AdventAI

Exodus 31:14

Ye shall keep the sabbath therefore; for it is holy unto you: every one that defileth it shall surely be put to death: for whosoever doeth any work therein, that soul shall be cut off from among his people.

King James Version

Commentary, part 2 of 2

Commentary part 2 of 2

Pioneers and periodicals

141 sources

Keep the Sabbath because it is holy to you, and anyone who defiles it by doing work in it shall surely be put to death and be cut off from among the people.RH Apr 17, 1900ST Feb 2, 1915RH Aug 4, 1903 The Sabbath commanded is the creation Sabbath, grounded in God making heaven and earth and sea in six days and resting on the seventh, and because its ground is creation it was made for all mankind and not for the Jewish nation alone.RH Jan 2, 1908ST Oct 26, 1904ST Dec 22, 1881RH Aug 13, 1857 It is given as a perpetual sign and covenant that the Lord sanctifies His people, marking them as worshipers of the Creator and serving as His seal of authority as Lawgiver.ST Feb 2, 1915ST Dec 11, 1879RH Aug 4, 1903RH Oct 20, 1863RH Jul 8, 1909 The infliction of death by stoning belonged to the civil law of the theocracy and is not to be carried out by the church now, those who held otherwise teaching that the death penalty shows the Sabbath was wholly Jewish and has ceased, while violation remains transgression of the moral law whose final punishment is suspended until God Himself judges the unpardoned.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Oct 15, 1872RH Aug 19, 1852ST Jan 24, 1884RH Mar 9, 1869 Kept in the faith of Jesus it becomes the final test of loyalty and the seal of the living God against the counterfeit day and the mark of the beast, and it will endure when all flesh worships from one Sabbath to another in the new earth.RH Oct 20, 1863ST Dec 22, 1881RH Mar 28, 1854RH May 26, 1853

Historical Setting at Sinai

The Lord spoke to Moses on Mount Sinai during the forty days in the cloud, at the close of communing about the ark, the mercy-seat, the sanctuary and the priesthood and just as the law written by God himself was about to be committed into the hands of Moses, again enjoining the Sabbath.RH Dec 31, 1861ST Mar 25, 1889RH Dec 31, 1861 It belongs to the instructions received during the forty-day stay and the forty days and nights on the mount, when directions concerning the sanctuary and worship were given, within the legislative part of Exodus.RH Dec 31, 1861ST Mar 25, 1889 It stands within the narrative of Exodus 19, 20 and 24-34, in the record of the personal descent of God upon Mount Sinai with His angels to give Israel His law, following the giving of the Sabbath in Exodus 16 and the espousal of Israel as a holy nation unto Himself in Exodus 19.RH Dec 24, 1861 It belongs to the instruction given on the mount within the account of the covenant and God's law, and the covenant did not change the nature or perpetuity of that law.ST Dec 10, 1896

It stands within the minute description in Exodus 25 to 40 of the worldly sanctuary and inner tabernacle built in the days of Moses in the wilderness, to be made exactly according to the pattern shown in the mount.ST Oct 29, 1894ST Jun 19, 1907 It belongs to God's explicit instructions concerning the building of the sanctuary and preparation for its services. It was in the sanctuary where worship of God upon the earth centered and around whose holy of holies, where rested the law of God under the mercy-seat, all earthly worship and service revolved, a building later replaced as the earthly center by Solomon's temple.ST Jun 19, 1907 The ancient tabernacle and sanctuary were constructed for ministry involving sacrifices and offerings, which services passed away when Christ died once for all, and the sanctuary typified the heavenly temple where Jesus now ministers.ST Jan 24, 1911 It is part of the law of Moses commanded at Horeb that is to be remembered in the last days, especially as set forth in Exodus 20 to 40 and Leviticus, together with civil regulations, sacrificial and ceremonial laws, health laws, laws of conduct between man and man, and moral laws, with the Ten Commandments included under the statutes and judgments, to be remembered not alone but together with both the great moral rule of conduct and the laws of offerings, sacrifices and types whose substance is traced in the new dispensation.

The Sabbath commandment here was not the first institution of the Sabbath, which was already known and observed before its promulgation with the Ten Commandments at Sinai.RH Dec 29, 1859RH Oct 21, 1851 The first mention of the Sabbath in Exodus, in chapter 16, came one month after Israel left Egypt and one month before reaching Sinai, and that account neither institutes the Sabbath nor enacts its observance.RH Dec 29, 1859 The Sabbath given was the ancient Sabbath of the Lord, made for mankind and already binding and set apart at creation for the benefit of all mankind, not imposed by a new commandment and not first instituted at Horeb.RH Oct 21, 1851RH Dec 31, 1861RH Mar 17, 1863 It became a sign between God and Israel by God's act of giving His Sabbath to Israel, not by the Sabbath coming into existence then, and it does not teach that the Sabbath was made only for Israel or began after the Hebrews left Egypt, nor does it contradict the account placing the Sabbath's institution at creation.RH Dec 31, 1861RH Mar 17, 1863 It became a gift to the Hebrews through providence in rescuing them from servitude and sending bread from heaven for six days while preserving food for the Sabbath, a miracle that openly declared the Sabbath every week for forty years and proved that the One who sanctified them was the Author of the Sabbath and therefore the Creator of heaven and earth, and giving the Sabbath to the Hebrews did not make God and His law and Sabbath Jewish but made the Hebrews the honored keepers of divine truth for the earth.RH Dec 31, 1861

Wording of the Command

The command is to keep the Sabbath because it is holy to those given it, and anyone who profanes it by doing any work in it is to be surely put to death, that person cut off from among the people.RH Apr 17, 1900RH Nov 6, 1913ST Feb 2, 1915RH Aug 4, 1903RH May 8, 1913 It is a solemn rest on the seventh day, kept as a perpetual covenant and as a sign between God and Israel throughout their generations, grounded in His making heaven and earth in six days and resting on the seventh.RH Apr 17, 1900RH Nov 6, 1913RH Mar 26, 1908ST Feb 2, 1915RH May 8, 1913 Under Israel's covenant law the defilement brought death or removal from the people, and obedience to the command is the right path toward life with Him.RH Apr 17, 1900RH Nov 6, 1913RH Mar 26, 1908RH Aug 4, 1903RH May 8, 1913

The therefore links keeping it to its purpose as a sign that the Lord sanctifies His people, kept as a perpetual covenant forever.RH Oct 7, 1851 The warning draws its authority from the Sabbath oracle itself, as every warning, prohibition and denunciation grows out of and hangs upon its own native statute in the constitution.RH Oct 7, 1851 It brings the Law-giver into view, His existence and His right of power and authority as Creator who made heaven and earth in six days and rested and was refreshed on the seventh.RH Oct 7, 1851RH Oct 7, 1851 For that reason it clothes the whole divine law and the whole Bible with majesty, power and authority, without which law would be powerless and obedience could not be compelled, and it shines with a halo of glory above all the other commandments.RH Oct 7, 1851RH Oct 7, 1851

Soul in the sentence means a person who can be killed and cut off, not an immortal deathless entity existing separately from the body.RH Sep 12, 1854RH Sep 1, 1859RH May 14, 1872 The offender who works on the Sabbath is the soul surely put to death and destroyed.RH Sep 12, 1854RH Sep 1, 1859RH May 14, 1872 The Hebrew word for Sabbath is definite, marked by the article where grammar allows, identifying a particular day, and it remains definite even where Hebrew grammar omits the article.RH Jan 1, 1875

Holy means separated, set apart and appointed to holy use, and only the seventh day was in itself blessed, sanctified and made holy by the divine Word for sacred use.RH Mar 20, 1866ST Jun 3, 1880RH Apr 7, 1851 It is holy to the Lord whether people acknowledge or profane its sanctity, and it must be kept holy as He made it.ST Nov 28, 1911RH Mar 20, 1866 No agreement can make the first day of the week the Sabbath or enable anyone to keep it holy, and a day not made holy by God cannot be kept as the Sabbath.RH Mar 20, 1866 To say no day is intrinsically holy contradicts that the seventh-day Sabbath is really and truly holy in itself, set apart from all other days in sacredness.ST Jun 3, 1880 Only holy men with holy hearts who know the Lord can keep holy what God made holy.ST Nov 28, 1911

The holy day must be observed as a whole day, for resting only part of it and part of the first day does not give rest during the full time made holy.ST Mar 8, 1883 It is a whole twenty-four-hour day beginning at sunset wherever those commanded live, each community beginning when the day reaches its part of the earth, and differences in local time do not lengthen it beyond twenty-four hours or invalidate its observance.RH Apr 21, 1851ST Mar 8, 1883 In Canaan, averaging about sixty-five miles wide east and west, sunset came about five minutes earlier beyond Jordan than on the shores of the Mediterranean, so the day did not begin at the same absolute moment everywhere.RH Oct 27, 1868 Each place began at its own sunset without those by the sea starting early or those on the east or west borders starting minutes before or after sundown to match Jerusalem or each other, yet all kept it equally according to the commandment.RH Apr 21, 1851RH Oct 27, 1868

Creation Origin and Memorial

The Sabbath commanded is the creation Sabbath, not a new institution begun at Sinai twenty-five hundred years after creation, for its ground is that the Lord made heaven and earth and sea in six days and rested and was refreshed on the seventh.RH Jan 2, 1908ST Oct 26, 1904RH Aug 13, 1857ST Nov 22, 1883ST Jun 13, 1916 It is a perpetual weekly memorial of that finished work, holy and binding as a perpetual covenant and a sign between God and Israel marking Him as the One who sanctifies His people.RH Jan 2, 1908ST Dec 22, 1881RH Aug 13, 1857ST Nov 22, 1883ST Jun 13, 1916 No other weekly Sabbath is commanded in Scripture, and its holiness and sign-character rest on that same six-day making followed by divine rest before any distinction between Jews and Gentiles existed.ST Oct 26, 1904ST Aug 7, 1879RH Aug 13, 1857ST Nov 22, 1883

Because its ground lies in creation before Jews and Gentiles existed, the Sabbath was set apart at creation for the benefit of all mankind and was made for man and all nations, universal to all with the same need and reason now as thousands of years ago.RH Aug 13, 1857RH Oct 21, 1851RH Jun 10, 1862RH Oct 21, 1851 It belongs to a law eternal and enduring as God Himself, outliving Jewish types and continuing without end, even into the new earth, rather than ending with typical institutions such as passover, priesthood, trumpets, incense, sacrifices and circumcision whose forever lasted only until Christ.RH Oct 21, 1851RH Jun 10, 1862RH Oct 21, 1851 This Sabbath is distinguished from ceremonial sabbaths which were shadows of things to come, for the Sabbath of the fourth commandment is instead a memorial pointing backward to the fact that in six days the Lord made heaven and earth and rested the seventh day, a fact as true now as when spoken at Sinai and written on stone.RH Jun 10, 1862 The command to Israel therefore does not show the Sabbath was intended for the Jews alone or made exclusively for the Jewish nation, and Israel is not limited to literal Jews since people of faith in Christ are counted as Israel and heirs of the promise, so the Sabbath remains a sign for them.RH Aug 13, 1857RH Oct 21, 1851

As memorial of creation the Sabbath identifies the true God as Creator, Lawgiver, Governor, King and rightful ruler, showing His name, office, power, authority and dominion and keeping the Creator in memory.RH Jul 8, 1909RH Feb 20, 1866ST Nov 16, 1876ST Dec 22, 1881ST Aug 7, 1879 It is God's sign or seal of His power and knowledge as Creator and of His law, and sign, seal and mark are equivalents.RH Jul 8, 1909RH Feb 20, 1866ST Nov 16, 1876ST Dec 22, 1881 Keeping the Creator's rest day marked Israel as worshipers of the only true God, left no place for false gods, guarded against heathenism, and preserved knowledge of God among the nations, for had man not turned away from the Sabbath he could not have forgotten God because the things made attest His eternal power and Godhead.RH Jul 8, 1909ST Dec 22, 1881ST Aug 7, 1879 It is also a sign of His recreative power in redemption and sanctification.RH Nov 16, 1914

The seventh day blessed by the Creator is a literal twenty-four-hour evening-and-morning day like the other six days in which the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea and all that is in them, days marked by alternate darkness and light before the making of the sun as light-bearer and especially marked by the sun from the fourth day onward.ST Oct 19, 1904 It is the same day God sanctified at creation and made known at Sinai, and the sign consisted in keeping holy that day on which God rested, not the sixth day nor one of the six workdays.ST Aug 7, 1879RH Jun 2, 1851ST Oct 19, 1904 Its sanctity is bound to the covenant and its force depends on keeping the seventh day God sanctified, so transferring observance to Sunday denies its God-given sanctity and keeping another day or any one day in seven is disobedience because the holiness is fixed to that day and cannot be kept with original force on a day God never made holy.ST Dec 11, 1879ST Aug 12, 1875RH May 3, 1864RH Nov 11, 1873 The Sabbath commandment is part of the Ten Commandments intended to be obeyed by all mankind, divinely instituted with Sabbath observance commanded and profanation forbidden under penalty of death and cutting off, while Sunday had no such divine command or sanction.ST Dec 11, 1879ST Aug 12, 1875RH May 3, 1864

The Sabbath it describes is the Christian Sabbath made by Jesus Christ at the creation of the world at the close of the creation week, because the command to remember points back to that same creation origin.ST Jun 13, 1916ST Sep 20, 1899ST Sep 3, 1896 It is the day God kept from the beginning and the day Christ kept as His example for His followers, established and blessed by Christ at creation and placed in the enduring divine law as a sign of His everlasting covenant and of submission to His will.ST Jun 13, 1916ST Feb 13, 1901ST Sep 20, 1899ST Sep 3, 1896 As part of the Fourth Commandment law from creation that Christ did not destroy but continues through the New Testament, the seventh day is still binding and must be kept with preparation made on Friday, bringing blessing to those who keep it.ST Nov 19, 1902

Sign Covenant and Sanctification

The Sabbath is holy and must be kept as a solemn rest on the seventh day, with work on it profaning it and bringing death and being cut off from the people.ST Feb 2, 1915ST Dec 11, 1879RH Aug 4, 1903 It is a sign between God and Israel throughout their generations forever and a perpetual covenant and perpetual weekly memorial, given so that they may know that he is the Lord who sanctifies them.RH Apr 17, 1900ST Feb 2, 1915ST Dec 11, 1879RH Aug 4, 1903RH Sep 14, 1869 That covenant observance is grounded in God making heaven and earth in six days and resting on the seventh, and holding to it gives comfort, courage and hope as expressing bond with God.ST Feb 2, 1915ST Dec 11, 1879RH Jan 2, 1908 Like the rainbow it continues as long as his people exist, and its severe penalty underscores that the command was binding and an act of obedience.RH Apr 17, 1900RH Sep 14, 1869 The sign is of sanctifying work for faithful people, not for those who reject him.RH Sep 14, 1869

Hallowing the Sabbath belongs to the sanctification of the soul, with the appointment an outward sign of goodwill toward sinful people.RH Sep 22, 1859 Love for the Sabbath and delight in keeping it are inward evidence that sanctification has begun and will continue.RH Sep 22, 1859 Keeping it marks a people sanctified by God under perpetual covenant, its holiness resting on divine presence and setting apart of the seventh day.ST Nov 22, 1899ST Feb 7, 1900 It is a memorial of creation and a sign of recreative power in redemption by the Spirit, by nature a sign of sanctification.RH Apr 17, 1900RH Nov 16, 1914 Its observance is enjoined on all who belong to Christ and is set apart for divine glory.ST Nov 22, 1899

The Sabbath is the sign or seal of the covenant contained in the Ten Commandments and the seal of the law, identifying the Lawgiver by name, office, power and authority as Creator.RH Feb 20, 1866ST Nov 16, 1876RH Jul 9, 1857 It identifies the living God as Creator and rightful ruler and the one who gave the law, so that keeping it recognizes his authority and dominion and shows him as true Lawgiver.RH Jul 8, 1909RH Jul 9, 1857 Sign, seal and mark are equivalents, and restoring Sabbath observance belongs to Sabbath reform for the church and holy nation continuing as God's people.RH Oct 20, 1863RH Jul 9, 1857 The sign remains between God and his people as long as they exist and will continue in the new earth forever as memorial of creation of heaven and earth. This sign applies to both natural and spiritual Israel, with those who keep it showing they know and worship the true God.RH Dec 29, 1859

The children of promise are counted as Israel, so those who follow Christ belong to God's Israel and are included in the Sabbath obligation, which is therefore not obsolete.ST Nov 22, 1899RH Dec 2, 1858ST Feb 11, 1875 The promise reaches Gentiles only as they join Jehovah, love his name, keep the Sabbath from profaning it and hold his covenant, so the Sabbath remains for all God's people and is not a Jewish-Gentile distinction.ST Nov 22, 1899RH Oct 20, 1863 Its wording does not say it is a sign for Israel only or that it cannot apply to others.RH Apr 5, 1864 Its peculiarity as a special sign arose because all other peoples had turned away while Israel had covenanted to keep the commandments; had all served and obeyed, the peculiarity would not have existed, and Gentiles keeping creation's memorial would know him in the same way.RH Oct 15, 1872 It is a sign to distinguish the true God as Creator that they might know he is God, not a sign to distinguish Jews from Gentiles.RH Oct 15, 1872

Those who held the opposing position taught that this sign-language shows the Sabbath belonged specially to Israel and was wholly Jewish, with Gentiles never commanded to keep it.RH Oct 15, 1872ST Jan 22, 1894 They likened it to circumcision as a typical precept teaching continuance in divine service and indicating by created things the rest of the kingdom, not of perpetual obligation like the other commandments, and held that this enacted law ceased.ST Jan 22, 1894 Against this, keeping the Creator's rest day marked Israel as worshipers of the only true God and kept the Creator in memory, since it rests on six-day creation and seventh-day rest.RH Dec 29, 1859ST Aug 7, 1879 Faithful keeping would leave no place for idolatry and guards from worshiping false gods, distinguishing him from all false gods.RH Dec 29, 1859ST Oct 18, 1883RH May 28, 1867 Regular observance keeps alive knowledge that the Lord made heaven and earth, and universal observance would have preserved knowledge of the true God among the nations, preserving a holy distinct character after deliverance from slavery and idolatry.RH Oct 15, 1872RH Sep 10, 1872

Penalty and Its Standing

Defiling the Sabbath by doing any work in it was punished by death and by being cut off from among the people, for neglect of the holy day brought the threatened punishment into effect.RH Sep 8, 1853ST Apr 14, 1881ST Sep 10, 1902RH May 10, 1864 The death was inflicted by stoning, as in the instance in Numbers 15:35, and was carried out by the civil magistrate.RH Oct 21, 1851RH Sep 8, 1853ST Apr 14, 1881 Examples named are picking up a stick and kindling a fire, set against the manna pattern of gathering on the six working days and gathering none on the seventh.RH Sep 8, 1853ST Dec 28, 1876RH Jan 8, 1867 In this penalty the Sabbath stands like the Passover, and the prohibition did not forbid works of mercy and necessity or the priests' appointed service, which Jesus affirmed as lawful doing of good and meeting of human need.ST Sep 10, 1902RH May 10, 1864

The death penalty and the commission to inflict it belonged to the added law given through Moses, to the civil and national law of the theocracy, and not to the Ten Commandments as first spoken by God and written on stone.RH Aug 19, 1852ST Jan 24, 1884RH Mar 9, 1869RH Jan 2, 1900 It was a temporary political arrangement and a local wilderness measure, part of the former ministration of death that was done away at the cross.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Oct 21, 1851RH Jan 25, 1906 It is therefore not to be carried out by the church now, but the divine penalty will be executed at the future judgment against those who remain unpardoned in sin.ST Apr 30, 1894RH Mar 9, 1869RH Jan 25, 1906 Sabbath observance itself belongs altogether to the law of God, which it is no business of the state to enforce, and state enforcement with its death penalty would work directly against the gospel instituted to hold that penalty in abeyance while opportunity to escape it is given.RH Jan 25, 1906

Temporal death under Moses was not the full and final penalty for violating God's law.RH Apr 7, 1851RH Oct 21, 1851RH Oct 28, 1858 That administration provided no atonement staying execution, so the Sabbath-breaker was put to death, while under the ministration of the Spirit Jesus as Sacrifice and Priest pleads for the transgressor to be spared to turn back to life and repentance.RH Apr 7, 1851ST Nov 16, 1876RH Oct 21, 1851 The stoning penalty ended, and infliction by men is suspended, yet absence of immediate execution does not mean the Sabbath law is abolished, for the command remains in force with the other moral precepts.ST Jan 21, 1886RH Oct 21, 1851ST Sep 8, 1909 Punishment is not escaped even if not immediate, for violators will be cut off by God, and the ultimate penalty remains eternal death, since the wages of sin is still death and God himself will punish the unpardoned.ST Jan 21, 1886ST Nov 16, 1876ST Apr 30, 1894 The Mosaic death was temporal punishment for violating Israel's civil law, not settlement of the offender's moral account or alteration of personal responsibility before God, and punishment for sin ultimately belongs to God rather than requiring execution of Sabbath-breakers now.RH Oct 28, 1858ST Apr 30, 1894

Profaning the Sabbath remains sin because sin is transgression of the Ten Commandments.ST Nov 16, 1876ST Nov 18, 1897ST May 31, 1910 The Sabbath law and its penalty of death belong also to God's universal government, so the end of Israel's theocracy does not make the law no longer binding or remove its penalty.ST Nov 18, 1897ST Apr 30, 1894RH Dec 8, 1859 Those who break it face judgment and death under that government unless pardoned through Christ, who saves those who are honest, willing and obedient.ST Nov 18, 1897ST May 31, 1910 The death sentence for presumptuous Sabbath-breaking illustrates that sin will meet its certain penalty even when punishment is not immediate, and the command with its penalty is presented as unalterable with no limit on its duration, to be observed only on the appointed seventh day rather than exalting human authority by another day.ST May 31, 1910ST Sep 8, 1909RH Dec 8, 1859

The penalties were righteous enactments of the sovereign Lawgiver against disobedience that was both gross impiety toward God as supreme moral Governor and daring rebellion against him as theocratic King.RH Oct 28, 1858 The guilt was peculiarly aggravated as willful and presumptuous transgression of plain positive enactments in the very face of God enthroned in their midst, after rescue by mighty power from Egyptian slavery and lifting from being no people to be his people with the adoption and the glory and the covenants and the giving of the law and the service of God and the promises. The punishment was not greater than the offense, for breaking a law binding alike as religious and civil statute and fixed as a special sign of his solemn and tender relation to that nation could no more pass with impunity under the theocracy than transgression of the law of the land in a well-ordered state today, and though mysterious the award is just since righteousness and right are the bases of his throne though clouds and darkness are round about him. Given by God acting as governor of Israel, the penalty protected lives and property, restrained evildoers, made offenders examples to turn the young from demoralizing practices, and checked what would subvert the whole nation, since treating the Sabbath as of no account leads into idolatry and idolatry means eternal destruction of many, so that it is better that the subverter perish than that the nation be destroyed. This governmental use of death does not cancel the individual duty of Thou shalt not kill, but belongs to government as earthly governments punish murder and crimes tending to subvert government with death.

Those who held otherwise taught that the relentless death penalty attached in positive form to the Jews is against Christians and contrary to a dispensation of grace, so the Sabbath is abolished, belonging to the bondage of the old covenant.RH Apr 15, 1873RH Mar 15, 1864RH Oct 24, 1854 In that reckoning the enacted Old Testament Sabbath law ceased as wholly Jewish, never commanding Gentiles, and both Sabbath and Passover ceased after Christ's crucifixion and resurrection with substitutes in the Lord's Day and the Lord's Supper until complete fulfillment in God's kingdom or the new earth.ST Jan 22, 1894RH May 10, 1864 The same line likened the Sabbath to circumcision as a typical precept teaching continuance in God's service and pointing by created things to the rest of God's kingdom, not of perpetual obligation like the other commandments, though the words of the Decalogue spoken by the Lord in his own person remain permanently with extension and increase by his advent in the flesh but not abrogation. It was even applied to argue that Jesus broke the Sabbath and, if the Sabbath were not abolished, should have been stoned as a sinner.RH Oct 24, 1854

The Sabbath was enforced by the penalty of death from Moses to David for five hundred years, and every violation in Joshua's days was punishable with death by special appointment of God.RH May 12, 1868RH Mar 15, 1864RH Jan 14, 1862RH Dec 10, 1861 Its absence from the record between Moses and David does not prove neglect or non-observance during that period.RH Apr 7, 1863RH Jan 14, 1862 Joshua and Israel going unpunished proves they did not break the Sabbath by marching around Jericho seven days in succession, for the verse forbids doing our own work and not doing work God appoints to be done.RH May 12, 1868 Even on the claim that entering Canaan typified Christ, the death-penalty Sabbath law would not be abolished until after entrance into the heavenly Canaan, which is still future, so it still binds now.RH May 12, 1868

Prophecy and Final Test

The seventh-day Sabbath points to a future thousand-year rest following six thousand years of Christ's work to create the new heavens and earth, with that Sabbath millennium expected to begin in 1843.SMV 20.2–21.1 The Sabbath is holy and must be kept, with profaning it by work carrying death and cutting off from the people, while serving as a sign of God's creative work and rest.SMV 20.2–21.1

Sabbath keeping becomes the decisive final test of loyalty to God versus human authority, with the Sabbath question central to the last conflict under the third angel's message.RH Oct 20, 1863ST Dec 22, 1881RH Mar 28, 1854RH Oct 23, 1900RH Apr 10, 1916 The Sabbath of the fourth commandment is the seal of the living God and the sign of sanctification, opposed to the counterfeit Sunday sabbath and the mark of the beast.RH Oct 20, 1863ST Dec 22, 1881RH Mar 28, 1854RH Apr 23, 1901RH Apr 10, 1916 As the seventh-day Sabbath it identifies God as Creator and sustainer of heaven and earth, marks His right to reign and the extent of His dominion, and seals His law as genuine against claims that replace His command with Sunday observance.ST Dec 22, 1881RH Mar 28, 1854RH Apr 10, 1916 It is and ever will be the dividing line between the people of God and the world, as designed at creation, a sign between God and the children of Israel forever and throughout their generations for a perpetual covenant, given so they may know that the Lord sanctifies them.RH Oct 20, 1863RH Oct 23, 1900 Its holiness and its role as a sign between God and His people mean its observance continues for God's people, identified as the church and the holy nation, even though the Jewish people have ceased to exist as a nation before God, and restoring its observance is part of the Sabbath reform.RH Oct 20, 1863 Accepting and keeping it proves true baptism and leading of the Holy Spirit in perfect obedience to God's holy law, while refusing it when pressed proves a counterfeit experience with no love, joy, and peace, which is rejection of God placing the person under Satan's deceptive sealing work as an angel of light.RH Apr 23, 1901 In six days the Lord made heaven and earth, and the seventh day commemorates that work as a perpetual reminder of His power and a safeguard against heathenism, for had man not turned away he could not have forgotten God, since the things made attest His eternal power and Godhead.ST Dec 22, 1881 To treat this God-given sign with contempt and displace it with Sunday without a sentence of Scripture is presumptuous, for sign, seal, and mark are equivalents, so the Sabbath is Jehovah's sign of power in opposition to Sunday as the pope's sign of power and peculiar mark of allegiance.ST Dec 22, 1881 Keeping the seventh-day Sabbath marks loyalty to God and distinguishes true Israel, in contrast to the counterfeit Sabbath associated with loyalty to earthly powers.RH Apr 10, 1916

The Sabbath will endure into the new earth, where all flesh will worship from one Sabbath to another as memorial of creation.RH Jun 10, 1862RH Apr 7, 1851 Its covenant reaches a thousand generations and mortal and immortal life, binding for as long as humanity exists in both states, as part of a perpetual covenant without limitation.RH May 26, 1853RH Apr 7, 1851 The sign is not limited to the Jews, for God's people in every age are Israel, and the Sabbath remains a sign between God and His people as long as they exist, applying to all who belong to Christ as Abraham's seed and heirs by faith. Forever and perpetual mean the utmost duration the thing can last, so when applied to typical Jewish institutions like passover, priesthood, trumpets, incense, sacrifices and circumcision they mean only until Christ, but when applied to the Sabbath they mean without end.RH Jun 10, 1862 The Sabbath is not a type pointing forward to Christ, for it was made at creation before sin entered and before types were needed, as a memorial pointing backward to the fact that in six days the Lord made heaven and earth and rested the seventh day, a fact as true now as when spoken at Sinai and written on stone.RH Jun 10, 1862 It was made for man and is universal to all men and nations, with the same need and reason now as thousands of years ago, belonging to a law eternal and enduring as God Himself, so it outlives Jewish types and continues forever, even into the new earth.RH Jun 10, 1862 It is God's creation memorial, not a typical Sabbath or ordinance that ceased, and it is called the people's only when they claim it by profaning it. The death threatened for defiling it by work was executed under Moses' law by putting the Sabbath-breaker to death, while under the gospel God for Jesus' sake spares the Sabbath-breaker to give space to repent until Jesus ceases to plead for Israel and steps out from the Father, when the great day of God's wrath destroys all sinners.RH Apr 7, 1851 The language binds every honest-hearted soul, and the covenant is perpetual like the kingdom of Jesus which shall have no end, reaching to the time when all flesh shall worship God on the Sabbath.RH Apr 7, 1851 Fallen mankind cannot keep it in the sinful state until it is restored from the dominion of the papal beast and his image by those laboring in the third angel's message.RH Apr 7, 1851 Even if limited to the literal descendants of Abraham it remains in full force today as at creation, because it was commanded for all their generations and those generations have not ceased or become extinct, and God's truth endures to all generations and His covenant of the ten commandments including the Sabbath stands to a thousand generations, at least thirty thousand years, reaching beyond the resurrection where all flesh will keep it.RH Apr 7, 1851

God has set His hand to restore the downtrodden Sabbath to the remnant after the 1844 messages by calling attention to the ark containing the law in heaven.RH Oct 20, 1863RH May 28, 1867RH Dec 4, 1856 The restoration belongs not to everyone who says Lord, Lord, but to those willing to do the will of the Father in heaven, and the work will be accomplished.RH Dec 4, 1856 After the first and second messages of 1844 God by the third angel's message based on the closing sanctuary work first proved the remnant by the Sabbath commandment, making commandment-keeping with the faith of Jesus the great sanctifying truth preparing the remnant church for translation.RH May 28, 1867 Keeping it with the faith of Jesus prepares the 144,000 sealed with the Father's name written in their foreheads in Revelation 7 and redeemed alive at the second advent.RH May 28, 1867 The Sabbath of the fourth commandment is the opposite of the mark of the beast and is the sign or seal of the living God, proving whether they would walk in His law and recognize Him as the only living and true God and Creator of heaven and earth and sea, distinguishing Him from all false gods and from the beast and his image.RH May 28, 1867 It is a golden link uniting God and His worshipers and the bond of the covenant joining duties to God in the first four commandments with duties to fellow men in the last six, and keeping it marks the people against whom the dragon, beast and worshipers make war but who will conquer while beast-worshipers are cast into the lake of fire.RH May 28, 1867

The Sabbath served as a weekly tangible reminder of the blessed inheritance of Canaan, which prefigured Eden restored.ST Oct 4, 1905 Obedience to the Sabbath served as a test of keeping the whole law, as a sign that Israel knew the Lord and that His sanctifying power was at work among them.ST Oct 4, 1905 Those who did not gain the spiritual rest offered through the Sabbath by faith did not enter Canaan.ST Oct 4, 1905 The command proves the Sabbath is part of the law of God whose validity and obligation do not depend on human belief, and proves the weekly Sabbath is distinct from the rest promised to Israel and given through Joshua. God never swore in wrath that Israel should not keep the Sabbath, as He swore they should not enter into the promised rest, while rebellious ones who did not keep the Sabbath were commanded to be put to death.

Obedience and Daily Life

Keeping the Sabbath is obedience to God's divine requirements, part of the perfect law that reveals His will and character and serves as the standard of righteousness whose principles determine life or death.RH Apr 17, 1900RH Nov 6, 1913 It is a specific sign of outward obedience by which reverence for the Creator is exhibited before fellow men, the only precept of the moral law instituted as His special memorial, honoring His creative and redemptive power.RH Apr 17, 1900ST Sep 17, 1902RH Feb 28, 1871 Keeping it is the right path toward life with Him and a test of loyalty, so rejecting that plain command brings condemnation while keeping it distinguishes the loyal from the disloyal.RH Nov 6, 1913RH Mar 26, 1908RH Feb 28, 1871 Esteeming it a non-essential that may be bent or abolished for convenience brings danger in the last grand test of loyalty, for which warning is sent beforehand.RH Mar 26, 1908RH Feb 28, 1871

The Lord's day is the seventh-day Sabbath, not the first day of the week, for the command identifies the Sabbath as the day God recognizes as His own.RH Jun 4, 1901ST May 11, 1904ST Apr 11, 1900 The commanded observance serves the holiness of that particular fixed day and cannot be replaced by another day or reduced to keeping any seventh part of time, so doing on another day what God commands for the Sabbath is disobedience that exalts human authority above God's.RH Jun 4, 1901ST May 31, 1910ST Apr 17, 1901 No command or threatening guards Sunday, while fearful threatenings guard the seventh day to urge its observance, with severe punishment for profaning it by work, unlike labor on the first day.ST May 31, 1910ST Apr 17, 1901RH Feb 7, 1916 Changing it would under biblical law have been capital, since defiling it by doing work brought death and being cut off from the people, and transgression remains sin whose wages are death, though Christ saves the honest, willing and obedient.ST May 31, 1910RH Feb 7, 1916

Keeping holy comprehends rest of the spiritual nature as well as the physical, requiring more than merely stopping physical work.RH Oct 21, 1851RH Aug 27, 1914 It requires resting from one's own labor, business and service to God, arranging business and temporal affairs through the entire week with reference to it, and welcoming it as a dear friend for added blessing.RH Oct 21, 1851RH Aug 27, 1914 Resting only part of it and part of the first day does not give rest during the full time made holy, and because the day begins at sunset rest must begin then, not at midnight.ST Mar 8, 1883 The prohibition did not forbid works of mercy or necessity, or the priests' appointed service, and Jesus affirmed that doing good and meeting human needs were lawful on the Sabbath.ST Sep 10, 1902 True observance rests from one's own labors and springs from loving submission to God, not from force or any other imposed motive.

Sabbath keeping is the fruit, not the cause, of salvation; no one can keep it unless saved, with Jesus dwelling within and holding him from falling.RH Mar 20, 1866 That keeping is not instantaneous perfection but a growth, often slow, and salvation must be kept day by day and moment by moment, since losing Jesus in a moment means losing salvation and committing sin. To the saved the gospel is the power of God that makes Sabbath keeping and all other good works possible, for the carnally minded and unconverted cannot truly keep what was made for man in innocency according to its original design.RH Mar 20, 1866 Only holy men with holy hearts who know the Lord can keep holy what God made holy, and hallowing it belongs to the sanctification of the soul.RH Sep 22, 1859ST Nov 28, 1911RH Sep 30, 1852 Love for the Sabbath and delight in keeping it are inward evidence that God has begun and will continue to sanctify the soul, while claiming to know God after the truth is made known and refusing to keep it denies Him in heart and conduct, and keeping the commandments cannot be compelled in one who does not know God.RH Sep 22, 1859ST Nov 28, 1911RH Sep 30, 1852

The Sabbath is holy unto the Lord, not holy to man and not holy to the state; it is holy to God and to be kept as a holy day, a sign of the relationship between people and their Creator and a memorial of His work for them. Unlike marriage, which concerns relations between people, home, children and posterity, property and citizenship, the Sabbath does not concern civil relations but worship belonging to God on one side and His human child on the other, relating to personal relations with God as do prayer, baptism and the Lord's supper. Sabbath observance therefore lies entirely outside the province of the state, beyond human legislation, and the state has no right to enforce Sabbath laws, for to enforce Sabbath-keeping by civil law is to enforce religion by civil law. Death is the penalty fixed by God Himself for violating the Sabbath law under the theocracy, not a penalty modern civil governments can enforce in accordance with the law of God, and a civil power assuming God's place to inflict it acts as antichrist while God will vindicate His own justice Himself.ST Oct 22, 1894RH Jan 25, 1906 The gospel was instituted by the Author of that law to hold that death penalty in abeyance while the transgressor is given opportunity to escape it, so state enforcement would work directly against the gospel, and in the last days this law will be invoked to demand death for transgressors of the pseudo Sabbath, Sunday.ST Oct 22, 1894RH Jan 25, 1906

The command convinced hearers to keep God's commandments and the seventh day, with preparation made on Friday bringing blessing to those who keep it.ST Jan 20, 1904ST Nov 19, 1902 The seventh-day commandment is given plainly and is not required to be repeated in the New Testament for Christians to be bound by it, for the New Testament's teaching and enforcement of God's commandments supports the duty, which remains unless clear and equally plain testimony shows abolition, since Christ did not destroy the Fourth Commandment law from creation but it continues.ST Nov 19, 1902RH Feb 17, 1852 The Sabbath of the Lord, engraven on stone as part of the moral law, is distinct from the sabbaths of the ceremonial law, the feast-day, yearly and land sabbaths called your sabbaths and her sabbaths, which were shadows of things to come and ceased at the cross.ST Sep 13, 1877RH Jul 28, 1868RH Oct 7, 1851 The seventh-day Sabbath is never spoken of as a shadow but is a memorial of a finished past work with no reference in its institution or commandment to anything future, grounded in God making all things in six days, resting the seventh, blessing and hallowing it, and commanding it be kept holy, and the word of the Lord endures forever.ST Sep 13, 1877RH Jul 28, 1868RH Jun 10, 1862 Its strict outward observance belonged to Israel's ceremonial order in one teaching, while its enduring moral and spiritual character remained grounded in its original sacred purpose, and its role as a sign to Israel does not mean it passed away with the ceremonial system, for the moral law which the passing of that system does not abolish still has it written in the fleshly tables of the heart, with speedy execution stayed to give pardon and life to the repentant.RH Jun 28, 1864RH Nov 4, 1858RH Oct 7, 1851 Forever and perpetual mean the utmost duration the thing can last, so when applied to typical institutions they mean only until Christ, but when applied to the Sabbath made at creation before sin and types as a memorial pointing backward they mean without end, universal to all men and nations, continuing even into the new earth.RH Jun 10, 1862

Christ speaking from the pillar of cloud commanded Sabbath keeping because the Sabbath is holy, a sign between Him and His people throughout their generations that He sanctifies them, and a perpetual covenant with the children of Israel forever, the seventh day being the Sabbath of rest holy to the Lord.RH May 8, 1913 The design of the institution proves the New Testament still enjoins observance of the seventh day, appointed by the Creator as the Sabbath for His people throughout all generations, neither changed nor abolished, binding before Moses alongside the other moral commandments and set apart at creation, which means Adam was given a command to keep it.RH Apr 3, 1855ST Jun 4, 1874RH Oct 11, 1864 It remains binding as part of God's enduring covenant and law, not merely a Jewish institution but a perpetual covenant and sign between God and His people forever, identifying the seventh-day Sabbath as God's own institution and memorial which true Israel remembers rather than replacing with human institutions.ST Sep 3, 1902RH Sep 10, 1857ST Jan 20, 1898 If Paul had taught or practiced breaking the Sabbath, the Jews eager to convict Sabbath-breakers and bringing many accusations against him would certainly have accused him of Sabbath-breaking under the Jewish civil law where working on it was punishable by death.RH Feb 5, 1867RH Jul 1, 1873 Since they never mentioned it, Paul neither taught nor practiced desecration but kept the Sabbath day as Jews and Christians always had, and the absence of such accusation against Christians evidences they did not work on the Sabbath.RH Feb 5, 1867RH Jul 1, 1873

Doctrinal Distinctions Defended

The Sabbath declared holy, with defiling it by doing work bringing death or exclusion from the people, stands among commands lasting throughout generations, yet its role as a sign to Israel does not mean it passed away with the ceremonial system.RH Jun 28, 1864 It belongs to the moral law, and the passing of that ceremonial system does not abolish it.RH Jun 28, 1864

The Sabbath is holy and must be kept, and doing work on it defiles it and under Israel's covenant law brought death or removal from the people.RH Mar 26, 1908 It is part of God's enduring law written by His own finger, and its holiness is grounded in His making heaven and earth and resting on the seventh day.RH Mar 26, 1908 It belongs to the sanctuary instructions and concerns the Sabbath commandment within God's ten-commandment law.RH Jun 21, 1864 That commandment was written on the stone tables placed in the ark of the covenant in the most holy place, and its place within that sacred law underscores the law's enduring authority, which the covenant did not change in nature or perpetuity.RH Jun 21, 1864ST Dec 10, 1896

Those who held the contrary teach that the Mosaic prescription of death for Sabbath-breaking should be restored today.ST Oct 26, 1904 In that teaching the restoration applies to violations of moral law generally.ST Oct 26, 1904 It includes Sabbath-breaking and idolatry together under the same restored penalty.ST Oct 26, 1904

Further points

Doing what God's word forbids brings being cut off from among God's people.RH Oct 8, 1908 That cutting off is excommunication in substance.RH Oct 8, 1908 It is withdrawal of fellowship from one who persists in wrongdoing.RH Oct 8, 1908

Sources

  1. ST Feb 2, 1915 Signs of the Times, Vol. 42, No. 5 — A Great Bulwark Against Apostasy T. E. Bowen, February 2, 1915
  2. RH Aug 4, 1903 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 80, No. 31 — The Sabbath and Israel L. A. S., August 4, 1903
  3. RH Apr 17, 1900 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 77, No. 16 — FOR A PERPETUAL COVENANT Ellen G. White, April 17, 1900
  4. RH Jan 2, 1908 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 85, No. 1 — THE PRESENT TRUTH January 2, 1908
  5. ST Oct 26, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 42 — THAT "SIGN SABBATH." Clarence K. Redfield, October 26, 1904
  6. ST Dec 22, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 48 — ENFORCEMENT OF THE "CHRISTIAN SABBATH." Alexander Campbell; Catholic Catechism, December 22, 1881
  7. RH Aug 13, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 10, No. 15 — REVIEW August 13, 1857
  8. ST Dec 11, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 47 — THE REAL SABBATH December 11, 1879
  9. RH Oct 20, 1863 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 22, No. 21 — Here are They That Keep the Commandments of God. Rev. xiv, 12 Isaac Sanborn, October 20, 1863
  10. RH Jul 8, 1909 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 86, No. 27 — The Mark of the Beast and the Seal of the Living God George I. Butler, July 8, 1909
  11. ST Nov 16, 1876 Signs of the Times, Vol. 2, No. 46 — The Bible Text Book B. A. Stephens, Fifth-day, November 16, 1876
  12. RH Oct 15, 1872 Review and Herald, Vol. 40, No. 18 — DISCUSSION ON THE SABBATH QUESTION Peter Vogel, October 15, 1872
  13. RH Aug 19, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 3, No. 8 — LETTERS John A. Loughhead, Thursday, August 19, 1852
  14. ST Jan 24, 1884 Signs of the Times, Vol. 10, No. 4 — The Penalty of the Sabbath W. N. Glenn, January 24, 1884
  15. RH Mar 9, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 33, No. 11 — A DIALOGUE Third-day, March 9, 1869
  16. RH Mar 28, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 10 — THE TWO-HORNED BEAST John Norton Loughborough, March 28, 1854
  17. RH May 26, 1853 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 4, No. 1 — TIME TO COMMENCE THE SABBATH Joseph Bates, May 26, 1853
  18. RH Dec 31, 1861 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 19, No. 5 — History of the Sabbath December 31, 1861
  19. ST Mar 25, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 12 — NOTE March 25, 1889
  20. RH Dec 31, 1861 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 19, No. 5 — History of the Sabbath December 31, 1861
  21. RH Dec 24, 1861 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 19, No. 4 — History of the Sabbath John Nevins Andrews, Third-Day, December 24, 1861
  22. ST Dec 10, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 49 — Supplied Words and Old and New Covenant December 10, 1896
  23. ST Oct 29, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 51 — THE SANCTUARY OF THE BIBLE Elder M. H. Brown, October 29, 1894
  24. ST Jun 19, 1907 Signs of the Times, Vol. 33, No. 25 — The Sanctuary, or the Temple, of God June 19, 1907
  25. ST Jan 24, 1911 Signs of the Times, Vol. 38, No. 4 — IF YE WILL INQUIRE, INQUIRE YE Editor, January 24, 1911
  26. RH Dec 29, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 6 — SABBATICAL CATECHISM December 29, 1859
  27. RH Oct 21, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 6 — The Seventh-day Sabbath Not Abolished October 21, 1851
  28. RH Dec 31, 1861 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 19, No. 5 — History of the Sabbath December 31, 1861
  29. RH Mar 17, 1863 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 21, No. 16 — Lessons for Bible Students Third-Day, March 17, 1863
  30. RH Nov 6, 1913 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 90, No. 45 — In the Spirit and Power of Elias Ellen G. White, Thursday, November 6, 1913
  31. RH May 8, 1913 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 90, No. 19 — Sabbath Observance Isaac Sanborn, May 8, 1913
  32. RH Mar 26, 1908 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 85, No. 13 — Teaching the Sabbath Truth Ellen G. White, March 26, 1908
  33. RH Oct 7, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 5 — THE TWO LAWS Hiram Edson, October 7, 1851
  34. RH Oct 7, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 5 — THE TWO LAWS Hiram Edson, October 7, 1851
  35. RH Sep 12, 1854 Review and Herald, Vol. 6, No. 1 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, September 12, 1854
  36. RH Sep 1, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 14, No. 15 — THE BREATH OF LIFE September 1, 1859
  37. RH May 14, 1872 Review and Herald, Vol. 39, No. 22 — What Is Soul? What Is Spirit? May 14, 1872
  38. RH Jan 1, 1875 Review and Herald, Vol. 45, No. 1 — Information Wanted John Harvey Waggoner, January 1, 1875
  39. RH Mar 20, 1866 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 27, No. 16 — The Sabbath J. H. Waggoner, Third-Day, March 20, 1866
  40. ST Jun 3, 1880 Signs of the Times, Vol. 6, No. 21 — DR. BENSON'S SUNDAY BOOK June 3, 1880
  41. RH Apr 7, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 1, No. 8 — THE HOLY SABBATH Joseph Bates, Monday, April 7, 1851
  42. ST Nov 28, 1911 Signs of the Times, Vol. 38, No. 47 — 3010 — The Sabbath for Israel Editor, November 28, 1911
  43. ST Mar 8, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 10 — Commencement of the Sabbath Editor, March 8, 1883
  44. RH Apr 21, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 1, No. 9 — TIME TO COMMENCE THE HOLY SABBATH Joseph Bates, Monday, April 21, 1851
  45. RH Oct 27, 1868 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 32, No. 18 — WHERE WAS THE SABBATH OBSERVED IN PAUL'S DAY? Third-day, October 27, 1868
  46. ST Nov 22, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 44 — A Check on Adventism November 22, 1883
  47. ST Jun 13, 1916 Signs of the Times, Vol. 43, No. 24 — The Making of the Sabbath Carlyle B. Haynes, June 13, 1916
  48. ST Aug 7, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 30 — Sunday Not the True Seventh Day John Nevins Andrews, August 7, 1879
  49. RH Jun 10, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 20, No. 2 — REVIEW OF A. N. SEYMOUR J. M. Aldrich, Third-Day, June 10, 1862
  50. RH Oct 21, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 6 — The Seventh-day Sabbath Not Abolished October 21, 1851
  51. RH Feb 20, 1866 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 27, No. 12 — The Seal of God, and the Mark of the Beast J. H. Waggoner, February 20, 1866
  52. ST Nov 16, 1876 Signs of the Times, Vol. 2, No. 46 — The Bible Text Book B. A. Stephens, Fifth-day, November 16, 1876
  53. RH Nov 16, 1914 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 91, No. 48 Extra — God's Message for Today F. M. Wilcox, Monday, November 16, 1914
  54. ST Oct 19, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 41 — The Creation Days and the Sabbath October 19, 1904
  55. RH Jun 2, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 1, No. 12 — THE TIME OF THE SABBATH Monday, June 2, 1851
  56. ST Dec 11, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 47 — THE REAL SABBATH December 11, 1879
  57. ST Aug 12, 1875 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 40 — Constantine J. H. Waggoner, August 12, 1875
  58. RH May 3, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 23, No. 23 — Opposers of Truth Should Have a Good Memory R. F. Cottrell, Third-Day, May 3, 1864
  59. RH Nov 11, 1873 Review and Herald, Vol. 42, No. 22 — WILLIAM BACON STEVENS ON THE SABBATH Wm. Penniman, November 11, 1873
  60. ST Sep 20, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 38 — The Sabbath and the New Testament G. E. Fifield, September 20, 1899
  61. ST Sep 3, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 35 — THE SABBATH, THE SUNDAY, THE CHANGE, AND THE RESTITUTION S. O. James, September 3, 1896
  62. ST Feb 13, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 7 — WHAT HISTORY SAYS CONCERNING THE CHANGE OF THE SABBATH W. A. Colcord, February 13, 1901
  63. ST Nov 19, 1902 Signs of the Times, Vol. 28, No. 47 — How They Became Convinced A. J. Stover, November 19, 1902
  64. RH Sep 14, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 34, No. 12 — THE SABBATH A SIGN John Matteson, September 14, 1869
  65. RH Sep 22, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 14, No. 18 — EXTRACTS FROM SCOTT September 22, 1859
  66. ST Feb 7, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 6 — THE SABBATH A SIGN OF GOD'S EVERLASTING COVENANT S. N. Haskell, February 7, 1900
  67. ST Nov 22, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 47 — THE SIGN OF GOD'S PEOPLE Ellen G. White, NOVEMBER 22, 1899
  68. RH Jul 9, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 10, No. 10 — THE TWO-HORNED BEAST Fifth-day, July 9, 1857
  69. RH Dec 29, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 6 — SABBATICAL CATECHISM December 29, 1859
  70. RH Dec 2, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 13, No. 2 — The Christian and Jewish Sabbath E. B. Sanders, Fifth-Day, December 2, 1858
  71. ST Feb 11, 1875 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 15 — Israel T. D. Clark, February 11, 1875
  72. RH Apr 5, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 23, No. 19 — BOTH SIDES OF THE SABBATH QUESTION Uriah Smith, Third-Day, April 5, 1864
  73. RH Oct 15, 1872 Review and Herald, Vol. 40, No. 18 — DISCUSSION ON THE SABBATH QUESTION J. H. Waggoner, October 15, 1872
  74. ST Jan 22, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 12 — ECHOES FROM THE "BAPTIST MINISTERS' MEETING" IN NEW YORK CITY Monday, January 22, 1894
  75. ST Oct 18, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 39 — The Sabbath Message J. D. Pegg, October 18, 1883
  76. RH May 28, 1867 Review and Herald, Vol. 29, No. 24 — OUR PRESENT POSITION, In the Waiting, Tarrying Time A. C. Bourdeau, May 28, 1867
  77. RH Sep 10, 1872 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 40, No. 13 — DISCUSSION ON THE SABBATH QUESTION John Harvey Waggoner, September 10, 1872.
  78. RH Sep 8, 1853 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 4, No. 9 — The Weekly Sabbath. Page 161 W. M. F., September 8, 1853
  79. ST Apr 14, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 15 — Notes on Sabbath Observance Winer; Lightfoot, Fifth-day, April 14, 1881
  80. ST Sep 10, 1902 Signs of the Times, Vol. 28, No. 37 — WHY NOT ALL OF IT? September 10, 1902
  81. RH May 10, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 23, No. 24 — BOTH SIDES OF THE SABBATH QUESTION Uriah Smith, Third-Day, May 10, 1864
  82. RH Oct 21, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 6 — THE TWO LAWS October 21, 1851
  83. ST Dec 28, 1876 Signs of the Times, Vol. 3, No. 1 — The Law of God R. F. Cottrell, Fifth-day, December 28, 1876
  84. RH Jan 8, 1867 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 29, No. 5 — LAW OF GOD vs. ADVENT HERALD Third-day, January 8, 1867
  85. RH Jan 2, 1900 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 77, No. 1 — Is the Sabbath Question a Dead Issue? January 2, 1900.
  86. RH Jan 25, 1906 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 83, No. 4 — A Champion of Sunday Laws L. A. S., Thursday, January 25, 1906
  87. ST Apr 30, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 26 — “UNDER THE LAW” AND THE SABBATH H. A. Thompson, Monday, April 30, 1894
  88. RH Apr 7, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 1, No. 8 — THE HOLY SABBATH Joseph Bates, Monday, April 7, 1851
  89. RH Oct 28, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 12, No. 23 — THE LAW AND ITS PENALTY Editor, October 28, 1858
  90. ST Jan 21, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 3 — Words of Jesus Bene-Barak, January 21, 1886
  91. ST Sep 8, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 35 — The Sabbath Through the Ages Charles L. Taylor, September 8, 1909
  92. ST Nov 18, 1897 Signs of the Times, Vol. 23, No. 45 — THE TWO GOVERNMENTS AND THE TWO LAWS W. L. Iles, November 18, 1897
  93. ST May 31, 1910 Signs of the Times, Vol. 37, No. 21 — He Can Not Do It May 31, 1910
  94. RH Dec 8, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 3 — SUNDAY LAWS Honestus, December 8, 1859
  95. RH Apr 15, 1873 Review and Herald, Vol. 41, No. 18 — ELD. VOGEL’S SEVENTH NEGATIVE Eld. Vogel, April 15, 1873
  96. RH Mar 15, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 23, No. 16 — Sabbath Discussion Elder Grant, Third-Day, March 15, 1864
  97. RH Oct 24, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 11 — Our Last Paper October 24, 1854
  98. RH May 10, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 23, No. 24 — BOTH SIDES OF THE SABBATH QUESTION Uriah Smith, Third-Day, May 10, 1864
  99. RH May 12, 1868 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 31, No. 22 — THE SABBATH IN TROUBLE IN THE DAYS OF JOSHUA Third-day, May 12, 1868.
  100. RH Mar 15, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 23, No. 16 — Sabbath Discussion Elder Cornell, Third-Day, March 15, 1864
  101. RH Jan 14, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 19, No. 7 — FIFTY UNANSWERABLE ARGUMENTS A. N. Seymour, January 14, 1862
  102. RH Dec 10, 1861 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 19, No. 2 — History of the Sabbath John Nevins Andrews, Third-Day, December 10, 1861
  103. RH Apr 7, 1863 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 21, No. 19 — Lessons for Bible Students Third-Day, April 7, 1863
  104. SMV 20.2–21.1 Synopsis of Miller's Views — XVI.—I believe the time can be known by all who desire to understand and to be ready for his coming. And I am fully convinced that some time between March 21st, 1843, and March 21st, 1844, according to the Jewish mode of computation of time, Christ will come, and bring all his saints with him; and that then he will reward every man as his work shall be. William Miller, 1843
  105. RH Oct 23, 1900 Review and Herald, Vol. 77, No. 43 — SUN WORSHIP VERSUS SABBATH REFORM S. N. H., October 23, 1900
  106. RH Apr 10, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 18 — The Judgment-Hour Message F. M. Wilcox, April 10, 1916
  107. RH Apr 23, 1901 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 78, No. 17 — THE FALSE AND THE TRUE, OR SATAN'S SEALING WORK Mrs. E. M. Peebles, Tuesday, April 23, 1901
  108. RH Apr 7, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 1, No. 8 — THE HOLY SABBATH Joseph Bates, Monday, April 7, 1851
  109. RH Dec 4, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 9, No. 5 — APPEAL TO SEVENTH-DAY BAPTISTS R. F. Cottrell, December 4, 1856
  110. ST Oct 4, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 40 — A MATTER OF FAITH Walter E. Gillis, October 4, 1905
  111. ST Sep 17, 1902 Signs of the Times, Vol. 28, No. 38 — Lesson 13.—September 28.—Review of the Quarter’s Lessons September 17, 1902
  112. RH Feb 28, 1871 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 37, No. 11 — Test of Loyalty Roswell F. Cottrell, Third-day, February 28, 1871
  113. RH Mar 26, 1908 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 85, No. 13 — Teaching the Sabbath Truth Ellen G. White, March 26, 1908
  114. ST May 11, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 19 — THE LORD'S DAY Editor, May 11, 1904
  115. ST Apr 11, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 15 — A STRANGE APPEAL FOR SUNDAY! April 11, 1900
  116. RH Jun 4, 1901 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 78, No. 23 — SIN AND ITS RESULTS Ellen G. White, Tuesday, June 4, 1901
  117. ST Apr 17, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 16 — The Observance versus the Day April 17, 1901
  118. RH Feb 7, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 7 — Bible Reasons for the Seventh Day and Claims of the First Day Contrasted February 7, 1916
  119. RH Oct 21, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 6 — THE TWO LAWS October 21, 1851
  120. RH Aug 27, 1914 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 91, No. 36 — Questions and Answers August 27, 1914
  121. RH Mar 20, 1866 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 27, No. 16 — The Sabbath J. H. Waggoner, Third-Day, March 20, 1866
  122. RH Sep 30, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 3, No. 11 — The Commandments of God, and the Mark of the Beast brought to view by the Third Angel of Rev. xiv, considered in connection with the Angel of Chap. vii, having the Seal of the Living God Hiram Edson, Thursday, September 30, 1852
  123. ST Oct 22, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 50 — An Indication Editor, October 22, 1894
  124. ST Jan 20, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 3 — How They Became Convinced JANUARY 20, 1904
  125. RH Feb 17, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 12 — Call at the Harbinger Office February 17, 1852
  126. ST Sep 13, 1877 Signs of the Times, Vol. 3, No. 36 — THE TEN COMMANDMENTS NOT ABOLISHED Joseph Harvey Waggoner, Fifth-day, September 13, 1877
  127. RH Jul 28, 1868 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 32, No. 6 — ARE THE TEN COMMANDMENTS, OR ANY PART OF THEM, BINDING ON CHRISTIANS? James White, July 28, 1868
  128. RH Oct 7, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 5 — THE TWO LAWS Hiram Edson, October 7, 1851
  129. RH Jun 28, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 24, No. 5 — BOTH SIDES OF THE SABBATH QUESTION Third-Day, June 28, 1864
  130. RH Nov 4, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 12, No. 24 — THE SABBATH J. A. Wilcox, November 4, 1858
  131. RH Apr 3, 1855 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 26 — SABBATH DISCUSSION M. E. Cornell, April 3, 1855
  132. ST Jun 4, 1874 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 1 — Letter from Denmark June 4, 1874
  133. RH Oct 11, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 24, No. 20 — Out of Patience for Light Editor, Third-Day, October 11, 1864
  134. ST Sep 3, 1902 Signs of the Times, Vol. 28, No. 36 — How They Became Convinced W. N. Glenn, September 3, 1902
  135. RH Sep 10, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 10, No. 19 — Awakened to the Sabbath Truth William Herald, Fifth-Day, September 10, 1857
  136. ST Jan 20, 1898 Signs of the Times, Vol. 24, No. 3 — REASONS FOR KEEPING SUNDAY W. N. G., January 20, 1898
  137. RH Feb 5, 1867 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 29, No. 9 — A Question for Sunday-keepers Dudley Marvin Canright, Third-day, February 5, 1867
  138. RH Jul 1, 1873 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 42, No. 3 — OBJECTIONS TO THE SABBATH ANSWERED Dudley Marvin Canright, July 1, 1873
  139. RH Jun 21, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 24, No. 4 — BOTH SIDES OF THE SABBATH QUESTION Preble, Third-Day, June 21, 1864
  140. ST Oct 26, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 42 — DEATH PENALTY FOR VIOLATION OF SUNDAY LAWS J. M. Foster, October 26, 1904
  141. RH Oct 8, 1908 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 85, No. 41 — Has the Church any Protection From Inward Foes? G. I. BUTLER, Thursday, October 8, 1908