Ezekiel 38:17
Thus saith the Lord GOD; Art thou he of whom I have spoken in old time by my servants the prophets of Israel, which prophesied in those days many years that I would bring thee against them?
Translations
Thus says the Lord GOD; Are you he of whom I have spoken in old time by my servants the prophets of Israel, which prophesied in those days many years that I would bring you against them?
Thus saith the Lord GOD; Art thou he of whom I have spoken in old time by my servants the prophets of Israel, which prophesied in those days many years that I would bring thee against them?
Thus saith the Lord God; Art thou he of whom I have spoken in old time by my servants the prophets of Israel, which prophesied in those days many years, that I would bring thee against them?
Thus saith the Lord GOD; Art thou he of whom I have spoken in old time by my servants the prophets of Israel, who prophesied in those days many years, that I would bring thee against them?
Thus saith the Lord GOD: Art thou he of whom I spake in old time by my servants the prophets of Israel, which prophesied in those days for many years that I would bring thee against them?
Thus saith the Lord Jehovah: Art thou he of whom I spake in old time by my servants the prophets of Israel, that prophesied in those days for many years that I would bring thee against them?
Thus said the Lord Jehovah: Art thou he of whom I spake in former days, By the hand of My servants, prophets of Israel, Who are prophesying in those days — years, To bring thee in against them?
Thus saith the Lord Jehovah: Art thou not he of whom I have spoken in old time through my servants the prophets of Israel, who prophesied in those days, for [many] years, that I would bring thee against them?
Thus, saith My Lord, Yahweh, Art thou, he of whom I spake in days aforetime by the hand of my servants the prophets of Israel, who kept on prophesying in those days for years,—That thou shouldest be suffered to come against them?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
This is what the Lord GOD says: Are you the one of whom I have spoken in former days through My servants, the prophets of Israel, who in those times prophesied for years that I would bring you against them?
“‘ The Lord GOD says: “ Are you he of whom I spoke in old time by my servants the prophets of Israel, who prophesied in those days for years that I would bring you against them?
This is what the Lord has said: You are he of whom I gave them word in earlier times by my servants, the prophets of Israel, who in those days went on saying, year after year, that I would make you come up against them.
Thus saith the Lord God, Art not thou he, of whom I haue spoken in olde time, by ye hand of my seruants the Prophets of Israel which prophecied in those dayes and yeeres, that I woulde bring thee vpon them?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Thus saith the Lord God: Thou then art he, of whom I have spoken in the days of old, by my servants the prophets of Israel, who prophesied in the days of those times that I would bring thee upon them.
Cross-references
- Ezekiel 39:1-6
Therefore, thou son of man, prophesy against Gog, and say, Thus saith the Lord GOD; Behold, I am against thee, O Gog, the chief prince of Meshech and Tubal:
Continues the prophecy of Gog’s invasion and defeat.
- Revelation 20:7-9
And when the thousand years are expired, Satan shall be loosed out of his prison,
Gog and Magog gather for a final attack after the thousand years.
- Ezekiel 38:2-6
Son of man, set thy face against Gog, the land of Magog, the chief prince of Meshech and Tubal, and prophesy against him,
Identifies Gog and the northern force, with Persia and other nations gathered against Israel.
- Ezekiel 39:9-12
And they that dwell in the cities of Israel shall go forth, and shall set on fire and burn the weapons, both the shields and the bucklers, the bows and the arrows, and the handstaves, and the spears, and they shall burn them with fire seven years:
same Gog defeat left unfulfilled in detail
- Revelation 16:14-16
For they are the spirits of devils, working miracles, which go forth unto the kings of the earth and of the whole world, to gather them to the battle of that great day of God Almighty.
Both describe nations gathered for the final battle at Armageddon.
- Ezekiel 38:12
To take a spoil, and to take a prey; to turn thine hand upon the desolate places that are now inhabited, and upon the people that are gathered out of the nations, which have gotten cattle and goods, that dwell in the midst of the land.
Gog comes to take spoil from the gathered people.
- Ezekiel 39:17-21
And, thou son of man, thus saith the Lord GOD; Speak unto every feathered fowl, and to every beast of the field, Assemble yourselves, and come; gather yourselves on every side to my sacrifice that I do sacrifice for you, even a great sacrifice upon the mountains of Israel, that ye may eat flesh, and drink blood.
Continues the destruction on the mountains of Israel.
- Ezekiel 38:9
Thou shalt ascend and come like a storm, thou shalt be like a cloud to cover the land, thou, and all thy bands, and many people with thee.
Gog comes like a storm
- Ezekiel 38:7-8
Be thou prepared, and prepare for thyself, thou, and all thy company that are assembled unto thee, and be thou a guard unto them.
These verses describe the latter-years events prophesied in the chapter.
- Genesis 10:2
The sons of Japheth; Gomer, and Magog, and Madai, and Javan, and Tubal, and Meshech, and Tiras.
Names Magog, Meshech, and Tubal among Japheth’s descendants.
- Ezekiel 38:22
And I will plead against him with pestilence and with blood; and I will rain upon him, and upon his bands, and upon the many people that are with him, an overflowing rain, and great hailstones, fire, and brimstone.
Pestilence and other plagues form part of God’s judgment.
- Isaiah 41:25
I have raised up one from the north, and he shall come: from the rising of the sun shall he call upon my name: and he shall come upon princes as upon morter, and as the potter treadeth clay.
earlier prophecy of attack from the north
- Jeremiah 6:22-23
Thus saith the LORD, Behold, a people cometh from the north country, and a great nation shall be raised from the sides of the earth.
earlier prophecy of attack from the north
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
1 source
The coming attacker against Israel is the one God had spoken of in former time through His servants the prophets of Israel.Ms 81, 1906, par. 26–27 Those prophets had prophesied in those days through many years that He would bring that power against His people.Ms 81, 1906, par. 26–27 The prophecy belongs to a chapter that also foretells the gathering of Israel's people and an invasion against them in the latter years.Ms 81, 1906, par. 26–27 That whole prophetic outline is bound up with the work now being carried forward in foreign countries.Ms 81, 1906, par. 26–27
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
49 sources
The question asks whether Gog is the long-foretold power God said He would bring against His people, an enemy coming from the north as ungodly oppressors had always come against Israel.ST Jul 8, 1930ST Dec 1, 1914ST May 4, 1904ST Sep 21, 1915ST Apr 20, 1915 It was part of what God would have done for restored Israel after Babylon if they had repented and returned wholeheartedly, to bring their enemies against them, defeat those enemies, dwell among them in glory and send them out to convert the nations.ST Oct 26, 1904ST Aug 1, 1911ST Mar 3, 1909ST May 16, 1911ST Sep 21, 1915 Gog means ruler, the prince of Rosh, Meshech, Tubal and Magog, the northern peoples settled in the land now held by Russia.RH Apr 18, 1907ST May 4, 1904ST Sep 21, 1915ST May 31, 1905RH Jun 25, 1901 Because Israel failed and returned only half-heartedly, fulfillment was deferred from that day to the last days on a broader scale.ST Apr 29, 1913ST Dec 1, 1914ST Oct 26, 1904ST Mar 3, 1909ST Aug 2, 1905 In its final fulfillment the names stand for the forces of world evil under Satan making the last effort to crush God's redeemed people in their own land at the close of the thousand years of Revelation 20 before their ultimate destruction, while those who place it before Christ comes teach it as the gathering of nations for Armageddon.ST Jul 8, 1930RH Jan 26, 1905ST Oct 1, 1896RH Apr 7, 1874ST Aug 7, 1893
Language and Old Testament Roots
The question is put to Gog whether he is the one of whom God spoke in old time by His servants the prophets of Israel, who prophesied in those days many years that He would bring him against them.ST Dec 1, 1914ST May 4, 1904ST Apr 20, 1915RH May 12, 1903 The attack upon Israel is thereby presented as something foretold long beforehand, not as a new or unforeseen invasion.ST Dec 1, 1914ST May 4, 1904ST Apr 20, 1915RH May 12, 1903 That ancient word was that God Himself would bring Gog against His people.ST Dec 1, 1914ST May 4, 1904ST Aug 7, 1893 In its final bearing it points to the great Gog and Magog war, when Gog and Magog who had oppressed God's people in the past are summoned to battle to receive the final doom pronounced through the prophet.ST Aug 7, 1893RH May 12, 1903
The earlier prophecies thus referred to are those in which God said through His prophets that He would bring an enemy from the north against Israel.ST Jul 8, 1930ST Sep 21, 1915 The names Gog, Magog, Rosh, Meshech and Tubal are used because, from the standpoint of Palestine, they stand for peoples from the north.ST Jul 8, 1930 The north was the region whence ungodly enemies and oppressors came against God's people Israel.ST Jul 8, 1930 In final fulfillment those names symbolize the forces of world evil under Satan's leadership making the last effort to crush the redeemed people of God in their own land, the home of the redeemed, at the close of the thousand years of Revelation 20 after the unrighteous have been raised in the second resurrection and before their ultimate destruction.ST Jul 8, 1930
The names listed in Ezekiel 38:1-6 — Gog of the land of Magog, Meshech and Tubal, Persia, Ethiopia, Libya, Gomer, Togarmah — are descendants of Noah divided in the earth after the Flood as recorded by Moses in Genesis.ST May 4, 1904 They are to be studied by name and country together with other related scriptures.ST May 4, 1904 Moses' history of the dispersion of the human race over the face of all the earth, now more than three thousand years old, is the oldest and most trustworthy account.ST May 4, 1904 It is verified by ethnology.ST May 4, 1904
The address to Gog carries a rebuke that sets his insignificance beside his pretensions.ST May 11, 1904 At the same time it declares that the time foretold in old time is now come, identifying Gog as the power long foretold by the prophets of Israel to be brought against them.ST May 11, 1904ST May 11, 1904 The issue is that in the presence of His people the whole world acknowledges that He is the Lord.ST May 11, 1904 After that deliverance there will be no religious liberty, but it will not matter because the end will have come, and God will deliver His people, every one whose name is written in the Lamb's book of life.ST May 11, 1904
Conditional Offer to Restored Israel
Ezekiel 38:17 belongs to the restoration promises of Ezekiel 36 to 48, and to the sanctuary prophecy of Ezekiel 37 to 48.ST May 16, 1911ST Sep 21, 1915ST Aug 12, 1913 It describes part of what the Lord would have done for His people if they had yielded to Him, including bringing their enemies against them and conquering those enemies.ST Aug 1, 1911ST Aug 12, 1913 These promises were conditional, for God's plans for nations and His people could change according to their response.ST Aug 1, 1911
The promise was first given in connection with the restoration from Babylonian captivity after seventy years.ST Oct 26, 1904 If Israel had been faithful, had forsaken sins, put away wickedness, returned wholeheartedly and been ashamed of iniquities, God would have brought all scattered Israel back from the nations to the mountains of Israel and to the land brought back from war.ST Oct 26, 1904ST Sep 20, 1910ST Dec 1, 1914STST Oct 1, 1896 That enemy attack and promised victory foretold many years before through His earlier prophets, that He would bring Gog and the kings of the north and enemies far and near against restored Israel, belonged to this conditional offer.ST Sep 21, 1915ST Sep 20, 1910ST Dec 1, 1914
What God was prepared to do then was to restore them to their own land and dwell among them in glory, with a new and far greater sanctuary and temple more glorious than ever.ST Dec 1, 1914ST Mar 3, 1909ST Sep 21, 1915 He would have given them prosperity, cleansed the land, redivided it among the twelve tribes, and sent Israel out to convert the nations.ST Mar 3, 1909 He would have destroyed with plagues the northern enemies described in Ezekiel 38-39, slain Gog and Magog and all nations that menaced them, brought them into subjection to Israel, cut off their enemies, and shown His glory in His people before the nations.ST Dec 1, 1914ST Mar 3, 1909ST Aug 2, 1910ST Sep 20, 1910
Because Israel did not truly repent, returned half-heartedly and only about forty thousand returned, mingled with other nations and disobeyed, and was not ashamed of iniquities, the conditions were never met.ST Oct 26, 1904ST Sep 21, 1915ST Sep 20, 1910ST The sanctuary was never rebuilt, the glory never rested on His children, and the resurrection did not take place.ST Mar 3, 1909 The prophecy was therefore never fulfilled in detail, fulfilled only in small part or in faint type, with only a partial victory over the northern confederacy then threatening them.ST Apr 29, 1913ST Oct 26, 1904ST Mar 3, 1909ST Aug 2, 1910
Its details must therefore be understood in light of the conditions under which it was given and the conditions on earth when it is fulfilled.ST Nov 10, 1914 Some parts will be fulfilled in the last days regardless of Israel's response, and some may be fulfilled after the thousand years, but not every local detail applies again.ST Nov 10, 1914ST Apr 29, 1913 Weapons will not be burned, and the land will not be cleansed by human hands, for national judgments take place before Christ comes when national boundaries and distinctions will no longer exist as at the end of the thousand years.ST Dec 1, 1914
Identity of Gog and Allies
Gog means ruler or czar, the ruler of the land of Magog and prince of Rosh, Meshech and Tubal, called Rosh in the Revised Version, who is the czar of Russia in the land of the czar.RH Apr 18, 1907ST May 31, 1905RH Jun 25, 1901 Magog, Meshech and Tubal were sons of Japheth who after the dispersion settled in the territory today occupied by the Russians.RH Apr 18, 1907RH Jun 25, 1901 From Magog descended the Scythians, Tartars and Avars, so that the land of Magog is Russia, Tartary and Siberia.RH Apr 18, 1907 From Rosh came the Roshans or Russians, from Meshech came the Moschi or Muscovites who founded Moscow, and the descendants of Tubal built Tobolsk east of the Ural Mountains, linked to Russia, Moscow and Tobolsk.RH Apr 18, 1907RH Jun 25, 1901
These tribes occupied the territory of Russia as roving barbarian bands for nearly three thousand five hundred years until the fourteenth century, when Ivan I united them, became virtually the founder of modern Russia and the first to assume the title of Grand Prince of all Russia, and is Gog, the chief prince of Meshech and Tubal.RH Apr 18, 1907 He first represented the Scythian peoples and their northern confederacy.RH Apr 18, 1907ST Apr 29, 1913 The names in Ezekiel 38:1-6 are descendants of Noah divided in the earth after the Flood as recorded by Moses in Genesis, to be studied by name and country together with other related scriptures, and Moses' more than three-thousand-year-old history of the dispersion is the oldest and most trustworthy account, verified by ethnology.ST May 4, 1904
The coalition led from the north by Russia, identified with Rosh, Meshech and Tubal, includes Persia, Ethiopia, Libya, Gomer and Togarmah.ST May 4, 1904ST Nov 3, 1914ST Dec 8, 1914 They are understood as Persia with Cush as Egypt, Put as Libya or Tripoli, Gomer as the Crimea, and Togarmah as the Armenians.ST Nov 3, 1914 They gather to seize territory and spoil in Turkish territory and the Holy Land, with Russia coming from the north with a mighty army into the Holy Land.ST Nov 3, 1914ST Dec 8, 1914
My people Israel against whom Gog is brought is not the Israelitish nation but God's people contingently dwelling safely in that day in a nation that guarantees religious liberty.ST May 11, 1904 In that day Gog comes against that nation like a storm to take a spoil, coming into the land brought back from war to pursue his own selfish ends.ST May 11, 1904ST May 11, 1904 When read with Ezekiel 38:11-12 no nation or country meets what is described except the United States.ST May 11, 1904 A nation is mentioned in Scripture only because of its connection with God's people, the salt of the earth.ST May 11, 1904
Timing and Prophetic Fulfillment
Ezekiel 38 and 39 concern Russia, with application to the closing years of the world's history.RH Nov 16, 1905 They show Russia and her international policy and ultimate destiny, in part already fulfilled and in much still to come to pass in the immediate future.ST May 4, 1904 The names Gog of the land of Magog, Meshech and Tubal, Persia, Ethiopia, Libya, Gomer and Togarmah are descendants of Noah divided in the earth after the Flood as recorded by Moses in Genesis, to be studied by name and country together with other related scriptures, and Moses' more than three-thousand-year-old history of the dispersion is the oldest and most trustworthy account, verified by ethnology.ST May 4, 1904 The events of Ezekiel 38:15-23 precede the final scenes of Gog's career in Ezekiel 39, and Gog is Russia, whose restraint comes before its final acts and ruin at the end of the world.ST May 18, 1904
The prophecy is conditional, and not all its details are fulfilled literally in one historical period.ST Dec 1, 1914 It would have been fulfilled in Israel's day if the people had met its conditions, but because they did not its fulfillment was deferred to the last days, under different conditions and on a broader, stronger, more glorious scale.ST Aug 26, 1913 God's purposes toward wicked nations and true Israel remain the same despite changed times and circumstances.ST Aug 2, 1905 Part of Ezekiel 38 and 39 will be fulfilled before Christ's second coming, as Revelation describes more clearly, and some will be fulfilled at the end of the thousand years.ST Dec 1, 1914 Gog and Magog, representing northern nations, will be punished partly in this world before and when Christ comes, and ultimately at the end of the thousand years, while Israel will be redeemed and receive the earth made new.ST Aug 2, 1905
The attack was spoken of in old time by God's servants the prophets of Israel who prophesied many years that God would bring this power against His people, meaning the earlier prophecies that God would bring an enemy from the north against Israel.ST Jul 8, 1930 Those names Gog, Magog, Rosh, Meshech and Tubal are used because from the standpoint of Palestine they stand for peoples from the north, the region whence ungodly enemies and oppressors came against Israel.ST Jul 8, 1930 It belongs to a prophecy of judgment against wicked nations that, under Satan's control, seek to destroy God's people.ST Oct 1, 1896 In final fulfillment they symbolize the forces of world evil under the leadership of Satan making the last effort to crush the redeemed people of God in their own land, the home of the redeemed, at the close of the thousand years of Revelation 20 after the unrighteous have been raised in the second resurrection and before their ultimate destruction in the final punishment of the wicked.ST Jul 8, 1930 Gog and Magog, who had oppressed God's people in the past, are associated with Satan's final gathering of the wicked after the thousand years; they are summoned to battle and will receive the final doom pronounced through the prophet.ST Aug 7, 1893
The attack against Israel was something God had spoken of beforehand through Israel's prophets.ST Dec 1, 1914 It belongs to a conditional promise: if Israel had been faithful, God would have brought them back to the land, destroyed the northern enemies described in Ezekiel 38-39 with plagues, and dwelt among them in glory.ST Dec 1, 1914 That attack would have taken place if God had given Israel the prosperity He intended for them, and the prophecy is not a literal prediction of an attack on Palestine in the last days.ST Apr 20, 1915 It was not to be fulfilled at the end of the thousand years, when national boundaries and distinctions would no longer exist, for national judgments take place before Christ comes.ST Dec 1, 1914 Ezekiel 38 describes combined armies that may resemble forces in future revolutions and may destroy lesser powers, but those events will not occur in the setting described by the prophecy.ST Apr 20, 1915 Its plagues, pestilence, hailstones, fire, and brimstone are judgments God pours out on the wicked who attack His people, and the setting of those judgments is disclosed more fully in Revelation.ST Apr 20, 1915
The prophecy is understood as especially mentioning Russia as the chief prince of Meshech and Tubal, called Rosh in the Revised Version.ST May 31, 1905 Japan is one of the means God is using to turn Russia back.ST May 31, 1905 The use of Ezekiel 38 to forecast Russia's destiny depends on the claim that the Jews will literally return to Palestine.RH Nov 16, 1905 Treating that return as a sign to watch for leads away from the third angel's message, and conflicting interpretations of the prophecy counsel waiting for more light before declaring Russia's destiny.RH Nov 16, 1905
Final Conflict and Present Application
The verse belongs to the outline of the gathering of the nations for the final universal war at Armageddon before Christ appears.RH Jan 26, 1905RH Apr 7, 1874ST Mar 1, 1877 The gathering of tribes and peoples under the czar is that prophetic gathering taking shape, and its wars and rumors of wars show the crisis and the Lord's appearing to be near.RH Jan 26, 1905RH Apr 7, 1874ST Mar 1, 1877 In that gathering Russia stands as guard or commander of the heathen powers associated with the dragon, which is paganism, roused for the final world crisis when the divisions of the world come into conflict.RH Nov 6, 1900 A future northern confederacy is to come against the southern power, with its head answering to the power outlined in Revelation 17.ST Apr 30, 1912
The last days are to be days of bloody strife, distress and carnage among the nations of the earth.RH Oct 8, 1857 Enemies of God rush from the north quarters like a storm against the mountains of Israel, and Jerusalem and the surrounding country bear the brunt of the nations' final attack just before Christ comes.RH Oct 8, 1857ST Oct 20, 1914 They then perish at the presence of God amid fire and brimstone, and the birds are called to feast on their carcasses.RH Oct 8, 1857 Christ appears to defeat and ruin them, and wars cease when He begins His reign.RH Apr 7, 1874ST Mar 1, 1877 This final slaughter leaves no room for a converted world before He comes to raise His people and sit in judgment on the human race.RH Oct 8, 1857
The invasion comes from the north with a mighty army into the Holy Land to be destroyed upon the mountains.ST Dec 8, 1914 It follows the driving of the Turks holding the Mohammedan religion from Europe, their temporary seat of government at Jerusalem, and the end of that empire with none to help it.ST Dec 8, 1914 Together with the union of Christian nations this arouses all heathen nations to concentrate their combined forces in the valley of Jehoshaphat north of Jerusalem for the final conflict.ST Dec 8, 1914 It belongs not to the present general European war for military and commercial supremacy but to the prelude to Armageddon, which will be a whole-world war for politico-religious supremacy.ST Dec 8, 1914 That final northern apostasy sweeps over the Holy Land with great power and destruction.ST Apr 30, 1912 Had Israel remained faithful they would have occupied Palestine when this invasion of the territory once occupied by Israel came, but being scattered the same evil plan seeks Palestine and also aims to destroy God's people scattered throughout the world.ST Nov 3, 1914
The tremendous final Gog and Magog war involving all the great nations of the earth is now close upon us.RH May 12, 1903 It is a conflict between the Cossack and the Anglo-Saxon that ends the era of war in one great collapse of navies and armies and national debts.RH May 12, 1903 Russia's determination to occupy Manchuria with Mongolia to follow in order to be free to turn its power to European Turkey marks the darkening sky and portentous shaping of events for this coming strife.RH May 12, 1903 With France taking the southern provinces, Great Britain acting on the Yangtse, and Germany increasing its holding until the ancient Chinese empire is a thing of the past, the sure word of prophecy points out this present position in its relation to things past and things to come.RH May 12, 1903 Russia's leadership and its growing influence over Persia, associated in the prophecy with the power from the north, is part of the nations lining up for Armageddon.RH Mar 24, 1903
Before the conflict God's message must be carried to those same peoples.RH Jan 26, 1905 As forces gather people for the final battle, gospel missionaries should gather God's people in Persia and nearby regions through the third angel's message.RH May 5, 1903 After that time there will be no religious liberty, but it will not matter because the end will have come.ST May 11, 1904 God will then deliver His people, every one whose name is written in the Lamb's book of life.ST May 11, 1904 What was promised to true Israel, faintly typified now, God will restore by His mighty power in the new heavens and new earth, when Israel is redeemed to receive the earth made new with future glory and immortal inheritance as described in later revelations.ST Oct 26, 1904ST Sep 20, 1910ST Aug 2, 1905
The destruction shown in Ezekiel 38 and 39 will occur in a place other than Gehenna, the valley of Hinnom.RH Aug 29, 1871 Gehenna has been and is to be a place of punishment by fire, and may again be so.RH Aug 29, 1871 That separate location proves the wicked are not now being punished in Gehenna and will never be kept alive there forever.RH Aug 29, 1871
Sources