Ezekiel 2:5
And they, whether they will hear, or whether they will forbear, (for they are a rebellious house,) yet shall know that there hath been a prophet among them.
Translations
And they, whether they will hear, or whether they will forbear, (for they are a rebellious house,) yet shall know that there has been a prophet among them.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
And they, whether they will hear, or whether they will forbear, (for they are a rebellious house,) yet shall know that there hath been a prophet among them.
And they, whether they will hear, or whether they will forbear, ( for they are a rebellious house,) yet shall know that there hath been a prophet among them.
And they, whether they will hear, or whether they will forbear ( for they are a rebellious house), yet shall know that there hath been a prophet among them.
and they — whether they hear, or whether they forbear, for a rebellious house they [are] — have known that a prophet hath been in their midst.
And they, whether they will hear or whether they will forbear — for they are a rebellious house — yet shall they know that there hath been a prophet among them.
And they! whether they will hear or whether they will forbear, for a perverse house, they are, shall then know that, a prophet, hath been in their midst.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
And whether they listen or refuse to listen— for they are a rebellious house— they will know that a prophet has been among them.
They, whether they will hear, or whether they will refuse— for they are a rebellious house— yet they will know that there has been a prophet among them.
And they, if they give ear to you or if they do not give ear ( for they are an uncontrolled people), will see that there has been a prophet among them.
But surely they will not heare, neither in deede will they cease: for they are a rebellious house: yet shall they knowe that there hath bene a Prophet among them.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
If so be they at least will hear, and if so be they will forbear, for they are a provoking house: and they shall know that there hath been a prophet in the midst of them.
Cross-references
- Ezekiel 3:17-19
Son of man, I have made thee a watchman unto the house of Israel: therefore hear the word at my mouth, and give them warning from me.
The watchman must warn the people whether or not they heed the warning.
- Ezekiel 3:11
And go, get thee to them of the captivity, unto the children of thy people, and speak unto them, and tell them, Thus saith the Lord GOD; whether they will hear, or whether they will forbear.
The prophet is told to speak whether the people listen or refuse.
- 2 Timothy 4:2
Preach the word; be instant in season, out of season; reprove, rebuke, exhort with all longsuffering and doctrine.
Both call for speaking the message whether people listen or not.
- Ezekiel 3:7
But the house of Israel will not hearken unto thee; for they will not hearken unto me: for all the house of Israel are impudent and hardhearted.
Both texts say Israel would not listen to God.
- Acts 7:51-52
Ye stiffnecked and uncircumcised in heart and ears, ye do always resist the Holy Ghost: as your fathers did, so do ye.
Israel is condemned for resisting God’s messengers.
- Luke 10:16
He that heareth you heareth me; and he that despiseth you despiseth me; and he that despiseth me despiseth him that sent me.
Rejecting Christ’s messengers is rejecting Christ.
- Isaiah 6:9-10
And he said, Go, and tell this people, Hear ye indeed, but understand not; and see ye indeed, but perceive not.
The people hear the prophet’s message but do not understand or perceive it.
- Isaiah 30:10
Which say to the seers, See not; and to the prophets, Prophesy not unto us right things, speak unto us smooth things, prophesy deceits:
Some demand agreeable messages instead of warnings.
- Acts 20:27
For I have not shunned to declare unto you all the counsel of God.
Paul declares God’s counsel without withholding it, whether hearers accept or refuse.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
45 sources
God sends His messenger to a rebellious people who may listen to his message or refuse to listen, yet even in refusal they will be made to know that a prophet has been among them.Lt 222, 1908, par. 8–15Lt 32a, 1908, par. 16–17Lt 32, 1908, par. 26–27Lt 222, 1908, par. 165T 691.1 The command lays duty on every messenger to deliver what God gives him whether people hear or forbear, and their response neither cancels nor changes that duty.Lt 32a, 1908, par. 16–17Lt 32, 1908, par. 26–2720MR 101.4–7 That duty is to speak plainly, faithfully and fully, declaring the whole counsel of God without narrowing or withholding it to suit acceptance or opposition.Lt 8, 1860, par. 7–8Lt 48, 1889, par. 2–4Lt 278, 1906, par. 7–8 The delivery itself stands as a witness, so the messenger is not responsible for convicting or converting the hearers, while those who hear remain responsible for their choice and are left without excuse if they turn away.7T 35.1STMW7 3.2Lt 182, 1902, par. 13–15Ms 1, 1874, par. 3Lt 146, 1902, par. 1–2 To reject the light and evidence God sends through His messengers is to reject Christ Himself, for there is no other Saviour.Lt 81, 1896, par. 26Lt 91, 1891, par. 17
Words and Historical Setting
God sent Ezekiel to a rebellious house with a message they might either hear or refuse to hear.Lt 222, 1908, par. 8–15Lt 32a, 1908, par. 16–17Lt 32, 1908, par. 26–27 Whether they listened or refused to listen did not cancel the sending, and the duty to deliver the message stood regardless of their response.Lt 32a, 1908, par. 16–17Lt 32, 1908, par. 26–27 Even in refusal they would still come to know that a prophet had been among them.Lt 222, 1908, par. 8–15Lt 32a, 1908, par. 16–17Lt 32, 1908, par. 26–27Lt 142, 1899, par. 8–9 The same holds for those who set themselves against messages from the Lord, whose rejection does not prevent them from recognizing that God sent a prophet to them.Lt 222, 1908, par. 8–15
The second chapter of Ezekiel is to be studied together with the sixth chapter of Isaiah.Lt 58, 1895, par. 22–25 Together they show that God directs complex work with perfect order.Lt 58, 1895, par. 22–25 Under His instruction human agents carry out their assigned parts.Lt 58, 1895, par. 22–25
The verse belongs to a message connected with the judgment described in Ezekiel 9.Lt 142, 1899, par. 8–9 Under that message wrongdoers are under God's scrutiny.Lt 142, 1899, par. 8–9 Judgment will come upon them.Lt 142, 1899, par. 8–9
Duty to Deliver Message
The verse lays on the prophet, and on every messenger after him, the duty to deliver what God has given whether the rebellious house will listen or will refuse to listen.Lt 32a, 1908, par. 16–17Lt 32, 1908, par. 26–2720MR 101.4–79T 227.18T 60.3 The response of the hearers does not cancel, excuse, remove, determine or change that duty to speak and to warn.Lt 32a, 1908, par. 16–17Lt 32, 1908, par. 26–2720MR 101.4–79T 227.18T 69.2–3 Truth must still be spoken whether people accept it or refuse to hear it, and the message for the neglected Southern field and the work of religious liberty must be written and presented regardless of how people respond.9T 227.18T 69.2–38T 60.3 Workers facing difficulty and opposition are therefore to carry out their calling without being deterred by resistance, examining their own conduct rather than hindering or judging fellow workers.20MR 101.4–7
That duty is to be done plainly, clearly, straightforwardly, faithfully and fully.Lt 8, 1860, par. 7–8Lt 48, 1889, par. 2–4Lt 278, 1906, par. 7–8Lt 38, 1909, par. 12–13Ms 24, 1888, par. 45–52 It calls for declaring the whole counsel of God and speaking what is known to be true, presenting the full, broad gospel without narrowing it to suit how people may respond.Lt 8, 1860, par. 7–8Lt 48, 1889, par. 2–4Lt 56, 1896, par. 4 A warning must be stated plainly even when hearers refuse to accept it, for their refusal does not change the truth or the duty to speak.Lt 278, 1906, par. 7–8Lt 38, 1909, par. 12–13Ms 24, 1888, par. 45–52 Whether they hear or forbear, they will know that a prophet has been among them.Lt 32a, 1908, par. 16–17Lt 32, 1908, par. 26–27Ms 24, 1888, par. 45–52
What is to be delivered in this way is reproof and warning, with counsel and encouragement.5T 73.4TBC1882 56.1–24T 231.3 It includes a plain testimony against selfishness and sin, rebuke of wrongdoing, and denunciation of oppression, hypocrisy and worldliness, given in order to move people to repent and seek God's favor.Lt 8, 1860, par. 7–8Ms 10, 1899, par. 23Lt 225c, 1906, par. 8–9 The messenger is to warn, counsel, reprove and encourage without making human approval the aim.4T 231.3 If after such denunciations people refuse to repent, He may withdraw His light and leave them to their chosen way.Ms 10, 1899, par. 23
The warning must go forward whether people are pleased or displeased, whether they accept or reject, whether they listen and change or refuse to listen.3T 439.2–440.113MR 121.45T 19.3–20.1Ms 64, 1902, par. 12 When God lays the burden to speak, His servants must not hesitate, hold back, abate one jot or tittle for favors, or withhold for frowns and alienations.3T 439.2–440.1Lt 14, 1889, par. 16–2112MR 17.2–18.1 They are not to be swayed by favor, opposition, consequences, fear that the message will be dismissed, or the prospect that some will leave the church and the truth, but with solemn resolve to vindicate what is right they are to stand at the assigned post, repeat the faithful testimony until wrongs are expelled, and trust results with God.3T 439.2–440.1Ms 64, 1902, par. 12Lt 14, 1889, par. 16–2112MR 17.2–18.1 Even refusal will not prevent the hearers from knowing that God sent a prophet among them.5T 19.3–20.112MR 17.2–18.1
The delivery itself stands as a witness to the hearers.7T 35.1STMW7 3.2Lt 182, 1902, par. 13–15 They are to be warned so that they may know that God's message has been delivered to them and that a prophet has been among them, leaving those who reject the testimony without excuse and responsible for their choice.7T 35.1STMW7 3.2Lt 182, 1902, par. 13–15Lt 17, 1903, par. 7–10
Hearers' Responsibility and Outcome
Whether they hear or forbear, though they are a rebellious house, they will come to know that a prophet has been among them, and God will make them know it, and their refusal does not remove their responsibility.Lt 222, 1908, par. 165T 691.1Lt 81, 1896, par. 26Lt 91, 1891, par. 1710MR 140.3–142.2 The word with its warnings and encouragement is designed to come to those in darkness and ignorant of the faith, and the warning is to be given to all as a witness whether they will hear or forbear.7T 35.1Ms 1, 1874, par. 3 It is to be held forth as the word of life and salvation so that all may have opportunity to receive the truth if they will.7T 35.1Ms 1, 1874, par. 3
Those who proclaim it are not responsible for convicting or converting the hearers, nor for their response and its consequences, for only God's power softens hearts.7T 35.1Ms 1, 1874, par. 3Lt 146, 1902, par. 1–210MR 140.3–142.2 Heavenly intelligences work with human effort to present words of life to those ready to perish, while the messenger rests in God's love and leaves results and consequences with God.Ms 1, 1874, par. 3Lt 146, 1902, par. 1–2 The hearers are responsible for their choice, and those who turn from truth of heavenly origin bring condemnation upon themselves.7T 35.1STMW7 3.2Ms 1, 1874, par. 3 Having received the testimony they are left without excuse.4T 231.3Lt 17, 1903, par. 7–10
Many will not hear because they have already refused the Great Teacher, and many will not accept correction because they trust their own judgment and consider their own ways right.5T 73.4TBC1882 56.1–2 Even those who reject the light and evidence God gives will know that a prophet has been among them, but rejecting that light is rejecting Christ, and there is no other Saviour.Lt 81, 1896, par. 26 The same pattern holds for Christ's messengers, so that rejecting their words is rejecting His words, as those who refused to hear His words would refuse theirs.Lt 91, 1891, par. 17 The denunciations against oppression, hypocrisy, and worldliness are declared to move people to repent and seek God's favor, yet if they refuse to repent He may withdraw His light and leave them to their chosen way.Ms 10, 1899, par. 23
Faithful Witness in Practice
Faithful witness means speaking what is known to be true and what God commands, whether people listen or refuse, presenting it as light from God rather than personal wisdom.5T 691.1Lt 48, 1889, par. 2–4Lt 8, 1894, par. 4–7Lt 145, 1902, par. 14 Personal words must not be substituted for the Lord's words, for that would weaken the testimony, and the message is to be given as the Spirit impresses, in love and with zeal under the constraining influence of Christ's love.5T 691.1Lt 8, 1894, par. 4–7Lt 145, 1902, par. 14Lt 14, 1889, par. 16–21 The response belongs to the hearers, while the messenger leaves the matter and the results and consequences in God's hands and with Jesus.4T 231.3Lt 8, 1894, par. 4–7Lt 146, 1902, par. 1–2Lt 145, 1902, par. 14Lt 14, 1889, par. 16–21 Resting in God's love in the knowledge that duty has been done, the messenger does not calculate consequences and does not make human approval the aim, but warns, counsels, reproves and encourages faithfully.4T 231.3Lt 146, 1902, par. 1–2Lt 14, 1889, par. 16–21 Faithful witness is also borne by a consistent life of self-denial, obedience to God's commandments, love for Christ and following His example, by which influence helps others see the way to life in God's city.Ms 171, 1904, par. 2
The verse requires standing faithfully at the assigned post and not leaving the work, repeating the faithful testimony until wrongs are expelled from the churches.Lt 50, 1889, par. 15–16Lt 14, 1889, par. 16–21 Not one jot or tittle is to be abated for favors, nor is the message to be withheld because of frowns and alienations.Lt 14, 1889, par. 16–21 This steadfastness holds even when the leavening influence of doubt and questioning is at work, spiritual life is ebbing from the churches, lightness, trifling, jesting and joking prevail, and brethren withdraw confidence, misjudge, misstate and refuse to confess their wrong course.Lt 50, 1889, par. 15–16 The same testimony applies to those who firmly oppose the Lord's messages and try to bring heaven's message into contempt: their rejection does not remove their responsibility and does not prevent recognition that God sent a prophet, and God deals with His people in the present as in the past.Lt 222, 1908, par. 8–15RH Sep 15, 1910Lt 222, 1908, par. 16
Workers facing difficulty and opposition are to carry out their calling without being deterred by resistance, examining their own conduct rather than hindering or judging fellow workers.20MR 101.4–7 The command to write and present the neglected Southern field is to be obeyed regardless of how people respond, whether they hear or forbear.8T 60.3SPBC 164.4 At North Fitzroy the warning divided hearers, with some receiving it as life-giving water while others rejected it and remained disaffected.Ms 49, 1898, par. 21–22 Though they could have been healed, their chosen course left them hardened and its influence persisted.Ms 49, 1898, par. 21–22 The warning may still bring people to know Christ and lead them to work for others' salvation, so labor is not a failure if even one is brought to salvation, and results that seem fruitless may be revealed in eternity.16MR 51.2 The Lord sustains the faithful worker, with His everlasting arms beneath him to finish the work God gave.Lt 50, 1889, par. 15–16
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
43 sources
God set Ezekiel as His mouthpiece to speak His words of warning and reproof to rebellious captives in Babylonia, and seeing God's glory prepared him not to fear them.ST Jul 26, 1910RH Jan 26, 1905ST Aug 12, 1913ST Jul 25, 1911ST Nov 10, 1909
He was commanded to speak whether they would listen or refuse to listen, for their response did not alter his duty, excuse his silence, or cancel the message.ST Nov 5, 1885RH Jan 26, 1905RH Dec 20, 1906ST Mar 23, 1882ST Apr 16, 1885
Faithfulness is measured by declaring the whole counsel of God plainly, personally, fearlessly and in love, to please God rather than men, not by popularity, support or visible results.ST Dec 4, 1884ST Jul 22, 1875RH Jun 6, 1865ST Mar 29, 1905ST Jun 17, 1889
Rejection by rebellious hearers does not make the message untrue, for refusing the prophet's message is refusing God's word, and even those who refuse will know that God has spoken to them and will be held accountable.ST Nov 5, 1885ST Jun 14, 1910ST May 28, 1885RH Nov 16, 1905RH Oct 18, 1870
That charge now requires proclaiming the Third Angel's Message, the Sabbath and God's law, and the nearness of the day of the Lord and Christ's return, without withholding or softening, whether men heed or scoff.ST Mar 23, 1882RH Feb 6, 1855ST Jun 28, 1883ST Jul 29, 1886
Ezekiel's Time and Calling
Ezekiel served as God's mouthpiece among the captives Nebuchadnezzar carried to Babylonia in 597 B.C., near the river Chebar, while Jeremiah prophesied in Jerusalem.ST Aug 12, 1913ST Jul 25, 1911 He did not seek the prophetic mission, but God assured him that He would be with him in his early experience as a prophet.ST Nov 10, 1909 His prophetic work involved delivering God's warnings and reproof to sinful people, and seeing God's glory prepared him not to fear them.ST Jul 26, 1910
A prophet is God's messenger, commissioned to speak God's words to the people, and whether they listen or refuse does not change the commission, yet they will know that a prophet has been among them.RH Jan 26, 1905 Israel did not listen to God speaking through Ezekiel, and their refusal marked them as a rebellious people.RH Sep 4, 1856 That rejection explains why the nation did not accept the blessings offered through him, though a remnant later accepted the offer and returned after the seventy years of captivity.RH Sep 4, 1856
Duty to Speak Regardless
The verse lays the duty to speak upon a rebellious people whether they will hear or whether they will forbear, and their listening or refusing does not alter the commission, excuse silence, or cancel the message.ST Nov 5, 1885RH Jan 26, 1905ST Jun 7, 1883ST Sep 21, 1882RH Apr 9, 1901 Rebellion makes plain warning all the more necessary, yet even those who reject the warning will know that a prophet has been among them, and rejection does not make the message untrue.ST Nov 5, 1885RH Dec 20, 1906ST Jun 7, 1883ST Sep 21, 1882RH Apr 9, 1901 The prophet is commissioned to speak God's words to the people, and the response of the hearers does not change that charge.ST Nov 5, 1885RH Jan 26, 1905RH Apr 9, 1901
The ministry is a divine calling and not merely a profession directed by a congregation, for the minister is accountable to Christ and must proclaim the whole counsel of God regardless of how people respond.ST Dec 4, 1884 He is to please God rather than tailor his preaching to avoid offending those who support him, serving as God's prophet for his time whether people listen or refuse.ST Dec 4, 1884ST Mar 29, 1905 Faithfulness is measured by declaring the whole counsel of God with God's glory and the people's good in view, not by popularity or worldly reward.RH Jun 6, 1865 Such preaching may bring loss of support, praise, and honor, along with persecution, reproach, and want.RH Jun 6, 1865
The messenger must expose sins and dangers to a judgment-bound generation and speak God's truth courageously, without being silenced by approval, pressure, or opposition.ST Jul 22, 1875 That witness is to be plain and personal, fearless and in love, even when it presses sins home or gives offense, and whether the people listen or refuse does not excuse silence.ST Jul 22, 1875ST Feb 19, 1885 Offense taken at truth preached with tenderness and love does not make the messenger responsible for the response, for he remains a faithful witness whether people accept the message or reject it.ST Jun 17, 1889ST Feb 19, 1885
The preacher's duty is to speak and not to demand immediate results, for having done his duty whether people listen or refuse, their response does not determine his faithfulness.ST Mar 23, 1882ST Apr 16, 1885 The hearers' response is not the messenger's responsibility, and the teacher's responsibility ends with faithfully delivering the message and leaving the hearers to choose what they will do with it.ST Mar 23, 1882RH Jul 24, 1900RH Jul 23, 1914 Continuing to speak whether the people listen or refuse does not make the labor vain, and limited interest does not excuse abandoning patient continuance.RH Aug 30, 1864RH Aug 7, 1866 Their response does not remove the duty to hope, pray, and labor, since judgment and results belong to God.RH Aug 30, 1864RH Jul 23, 1914 The preaching to be done is the preaching God bids, following His explicit commands.RH Sep 17, 1901
Hearers' Response and Accountability
Rejection by rebellious hearers does not make the message untrue, nor does it remove the duty to proclaim it.ST Nov 5, 1885 The prophet must speak even to a rebellious people, whether they listen or refuse to listen, and they will still know that a prophet has been among them.ST Nov 5, 1885 The prophet's message remains God's word whether the people hear it or refuse it.ST May 28, 1885 Refusing the message is refusing the word God has sent, and the people are accountable for having received it.ST May 28, 1885
God's warnings and greetings reach people whether they heed them or not.RH Nov 16, 1905RH Oct 18, 1870 Their response does not change what God has purposed, the warning will be fulfilled, and the coming day of the Lord will surely arrive.RH Nov 16, 1905 Even those who refuse to listen will nevertheless know that God has spoken to them.RH Oct 18, 1870 A rebellious people may refuse to listen because they are rebellious, which is the danger facing a missionary, yet they will still know that a prophet has been among them.ST Jun 14, 1910 This encourages proclaiming the truth whether people listen or refuse, while living out that truth.
People must have the truth proclaimed to them whether they believe it or not, so that they have the opportunity to hear it.RH Sep 21, 1905RH Aug 19, 1852 They must faithfully be given God's warning and mercy through those entrusted with it, whether they hear it or reject it, so that they have had the opportunity to know God's message through His messengers.RH Sep 21, 1905
Doctrinal Warnings to Proclaim
Ezekiel 2:5 requires the Third Angel's Message to be proclaimed fully without withholding or softening any part of it, even when it sounds unpleasant to those who do not want to listen.ST Mar 23, 1882 The messenger must give that warning whether people heed it or refuse it, and the hearers' response is not the messenger's responsibility.ST Mar 23, 1882 The same charge requires warning God's people about their transgression of His commandments without holding back.ST Jun 28, 1883 The truth about the Sabbath and God's law is to be made known regardless of response, presented whether people accept it or refuse to hear it, and even a rebellious people will still know that a prophet has been among them.RH Feb 6, 1855ST Jun 28, 1883
The world must be warned that the day of the Lord and Christ's return are near, whether people heed the alarm or reject it. That warning is to be given even to a rebellious people, despite scoffers and those who say that the Lord delays His coming.ST Jul 29, 1886 The final message of mercy is to be carried to a rebellious house, though its hearers may refuse to hear, yet they will know that a prophet has been among them. God's warning and saving message is to be given whether people listen or refuse, without making its delivery depend on a favorable response, even when it brings persecution, in order to call people away from sin and lead those willing to do right to salvation.ST Jun 6, 1900
Forceful warnings about prophecy and coming events illustrate this duty to speak regardless of how hearers respond, since their response does not cancel the message.ST Sep 26, 1878RH Oct 7, 1862 The signs of the times are to be proclaimed boldly whether people hear or refuse to hear, and even a rebellious people will know that a prophet has been among them.ST Sep 26, 1878 Truth must be presented with a clear testimony despite opposition from those who reject it and try to bring heaven's message into contempt.RH Sep 15, 1910 Such rejection by a rebellious people does not stop the message.RH Sep 15, 1910
Ministry Practice and Mission
Canvassers are taught by the verse to share God's warning and mercy by faithfully delivering the truth entrusted to them whether people hear it or reject it, so that hearers have had opportunity to know God's message through His messengers.RH Sep 21, 1905 The same duty governs tract distribution, where readers may welcome the written message, refuse to read it, or reject further reading, yet the messengers still do their work and the full result will be known on the great day of the Lord.RH Sep 29, 1868 The message must be given to neglected fields and to Porto Rico regardless of whether the people hear it, and even when a rebellious people refuse to listen they will know that a prophet has been among them.RH Dec 20, 1906RH Oct 19, 1905
Patient continuance in proclaiming the truth despite limited interest is required, since the hearers' response does not remove the duty to speak.RH Aug 7, 1866 Apparent lack of early results does not excuse abandoning the work, as shown by the long delay before the Kol converts increased, for the preacher's duty is to speak and not to demand immediate results.ST Dec 28, 1876 The principle also applies to preaching to both the willing and the unwilling, as illustrated by the lace-making woman preaching the gospel both to women willing to hear and to women unwilling to hear, since even those who reject the witness hear it and know that a prophet has been among them.ST Sep 17, 1894 It likewise applies to a warning addressed to a rich person whether he listens or refuses, teaching that riches are a gift and a talent for doing good but he must not set his heart on them nor make them his chief delight or source of happiness nor treat them as his god.RH Jan 31, 1856
God's servants standing face to face with a world doomed to destruction must warn its inhabitants even as the Ninevites were warned, whether people listen or refuse to listen.RH Sep 17, 1901 The preaching to be done is the preaching God bids, following His explicit commands, and the conversion of the great heathen city of Nineveh by just one messenger shows what may be expected today when those commands are followed.RH Sep 17, 1901 A minister therefore must speak freely as God's prophet without depending on the congregation he serves, delivering God's message whether the people listen or refuse, so that even a rebellious people will know a prophet has been among them.ST Oct 27, 1909
Sources