Ezra 5:4
Then said we unto them after this manner, What are the names of the men that make this building?
Translations
American King James Version, Webster Bible
Then said we to them after this manner, What are the names of the men that make this building?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Then said we unto them after this manner, What are the names of the men that make this building?
Then spake we unto them after this manner, What are the names of the men that make this building?
Then we told them after this manner, what the names of the men were that were making this building.
Then thus we have said to them, 'What [are] the names of the men who are building this building?'
And they said to them after this manner: What are the names of the men that build this building?
Then, after this manner, spake we unto them,—What are the names of these men, who, this building, do rear?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
They also asked, “ What are the names of the men who are constructing this building?”
They also asked for the names of the men who were making this building.
Then they said these words to them: What are the names of the men who are at work on this building?
Then sayde we vnto them after this maner, What are the names of the men that buylde this buylding?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
In answer to which we gave them the names of the men who were the promoters of that building.
Cross-references
- Ezra 6:1-12
Then Darius the king made a decree, and search was made in the house of the rolls, where the treasures were laid up in Babylon.
Darius finds Cyrus’s decree and orders the rebuilding supported and completed.
- Ezra 1:1-4
Now in the first year of Cyrus king of Persia, that the word of the LORD by the mouth of Jeremiah might be fulfilled, the LORD stirred up the spirit of Cyrus king of Persia, that he made a proclamation throughout all his kingdom, and put it also in writing, saying,
Cyrus’s decree authorized the temple’s rebuilding.
- Ezra 6:14
And the elders of the Jews builded, and they prospered through the prophesying of Haggai the prophet and Zechariah the son of Iddo. And they builded, and finished it, according to the commandment of the God of Israel, and according to the commandment of Cyrus, and Darius, and Artaxerxes king of Persia.
Identifies the temple-building account as the setting for Haggai’s message.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
1 source
The verse records an official investigation of the rebuilding of the temple, in which provincial officers demanded to know the names of the men carrying out the building work.RH Dec 26, 1907 That inquiry came from men in authority and had the power to stop the work altogether, yet God kept watch over the Jewish elders through the danger.RH Dec 26, 1907 The elders gave a wise answer, and instead of halting the enterprise the officials sent the matter up to Darius for decision.RH Dec 26, 1907
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
12 sources
Ezra 5:4 records the demand of the Persian provincial officers, led by Tatnai and his deputation, for the names of the men rebuilding the temple, so that those responsible could be identified, their claim of royal authorization challenged, and their names reported to the king for investigation.ST Jun 2, 1909ST May 7, 1912ST Sep 6, 1910RH Feb 7, 1907ST Jun 14, 1910 The confrontation came when the work resumed in the second year of Darius Hystaspes, B.C. 520, after it had ceased, as Haggai and Zechariah stirred up the Jews to build and opposition arose as soon as building began again.ST Jul 14, 1887ST Feb 18, 1886ST Jan 9, 1893 The matter was carried to Darius by an honest letter from the governor with the Jews' report of Cyrus's earlier decree, a search of the records found that decree, and Darius confirmed and renewed it, commanding that the Jews be left alone and speedily helped with money from the tribute and treasury and with all needed supplies for the work and worship until the temple was finished in his sixth year.ST Jul 14, 1887ST Feb 18, 1886ST Sep 6, 1910 Although the inquiry by men in authority could have stopped the work, God watched over the elders, the officers made a fair inquiry and referred the case to Darius instead of halting the building, and the Jews answered wisely and kept building without fear in obedience to God.RH Dec 26, 1907ST Jun 14, 1910 That decree of Darius authorized the temple to go forward, but it did not extend the decree of Cyrus nor give the command to restore and rebuild Jerusalem that begins Daniel's prophetic period.ST Feb 25, 1886
Historical Context and Inquiry
The demand is for the names of the men making the building, to identify the individuals carrying out the interrupted work of rebuilding the temple after opposition had stopped it.RH Dec 26, 1907ST May 7, 1912ST Jun 14, 1910 It was put in the course of an investigation by the provincial officers into the Jews' rebuilding, asking who the builders were and who had authorized the work.RH Dec 26, 1907ST Jun 14, 1910 The inquiry by men in authority could have stopped the work, but God watched over the elders and they answered wisely.RH Dec 26, 1907 The builders continued without fear because they had faith to obey God.ST Jun 14, 1910
The questioners were Samaritan, Syrian, and Persian provincial officers, including Tatnai and his deputation, acting in the course of Tatnai's letter and reply.ST Sep 6, 1910RH Feb 7, 1907 They were investigating the rebuilding of the temple and city, challenging whether the Jews had authority to continue.ST Sep 6, 1910ST Feb 25, 1886 They asked for the builders' names so they could report them to the king. The letter from the governor of Syria to Darius asked him to investigate whether the Jews were telling the truth about a Persian decree authorizing the rebuilding.ST Jun 2, 1909 The Israelites reported that an earlier royal decree authorized the work, a search of the government records confirmed the report, and the king renewed the decree.
The confrontation belongs to the renewed opposition when the work resumed after ceasing about two years under Smerdis.ST Jul 14, 1887 Building restarted in the second year of Darius Hystaspes, B.C. 520, as Haggai and Zechariah stirred up the Jews to build, and the demand for names was part of the interference that came as soon as building began again.ST Jul 14, 1887ST Feb 18, 1886 Zechariah prophesied at Jerusalem to confirm Haggai, beginning between Haggai's second and third prophecies and speaking into the following year in the beginning of March 519 B.C., and through the prophesying of Haggai and Zechariah the Jews prospered in the work.ST Jan 9, 1893 The matter came before a new governor who was an honest man, and he sent Darius an honest account.ST Jul 14, 1887 That brought a decree not only to let the work go on but to help it speedily with money from the king's tribute and with bullocks, rams, and lambs, wheat, salt, wine, and oil, all that was needed at Jerusalem, the Jews were left alone and supplied with resources for the work and worship, and the temple was completed in Darius's sixth year.ST Jul 14, 1887ST Feb 18, 1886ST Sep 6, 1910
The questioning expresses the opposition of enemies and the discouragement of the Jews that held back the temple.ST Jan 23, 1893 The building was begun in 536 B.C. and was not finished until February 515 B.C. in the sixth year of Darius, a little over four years after Zechariah 1:7.ST Jan 23, 1893 It thus spanned twenty years, but for fifteen years nearly nothing was done.ST Jan 23, 1893 The troubles surrounding the rebuilding illustrate the difficult circumstances against which God promised Jerusalem peace and protection if the people remained obedient.ST Jun 21, 1883
Resolution and Significance
The questioning brought the matter before Darius after work that had ceased about two years under Smerdis was restarted in the second year of Darius Hystaspes, B.C. 520, when Haggai and Zechariah stirred up the Jews to build, and interference came as soon as building began again.ST Jul 14, 1887ST Feb 18, 1886ST Sep 6, 1910 The demand for the names of the builders was part of that renewed Samaritan attempt to stop the rebuilding of the temple at Jerusalem, pressed by a Samaritan deputation and by Persian officers investigating the rebuilding of the temple and city.ST Jul 14, 1887ST Sep 6, 1910 The matter came before a new governor who was an honest man, and he sent Darius an honest account and letter that laid the case fairly before the king.ST Jul 14, 1887ST Sep 6, 1910 That letter was followed by the Israelites' report that an earlier royal decree authorized the work, and a search of the government records confirmed the report by finding Cyrus's original decree.ST Feb 18, 1886ST Sep 6, 1910 Darius confirmed and renewed that decree, ordering that the Jews be left alone and that the work be helped speedily with money from the king's tribute and from the imperial treasury and with supplies for the work and worship, including bullocks, rams, and lambs, wheat, salt, wine, and oil, all that was needed at Jerusalem, and the temple was completed in Darius's sixth year.ST Jul 14, 1887ST Feb 18, 1886ST Sep 6, 1910
His decree authorized continuation of the temple work but did not extend Cyrus's decree nor provide the command to restore and rebuild Jerusalem that began Daniel's prophetic period.ST Feb 25, 1886
Although the inquiry by men in authority could have stopped the work, God watched over the elders and they answered wisely.RH Dec 26, 1907ST Jun 14, 1910 The officials made a fair-minded inquiry into who was leading the work and who had authorized it, asking for the builders' names so they could report them to the king, and they referred the matter to Darius rather than halting the work.RH Dec 26, 1907ST Jun 14, 1910 The Jews continued building without fear despite the attempt to halt it because they had faith to obey God.ST Jun 14, 1910
Sources