Ezra 5:9
Then asked we those elders, and said unto them thus, Who commanded you to build this house, and to make up these walls?
Translations
Then asked we those elders, and said to them thus, Who commanded you to build this house, and to make up these walls?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Then asked we those elders, and said unto them thus, Who commanded you to build this house, and to make up these walls?
Then we asked those elders, and said to them thus, Who commanded you to build this house, and to erect these walls?
Revised Version, American Standard Version
Then asked we those elders, and said unto them thus, Who gave you a decree to build this house, and to finish this wall?
Then we have asked of these elders, thus we have said to them, Who hath made for you a decree this house to build, and this wall to finish?
Then asked we those elders: thus we said to them, Who gave you orders to build this house and to complete this wall?
Then asked we of these elders, thus, we said to them,—Who hath issued to you an edict, this house, to build, and, this wall, to complete?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
So we questioned the elders and asked, “ Who authorized you to rebuild this temple and restore this structure?”
Then we asked those elders, and said to them thus, “ Who gave you a decree to build this house, and to finish this wall?”
Then we said to the men responsible, who gave you authority for the building of this house and these walls?
Then asked we those Elders, and sayd vnto them thus, Who hath giuen you commandement to buylde this house, and to lay the foundation of these walles?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And we asked those ancients, and said to them thus: Who hath given you authority to build this house, and to repair these walls?
Cross-references
- Ezra 6:1-12
Then Darius the king made a decree, and search was made in the house of the rolls, where the treasures were laid up in Babylon.
Darius finds Cyrus’s decree and orders the temple work to continue.
- Ezra 4:23-24
Now when the copy of king Artaxerxes’ letter was read before Rehum, and Shimshai the scribe, and their companions, they went up in haste to Jerusalem unto the Jews, and made them to cease by force and power.
Opposition brought a Persian order that stopped the temple work until Darius.
- Haggai 1:1-14
In the second year of Darius the king, in the sixth month, in the first day of the month, came the word of the LORD by Haggai the prophet unto Zerubbabel the son of Shealtiel, governor of Judah, and to Joshua the son of Josedech, the high priest, saying,
Haggai urges the people to resume building the temple.
- Ezra 5:1-2
Then the prophets, Haggai the prophet, and Zechariah the son of Iddo, prophesied unto the Jews that were in Judah and Jerusalem in the name of the God of Israel, even unto them.
The Jews resumed building the temple before the inquiry was made.
- Zechariah 4:6-10
Then he answered and spake unto me, saying, This is the word of the LORD unto Zerubbabel, saying, Not by might, nor by power, but by my spirit, saith the LORD of hosts.
God sustains the temple rebuilding and brings it to completion despite obstacles.
- Ezra 5:5
But the eye of their God was upon the elders of the Jews, that they could not cause them to cease, till the matter came to Darius: and then they returned answer by letter concerning this matter.
God watches over the builders while officials question them.
- Ezra 6:14
And the elders of the Jews builded, and they prospered through the prophesying of Haggai the prophet and Zechariah the son of Iddo. And they builded, and finished it, according to the commandment of the God of Israel, and according to the commandment of Cyrus, and Darius, and Artaxerxes king of Persia.
gives the prospered result of the work questioned in Ezra 5:9
- Ezra 1:1
Now in the first year of Cyrus king of Persia, that the word of the LORD by the mouth of Jeremiah might be fulfilled, the LORD stirred up the spirit of Cyrus king of Persia, that he made a proclamation throughout all his kingdom, and put it also in writing, saying,
original decree whose existence the letter questions
- Ezra 4:17-22
Then sent the king an answer unto Rehum the chancellor, and to Shimshai the scribe, and to the rest of their companions that dwell in Samaria, and unto the rest beyond the river, Peace, and at such a time.
An earlier complaint led to an order to stop the work.
- Ezra 4:7
And in the days of Artaxerxes wrote Bishlam, Mithredath, Tabeel, and the rest of their companions, unto Artaxerxes king of Persia; and the writing of the letter was written in the Syrian tongue, and interpreted in the Syrian tongue.
Contrasts an earlier stop order with the claimed permission to build.
- Ezra 4:1-5
Now when the adversaries of Judah and Benjamin heard that the children of the captivity builded the temple unto the LORD God of Israel;
Adversaries oppose the rebuilding of the temple.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
1 source
The challenge was addressed to the Jewish elders by the provincial officials, who demanded to know who had commanded them to build the house and to make up its walls.RH Dec 26, 1907 Their question called for the authority behind the rebuilding of the temple and the completion of its surrounding work.RH Dec 26, 1907 It came from men of high authority and carried a real threat of hindering the rebuilding.RH Dec 26, 1907
In that time of pressure the builders trusted the Lord for guidance.RH Dec 26, 1907 God's watchful care was over them, restraining the officials from stopping the work.RH Dec 26, 1907 They were kept from interference until the matter could be referred to Darius for decision.RH Dec 26, 1907
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
12 sources
Persian provincial officials, including Tatnai and his companions, demanded of the Jewish elders by whose authority they were rebuilding the temple and finishing its walls.ST Feb 18, 1886ST Sep 6, 1910RH Feb 7, 1907 The challenge came after the work had long ceased under a stop decree and the builders had resumed in the second year of Darius son of Hystaspes, in B.C. 520, when stirred up by the messages of Haggai and Zechariah.ST Jul 14, 1887ST Aug 23, 1899ST Jun 2, 1909 Though the inquiry by men of high authority threatened to hinder the work amid the opposition of adversaries, God's watchful care kept the officials from stopping the builders before the matter reached Darius, to whom an honest and fair report was sent.RH Dec 26, 1907ST Jul 14, 1887ST Apr 19, 1883ST Jun 21, 1883 The question led the elders to recount the temple's history and cite the decree of Cyrus, prompting a search of the Persian records that confirmed their claim and led Darius to renew the decree.ST Feb 18, 1886ST Sep 6, 1910ST Feb 25, 1886 The result was not only permission to go on but a command for speedy help from the king's tribute with money and with bullocks, rams, and lambs, wheat, salt, wine, and oil, so that through the prophesying of Haggai and Zechariah the Jews prospered.ST Jul 14, 1887ST Sep 6, 1910ST Jan 9, 1893
Setting and Inquiry
The verse records the direct challenge put by Persian provincial officials to the Jewish elders, asking by what authority they were rebuilding the house, that is the temple, and finishing its walls.ST Feb 18, 1886ST Sep 6, 1910 Those asking were Tatnai and his companions, with the governor over Syria, and Persian officers acting in the province.ST Jun 2, 1909RH Feb 7, 1907 Their question demanded to know who had commanded the work and who had ordered the walls to be made up or repaired.ST Jun 2, 1909RH Feb 7, 1907
The inquiry came after the temple work had languished and then ceased for about two years under a stop decree obtained from the impostor Smerdis.ST Jul 14, 1887ST Aug 23, 1899 That ruler is identified as Artaxerxes the pseudo-Smerdis, who obtained the kingdom by fraud and was slain in 522 B.C.ST Jul 14, 1887ST Jun 2, 1909 The builders resumed in the second year of Darius son of Hystaspes, who succeeded in 521 B.C., in B.C. 520, when stirred up through messages by Haggai and Zechariah to go on, so the verse belongs to the same period as Haggai's call to rebuild.ST Jul 14, 1887ST Aug 23, 1899ST Jun 2, 1909
In its wider chronology the building began in 536 B.C. and was finished in the sixth year of Darius in February 515 B.C., twenty years in all, but for fifteen years of that time nearly nothing was done because of the opposition of enemies and the discouragement of the Jews.ST Jan 23, 1893 The question arose amid Samaritan opposition and complaints from Israel's enemies, as adversaries sought to hinder Zerubbabel and Joshua in the renewed construction.ST Apr 19, 1883ST Sep 6, 1910ST Feb 25, 1886 It was included in a report or letter to King Darius, a fair report asking that search be made in the government records to see if the Jews were telling the truth that a Persian decree had authorized the rebuilding.ST Jun 2, 1909ST Sep 6, 1910ST Feb 25, 1886
Opposition and Providential Outcome
The demand to name who had authorized the rebuilding of the house and the finishing of its walls came from men of high authority and threatened to hinder the work.RH Dec 26, 1907ST Apr 19, 1883 It belongs to the period of trouble the Jews suffered while rebuilding Jerusalem and the temple at the hands of adversaries who sought to hinder Zerubbabel and Joshua.ST Apr 19, 1883ST Jun 21, 1883 Those difficulties made God’s promise of a peaceful, thriving city seem remarkable.ST Jun 21, 1883
The builders trusted the Lord for guidance under that pressure, and God’s watchful care kept the officials from stopping them before the matter reached Darius.RH Dec 26, 1907 The new governor over them was an honest man who sent Darius a fair and honest account of the matter in a report asking that search be made.RH Dec 26, 1907ST Jul 14, 1887 His question was part of that fair report to the king rather than a summary stop order.
The question led the elders to explain the temple’s history and to cite Cyrus’s decree for its restoration as their authority. It prompted an investigation and a search of the Persian government records to see if the Jews were telling the truth.ST Feb 18, 1886ST Feb 25, 1886 That search confirmed their claim and their answer, leading the king to renew the decree.ST Feb 18, 1886
The dispute thus resulted in the discovery of Cyrus’s decree and in a decree from Darius that did far more than let the work at Jerusalem go on.ST Jul 14, 1887ST Sep 6, 1910 The new decree ordered speedy help from the king’s tribute with money and with bullocks, rams, and lambs, wheat, salt, wine, and oil, all that was needed at Jerusalem.ST Jul 14, 1887 What had arisen amid Samaritan opposition and complaints from Israel’s enemies was turned into royal support for the rebuilding.ST Sep 6, 1910
The whole account in Ezra 5 and 6 shows the condition of affairs in Jerusalem when Zechariah came to confirm Haggai and reveal additional truth.ST Jan 9, 1893 He began to prophesy between the second and third recorded prophecies of Haggai, speaking the prophecy of the lesson in March 519 B.C.ST Jan 9, 1893 Through the prophesying of Haggai and Zechariah the Jews prospered in the temple work.ST Jan 9, 1893
Sources