabbath, is religious and spiritual in nature, not purely secular utilitarian, meeting spiritual needs.ST Feb 27, 1893ST Sep 4, 1901 Unlike the fourth commandment about the Sabbath, it is not said to have been shifted from its original place or observance.ST Dec 2, 1880 New Testament lists mention duties like not killing while omitting the Sabbath because the Sabbath is a positive precept needing revelation, whereas killing has always been wrong and universally recognized as immoral, remembered without the special remember that guards the Sabbath broken through forgetfulness.RH Oct 10, 1854ST Aug 26, 1889RH Mar 20, 1866
Commentary part 3 of 4
Pioneers and periodicals (continued)
Core Prohibition Protecting Life
Thou shalt not kill forbids every person from taking another person's human life under any circumstances or provocation, for human life is sacred as God's gift continually dependent on Him, only the Giver has right and knowledge to withhold it, and no human power can restore it once taken by one rash act, so the command guards each neighbor's natural right to live and makes every person's life inviolate.ST Dec 16, 1908RH Jul 7, 1874RH May 23, 1907RH Sep 18, 1860 It stands in the numbered sequence as the sixth commandment, placed fifth in the Catholic list which omits the command against graven images and divides coveting into two, and knowing it makes the wrong clearer and increases responsibility because sin darkens the mind against rights.RH May 23, 1907RH Jul 9, 1857 It simply forbids murder and killing as the deliberate wanton taking of innocent human life, plainly wrong and needing no proof as violation of moral law, a crime and high crime belonging to the second table summed in love to man, distinct from local temporary legislation, unchangeable by legislation or civilization, not abolished by Christianity but continually quoted by Christ and the apostles.RH Oct 10, 1907ST Dec 6, 1883ST Feb 5, 1902RH Jul 15, 1875RH Mar 12, 1908 In Christ it is not only prohibition but enabling word giving power to obey, becoming law of liberty in which the obedient delight, and faithful obedience to it with the other precepts would end sin; it is no yoke to the honest and pure in heart.RH Oct 10, 1907RH Jul 15, 1875
It guards life, personal safety and right to life for all including wife, parent, child, the small and insignificant and all dear ones against the stronger, as moral foundation of civilization and first condition of society, revealing God as protector of life and requiring severe punishment for such murder as invading a dwelling to kill.ST Dec 16, 1908RH Jul 7, 1874RH May 23, 1907RH Sep 18, 1860 The word kill in itself includes taking life generally, but the verse does not forbid killing animals, birds, reptiles, insects or plants when necessary, nor killing an ox for market, nor destroying pests such as bedbugs, fleas and potato beetles, for its circumstances show it concerns duties toward other people.RH Mar 11, 1909ST May 20, 1908RH Apr 12, 1864ST Feb 5, 1902 Those who held otherwise taught that the sixth precept forbids slaughter of animals for food and requires abstinence from flesh meat, allowing destruction of inferior animals only in dire necessity where one's own life is at stake, because man's life is worth more than lower animals and life is more than meat.ST Oct 8, 1894
It forbids lying in wait to kill unsuspecting inoffensive persons with deadly weapons, assassination and revolution for pleasure, riches and honors, shooting others, dueling, killing an enemy in revenge even when the victim killed one's father, and everyday murders such as shooting a wife, stabbing a father or killing over opinion, and hearing it convicts the murderer with terror to confession and pardon while calling it obsolete leaves shooting, beating and swearing uncondemned.ST Jul 17, 1907ST Jan 1, 1894ST Aug 16, 1910ST Jan 13, 1887ST May 13, 1886 Its restraint removed would leave life unrespected, the strongest to take by violence and become richest, children to kill parents for corrupt desires, and the world a horde of robbers and assassins without peace, rest or happiness, with disobedience sowing disobedience and teaching release from it opening flood-gates of lawlessness, murder, fraud and robbery; the law is not to be reduced but men changed to meet it.ST Jul 17, 1907 It forbids not only killing with poison, pistol or knife but killing as surely if more slowly by conduct, as when a disobedient son kills parents by vileness of life or a husband kills his wife by coldness, brutality, unfaithfulness and intemperance, who are in every sense murderers, and it forbids conduct hastening another's death such as repeatedly serving harmful food even without ill will.ST Sep 17, 1902ST Oct 28, 1930 It forbids destroying the person made in God's image whether just begun and yet unborn or in full maturity, whether suddenly or gradually by act or intention, since human life as breath of God quickening His image is sacred from conception, condemning abortion by poison or instruments among educated rich as well as heathen drowning of newborns for birds and reptiles, deserving civil prison punishment and church reprimand without partiality to the respectable.ST Aug 25, 1887RH Jun 25, 1867ST Sep 10, 1885
It forbids eating blood and things strangled because blood is life, binding from the beginning and now, inconsistent with Christ's life as law in perfection.ST Dec 12, 1892 Withholding the gospel so people die for want of spiritual knowledge, leaving a wounded person to die when one can care for him even if an enemy, and excusing failure to make effort to keep someone alive, also transgress it, for it requires love seeking another's good beyond refraining from injury.RH Jan 8, 1867RH Feb 20, 1900ST May 12, 1881 It guards the joy of living, given by the Father as absolutely necessary to happiness and life in His family, whose disregard would be fatal to all intelligent beings in heaven and earth, unchangeable everywhere and abolished only by writing its love inwardly so one pleases to do only what it requires, Christ thus its end for righteousness to believers for perfect liberty.ST Sep 13, 1899 It forbids taking human life including ending a patient's life on mercy grounds, since men cannot know incurability or greater good nor restore life, and assuming authority to kill under circumstances usurps God.ST Nov 8, 1899
Even an accidental blow nearly causing death can make one fear becoming a murderer despite lack of intent, showing its gravity for conscience.ST Nov 13, 1893 It is no obstacle or contrary to an innocent person but applies against one who has murder in heart or is actually a murderer, remaining binding when anger tempts as with hand on revolver, where calling it bondage resists it and love brings willing obedience; its requirements are safe rule for the narrow way, not opposed to gospel salvation but expected with looking to Jesus.ST Feb 4, 1886RH Jun 10, 1852ST Feb 4, 1886ST Nov 20, 1893 Refraining from killing is part of perfect conformity under moral government, while killing violates moral law.ST Feb 4, 1886ST Mar 17, 1914 It is one of eight prohibitions, the other two requiring honor to Sabbath and parents, meant for all time and classes; breaking it is sin as transgression of law, a grave sin of commission like theft, adultery and perjury justly met by civil and church penalties, and included among sins bringing curse for withholding the Lord's due.ST Jun 19, 1884RH Apr 27, 1905
It forbids taking lives for differences of belief as murder bringing guilt, awakening individual accountability to God and questioning secular killing for faith, pressing full claims against religious coercion, church-state union, enforcing worship by sovereign or majority, silencing dissent, and wars of religion as continued medieval intolerance, since faith has value only when free and others' opinions must be borne.ST May 28, 1912ST Aug 18, 1909 It is one of only three Decalogue precepts repeated word for word in the New Testament, though lack of verbatim repetition does not release from keeping any precept.ST Apr 19, 1877 It establishes murder and adultery as morally wrong so that claiming a right to them corrupts judgment, presenting absolute standards not changeable conventions, with covetousness as grave as murder and right and wrong as real distinctions.RH May 9, 1871ST Aug 16, 1910RH Oct 19, 1916ST Jul 17, 1879 Following Scripture literally does not lead to violating it, for the Pocasset murder came from personal impressions in disregard of its plain precept, not from obeying the Bible.ST Jun 19, 1879
Urging stoning of those who teach obedience to God's commandments contradicts it and conflicts with its prohibition, while blaming others or claiming beguilement does not excuse transgression.ST Mar 4, 1875RH Feb 18, 1875ST Jun 10, 1889 Killing is moral wrong unjustifiable by pressure or circumstances, as harvesting on Sabbath cannot be so excused.RH Jul 2, 1861 It addresses each person as individual duty, not merely rule for society.ST Aug 5, 1913 Murder is prohibited totally every day, not only Sunday or holidays, so limiting prohibition weakens law; likewise liquor traffic making criminals like murder and theft must be totally prohibited all days rather than merely closed Sunday which legalizes evil other days, for destroying life remains wrong every day not only on sacred day.RH Jan 27, 1910ST Oct 17, 1900 Violating it in hope of gaining the victim's property is crime for illusory reward with no lasting gain, since sin earns death.RH Feb 24, 1874ST Mar 11, 1880
Taking a neighbor's life violates God's law and is a form of theft depriving him of what is rightfully his, coming under the law's cutting-off penalty for willful transgression requiring strict obedience.ST May 31, 1910ST Oct 22, 1902 It rules out killing to gain mastery, condemning rulership by crushing others and war as toll of ambition for dominion, against God's purpose shown in Christ's service, with eternal victory for those awaiting God's restoration. It forbids taking another's life for perishable or imperishable gain, vengeance belonging to God and enemies to be fed not revenged.ST Mar 31, 1898 Its prohibition rules out taking life even claiming death brings heavenly bliss, for treating death as call to Jesus cannot make killing children or righteous right, and the Ten are not abolished.ST Nov 16, 1882 Avoiding harm outweighs social etiquette, so regard for comfort and dignity must not yield to custom, and breaking it is far graver than table breach like lifting knife instead of fork to lips.ST Nov 26, 1912ST Dec 13, 1883
Heart Motive and Spirit
Thou shalt not kill reaches beyond the outward deed of taking life to the desire, thoughts, principles and motives that lead to it, condemning anger, hatred, malice, envy, pride and revenge and requiring a right heart conformed to love after the example of Jesus.ST May 13, 1897ST Dec 15, 1898ST Nov 13, 1893 Right desires would keep a person from killing, while uncontrolled temper and desire to kill make guilty before God whether or not the act was planned.ST Nov 13, 1893 The command uproots sin to its innermost cause, condemning the desire to harm that precedes the act and judging, condemning and speaking evil of others, for all death is contrary to God's will.ST Dec 15, 1898 It forbids murder in outward deed and in heart motive and requires love to neighbor as self, doing to others as one would have them do, as one precept of Exodus 20:1-17 to be kept whole and enshrined in the heart.
Anger without cause is subject to judgment, hatred of a brother is murder, and malice and revenge are murder in source, while righteous indignation at God's dishonor or oppression is not sinful.ST May 13, 1897ST Dec 15, 1898ST Nov 13, 1893 Those who keep this with the rest of the commandments are pure in heart to see God and have right to the tree of life and entrance through the gates into the city to immortal life, while murderers are left without. It always forbade hatred even in Old Testament times and was just as broad then as now, for Cain was already a murderer before he shed his brother's blood.ST Sep 27, 1883 To say hatred was once allowed would leave unconverted haters fit for heaven, which cannot be, for the law was perfect for converting the soul and demanded a heart cleansed from every sinful desire.ST Sep 27, 1883
Jesus in Matthew 5 did not make the command more or less than it ever had been, did not enlarge or diminish it, but magnified it and made it honorable by making its spiritual depth clear and giving it broad spiritual application to the thoughts and intents of the heart.RH May 17, 1864RH Apr 3, 1879ST Sep 27, 1883 Anger is related to murder as its root, must precede murder, and cherishing anger must be broken before murder can follow.RH Apr 3, 1879 His teaching on murder raises the standard rather than repealing or weakening it, for the gospel spiritualizes and perfects the moral law, strengthening obligation as a rule of life revealing duty and forbidding sin.RH Mar 10, 1859RH Jan 1, 1861 Narrowing the command to the outward act is an evasion to defend the change of the Sabbath and of times and laws by Rome.ST Sep 27, 1883 Nor can Matthew 5 be a new code replacing it, since that would place the new enactment three and a half years before the abolition of the old and would refer to at most three of the ten and therefore be incomplete.RH May 17, 1864
Keeping the letter without the spirit is not keeping it, for outward conformity alone is not obedience, and the command must be kept spiritually in both letter and spirit.RH Jan 27, 1916RH Feb 17, 1859ST Jun 9, 1890ST Sep 18, 1893 Its spirit forbids hating a brother, so one who hates without killing breaks it in spirit and is a murderer in spirit.ST May 9, 1878 Yet keeping the spirit never excuses breaking the letter, so one who willingly kills cannot claim still to keep it in spirit, and letter obedience is needed for its spirit.ST May 9, 1878 The law governs the heart as well as outward conduct, directing the spirit in its outward actions, for human life is sacred and must be treated with due regard.ST Jun 9, 1890 The question about keeping the spirit as well as the letter therefore calls for obedience to the intent, not merely the wording.RH Jan 27, 1916
Evil-speaking, judging, condemning, hateful words, reproachful names, variance, strife, quarrel, envy, unkind words and selfishness violate it, and reconciliation must precede worship.ST Dec 15, 1898ST Jul 1, 1889 Hatred, envy, unkind words, reproachful names, and thoughts or desires leading toward the crime also violate it, as one of the Ten expressing love toward others and reaching into thoughts and purposes of the heart.ST Jul 1, 1889 Its positive meaning is to do good, preserve life, value and guard a neighbor's life as one's own, using opportunities to increase one another's comfort and happiness rather than merely refraining from harm.ST Oct 6, 1887ST Aug 24, 1882 God protects every person's life by expressly forbidding killing, safeguarding not only one's own life but the lives of loved ones, with serious punishment rightly following murder.ST Oct 6, 1887ST Aug 24, 1882 Fulfilled by love it requires active unselfish concern illustrated by Jesus' life of doing good, and is fulfilled not merely by outward obedience but by love established in the heart.ST Jan 30, 1901RH Jan 26, 1905
The prohibition reflects the presence of sin, while teaching the enduring principle of protecting life, and obedience would prevent crimes with their imprisonment and executions and help preserve peace and happiness.ST May 13, 1897ST Feb 8, 1905 Those who held the narrower view taught that it requires only refraining from killing as one of eight negative duties, with Sabbath-keeping and honoring parents as the only two positive duties, meaning not doing the act but not commanding positive love.RH Jan 31, 1854 On that view a person could refrain from killing, idolatry, profanity, stealing, adultery, false witness and covetousness while keeping the Sabbath and honoring parents, and still knowingly leave a next-door neighbor to starve and freeze while having plenty, so keeping it would not fulfill the royal law of loving neighbor as self.RH Jan 31, 1854 On that same view Adam could have obeyed this and every other one of the ten and still have become a sinner by breaking God's earlier law in Eden, showing sin and death entered not by transgressing this code two thousand years before it was given.RH Jan 31, 1854
Every premeditated taking of life is rooted in coveting, for no forethought murder happens without coveting money, wealth, place, reputation or power to inflict vengeance, so violation begins with a covetous heart longing for what it does not have.ST Aug 2, 1905ST Feb 5, 1902 The tenth commandment thus interlinks with this, secret unlawful desire leading to murder.ST Aug 2, 1905ST Feb 5, 1902 The verse also reaches beyond physical death, as shown when Adam and Eve broke it in Eden by eating and thereby killed themselves and the whole family, by whose trespass the many died.RH May 16, 1907 Unrepented sin causes the sinner to die the second death and drags down to perdition some soul whom he might have influenced to eternal life, for none lives or dies to himself.RH May 16, 1907
By implication it requires the opposite positive duty and forbids lesser faults of the same kind, calling for avoiding occasions and temptations to kill, not encouraging others to do so, and restraining them when possible.RH Feb 20, 1872 It forbids helping another break it, as lending a weapon to a murderer would provide the means for violation. Keeping it means more than refraining from taking life; it means not to hate, because to hate is to kill, requiring humane conduct and freedom from hatred through submission to God by faith.RH Mar 14, 1907RH Feb 26, 1914ST Jan 21, 1886 Cherishing envy, hatred and enmity breaks it as truly as actual murder, so it must be obeyed outwardly and from the heart.ST Jan 21, 1886 Read through the life of Jesus Christ and the principle of love as God's purpose for life, it becomes true by saying to God to make it true while cooperating with Him, through whose grace He keeps from hate by keeping in perfect peace, making the holy law life in character by faith which thus establishes the law.RH Mar 14, 1907
It covers a variety of sins and wrongs beyond open killing, magnified with the seventh in Matthew 5:17-37 to show breaches that would never have been discovered without inspiration.RH Sep 27, 1864 This magnifying makes the law honorable and provides the pattern for understanding His teaching on swearing as magnification of the third commandment.RH Sep 27, 1864
Health Self and Neighbor
Thou shalt not kill forbids taking one's own life, for suicide is murder that despises God's gift of life and rebels directly against His authority, whether driven by despair, fear of suffering or disgrace, or any other cause, whether by shooting, poisoning, drowning, starving, or by a prisoner seeking to avoid a certain death sentence, and to permit it or to teach that suicide is no sin annuls a commandment that is eternal and unchangeable.RH Jun 23, 1868RH Dec 20, 1853ST Sep 24, 1912 The same prohibition reaches drinking whisky as murdering oneself and wilfully starving oneself as self-murder, binding across all ages as Cain's act and these acts violate the same unchanging law.ST Dec 15, 1898ST Sep 24, 1912 It also forbids defeating the law of nature, which men commit without knowing it while conscience is scarcely stirred because fashion has made the sin common and sophistry has filed off its sharp edges, so the sin must be plainly named as murder with commandment and breach laid side by side until conscience is torn and smitten and the humbled soul looks to Christ as Saviour from sin and not as minister of sin.RH Feb 21, 1871 Obedience includes living in harmony with the natural laws God established, and violating those laws through depraved appetite and lustful passions is disobedience to God and contributes to the disease afflicting the world.RH Mar 6, 1913
Destroying health and shortening life by unnecessary indulgence is killing and is sin against God, including drinking intoxicating drinks, smoking and chewing tobacco, using opium, tea, coffee and other stimulants, tight dressing, unwholesome food, intemperate eating, overeating, overwork, sexual excess and other harmful habits and excesses that weaken body and mind, impair health, rapidly destroy life, shorten the average length of human life, impair the vitality of children born, and cause unhappiness, suffering, poverty and discomfort.ST May 6, 1889RH Nov 3, 1874RH Mar 17, 1863RH Mar 13, 1866RH Dec 2, 1873 Knowingly using tea or tobacco when they are known to injure health violates the commandment, for harming one's own health is contrary to not killing, and those professing respect for all of God's commandments must lay aside what harms the body.RH Mar 17, 1863RH Mar 13, 1866ST Oct 29, 1885 Tobacco is a powerful poison destroying vital force and the functions needed for healthy life, whose temporary stimulation and soothing comes at the cost of life and health, and using it so as to weaken health and shorten life amounts to suicide in a constructive sense.RH Nov 3, 1874ST Oct 29, 1885 Using stimulants, poisons, or things contrary to nature that tear down rather than build up the body violates the commandment, especially when a person has learned the truth about their effects.RH Jul 2, 1867
The prohibition also forbids harming others by those habits, including bringing wretchedness and sorrow on wife, children and neighbor through drink, polluting the air that wife, child, friends, neighbors and strangers must breathe with tobacco smoke that can even destroy the life of infants, and by tight dressing preventing development of the body, displacing organs, producing deformity, and making women unable to bear well-developed healthy children and nurse them successfully.ST May 6, 1889 The liquor traffic deliberately brings death through accidents, disease and ruin, and belongs under the same condemnation of destroying life.ST May 6, 1889
The commandment requires preserving health and prolonging life by every proper means, for knowingly and carelessly causing sickness by violating health laws is sinful, and habits of eating, drinking, and laboring that damage the body and bring disease or premature death, including overeating and overwork causing premature death, are forbidden.RH Jul 2, 1867RH Feb 26, 1867ST Dec 15, 1898 Natural and physical laws are God's laws as truly as the Decalogue, so violating them is sin and disobedience to God.RH Feb 26, 1867RH Mar 6, 1913 Taking into the body what injures it transgresses whether the harm comes from a dose of poison that kills quickly or from smaller doses repeatedly taken, as with moderate drinking.ST Jun 10, 1908 To defile the body, to make it strengthless and diseased by indulgence of appetite and passion for tobacco, liquor, or any hurtful thing, to enfeeble body, nerves, brain and judgment and become a health-destroyer and self-made invalid, is to break the commandment, for the body is God's property by creation and by redemption and is His temple to be consecrated to His service.ST Apr 4, 1900 Those who keep themselves from the defilement of appetite and passion keep the commandment, become partakers of the divine nature, keep clear perceptions, preserve every faculty in health to present to God in service, and can be used by Him.ST Apr 4, 1900
Its principle also requires preventing preventable death as far as lies in human power, so failing to prevent tuberculosis when it is a preventable disease violates it.RH Apr 7, 1910 It forbids drunkenness and all other sins against bodily life and welfare, so no added commandment against drunkenness is needed, and drunkenness is also a fruitful source of sins that break this commandment and the seventh commandment.RH Mar 31, 1910 God may show mercy to people who break His law without understanding its true character, but growing light about the law calls people to prepare characters fit for citizenship in His kingdom.RH Jul 2, 1867ST Dec 15, 1898 Keeping the commandment also fulfills duty to self, securing self-support, self-defense, self-control, and self-culture, because failing to support oneself takes support wrongfully from others, failing to control oneself leads to sin against others, and failing to train body, mind, and heart prevents proper service in society.ST Jun 23, 1887
Government War and Exceptions
The general prohibition is not broken by carrying out a judicial sentence at God's command when Israel was a theocracy under God as King, where people acted only as God's agents and executors of His will with responsibility assumed by Him through prophet or priest, as in putting to death one who entices to other gods under Deuteronomy 13:6-9, executing the Sabbath-breaker under Numbers 15:32-36, and destroying the Canaanites, which was obedience not murder, so that sparing what God commanded to destroy brought rebuke and punishment, and such actions must be weighed by motives, circumstances and instruction given rather than taken as permission for murder.ST Apr 9, 1912RH Aug 27, 1857RH Oct 21, 1862RH Oct 21, 1862
God as King could order the death of persons or nations as judgment directly or through human agents without violating an immutable precept, when wickedness was complete and nations had rejected saving truth and become identified with sin, receiving the wages of sin, with mercy still open to the truly repentant.ST Mar 20, 1901RH Apr 6, 1916 Such judgments could warn future generations that sin leads to death, protect those who might otherwise be led into deeper depravity, bring recognition to God, and in the case of deeply corrupt nations like the Canaanites act in mercy to prevent further crime and vice, carried out in the wisest and most loving way consistent with character, needs and free will, though human agents might limit or distort the work without their sins being charged to Him.ST Mar 20, 1901RH Apr 6, 1916 All life comes from God as a trust for humanity's eternal good, so His taking of life is not violation of His own law against wrongful taking of human life.RH Apr 6, 1916
The prescribed penalty for wilful premeditated murder distinct from accident is death, shown by the cities of refuge, and government ordained by God to punish wrongdoing in executing a murderer convicted beyond question inflicts the penalty for violating the commandment rather than violating it, and restrains future crime.RH Mar 7, 1871 Every person's life is made inviolate, guarding wife, parent, child and all dear lives, so that invading a dwelling to murder ought to receive severe punishment, revealing God as protector of life, and wanton violators who fear neither God nor punishment beyond the grave when the command is enacted as civil statute are hanged by the neck until dead.RH Sep 18, 1860ST Apr 1, 1897 Human governments do not make murder wrong but punish it because it is wrong, and the commandment incorporated into Israel's civil law assigned death as civil penalty punishing the offender as violator of the commonwealth, leaving him still to answer to God at judgment, with the precept binding Gentiles as well as Jews and enduring after special local laws ended.ST Jun 12, 1879RH Mar 7, 1871 The sacredness of human life as God's breath quickening His image is not set aside by death as penalty under Moses, by civil statutes taking the lives of wanton destroyers of life, or by self-protection even when it requires taking life, for rights and duties do not conflict, though limits must be jealously guarded in true reverence for man.ST Aug 25, 1887
Civil law addresses only the outward deed to repress incivility, repress crime, conserve civil rights and protect rights, and would be recognized as necessary even where God is not known, while the commandment is wholly spiritual belonging to the inner life and forbidding motive, thought, hatred and unrighteous anger, so that one who hates his brother is a murderer in God's sight even without taking life.ST Dec 24, 1912ST Jul 18, 1900 A civil law may use the same words and forbid the same outward act without making the command merely civil, and civil law cannot remove inward guilt or make people moral but can only suppress and punish the outward act.ST Mar 17, 1887ST Aug 6, 1912 The civil penalty attached in Israel's theocratic government ceased with that government without abolishing the moral commandment, and violations not recognized or punished by human law remain forbidden as interpreted in the New Testament.RH Mar 26, 1872
War is murder even when only one is killed, and no glossing or disguising changes that, for war is right only if murder is right and wrong if murder is wrong, defying the command through national slaughter repeated generation to generation, killing even those bound by family, as the bitter end of contentious tempers begun in childhood for which instigators bear responsibility.RH Aug 28, 1900RH Feb 27, 1900ST Jan 9, 1901 Firing on an enemy in war is disobedience to the command, patriotism can deceive people into violating it by encouraging killing, and the command stands as infinite standard thundering unmodified down the ages as long as time lasts, calling to follow the Prince of Peace toward the coming age when war and hate cease rather than Mars and Moloch for greed, conquest, wrong and butchery.RH Apr 14, 1903ST Apr 9, 1902 Those who hold this therefore teach that Christians must refuse arms, seek service that saves life such as the medical corps rather than deliberately destroying life, refuse to support soldiers and warfare by voluntary offerings while teaching the commandment, and accept martyrdom rather than kill when drafted.RH Aug 28, 1900RH Oct 2, 1900
Those who held otherwise teach that the verse does not forbid all killing in war, does not by itself rule out taking life in a just war, and is consistent with God's commands to Israel to wage war, inflict capital punishment, and the magistrate's bearing the sword as God's minister to punish wrongdoing.RH Oct 21, 1862RH Oct 14, 1862 Defensive war to protect government and people's rights and lawful government against rebellion or invasion is held not to be murder, as shown by Abraham who kept God's commandments yet fought to rescue Lot and defend allies and was blessed as God's servant, and by Michael the Prince of Peace leading holy angels to protect God's government against rebels without violating the commandment kept by Christ and by angels that do His commandments.RH Oct 14, 1862RH Oct 28, 1862 Paid military service is held to remain open, since soldiers told to be content with wages are still soldiers and soldiers refusing to fight when required would earn no pay, with no command to drafted soldiers to resist authorities, risk death or prison and go home, though volunteering for an unjust war like Herod's war to keep his brother's wife or a war to maintain slavery is wrong, and killing enemies who began hostilities and first shed blood was not regarded as violation under the rule that shed blood requires blood.RH Sep 30, 1862RH Dec 16, 1862
Military service requires implicit unquestioning obedience to the commanding officer regardless of the commandment, putting the officer in God's place between soldier and God, so one unwilling to let man come between must stay out of the army. The holy ten lay binding duty above commanders' orders, to be obeyed even when disobedience brings punishment and imprisonment, as faithfulness to One higher in the patience of the saints and ground for witness by word, deed and publications before officers and fellow soldiers.RH Sep 26, 1907 Being drafted places a person under government's responsibility for violating the command, while resisting military law until shot takes responsibility for suicide.RH Aug 12, 1862
A civil statute commanding murder is unjust, binds no one, and should be repealed rather than enforced, for God's law is higher than human law, and the express command must not be disregarded or violated under compulsion of national law.ST Jun 10, 1886RH Jun 8, 1916 Civil laws protecting life may exist independently of religion or knowledge of the Decalogue, and enforcing them is distinct from compelling love or religious observance, with authority over religious questions remaining between soul and God rather than civil government.ST Sep 24, 1894ST Oct 16, 1893 Killing was understood to be forbidden, so that Abraham at first doubted the command to slay Isaac as possible deception since God would not command what He had forbidden, before conviction that the command was genuine and trust that God could raise Isaac and fulfill promises through him, while the prohibition was also used to tempt him to doubt on the ground God would not require what He had once forbidden.ST Apr 1, 1875ST Apr 3, 1879AUST Jun 14, 1920
The commandment was claimed to support the civil magistrate as preserver of both tables entitled to punish all breaches of both, compelling subjects by penalty to hear for instruction and conversion and punishing further refusal to join the church, joining Bible with sword to preserve uniformity by violent repression.RH Jul 2, 1908 Exodus 20:1-17 was made supreme law and cornerstone of government in Massachusetts Bay with the Bible as statute-book and church dominating civil power, making breaches concerning parents, false worship, adultery and covetousness alike capital, while the command not to kill did not protect Indians identified as Canaan, Amalekites, Amorites and Philistines worthy only of death.ST Jul 26, 1899 By contrast the command belongs to the second table of the last six defining duties and rights between people which people may require of one another and which belong to the proper field of civil legislation over outward acts, distinguished from duties owed to God which no person may enforce or use civil power to compel.ST Jan 6, 1887ST Feb 17, 1914ST Nov 11, 1889 Disagreement over the binding prohibition against murder does not remove the state's duty to legislate against it, and claimed religious duty does not make murder lawful or exempt, for government must uphold the second table.RH May 17, 1870ST Jan 5, 1882
The destruction of the enemy fleet and deaths of hundreds at Manila Bay raise the question whether killing in a claimed victory is more wicked and dishonoring to God than fleeing to save life.ST Aug 25, 1898 Civil governments may regulate murder, theft, adultery and injury to reputation for safety and protection even without following God, without thereby becoming agents enforcing spiritual law, and belief in the ten does not mean every commandment should be civilly enforced, stealing being properly legislated in contrast to Sunday observance.ST Oct 23, 1893ST Sep 2, 1889 The state has no authority to exempt anyone from obeying the command against murder as God's command, nor did God submit what He spoke to popular vote or hand authority over it to people or civil power to enforce or change without bringing doom.RH Mar 1, 1906ST Nov 28, 1895 It stands on record as ethical commandment remaining in force until repealed by record, and no record of repeal exists, so it is still binding.RH Nov 24, 1910
Unity Sabbath and Wholeness
The prohibition of killing belongs to a single unbroken chain of ten, so that to violate it is to become a transgressor of the whole law and guilty of all, because offense against one precept is offense against the authority that gave them all.ST Oct 22, 1874ST Jun 12, 1907ST Nov 3, 1914RH Jun 2, 1851ST Nov 7, 1878 Keeping it therefore requires keeping all ten together, and keeping all but this one still leaves guilt, since the law remains whole only as each distinct point remains binding.RH Oct 27, 1868ST Nov 3, 1914RH Jun 2, 1874 It is the sixth commandment of the Decalogue spoken by Jehovah alongside the Sabbath, defining duty to neighbor within the same royal law and law of liberty by which Christians are judged.ST Oct 22, 1874ST Jun 12, 1907RH Jun 2, 1851 That law is unalterable and perpetuated to the end of the gospel dispensation, coeval and coextensive with eternity, giving right to the tree of life and entrance through the gates into the city when Jesus comes to those who keep the whole duty of man.RH Oct 27, 1868RH May 7, 1872
It is inseparably bound with the fourth commandment and the Sabbath, so that an argument against the Sabbath strikes with equal force against it and against the Decalogue itself.ST Jul 29, 1913ST Jul 27, 1882ST Mar 18, 1875 To admit continuing obligation not to kill while denying continuing obligation to observe the Sabbath day of the Decalogue is faulty logic, for its principle still exists and still binds now exactly as when the law was in force, and setting aside the set form of the ten did not release from the duty it enjoins.ST Nov 13, 1879ST Mar 10, 1881 Denying the continuing authority of the fourth commandment undermines the claim that the Ten as a whole have supreme authority, and keeping this precept while rejecting the Sabbath is partial handling that makes appeal powerless.ST Jun 8, 1904ST Mar 10, 1881 Together they are the sum of all morality and the reflection of God's character, perfect and unchangeable, so that it is easier for heaven and earth to pass than for one tittle to fail, and they stand as the test of all voices and teachings.ST Jun 8, 1904
It stands on the same authority and permanence as the commands against adultery and for the Sabbath, spoken by the same God, so that breaking the Sabbath is sin just as killing is sin.RH May 23, 1854ST Nov 7, 1878ST Sep 27, 1883 God is as earnest about the command not to kill as about the fourth commandment, and all ten are fundamental law, the constitution of the moral world, binding on all people in every age and never abolished nor needing re-enactment after the resurrection.ST Sep 13, 1905ST Sep 27, 1883 The Sabbath command stands among the same enduring laws, and Sabbath-breaking could open the way to grave crimes including murder, though the death penalty once imposed on Sabbath-breakers belonged to Israel's temporary civil regulations, not to the permanent moral law.RH May 23, 1854
The papacy was permitted to control and alter the law for the prophetic period of 1260 years, and in its catechism the second commandment was struck out and the tenth divided to make a ninth repeating the seventh, while power was claimed to change the Sabbath from Saturday the seventh day to Sunday the first day without Scriptural authority.ST Jul 13, 1915RH Oct 30, 1856RH May 7, 1872RH Sep 29, 1863 This command remains unchanged in papal editions and is held in common by the biblical Decalogue and the papal version, yet the law as a whole was trampled by the little horn and is to be restored with high reverence by the remnant in the last days.RH Oct 30, 1856RH Jun 14, 1867RH Jan 8, 1857RH Apr 21, 1874 That restoration is associated with Sabbath reform, for the remnant keeps the unchangeable precepts spoken at Sinai and written on stone by God.RH Jun 14, 1867RH Jan 8, 1857
Narrowing the prohibition to the outward act of killing only is an evasion to defend Rome's change of times and laws by the man of sin.ST Sep 27, 1883 It always forbade hatred even in Old Testament times and was just as broad then as now, perfect for converting the soul and demanding a heart cleansed from every sinful desire, with Cain already a murderer before shedding blood.ST Sep 27, 1883 Jesus in Matthew 5 did not enlarge or diminish it or make it more or less than it ever had been, and to say hatred was once allowed would leave unconverted haters fit for heaven, which cannot be.ST Sep 27, 1883
Keeping this precept alone cannot distinguish whether a person intends to obey God or the papacy, since both laws contain this prohibition alike.ST Apr 22, 1880RH Jun 2, 1851ST Sep 17, 1874RH Apr 21, 1874 None of the precepts held in common can distinguish the two classes of worshipers; only action on a precept that has been changed distinguishes the worshiper of God who keeps it as God gave it from the follower of the changing power who keeps it as changed.RH Apr 21, 1874 The errors of interpretation in leaving out the second and dividing the tenth are distinct from the intentional change of thinking to change times and laws, which is found in the fourth commandment alone where change is expressly claimed.ST Sep 17, 1874RH Nov 6, 1913 The command therefore proves that the mark concerns the change made in the law of God.RH Apr 21, 1874
If the Sabbath could be changed every command could be changed, for treating the Sabbath command as changeable would give license to remove not from the command against killing and thereby permit murder, since God's law is not to be mutilated.RH Mar 7, 1854RH Nov 27, 1866ST Feb 13, 1901 Removing not would reverse its requirement, and to declare God does not mean what He says in the fourth commandment is to tell the hater of men that God does not mean what He says in the sixth, thus breaking down all moral restraint.RH Nov 27, 1866ST Feb 13, 1901 Its absence from the four prohibitions in Acts 15:24-29 does not set it aside, for not one of the ten is named there, and to argue that what the apostles did not repeat is abolished would make murder, swearing, lying, stealing and coveting lawful.ST Aug 30, 1877RH Oct 26, 1911ST Jun 3, 1875 The council rejected circumcision and the law of Moses as conditions of salvation, not the commandment against killing or other moral duties.ST Aug 30, 1877
Christ's warning about breaking even a least commandment and teaching others to do so applies to this commandment, showing it remains binding and must not be rejected as abolished.ST May 13, 1886RH Apr 7, 1851ST Mar 25, 1889 Those who teach the law abolished and keeping it a fall from grace logically teach that keeping this commandment is also wrong, that killing is no sin, and even that people must kill to secure favor, though professing abhorrence of murder, for contempt for law comes from hatred of the Sabbath and of all restraint.ST May 13, 1886 If the commandment were abolished without being given again by God there would be no law against that sin.RH Apr 7, 1851 Refraining from killing was obligatory from creation upon Adam and his descendants as inferred from Cain and Abel, so giving the law again on Sinai does not mean it was not binding before, and if moral obligation still endures and those commandments stand, the Sabbath stands with them.RH Sep 20, 1853RH Jun 28, 1864RH Oct 11, 1864
It stands among the Sinai commands in which the Sabbath is grounded on God's work of creation, a different reason and work from Israel's rest from bondage in Egypt.RH Aug 6, 1872ST Nov 25, 1880RH Feb 25, 1875 It belongs to the last six precepts on the second table teaching duty to neighbor, and its binding authority like that of the other moral precepts rests on God being Creator and Maker of heaven and earth as set forth in the fourth commandment and commemorated by the seventh-day Sabbath.RH Feb 25, 1875 What gives the Lord right to forbid killing is that He made all things, and the weekly Sabbath after six days labor is the appointed reminder of that creation work and of human obligation to the Maker, whose distinguishing attribute is creative power proving existence, power, authority and distinction from false gods.RH Feb 25, 1875ST Feb 11, 1875 The Sabbath precept is the seal to God's law without which the law would have no authority, so all other moral precepts depend for authority on the creation fact the Sabbath preserves.ST Feb 11, 1875
The written Decalogue containing it does not command Sunday-keeping, so the claim that disregarding Sunday tramples the Decalogue cannot be supported by the commandments' text, and pleading for Sunday observance as religious law is ruled out by God's constitution.ST Jul 3, 1884ST Jul 4, 1905 Teaching only a short selection of four commandments instead of the whole original law sets aside the authority of God's law, makes human beliefs and practices the standard of morality, and substitutes commandments of men under pretended divine sanction.RH Mar 30, 1905 It is part of the ten as God gave them and part of the principles of morality for staying lawlessness, and it cannot be omitted or amended to conform to human teachings.RH Mar 30, 1905
It belongs to the unchangeable Sinai precepts to be restored by the remnant in the last days after trampling, with Sabbath reform, and in the last generation a people arise who observe all ten and recognize the revival of the spirit of prophecy, as the remnant seed who keep the commandments and have the testimony of Jesus against whom the dragon makes war.RH Jun 14, 1867RH Jan 8, 1857RH Mar 8, 1870RH Aug 14, 1856 The predicted end-time controversy concerns restoring what was trodden underfoot, and those approved keep God's commandments and therefore do not claim the law abolished, with the Sabbath question discussed among believers after separation from the churches as preparation for the third angel's message calling to keep them all.RH Mar 8, 1870RH Aug 14, 1856RH Dec 18, 1855 Obeying it with the other commands is doing the Father's revealed will embodied in the one perfect moral code, still binding neither changed nor abolished, so that entering the kingdom requires doing and not merely saying Lord, Lord.ST Feb 24, 1887RH Jun 23, 1863RH Aug 18, 1863 Keeping this prohibition is part of keeping covenant and remembering commandments to do them, on which fulfillment of promises depends, that days may be prolonged and believers abide in God's tabernacle, holy hill, Christ's love and full joy, as Jesus kept His Father's commandments and calls to the same obedience.ST Oct 29, 1912
Denying it as part of denying God's law leaves men free to set up their own standard or accept public opinion, bearing fruit in teaching nothing fundamentally true or sacred and no commandments from God.RH Aug 26, 1909 The desire to escape seventh-day Sabbath obligation led to teaching the law abolished and men under grace not law, then to abolishing ten and re-enacting nine omitting the fourth.RH Aug 26, 1909 Attempts to discredit, change or set aside the Ten promote lawlessness toward destruction, and disregard for the Sabbath weakens respect for the whole law, inclining people to break any commandment conflicting with interest, while weakening authority encourages removal of restraint.RH Mar 9, 1905RH May 18, 1911ST Jul 22, 1886ST Mar 13, 1879ST Dec 29, 1887 Its observance urged under the Spirit's convicting power would help hold back lawlessness, to be taught in church and home not by the state, as the only sound basis for genuine morality in God's eternal unchangeable law.RH Mar 9, 1905
God's people remain faithful to its principles even when threatened with death for refusing to abandon the seventh-day Sabbath.RH Dec 3, 1901 Outward refraining from killing, lying and stealing from human and worldly motives does not mark obedience to God as Sabbath observance does, for many who care nothing for God or religion still will not openly kill to evade the law of the land and live in good society.ST Feb 27, 1893ST Sep 4, 1901ST Sep 6, 1899 Constant conscientious refraining from worldly work and amusements on the Sabbath does mark one who recognizes God's authority and seeks humbly to obey, while the law against killing, like the Sabbath, is religious and spiritual in nature, not purely secular utilitarian, meeting spiritual needs.ST Feb 27, 1893ST Sep 4, 1901 Unlike the fourth commandment about the Sabbath, it is not said to have been shifted from its original place or observance.ST Dec 2, 1880 New Testament lists mention duties like not killing while omitting the Sabbath because the Sabbath is a positive precept needing revelation, whereas killing has always been wrong and universally recognized as immoral, remembered without the special remember that guards the Sabbath broken through forgetfulness.RH Oct 10, 1854ST Aug 26, 1889RH Mar 20, 1866
Sources