Hosea 4:1
Hear the word of the LORD, ye children of Israel: for the LORD hath a controversy with the inhabitants of the land, because there is no truth, nor mercy, nor knowledge of God in the land.
Translations
Hear the word of the LORD, you children of Israel: for the LORD has a controversy with the inhabitants of the land, because there is no truth, nor mercy, nor knowledge of God in the land.
King James Version, Webster Bible, Revised Version
Hear the word of the LORD, ye children of Israel: for the LORD hath a controversy with the inhabitants of the land, because there is no truth, nor mercy, nor knowledge of God in the land.
Hear the word of the Lord, ye children of Israel:
For the Lord hath a controversy with the inhabitants of the land,
Because there is no truth, nor mercy, nor knowledge of God in the land.Hear the word of Jehovah, ye children of Israel; for Jehovah hath a controversy with the inhabitants of the land, because there is no truth, nor goodness, nor knowledge of God in the land.
'Hear a word of Jehovah, sons of Israel, For a strife [is] to Jehovah with inhabitants of the land, For there is no truth, nor kindness, Nor knowledge of God, in the land,
Hear the word of Jehovah, ye children of Israel; for Jehovah hath a controversy with the inhabitants of the land; for there is no truth, nor goodness, nor knowledge of God in the land.
Hear the word of Yahweh, ye sons of Israel,—that, a controversy, hath Yahweh with the inhabitants of the land, because there is no faithfulness, nor lovingkindness, nor knowledge of God, in the land:
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Hear the word of the LORD,
O children of Israel,
for the LORD has a case
against the people of the land:
“ There is no truth, no loving devotion,
and no knowledge of God in the land!Hear the LORD’s word, you children of Israel,
for the LORD has a charge against the inhabitants of the land:
“ Indeed there is no truth, nor goodness,
nor knowledge of God in the land.Give ear to the word of the Lord, O children of Israel; for the Lord has a cause against the people of this land, because there is no good faith in it, and no mercy and no knowledge of God in the land.
Heare the worde of the Lord, ye children of Israel: for the Lord hath a controuersie with the inhabitants of the lande, because there is no trueth nor mercie nor knowledge of God in the lande.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Hear the word of the Lord, ye children of Israel, for the Lord shall enter into judgment with the inhabitants of the land: for there is no truth, and there is no mercy, and there is no knowledge of God in the land.
Cross-references
- Hosea 4:6
My people are destroyed for lack of knowledge: because thou hast rejected knowledge, I will also reject thee, that thou shalt be no priest to me: seeing thou hast forgotten the law of thy God, I will also forget thy children.
Lack of knowledge and rejection of God’s law bring destruction.
- Jeremiah 25:31
A noise shall come even to the ends of the earth; for the LORD hath a controversy with the nations, he will plead with all flesh; he will give them that are wicked to the sword, saith the LORD.
Both describe the Lord’s controversy and judgment against the wicked.
- Hosea 6:6-7
For I desired mercy, and not sacrifice; and the knowledge of God more than burnt offerings.
God desires mercy and knowledge, yet Israel has broken the covenant.
- Jeremiah 4:22
For my people is foolish, they have not known me; they are sottish children, and they have none understanding: they are wise to do evil, but to do good they have no knowledge.
Both describe the people’s lack of knowledge of God.
- Hosea 12:2
The LORD hath also a controversy with Judah, and will punish Jacob according to his ways; according to his doings will he recompense him.
The Lord has a controversy with Judah and will punish Jacob for his deeds.
- Isaiah 59:14-15
And judgment is turned away backward, and justice standeth afar off: for truth is fallen in the street, and equity cannot enter.
Describes truth as fallen and failing.
- Proverbs 3:3
Let not mercy and truth forsake thee: bind them about thy neck; write them upon the table of thine heart:
Both texts connect truth and mercy with the life of God’s people.
- Titus 1:16
They profess that they know God; but in works they deny him, being abominable, and disobedient, and unto every good work reprobate.
People profess to know God but deny him by their actions.
- Exodus 20:1-17
And God spake all these words, saying,
Hosea identifies breaking the Ten Commandments as the cause of the LORD’s controversy.
- Proverbs 12:19
The lip of truth shall be established for ever: but a lying tongue is but for a moment.
Says truthful speech endures.
- Proverbs 23:23
Buy the truth, and sell it not; also wisdom, and instruction, and understanding.
Urges people to acquire truth and not give it up.
- Isaiah 26:2
Open ye the gates, that the righteous nation which keepeth the truth may enter in.
Speaks of a nation that keeps the truth.
- Psalms 15:2
He that walketh uprightly, and worketh righteousness, and speaketh the truth in his heart.
Describes speaking truth from the heart.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
17 sources
The Lord speaks to His people Israel to declare His controversy with them because truth and mercy and knowledge of Him are gone from the land, and their forgetting His law and multiplying transgression in falsehood and violence brings shame and punishment that falls upon the land and all living in it.PK 281.3PK 297.318MR 353.5–354.1 That same godless condition was fearfully fulfilled when the Scriptures were banished under Romish power, leaving priests and people without the light of God's law and giving free course to fraud and avarice and debauchery and bloodshed under moral and intellectual paralysis.4SP 64.3GC 60.2–3GC88 60.3 False shepherds who turn men from God's law to human theories produce that prevailing impiety, which marks the world in the present day and will meet its full judgment upon mystic Babylon.Ms 60, 1900, par. 17–18Ms 42, 1900, par. 4–6 The controversy centers on trampling God's law by human laws, especially in setting aside His memorial of creation for Sunday and demanding all conform to it though few honor His rest.Ms 163, 1897, par. 24–26 He therefore holds His people and His institutions accountable for selfishness and worldliness, calling them to purge defilement, seek Him diligently, and prepare for the coming of the Lord while repentance is still possible.Ms 101, 1901, par. 38–4110MR 352.3–353.2Ms 40, 1903, par. 30–31Ms 18, 1904, par. 25Lt 66, 1897, par. 6
Israel's Charge and Setting
Hear the word of the Lord is a message addressed to the children of Israel, warning that forgetting His law and increasing in transgression would bring shame and punishment.PK 281.3 It belongs to the time before the ten tribes went into captivity and before the northern kingdom fell, when the people disobeyed God and treated His law as worthless.PK 297.3RH Feb 26, 1914 Disregard for His law opened the way for widespread wickedness, including false swearing and lying and killing and stealing and adultery, until bloodshed spread through the land.PK 297.3RH Feb 26, 1914 That charge against Israel parallels the corruption of the world before the Flood and of Sodom, where lawlessness likewise reached the point of divine judgment.RH Feb 26, 1914
The absence of truth and mercy and knowledge of God in the land is the ground of the Lord's controversy with its inhabitants.PK 297.3RH Feb 26, 1914 That controversy leads to the consequences for transgression set out in the following verses, where the curse falls upon the land and its creatures.18MR 353.5–354.1 The curse grows as widespread and deep as the transgression itself.18MR 353.5–354.1
Later and Future Fulfillments
The absence of truth and mercy and knowledge of God in the land was fearfully and strikingly fulfilled in the world under Romish power at the noon of the papacy, when the word of God was banished.4SP 64.3GC 60.2–3GC88 60.3 With the Holy Scriptures almost unknown alike to people and priests, with papal leaders hating the light that would reveal sin, and with God's law as the standard of righteousness removed, there was no truth nor mercy nor knowledge of God in the land.GC 60.2–3 Banishing God's Word produced unlimited exercise of power and unrestrained vice, with fraud and avarice and profligacy prevailing and crimes committed to gain wealth or position.GC 60.2–3 The vilest debauchery filled the palaces of popes and prelates, while swearing and lying and killing and stealing and adultery broke out until blood touched blood.4SP 64.3GC 60.2–3GC88 60.3 For centuries there was no progress in learning or arts or civilization, under a moral and intellectual paralysis upon Christendom.GC 60.2–3
That condition comes from false shepherds turning people away from the laws of the kingdom of God to exalt their own theories and suppositions in opposition to God's law, producing prevailing impiety and growing wickedness.Ms 60, 1900, par. 17–18 The same word will be fulfilled in the future when their work reacts upon themselves and the judgment of God falls upon mystic Babylon.Ms 60, 1900, par. 17–18 The world without truth and mercy and knowledge of God, against whose inhabitants God brings a charge, characterizes the world in the present day.Ms 42, 1900, par. 4–6
God has a controversy with the inhabitants of the land because there is no truth and no knowledge of God among them, shown when those who trample upon God's law make human laws and force the people to accept them.Ms 163, 1897, par. 24–26 Men blinded by error take their words from the lips of priests and human lawmakers, devise and plan what to do, and suppose it does not matter if they do not keep the law of God instituted in Eden when the foundations of the earth were laid and all the sons of God shouted for joy.Ms 163, 1897, par. 24–26 This applies to demanding that the few in number conform to the laws of the land because the whole world keeps Sunday.Ms 163, 1897, par. 24–26 God's memorial was then given that man might honor the living God who made the world in six days and sanctified and blessed the day of His rest, and rejecting that memorial for Sunday is the controversy announced.Ms 163, 1897, par. 24–26
Accountability and Present Application
The Lord holds people accountable where there is no truth, nor mercy, nor knowledge of God in the land, and this accountability falls upon publishing houses whose commercial work and worldly ambition reveal an order of things He cannot accept, carrying with it a warning of loss.Ms 40, 1903, par. 30–31 The controversy is with managers of publishing houses and sanitariums for taking the position that the institutions with which they are connected are undenominational.Ms 18, 1904, par. 25 God has chosen Seventh-day Adventists as His peculiar people to stand on a high plane and carry forward His work, and to them, if they are faithful, He will make known His will.Ms 18, 1904, par. 25
Selfishness and covetousness mingled with every part of the Lord's work defile it and dishonor Him and must be purged.Ms 101, 1901, par. 38–41 Every institution is to stand in heaven-born righteousness, not dealing selfishly with another institution carrying a different line of God's work, but blending interests together.Ms 101, 1901, par. 38–41 It is a call to awake out of sleep and become workers together with God, not acting with anger and unchristlike deeds, but diligently seeking the Lord, studying His Word to know and do His will, calling on Him in great necessity, and showing repentance that needeth not to be repented of.Ms 101, 1901, par. 38–41 The state of the inhabitants of the land set forth in the chapter is connected with a message calling God's people to prepare for the coming of the Lord.10MR 352.3–353.2Lt 100, 1902, par. 10–11
The Lord has a controversy with people guilty of wrongdoing, as seen in His charge concerning Fannie and Caldwell over their conduct toward each other.Lt 114, 1897, par. 14–16 He brings a charge against people for departing from His principles, with His controversy directed at those whose conduct and decisions have brought embarrassment on His cause despite repeated warnings and counsel.Lt 66, 1897, par. 6 They are accountable for their actions, but repentance and a changed character are still possible.Lt 66, 1897, par. 6
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
31 sources
The Lord brings a legal charge against the inhabitants of the land because truth and mercy and the knowledge of God are gone from among them.ST Feb 3, 1887ST Mar 31, 1914ST Aug 21, 1907 That lack is shown in open wickedness of false swearing and broken faith, killing, stealing and adultery, with bloodshed following upon bloodshed.ST Feb 3, 1887ST Mar 31, 1914ST Aug 21, 1907 The knowledge at issue is knowledge of Him as Creator, kept in remembering and hallowing the Sabbath as the memorial of creation, so that to forget and reject the fourth commandment is in practice to deny Him.RH Sep 30, 1852RH Sep 30, 1852RH Sep 30, 1852 The charge belongs to the time when the day of the Lord and the end of the world are near, even at hand.ST Feb 3, 1887ST Mar 31, 1914ST Oct 29, 1912 Its real cause is transgression of the Ten Commandments, bringing judgment upon land and living creatures in the seven last plagues, while storms, earthquakes, famines, pestilences, fires, floods and distress are God's voice solemnly calling the nation to repentance.RH Sep 30, 1852ST Dec 5, 1916ST Nov 14, 1906ST Oct 29, 1912ST Dec 17, 1874
Words and Historical Setting
Hear is God speaking directly to his people in Scripture, and it is to be read with solemnity and reverence.RH Nov 28, 1912 The Lord's controversy is a legal charge or case against the inhabitants of the land, brought because there is no truth, nor mercy or goodness, nor knowledge of God in the land.ST Feb 3, 1887ST Mar 31, 1914ST Aug 21, 1907ST Jun 9, 1914ST Jul 26, 1899 The knowledge at issue is knowledge of him as Creator, connected with remembering and hallowing the Sabbath as the memorial of creation.RH Sep 30, 1852
The verse belongs to the message of Hosea, whose name means salvation, the last of the great prophets of the northern kingdom, with chapters 4-14 written about 734.ST Sep 2, 1913 It exposes the sad moral degeneration and decay of the nation, including the gross iniquity of priests and princes.ST Sep 2, 1913 It stands within a prediction of the coming captivity of the tribes and a warning against alliance with Egypt, with the prophet's own painful personal history symbolizing Jehovah's separation from his people.ST Sep 2, 1913 It also opens a prophecy that warns against wickedness and foretells coming captivity, yet includes hopeful remonstrance and tender appeals.ST Sep 2, 1913ST Dec 1, 1909
The charge is especially directed against Ephraim, though Judah is also reproved; Judah is treated more favorably, while Ephraim's sin is described as beyond recall.ST Mar 2, 1904 The lack of truth, mercy, and knowledge of God marks spiritual unfaithfulness and apostasy, rather than lawful use of civil laws for temporal matters.RH Aug 28, 1860 The same lack is cited in connection with oppression of the poor and perversion of justice.RH Jun 16, 1868
Sin and Divine Judgment
The absence of truth and mercy and knowledge of God does not remain inward but breaks out in open public wrongdoing, named in the next verse as swearing and lying or breaking faith, killing and stealing and adultery, with blood touching blood.ST Mar 31, 1914ST Aug 21, 1907ST Mar 2, 1904 That catalogue marks a time of extreme wickedness, when violence and theft and adultery are widespread and bloodshed follows upon bloodshed.ST Feb 3, 1887ST Aug 21, 1907ST Feb 17, 1898ST Feb 3, 1898 Applied to the present, the same indictment exposes increasing crime and social disorder as the sign of coming calamities.ST Feb 3, 1887ST Feb 17, 1898ST Feb 3, 1898
The charge comes while religious office and profession still continue, yet priests and prophets stumble, reject knowledge, forget God's law and feed upon the sin of the people.ST Jun 9, 1914 Because Israel has forgotten the law and multiplied transgression, its glory is turned to shame, and people and priests together are punished for their ways.RH Jan 29, 1914ST Jun 9, 1914
Human sin in this prophecy draws the land itself into mourning and languishing, bringing suffering and loss upon people and animals together.ST Mar 31, 1914ST Apr 27, 1904 The threatened judgment therefore reaches beyond the inhabitants to beasts and birds and fishes.RH Sep 30, 1852 That wasting of the land and its creatures is also read as the destruction brought by the seven last plagues, and diseased animals in the present are taken as the consequence of the very conditions Hosea describes.ST Jul 26, 1899ST Apr 27, 1904RH Sep 30, 1852
The knowledge of God that is lacking is knowledge of Him as Creator, bound up with remembering and hallowing the Sabbath as the memorial of creation.RH Sep 30, 1852 Want of true Sabbath observance demonstrates the charge, for few even among professed Sabbathkeepers grasp that the Sabbath was instituted to reveal and perpetuate knowledge of the Creator.RH Sep 30, 1852RH Sep 30, 1852 Forgetting and rejecting the fourth commandment, which identifies God as Creator, makes the law void and denies God in practice even where men profess to know Him.RH Sep 30, 1852
Ignorance and forgetfulness furnish no excuse for lack of knowledge, and when the Lord takes up His controversy the land and its inhabitants suffer under it.RH Dec 25, 1860 Though He is merciful and patient, those who persist in breaking His law will not stand when He rebukes them, for He sees unbelief and hypocrisy, pride and selfishness and disobedience, and will punish them.ST Mar 12, 1894 He can have no harmony with those who reject His commandments and lead children and neighbors into transgression, and a church that sets aside God's commandments by its traditions encourages sinners in wrongdoing.ST Mar 12, 1894
The charge against Israel stands alongside the corruption of the world before the Flood and of Sodom, where disregard for God's law opened the way to lawlessness until it reached the point of divine judgment.RH Feb 26, 1914 Before the northern kingdom fell that same disregard produced false swearing and lying, killing and stealing, adultery and bloodshed.RH Feb 26, 1914 The controversy is God's protest against sin, by which He confronts evildoers and may use mighty judgments to awaken them to their condition and lead them to righteousness and salvation, judgments that display His power as signs of the end of earthly things.ST Dec 5, 1916ST Dec 5, 1916
Prophecy for the Last Days
Hosea 4:1 describes the time when the day of the Lord and the end of the world are near, for the Lord's controversy with the inhabitants of the land belongs to the latter days and is near at hand.ST Feb 3, 1887ST Mar 31, 1914ST Sep 2, 1913 Chronological calculation and the general appearance of the world show that the events of the latter days have come, and the absence of truth, mercy, and knowledge of God, with increasing wickedness, violence, theft, adultery, swearing, lying, killing and stealing, is applied to the troubled conditions of the time.ST Feb 3, 1887ST Mar 31, 1914ST Sep 2, 1913 The land and its people mourning and languishing under swearing, lying, killing, stealing, adultery and bloodshed is the warning for that troubled age, and destructive storms and other disasters are consequences of the earth's degradation under sin warning that the end is near.ST Mar 31, 1914ST Oct 29, 1912
The charge that there is no truth, mercy, and knowledge of God in the land is applied to the moral condition of the present age, with increasing crime, violence, theft, bloodshed and social disorder presented as evidence of a society lacking truth and godliness.ST Apr 27, 1904ST Feb 17, 1898ST Feb 3, 1898ST Jul 26, 1899 That crime and disorder are a sign of coming calamities, and the times are marked by widespread moral corruption that dulls the sense of sin and makes wrongdoing seem ordinary.ST Feb 17, 1898RH Sep 14, 1869 The real cause identified is transgression of God's Ten Commandments, as applied to the earthquake in Chile of November 14, 1906.ST Nov 14, 1906 The threatened judgment extending beyond the inhabitants to the beasts, birds, and fish is applied to the destruction brought by the seven last plagues.RH Sep 30, 1852
In its setting the charge accompanies widespread wrongdoing while human sin is connected with the land's mourning and with suffering and loss among people and animals.ST Jul 26, 1899ST Apr 27, 1904 That moral corruption is linked to sickness and loss among people and animals, and diseased animals, such as consumption in dairy cows with its flesh-eating consequences, are identified as a consequence of the conditions Hosea describes.ST Jul 26, 1899ST Apr 27, 1904
The Lord has a controversy with the wicked inhabitants of the land because wickedness has displaced truth, mercy, and knowledge of God, and this controversy is a protest against sin in which God confronts sin and may use mighty judgments to awaken people to their condition and lead them to righteousness and salvation.ST Dec 5, 1916ST Oct 29, 1912ST Dec 5, 1916 Thunder, clouds, winds, locusts, drought, earthquakes, famines, pestilences, fires, floods, storms, destructive storms and financial distress are dispensations by God's hand connected with those sins and consequences of the earth's degradation under sin.ST Oct 29, 1912ST Dec 17, 1874 These calamities are the voice of God solemnly calling the nation to repentance, demonstrating His power as signs of the end of earthly things, as similar calamities occurred in connection with great events in the history of redemption, preceded the destruction of Jerusalem, and will precede manifestations of the kingdom of God until Christ's final coming at the end of the world.ST Dec 17, 1874RH Sep 29, 1874ST Dec 5, 1916 Looking for much but bringing in little happens because God blows upon it, and it is the duty of ministers of religion and conductors of the religious press to interpret these signs of the times to the people, with such times as the auspicious season above all others for lovers of Christ and country to lift up a testimony for truth and press forward every movement of reform.ST Dec 17, 1874RH Sep 29, 1874
Sources