This so-called wisdom is wisdom only by bitter irony, for it is the lowest and most degrading kind the mind can conceive and the direct opposite of what is heavenly.RH Oct 13, 1868RH Nov 24, 1874 It does not come down from God above but comes from below and beneath, belonging wholly to this passing world that lasts only a few years and offers nothing beyond this life.RH May 3, 1906ST Jul 9, 1912RH Sep 14, 1869RH Jul 16, 1901RH Jun 23, 1868 It is animal and natural, governed by selfish desire and human passion rather than by God, and it shares the selfish character of Satan who loves only those who love in return.RH Apr 1, 1873RH May 3, 1870ST Mar 4, 1903ST Nov 1, 1905 In contrast to the wisdom from above that is pure, peaceable, gentle, open to reason, merciful, fruitful and sincere, it is known by bitter envy and strife in the heart, and where it rules there is confusion and every evil work.ST Oct 30, 1901RH Dec 16, 1915RH Dec 13, 1906 It must therefore be detected and abandoned as a deadly foe to true religion, for it corrupts thought, poisons speech, breeds division among believers, and can never enter the way of holiness.RH Dec 13, 1906ST Jan 8, 1902ST Aug 5, 1897ST Oct 10, 1878
Meaning of Its Words
To call this principle wisdom is sarcastic irony that exposes its wretchedness, for it is the lowest, most censurable and degrading kind of wisdom the mind can conceive, the most strikingly opposite to heavenly wisdom.RH Oct 13, 1868RH Nov 24, 1874 It works by envy and strife, which are distressingly injurious if not destructive to any enterprise they are used against, with the injury measured by the strength of the evil disposition shown, especially when exercised within the same brotherhood and community.RH Oct 13, 1868RH Nov 24, 1874 Those who use it gain nothing except injury to those they hated and should have loved, and hindrance to the excellent principles they should have shown in their lives, gaining only the displeasure of God and the approval of wicked spirits and of the kind of men nations abhor.RH Oct 13, 1868RH Nov 24, 1874 What looks like gain is only a loss too great for finite minds to estimate.RH Oct 13, 1868RH Nov 24, 1874
This wisdom does not descend from above and does not come from God, but comes from below and from beneath.ST Oct 5, 1882RH Sep 14, 1869RH Jun 23, 1868PGGC 113.2RH Jan 23, 1900 It is not the wisdom that leads to true freedom, which comes through obedience to God.RH Sep 14, 1869 Supernatural phenomena and miracles do not prove a divine source, for such wisdom may affirm part of the truth while urging rejection of another part.PGGC 113.2RH Jan 23, 1900 Its pleasure is a cherished bodily appetite rather than hunger for righteousness, holiness, or God's presence, as in dependence on tea, coffee, tobacco, opium, or alcohol, which deadens natural sensibilities, makes a person less open to the Holy Spirit, and weakens zeal in worship.ST Oct 5, 1882 Popular fiction that draws people from Scripture and God is the opposite of what comes from heaven.RH Jun 23, 1868
It is earthly because it belongs wholly to this world, is self-centered and transient, lasting only a few years and offering nothing beyond this life.RH May 3, 1906ST Jul 9, 1912 It can be gained in great measure yet cannot save its possessor from perishing at the day of God, in contrast to wisdom that gives greatest attention to preparing for eternal life.ST Jul 9, 1912 Though the world counts this earthly wisdom the highest and best, the principal thing, God calls it foolishness.RH Jul 16, 1901 The only correct understanding of anything is to know it as God teaches it, and pure wisdom and true understanding come by faith only as all His children are taught by Him, so without faith there can be but little true understanding, and in the last days misunderstanding will increase as knowledge increases even when much truth is taught.RH Jul 16, 1901 Reading James 3 is needful when a person cannot have his own way, for its lesson is to control the tongue and reject selfish, contentious wisdom.RH May 3, 1906
It is sensual or psychical because it is animal and natural, fitted to animal existence and governed by selfish desires and human affections and passions rather than by God.RH Apr 1, 1873ST Mar 4, 1903ST Sep 21, 1882 Wisdom arising from bitter envy and strife and producing division and harmful speech is therefore earthly, driven by selfish human desires, and devilish, producing confusion and every evil work.ST Mar 4, 1903 It is devilish because it is like the wisdom demons may have and partakes of the devil's qualities.RH Apr 1, 1873RH May 3, 1870 Envy of this kind can blind people and drive them to outward crimes even to murder, and its destructive power is checked only by God's power and providence.RH May 3, 1870 It is the selfish love possessed by Satan and his servants, who love only those who love in return, not self-renouncing but selfish, lower than the love God plants in the soul and sheds abroad in the heart by the Holy Spirit, which is higher, purer and holier, loving a rebellious world and enemies so that it gave Jesus to die that sinners might choose life.ST Nov 1, 1905
Earthly, sensual and devilish are synonymous terms for what is incompatible with Christ.ST Jan 8, 1902ST Aug 5, 1897 What is earthly and devilish does not belong to Christ, so His followers are not to belong to the world or conform to it.ST Jan 8, 1902 The reasoning, love, principle, or logic that seeks to blend righteousness with unrighteousness, light with darkness, Christ with Belial, faith with infidelity, and the temple of God with idols must be abandoned and cast out of the heart as a deadly foe.ST Aug 5, 1897 Religion shaped by the world and the flesh and driven by sense rather than by God and the Spirit is therefore not true heavenly religion.ST Oct 10, 1878 The way of holiness is so high that nothing earthly, sensual, or devilish can enter it, but God cleanses the sinful, gives a new heart and spirit, and enables the redeemed to walk in that way.RH Apr 23, 1901
It is the false knowledge Adam and Eve gained by disobedience when the serpent deceptively promised they would be as gods knowing good and evil.ST Apr 13, 1904 They already knew good before disobeying, and disobedience added only a knowledge of evil that displaced the wisdom from above they had possessed, which is love, joy and peace, leaving humanity in a mixed condition of good and evil with evil greatly in the ascendancy.ST Apr 13, 1904 Sin does not raise people to a higher state but debases them, for Adam sought elevation through sin and found that sin could only degrade him into what is earthly, sensual, and devilish.RH May 12, 1874 Transgression darkens the mind and effaces God's image in humanity into this fallen nature.ST Dec 4, 1901 Jacob shows this earthly wisdom when his wisdom passes from heavenly vision into quick-witted scheming, for he was both a hero of faith and a schemer, a type found among Gentiles no less than among Jews.RH Aug 26, 1902 In the present day the same earthly wisdom appears as prudential vices that mar what would otherwise be worthy of praise and most formidably tempt the religious temperament, so that the man who thanks God that he is not like worldlings or other men falls short of even the excellences they possess, yet the religious temperament with all its faults can pass into the matured holiness of one who is not religious only but godly.RH Aug 26, 1902
Contrast With Heavenly Wisdom
This wisdom stands in direct opposition to the wisdom from above, which is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, easy to be entreated, full of mercy and good fruits, without partiality and without hypocrisy.ST Oct 30, 1901ST Oct 20, 1898RH Dec 16, 1915RH Dec 13, 1906 That heavenly wisdom is merciful and fruitful, open to reason and sincere, marked by purity, peace, gentleness, mercy and righteousness, while the earthly wisdom is false and must be detected and rejected in favor of God's wisdom.ST Oct 30, 1901ST Jan 11, 1883RH Mar 18, 1902RH Dec 16, 1915ST Feb 15, 1899 Wisdom used to justify cruel experimentation on helpless people belongs to the wisdom from below, not to the peaceable, gentle, open, merciful and fruitful wisdom God gives.ST Feb 15, 1899
True wisdom is proved by good conduct with meekness of wisdom, not by bitter envying and strife in the heart with glorying and lying against the truth.ST Oct 20, 1898ST Feb 13, 1901RH May 7, 1867 Where envying and strife rule there is confusion and every evil work, opposite to unity and harmony, and unless every fiber of that root of bitterness is eradicated it defiles many and kills spirituality by selfishness and self-sufficiency that treats others harshly.ST Oct 20, 1898ST Feb 13, 1901 The fruit of righteousness is sown in peace by those who make peace, keeping believers perfectly joined together in the same mind and judgment with no divisions.ST Oct 20, 1898ST Feb 13, 1901 Outward agreement with God's Word is not enough to prove a person right, for the kind of spirit shown in the heart reveals the source of the wisdom claimed.RH Jan 10, 1907RH Jan 10, 1907 Envy and strife and a boastful proud spirit reveal wisdom that does not come from God, so the heart must be humbled before Him and submitted to His leading.RH Jan 10, 1907RH Jan 10, 1907
Worldly wisdom belongs wholly to this world, can be gained in great measure, and is transient, lasting only a few years and offering nothing beyond this life, in contrast to wisdom that gives greatest attention to preparing for eternal life.ST Jul 9, 1912ST Mar 24, 1881RH Jul 16, 1901 Those shaped by it are honored and applauded by people, while those who live by godly wisdom may be treated as low and contemptible as they follow the path to heaven.ST Jul 9, 1912ST Mar 24, 1881 It cannot save its possessor from perishing at the day of God, and though the world counts this earthly wisdom the highest and best, the principal thing, God calls it foolishness.ST Jul 9, 1912RH Jul 16, 1901 The only correct understanding of anything is to know it as God teaches it, and pure wisdom and true understanding come by faith only, so that without faith there can be but little true understanding, and in the last days when there is little faith misunderstanding will increase even as knowledge increases and much truth is taught.RH Jul 16, 1901 Unlike wisdom from below, the wisdom that leads to true freedom comes through obedience to God, and it belongs with the life-giving religion of Jesus Christ rather than corrupt worldly wisdom.RH Sep 14, 1869ST May 26, 1898
It is also marked by pride, criticism, worldly aims, selfishness, self-sufficiency and independence.ST Nov 12, 1885ST Jan 11, 1883RH Jan 10, 1907 Its manner is boastful, defiant and contentious, seeking personal victory and triumph and pressing its views even on unwilling hearers.ST Oct 30, 1901RH Jan 10, 1907RH Nov 6, 1856ST Oct 12, 1876ST Nov 27, 1884 The kind of spirit shown reveals the source of the wisdom claimed, and such traits show communion with an evil spirit rather than with God.ST Jan 11, 1883RH Jan 10, 1907 Humble servants instead need love, unity, humility and willingness to learn from others, with a humble heart and true purpose to discern truth from falsehood.ST Nov 12, 1885
Where this wisdom rules there is confusion and every kind of evil work.ST Oct 30, 1901RH Dec 16, 1915RH Dec 13, 1906ST Mar 4, 1903 Spreading fellow believers' faults and stirring discord show love is not burning as it should. Jealousy and faction help cause alienation among believers.RH Dec 13, 1906
It works by envy and strife to injure or even destroy any enterprise it is turned against, with the injury measured by the strength of the evil disposition, especially when exercised within the same brotherhood and community.RH Oct 13, 1868RH Nov 24, 1874 It injures those who should have been loved and hinders excellent principles that should have been lived out.RH Oct 13, 1868RH Nov 24, 1874 Those who use it gain nothing but God's displeasure and the approval of wicked spirits and of the kind of men nations abhor, so what looks like gain is a loss too great for finite minds to estimate.RH Oct 13, 1868RH Nov 24, 1874
Envy blinds the mind, perverts judgment, and drives people to outward crimes, even to murder.RH May 3, 1870RH May 3, 1870 It also drives toward lies, rebellion and plots against the innocent, and stirs up slander, detraction, treachery, falseness, hypocrisy, bitterness, wrath and other uncharitable acts.ST Nov 28, 1892RH May 3, 1870 Its destructive power, which can take hold in every rank including rulers and the wealthy, is checked only by God's power and providence.RH May 3, 1870RH May 3, 1870 It must not remain in the heart even as a secret wish for another's failure or harm, and meekness and submission to God's will are needed to escape it.ST Nov 28, 1892RH May 3, 1870
Its spirit corrupts thoughts and the whole person and produces evil rather than righteousness.ST Mar 3, 1887 Delaying the pursuit of heavenly wisdom lets that corruption grow until unchecked lust ends in death.ST Mar 3, 1887 Fixing the heart on worldly gain or other finite goods degrades the soul and weakens the intellect, while selfish pursuit of wealth narrows a person and indulgence of appetite and passion debases the whole nature, perverts judgment and resists truth, descending into vice and folly when the will is surrendered to Satan.ST Oct 7, 1913ST Mar 3, 1887
It produces poisoned speech and discord from an unconverted heart, for sweet and bitter water cannot come from a pure source. A person cannot bless God and curse people made in God's likeness as though both came from a pure fountain. Evil-speaking, accusing and fault-finding display Satan's spirit rather than Christ's, and believers are called to guard the tongue and live peaceably.ST Sep 19, 1900 It belongs with hypocritical judging that sees the mote in a brother's eye while blind to the beam in one's own eye, and with the untamed tongue that defiles and sets on fire, which only the Lord's help can bring into subjection to Christ.RH Oct 29, 1901
Envy grows when virtue corrupted by vain-glory turns to pride and pride poisoned by malice becomes envy.RH Dec 15, 1859 It makes another person's happiness a torment and turns God's blessing into a curse, resting on overestimating what others enjoy, so that knowing how little others truly enjoy would take envy out of the world.RH Dec 15, 1859 Humility joined with virtue leaves no footing for pride and no entrance for envy.RH Dec 15, 1859 Envy that resents another's lot is devilish and must be rejected by accepting God's will and doing the work of one's own situation, for jealousy and envy of a neighbor's success bring more inner bitterness than any outside enemy.ST Mar 3, 1898RH Apr 25, 1871ST Jan 27, 1881
The verse is cited in connection with the heart as the fountain of thought, where a pure heart produces pure thoughts.ST Oct 30, 1901 Its strife for higher place, rooted in hearts blinded by riches, showed the apostolic congregations already touched by error and division, as false wisdom from below rather than from God.ST Aug 24, 1904
Doctrinal Errors Exposed
This wisdom is the wisdom imparted by Spiritualism, skillfully adapted to deceive all classes while its true character is concealed when concealment suits the purpose, presented to persons of culture and refinement in refined and intellectual aspects to draw them into the snare.RH Sep 11, 1916 It comes in the most attractive manner as an angel of light, appealing to reason by elevating themes, delighting fancy, enlisting the affections by love and charity, and exciting the imagination to lofty flights.RH Sep 11, 1916 So it leads men to pride in their own wisdom until they despise the Eternal One and have their senses perverted unless shielded by divine power.RH Sep 11, 1916
It is also the wisdom of occult and psychic pursuits pursued apart from instruction of the Bible, and claims of scientific investigation do not make it godly.RH Mar 17, 1859RH Dec 21, 1905 It is seen in obscure unintelligible communications of familiar spirits, whose voice is low like speech from the dust and brings confusion, mystery and darkness rather than clear light and wisdom.RH Mar 17, 1859 It works through mediums, dreams, impersonations, and knowledge of past or future events that may affirm part of the truth while urging rejection of another part.PGGC 113.2 Supernatural phenomena and miracles do not prove a divine source, for such manifestations may come from beneath rather than from God.PGGC 113.2RH Jan 23, 1900
It is the wisdom of rationalism that elevates human reason over Scripture and denies the living, personal, ruling God, belonging to the sphere of the psyche and like what demons may have.RH Apr 1, 1873 It is reasoning used to justify disobedience to God's truth by human arguments that portray God as ignorant or short-sighted or claim He made an institution for humanity that could not be universally enjoyed.RH Feb 3, 1852 It is wisdom shaped by human expediency rather than obedience, judging whether God's law should be obeyed by human ideas of what is proper or convenient.RH Oct 31, 1854 Scripture and the general principles of divine law guide conduct, and human judgment may rightly determine how to apply those principles where Scripture gives no specific rule, but not whether to carry them out.RH Oct 31, 1854
It is the reasoning that urges delaying obedience to a clear divine command by deferring to learned interpreters skilled in explaining away God's law.ST Aug 2, 1877ST Mar 18, 1886RH Jun 12, 1856 With regard to the Sabbath as the subject of direct and unequivocal command, the plea that one may be mistaken about duty and therefore should delay belongs to that earthly wisdom, and its object is to induce deference to men of learning instead of obeying the plain command to keep holy the seventh day.ST Jun 25, 1874ST Jun 10, 1875RH Aug 19, 1852 Practical duties are stated in very simple language so plainly that ordinary people, those of small intellectual capacity as well as those of expanded powers, and children as well as those of mature age, can understand and decide for themselves, because everyone must give account for himself and not another for him.ST Aug 2, 1877ST Jun 25, 1874
It is human-devised wisdom used to justify observing the first day in honor of the resurrection when Scripture does not instruct this observance, and a course's legitimacy must be tested by Scripture.ST Mar 20, 1893 It is wisdom resting on the unrevealed claim that redemption is greater than creation to justify keeping resurrection day instead of the Sabbath, which has not been revealed by God, does not establish which day God requires, and cannot turn human choice into obedience to the commandment to keep the seventh day.RH Oct 23, 1856 The same earthly, sensual, devilish description applies to forces opposed to the shamefully abused Sabbath truth.RH Jul 21, 1863 It marks the pope's courteous appeal for Protestants to return to Rome as worldly rather than Christian wisdom, for Christian wisdom is reverence for God that treats His will as wisest, keeps His commandments, and rests on God's word in Christ rather than on any Protestant, Roman, or other human creed.ST Aug 20, 1894
It is wisdom opposed to God's word coming from below, seen in popular fiction as the opposite of what comes from heaven and a corrupting influence drawing people from Scripture and God.RH Jun 23, 1868 It is godless ingenuity inventing weapons and preparations for war, advancing strife rather than peace.RH Jun 9, 1868 It is displayed in worldly church entertainments and money-raising practices with a carnal fleshly spirit rather than true spirituality, where churches replenish the treasury and reach the purse only by appeal to appetite through fairs and scenic performances.RH Aug 3, 1876ST Jun 10, 1880 That idea that God is best served by ministering to the flesh teaches people to purchase pleasure instead of loving the Lord and cuts charity up by the roots.ST Jun 10, 1880
It marks the vain imaginations and opposition to Christ by the Jewish leaders, who professed belief in the sacrifices pointing to the Lamb of God yet rejected Christ and shut their eyes to the meaning of the system.ST Nov 7, 1892 It identifies wisdom leading people to break God's law and indulge sinful desires as incompatible with the Spirit of God and its fruit.RH Feb 20, 1900 James condemned such sinful conduct on the basis of the same moral law rather than a new code of morals, so righteous people must avoid what is filthy and polluting.ST Sep 2, 1889
Life and Fellowship Applied
Christ's servants must reject self-sufficiency and independence, cultivating instead love, unity, humility and willingness to learn from others, for a humble heart with true purpose discerns truth from falsehood and distinguishes earthly selfish wisdom from wisdom from above.ST Nov 12, 1885 Jealousy and faction cause alienation among believers, and wisdom marked by bitter jealousy does not come from God but is earthly, sensual and devilish, in contrast to the pure, peaceable, gentle and merciful wisdom from above whose presence brings confusion and evil deeds.RH Dec 13, 1906 Wisdom marked by envy, suspicion, faultfinding and evil surmising is not from God but is earthly, sensual and devilish, and cherishing it weakens believers spiritually, hinders God's work, brings confusion and evil work, and damages the church's witness.RH Feb 25, 1904 Wisdom joined to bitter envying and strife in the heart, with glorying and lying against the truth, does not come from above but is earthly, sensual and devilish, and is the root of bitterness that breaks Christian unity and harmony.ST Feb 13, 1901
Unless every fiber of that root of bitterness is eradicated it defiles many and kills spirituality by selfishness and self-sufficiency that treats others harshly, for where this wisdom rules there is confusion and every evil work, opposite to wisdom from above which is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, easy to be entreated, full of mercy and good fruits, without partiality and without hypocrisy, whose fruit of righteousness is sown in peace by peacemakers.ST Feb 13, 1901 The chapter's teaching about the tongue calls believers to guard their speech and live peaceably, for wisdom that produces division and harmful speech is not from God but is earthly, driven by selfish desires, and devilish. Reading James 3 is the remedy when a person cannot have his own way, pointing to controlling the tongue and rejecting selfish, self-centered, contentious and devilish wisdom that does not come from above.RH May 3, 1906 Personal attacks and bitter assaults on character marked by envy, jealousy or malice reveal this evil earthly, sensual and devilish source, not zeal for the Lord.RH Dec 14, 1869
Envy and strife in the heart produce a false wisdom not from God, bringing confusion and every evil work, and its presence among Christians signals that love is not burning as it should, shown especially in spreading fellow believers' faults and stirring discord. Evil-speaking, accusing and faultfinding display Satan's spirit rather than Christ's, for wisdom opposed to God is earthly, unspiritual and devilish and God regards the use of the tongue seriously.ST Sep 19, 1900 Wisdom marked by strife and contention does not come from God but is earthly, unspiritual and devilish, with envy, jealousy and malice belonging to this opposing spirit, while those controlled by God's Spirit show a Christlike character that such hostility cannot overthrow.ST Jul 14, 1887 Wisdom expressed in a boasting, defiant manner does not come from above, so those who know the truth should treat the ignorant with compassion and remember that what they received gives no grounds for boasting.RH Nov 6, 1856
Wisdom marked by contention and desire for personal victory does not come from God but is earthly and grows out of selfishness, leading people to press religion on others against their will, unlike the willing service God desires.ST Oct 12, 1876 Wisdom rooted in selfishness produces love of contention and personal triumph, leading to pressing truth on unwilling hearers and arguing until they are driven away instead of brought to God.ST Nov 27, 1884 Love without self-sacrificial giving is not from above but is earthly, sensual and devilish, for true love gives while love seeking only admiration, possession or personal satisfaction is selfish rather than God's love.RH Apr 16, 1901 There is a kind of love and wisdom that does not come from above but is the love possessed by Satan and his servants, loving only those who love in return, not self-renouncing but selfish and when standing alone sensual and devilish, lower than the love God plants and sheds abroad by the Holy Spirit which is higher, purer and holier, loving a rebellious world and enemies and so loving that it gave Jesus to die that sinners might choose life.ST Nov 1, 1905
Wisdom and inspiration rooted in tobacco do not come from God but are earthly, sensual and devilish, so depending on tobacco to feel enjoyment, to speak or to pray in worship relies on an agency from beneath rather than the Holy Spirit.RH Oct 4, 1864 Tobacco appetite as earthly, sensual and devilish is an ungodly indulgence that obstructs the soul's receptiveness to the gospel and the Holy Spirit.RH Oct 4, 1864 Whether enjoyment comes from above or beneath tests dependence on tea, coffee, tobacco, opium or alcohol, whose pleasure is cherished bodily appetite not hunger for righteousness, holiness or God's presence, deadening natural sensibilities of body and mind, closing the person to the Holy Spirit, and weakening interest and zeal in worship, for wisdom from beneath is earthly, sensual and devilish.ST Oct 5, 1882 Living on a carnal physical plane while aspiring to mental and moral elevation is earthly and sensual, as in substituting meat for properly prepared grains as a deceptive remedy for stomach trouble.
Wisdom arising from fear of people or human schemes is not from God but is earthly, sensual and devilish, as in federations seeking reform through laws that overawe and compel conscience, which cannot establish righteousness or influence those who truly fear the Lord.ST Dec 27, 1905 Wisdom belonging to this world does not come from God but is earthly, sensual and devilish, in contrast to the wisdom of those who fear God and keep His commandments.RH May 2, 1854 Worldly carnal desires are sensual and devilish, and minds filled with worldly things will not enter heaven.RH Dec 11, 1900 The way of holiness is so high that nothing earthly, sensual and devilish can enter it, but God cleanses the sinful, gives a new heart and spirit, and enables the redeemed to walk in that way.RH Apr 23, 1901 Wisdom used to justify cruel experimentation on helpless people is not from God but is earthly, sensual and devilish, whereas God-given wisdom is peaceable, gentle, open to reason, merciful and fruitful.ST Feb 15, 1899
Wisdom that does not come from God as earthly, sensual and devilish characterizes the cruelty, deceit, immorality and idolatry of those living without knowledge of God.RH Sep 26, 1871 The same earthly, sensual and devilish wisdom marks swinish natures so gross, selfish and swinish that they see no more value in priceless pearls of truth than in worthless clay, acting as Satan's agents to hinder the work, consume ministers' time, lower spiritual truths of the Gospel to worldly things, and needing to be reached in some other way than by feeding them pearls of spiritual truth.ST Jul 17, 1901
Commentary part 2 of 2
Pioneers and periodicals
87 sources
This so-called wisdom is wisdom only by bitter irony, for it is the lowest and most degrading kind the mind can conceive and the direct opposite of what is heavenly.RH Oct 13, 1868RH Nov 24, 1874 It does not come down from God above but comes from below and beneath, belonging wholly to this passing world that lasts only a few years and offers nothing beyond this life.RH May 3, 1906ST Jul 9, 1912RH Sep 14, 1869RH Jul 16, 1901RH Jun 23, 1868 It is animal and natural, governed by selfish desire and human passion rather than by God, and it shares the selfish character of Satan who loves only those who love in return.RH Apr 1, 1873RH May 3, 1870ST Mar 4, 1903ST Nov 1, 1905 In contrast to the wisdom from above that is pure, peaceable, gentle, open to reason, merciful, fruitful and sincere, it is known by bitter envy and strife in the heart, and where it rules there is confusion and every evil work.ST Oct 30, 1901RH Dec 16, 1915RH Dec 13, 1906 It must therefore be detected and abandoned as a deadly foe to true religion, for it corrupts thought, poisons speech, breeds division among believers, and can never enter the way of holiness.RH Dec 13, 1906ST Jan 8, 1902ST Aug 5, 1897ST Oct 10, 1878
Meaning of Its Words
To call this principle wisdom is sarcastic irony that exposes its wretchedness, for it is the lowest, most censurable and degrading kind of wisdom the mind can conceive, the most strikingly opposite to heavenly wisdom.RH Oct 13, 1868RH Nov 24, 1874 It works by envy and strife, which are distressingly injurious if not destructive to any enterprise they are used against, with the injury measured by the strength of the evil disposition shown, especially when exercised within the same brotherhood and community.RH Oct 13, 1868RH Nov 24, 1874 Those who use it gain nothing except injury to those they hated and should have loved, and hindrance to the excellent principles they should have shown in their lives, gaining only the displeasure of God and the approval of wicked spirits and of the kind of men nations abhor.RH Oct 13, 1868RH Nov 24, 1874 What looks like gain is only a loss too great for finite minds to estimate.RH Oct 13, 1868RH Nov 24, 1874
This wisdom does not descend from above and does not come from God, but comes from below and from beneath.ST Oct 5, 1882RH Sep 14, 1869RH Jun 23, 1868PGGC 113.2RH Jan 23, 1900 It is not the wisdom that leads to true freedom, which comes through obedience to God.RH Sep 14, 1869 Supernatural phenomena and miracles do not prove a divine source, for such wisdom may affirm part of the truth while urging rejection of another part.PGGC 113.2RH Jan 23, 1900 Its pleasure is a cherished bodily appetite rather than hunger for righteousness, holiness, or God's presence, as in dependence on tea, coffee, tobacco, opium, or alcohol, which deadens natural sensibilities, makes a person less open to the Holy Spirit, and weakens zeal in worship.ST Oct 5, 1882 Popular fiction that draws people from Scripture and God is the opposite of what comes from heaven.RH Jun 23, 1868
It is earthly because it belongs wholly to this world, is self-centered and transient, lasting only a few years and offering nothing beyond this life.RH May 3, 1906ST Jul 9, 1912 It can be gained in great measure yet cannot save its possessor from perishing at the day of God, in contrast to wisdom that gives greatest attention to preparing for eternal life.ST Jul 9, 1912 Though the world counts this earthly wisdom the highest and best, the principal thing, God calls it foolishness.RH Jul 16, 1901 The only correct understanding of anything is to know it as God teaches it, and pure wisdom and true understanding come by faith only as all His children are taught by Him, so without faith there can be but little true understanding, and in the last days misunderstanding will increase as knowledge increases even when much truth is taught.RH Jul 16, 1901 Reading James 3 is needful when a person cannot have his own way, for its lesson is to control the tongue and reject selfish, contentious wisdom.RH May 3, 1906
It is sensual or psychical because it is animal and natural, fitted to animal existence and governed by selfish desires and human affections and passions rather than by God.RH Apr 1, 1873ST Mar 4, 1903ST Sep 21, 1882 Wisdom arising from bitter envy and strife and producing division and harmful speech is therefore earthly, driven by selfish human desires, and devilish, producing confusion and every evil work.ST Mar 4, 1903 It is devilish because it is like the wisdom demons may have and partakes of the devil's qualities.RH Apr 1, 1873RH May 3, 1870 Envy of this kind can blind people and drive them to outward crimes even to murder, and its destructive power is checked only by God's power and providence.RH May 3, 1870 It is the selfish love possessed by Satan and his servants, who love only those who love in return, not self-renouncing but selfish, lower than the love God plants in the soul and sheds abroad in the heart by the Holy Spirit, which is higher, purer and holier, loving a rebellious world and enemies so that it gave Jesus to die that sinners might choose life.ST Nov 1, 1905
Earthly, sensual and devilish are synonymous terms for what is incompatible with Christ.ST Jan 8, 1902ST Aug 5, 1897 What is earthly and devilish does not belong to Christ, so His followers are not to belong to the world or conform to it.ST Jan 8, 1902 The reasoning, love, principle, or logic that seeks to blend righteousness with unrighteousness, light with darkness, Christ with Belial, faith with infidelity, and the temple of God with idols must be abandoned and cast out of the heart as a deadly foe.ST Aug 5, 1897 Religion shaped by the world and the flesh and driven by sense rather than by God and the Spirit is therefore not true heavenly religion.ST Oct 10, 1878 The way of holiness is so high that nothing earthly, sensual, or devilish can enter it, but God cleanses the sinful, gives a new heart and spirit, and enables the redeemed to walk in that way.RH Apr 23, 1901
It is the false knowledge Adam and Eve gained by disobedience when the serpent deceptively promised they would be as gods knowing good and evil.ST Apr 13, 1904 They already knew good before disobeying, and disobedience added only a knowledge of evil that displaced the wisdom from above they had possessed, which is love, joy and peace, leaving humanity in a mixed condition of good and evil with evil greatly in the ascendancy.ST Apr 13, 1904 Sin does not raise people to a higher state but debases them, for Adam sought elevation through sin and found that sin could only degrade him into what is earthly, sensual, and devilish.RH May 12, 1874 Transgression darkens the mind and effaces God's image in humanity into this fallen nature.ST Dec 4, 1901 Jacob shows this earthly wisdom when his wisdom passes from heavenly vision into quick-witted scheming, for he was both a hero of faith and a schemer, a type found among Gentiles no less than among Jews.RH Aug 26, 1902 In the present day the same earthly wisdom appears as prudential vices that mar what would otherwise be worthy of praise and most formidably tempt the religious temperament, so that the man who thanks God that he is not like worldlings or other men falls short of even the excellences they possess, yet the religious temperament with all its faults can pass into the matured holiness of one who is not religious only but godly.RH Aug 26, 1902
Contrast With Heavenly Wisdom
This wisdom stands in direct opposition to the wisdom from above, which is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, easy to be entreated, full of mercy and good fruits, without partiality and without hypocrisy.ST Oct 30, 1901ST Oct 20, 1898RH Dec 16, 1915RH Dec 13, 1906 That heavenly wisdom is merciful and fruitful, open to reason and sincere, marked by purity, peace, gentleness, mercy and righteousness, while the earthly wisdom is false and must be detected and rejected in favor of God's wisdom.ST Oct 30, 1901ST Jan 11, 1883RH Mar 18, 1902RH Dec 16, 1915ST Feb 15, 1899 Wisdom used to justify cruel experimentation on helpless people belongs to the wisdom from below, not to the peaceable, gentle, open, merciful and fruitful wisdom God gives.ST Feb 15, 1899
True wisdom is proved by good conduct with meekness of wisdom, not by bitter envying and strife in the heart with glorying and lying against the truth.ST Oct 20, 1898ST Feb 13, 1901RH May 7, 1867 Where envying and strife rule there is confusion and every evil work, opposite to unity and harmony, and unless every fiber of that root of bitterness is eradicated it defiles many and kills spirituality by selfishness and self-sufficiency that treats others harshly.ST Oct 20, 1898ST Feb 13, 1901 The fruit of righteousness is sown in peace by those who make peace, keeping believers perfectly joined together in the same mind and judgment with no divisions.ST Oct 20, 1898ST Feb 13, 1901 Outward agreement with God's Word is not enough to prove a person right, for the kind of spirit shown in the heart reveals the source of the wisdom claimed.RH Jan 10, 1907RH Jan 10, 1907 Envy and strife and a boastful proud spirit reveal wisdom that does not come from God, so the heart must be humbled before Him and submitted to His leading.RH Jan 10, 1907RH Jan 10, 1907
Worldly wisdom belongs wholly to this world, can be gained in great measure, and is transient, lasting only a few years and offering nothing beyond this life, in contrast to wisdom that gives greatest attention to preparing for eternal life.ST Jul 9, 1912ST Mar 24, 1881RH Jul 16, 1901 Those shaped by it are honored and applauded by people, while those who live by godly wisdom may be treated as low and contemptible as they follow the path to heaven.ST Jul 9, 1912ST Mar 24, 1881 It cannot save its possessor from perishing at the day of God, and though the world counts this earthly wisdom the highest and best, the principal thing, God calls it foolishness.ST Jul 9, 1912RH Jul 16, 1901 The only correct understanding of anything is to know it as God teaches it, and pure wisdom and true understanding come by faith only, so that without faith there can be but little true understanding, and in the last days when there is little faith misunderstanding will increase even as knowledge increases and much truth is taught.RH Jul 16, 1901 Unlike wisdom from below, the wisdom that leads to true freedom comes through obedience to God, and it belongs with the life-giving religion of Jesus Christ rather than corrupt worldly wisdom.RH Sep 14, 1869ST May 26, 1898
Signs and Destructive Fruits
This false wisdom is marked by bitter envy and strife in the heart, including jealousy, faction, suspicion, faultfinding, evil surmising and malice.ST Oct 30, 1901RH Dec 16, 1915RH Jul 31, 1856RH Dec 13, 1906ST Jun 9, 1914 To cherish such envy and strife while claiming advanced spiritual knowledge is to glory and lie against the truth.RH Oct 29, 1901 True wisdom is pure, peaceable, gentle, merciful and fruitful, free from hypocrisy, while this wisdom is earthly, sensual and devilish and not from God.ST Oct 30, 1901RH Dec 16, 1915ST Jun 9, 1914RH Aug 19, 1851ST Mar 4, 1903
It is also marked by pride, criticism, worldly aims, selfishness, self-sufficiency and independence.ST Nov 12, 1885ST Jan 11, 1883RH Jan 10, 1907 Its manner is boastful, defiant and contentious, seeking personal victory and triumph and pressing its views even on unwilling hearers.ST Oct 30, 1901RH Jan 10, 1907RH Nov 6, 1856ST Oct 12, 1876ST Nov 27, 1884 The kind of spirit shown reveals the source of the wisdom claimed, and such traits show communion with an evil spirit rather than with God.ST Jan 11, 1883RH Jan 10, 1907 Humble servants instead need love, unity, humility and willingness to learn from others, with a humble heart and true purpose to discern truth from falsehood.ST Nov 12, 1885
Where this wisdom rules there is confusion and every kind of evil work.ST Oct 30, 1901RH Dec 16, 1915RH Dec 13, 1906ST Mar 4, 1903 Spreading fellow believers' faults and stirring discord show love is not burning as it should. Jealousy and faction help cause alienation among believers.RH Dec 13, 1906
It works by envy and strife to injure or even destroy any enterprise it is turned against, with the injury measured by the strength of the evil disposition, especially when exercised within the same brotherhood and community.RH Oct 13, 1868RH Nov 24, 1874 It injures those who should have been loved and hinders excellent principles that should have been lived out.RH Oct 13, 1868RH Nov 24, 1874 Those who use it gain nothing but God's displeasure and the approval of wicked spirits and of the kind of men nations abhor, so what looks like gain is a loss too great for finite minds to estimate.RH Oct 13, 1868RH Nov 24, 1874
Envy blinds the mind, perverts judgment, and drives people to outward crimes, even to murder.RH May 3, 1870RH May 3, 1870 It also drives toward lies, rebellion and plots against the innocent, and stirs up slander, detraction, treachery, falseness, hypocrisy, bitterness, wrath and other uncharitable acts.ST Nov 28, 1892RH May 3, 1870 Its destructive power, which can take hold in every rank including rulers and the wealthy, is checked only by God's power and providence.RH May 3, 1870RH May 3, 1870 It must not remain in the heart even as a secret wish for another's failure or harm, and meekness and submission to God's will are needed to escape it.ST Nov 28, 1892RH May 3, 1870
Its spirit corrupts thoughts and the whole person and produces evil rather than righteousness.ST Mar 3, 1887 Delaying the pursuit of heavenly wisdom lets that corruption grow until unchecked lust ends in death.ST Mar 3, 1887 Fixing the heart on worldly gain or other finite goods degrades the soul and weakens the intellect, while selfish pursuit of wealth narrows a person and indulgence of appetite and passion debases the whole nature, perverts judgment and resists truth, descending into vice and folly when the will is surrendered to Satan.ST Oct 7, 1913ST Mar 3, 1887
It produces poisoned speech and discord from an unconverted heart, for sweet and bitter water cannot come from a pure source. A person cannot bless God and curse people made in God's likeness as though both came from a pure fountain. Evil-speaking, accusing and fault-finding display Satan's spirit rather than Christ's, and believers are called to guard the tongue and live peaceably.ST Sep 19, 1900 It belongs with hypocritical judging that sees the mote in a brother's eye while blind to the beam in one's own eye, and with the untamed tongue that defiles and sets on fire, which only the Lord's help can bring into subjection to Christ.RH Oct 29, 1901
Envy grows when virtue corrupted by vain-glory turns to pride and pride poisoned by malice becomes envy.RH Dec 15, 1859 It makes another person's happiness a torment and turns God's blessing into a curse, resting on overestimating what others enjoy, so that knowing how little others truly enjoy would take envy out of the world.RH Dec 15, 1859 Humility joined with virtue leaves no footing for pride and no entrance for envy.RH Dec 15, 1859 Envy that resents another's lot is devilish and must be rejected by accepting God's will and doing the work of one's own situation, for jealousy and envy of a neighbor's success bring more inner bitterness than any outside enemy.ST Mar 3, 1898RH Apr 25, 1871ST Jan 27, 1881
The verse is cited in connection with the heart as the fountain of thought, where a pure heart produces pure thoughts.ST Oct 30, 1901 Its strife for higher place, rooted in hearts blinded by riches, showed the apostolic congregations already touched by error and division, as false wisdom from below rather than from God.ST Aug 24, 1904
Doctrinal Errors Exposed
This wisdom is the wisdom imparted by Spiritualism, skillfully adapted to deceive all classes while its true character is concealed when concealment suits the purpose, presented to persons of culture and refinement in refined and intellectual aspects to draw them into the snare.RH Sep 11, 1916 It comes in the most attractive manner as an angel of light, appealing to reason by elevating themes, delighting fancy, enlisting the affections by love and charity, and exciting the imagination to lofty flights.RH Sep 11, 1916 So it leads men to pride in their own wisdom until they despise the Eternal One and have their senses perverted unless shielded by divine power.RH Sep 11, 1916
It is also the wisdom of occult and psychic pursuits pursued apart from instruction of the Bible, and claims of scientific investigation do not make it godly.RH Mar 17, 1859RH Dec 21, 1905 It is seen in obscure unintelligible communications of familiar spirits, whose voice is low like speech from the dust and brings confusion, mystery and darkness rather than clear light and wisdom.RH Mar 17, 1859 It works through mediums, dreams, impersonations, and knowledge of past or future events that may affirm part of the truth while urging rejection of another part.PGGC 113.2 Supernatural phenomena and miracles do not prove a divine source, for such manifestations may come from beneath rather than from God.PGGC 113.2RH Jan 23, 1900
It is the wisdom of rationalism that elevates human reason over Scripture and denies the living, personal, ruling God, belonging to the sphere of the psyche and like what demons may have.RH Apr 1, 1873 It is reasoning used to justify disobedience to God's truth by human arguments that portray God as ignorant or short-sighted or claim He made an institution for humanity that could not be universally enjoyed.RH Feb 3, 1852 It is wisdom shaped by human expediency rather than obedience, judging whether God's law should be obeyed by human ideas of what is proper or convenient.RH Oct 31, 1854 Scripture and the general principles of divine law guide conduct, and human judgment may rightly determine how to apply those principles where Scripture gives no specific rule, but not whether to carry them out.RH Oct 31, 1854
It is the reasoning that urges delaying obedience to a clear divine command by deferring to learned interpreters skilled in explaining away God's law.ST Aug 2, 1877ST Mar 18, 1886RH Jun 12, 1856 With regard to the Sabbath as the subject of direct and unequivocal command, the plea that one may be mistaken about duty and therefore should delay belongs to that earthly wisdom, and its object is to induce deference to men of learning instead of obeying the plain command to keep holy the seventh day.ST Jun 25, 1874ST Jun 10, 1875RH Aug 19, 1852 Practical duties are stated in very simple language so plainly that ordinary people, those of small intellectual capacity as well as those of expanded powers, and children as well as those of mature age, can understand and decide for themselves, because everyone must give account for himself and not another for him.ST Aug 2, 1877ST Jun 25, 1874
It is human-devised wisdom used to justify observing the first day in honor of the resurrection when Scripture does not instruct this observance, and a course's legitimacy must be tested by Scripture.ST Mar 20, 1893 It is wisdom resting on the unrevealed claim that redemption is greater than creation to justify keeping resurrection day instead of the Sabbath, which has not been revealed by God, does not establish which day God requires, and cannot turn human choice into obedience to the commandment to keep the seventh day.RH Oct 23, 1856 The same earthly, sensual, devilish description applies to forces opposed to the shamefully abused Sabbath truth.RH Jul 21, 1863 It marks the pope's courteous appeal for Protestants to return to Rome as worldly rather than Christian wisdom, for Christian wisdom is reverence for God that treats His will as wisest, keeps His commandments, and rests on God's word in Christ rather than on any Protestant, Roman, or other human creed.ST Aug 20, 1894
It is wisdom opposed to God's word coming from below, seen in popular fiction as the opposite of what comes from heaven and a corrupting influence drawing people from Scripture and God.RH Jun 23, 1868 It is godless ingenuity inventing weapons and preparations for war, advancing strife rather than peace.RH Jun 9, 1868 It is displayed in worldly church entertainments and money-raising practices with a carnal fleshly spirit rather than true spirituality, where churches replenish the treasury and reach the purse only by appeal to appetite through fairs and scenic performances.RH Aug 3, 1876ST Jun 10, 1880 That idea that God is best served by ministering to the flesh teaches people to purchase pleasure instead of loving the Lord and cuts charity up by the roots.ST Jun 10, 1880
It marks the vain imaginations and opposition to Christ by the Jewish leaders, who professed belief in the sacrifices pointing to the Lamb of God yet rejected Christ and shut their eyes to the meaning of the system.ST Nov 7, 1892 It identifies wisdom leading people to break God's law and indulge sinful desires as incompatible with the Spirit of God and its fruit.RH Feb 20, 1900 James condemned such sinful conduct on the basis of the same moral law rather than a new code of morals, so righteous people must avoid what is filthy and polluting.ST Sep 2, 1889
Life and Fellowship Applied
Christ's servants must reject self-sufficiency and independence, cultivating instead love, unity, humility and willingness to learn from others, for a humble heart with true purpose discerns truth from falsehood and distinguishes earthly selfish wisdom from wisdom from above.ST Nov 12, 1885 Jealousy and faction cause alienation among believers, and wisdom marked by bitter jealousy does not come from God but is earthly, sensual and devilish, in contrast to the pure, peaceable, gentle and merciful wisdom from above whose presence brings confusion and evil deeds.RH Dec 13, 1906 Wisdom marked by envy, suspicion, faultfinding and evil surmising is not from God but is earthly, sensual and devilish, and cherishing it weakens believers spiritually, hinders God's work, brings confusion and evil work, and damages the church's witness.RH Feb 25, 1904 Wisdom joined to bitter envying and strife in the heart, with glorying and lying against the truth, does not come from above but is earthly, sensual and devilish, and is the root of bitterness that breaks Christian unity and harmony.ST Feb 13, 1901
Unless every fiber of that root of bitterness is eradicated it defiles many and kills spirituality by selfishness and self-sufficiency that treats others harshly, for where this wisdom rules there is confusion and every evil work, opposite to wisdom from above which is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, easy to be entreated, full of mercy and good fruits, without partiality and without hypocrisy, whose fruit of righteousness is sown in peace by peacemakers.ST Feb 13, 1901 The chapter's teaching about the tongue calls believers to guard their speech and live peaceably, for wisdom that produces division and harmful speech is not from God but is earthly, driven by selfish desires, and devilish. Reading James 3 is the remedy when a person cannot have his own way, pointing to controlling the tongue and rejecting selfish, self-centered, contentious and devilish wisdom that does not come from above.RH May 3, 1906 Personal attacks and bitter assaults on character marked by envy, jealousy or malice reveal this evil earthly, sensual and devilish source, not zeal for the Lord.RH Dec 14, 1869
Envy and strife in the heart produce a false wisdom not from God, bringing confusion and every evil work, and its presence among Christians signals that love is not burning as it should, shown especially in spreading fellow believers' faults and stirring discord. Evil-speaking, accusing and faultfinding display Satan's spirit rather than Christ's, for wisdom opposed to God is earthly, unspiritual and devilish and God regards the use of the tongue seriously.ST Sep 19, 1900 Wisdom marked by strife and contention does not come from God but is earthly, unspiritual and devilish, with envy, jealousy and malice belonging to this opposing spirit, while those controlled by God's Spirit show a Christlike character that such hostility cannot overthrow.ST Jul 14, 1887 Wisdom expressed in a boasting, defiant manner does not come from above, so those who know the truth should treat the ignorant with compassion and remember that what they received gives no grounds for boasting.RH Nov 6, 1856
Wisdom marked by contention and desire for personal victory does not come from God but is earthly and grows out of selfishness, leading people to press religion on others against their will, unlike the willing service God desires.ST Oct 12, 1876 Wisdom rooted in selfishness produces love of contention and personal triumph, leading to pressing truth on unwilling hearers and arguing until they are driven away instead of brought to God.ST Nov 27, 1884 Love without self-sacrificial giving is not from above but is earthly, sensual and devilish, for true love gives while love seeking only admiration, possession or personal satisfaction is selfish rather than God's love.RH Apr 16, 1901 There is a kind of love and wisdom that does not come from above but is the love possessed by Satan and his servants, loving only those who love in return, not self-renouncing but selfish and when standing alone sensual and devilish, lower than the love God plants and sheds abroad by the Holy Spirit which is higher, purer and holier, loving a rebellious world and enemies and so loving that it gave Jesus to die that sinners might choose life.ST Nov 1, 1905
Wisdom and inspiration rooted in tobacco do not come from God but are earthly, sensual and devilish, so depending on tobacco to feel enjoyment, to speak or to pray in worship relies on an agency from beneath rather than the Holy Spirit.RH Oct 4, 1864 Tobacco appetite as earthly, sensual and devilish is an ungodly indulgence that obstructs the soul's receptiveness to the gospel and the Holy Spirit.RH Oct 4, 1864 Whether enjoyment comes from above or beneath tests dependence on tea, coffee, tobacco, opium or alcohol, whose pleasure is cherished bodily appetite not hunger for righteousness, holiness or God's presence, deadening natural sensibilities of body and mind, closing the person to the Holy Spirit, and weakening interest and zeal in worship, for wisdom from beneath is earthly, sensual and devilish.ST Oct 5, 1882 Living on a carnal physical plane while aspiring to mental and moral elevation is earthly and sensual, as in substituting meat for properly prepared grains as a deceptive remedy for stomach trouble.
Wisdom arising from fear of people or human schemes is not from God but is earthly, sensual and devilish, as in federations seeking reform through laws that overawe and compel conscience, which cannot establish righteousness or influence those who truly fear the Lord.ST Dec 27, 1905 Wisdom belonging to this world does not come from God but is earthly, sensual and devilish, in contrast to the wisdom of those who fear God and keep His commandments.RH May 2, 1854 Worldly carnal desires are sensual and devilish, and minds filled with worldly things will not enter heaven.RH Dec 11, 1900 The way of holiness is so high that nothing earthly, sensual and devilish can enter it, but God cleanses the sinful, gives a new heart and spirit, and enables the redeemed to walk in that way.RH Apr 23, 1901 Wisdom used to justify cruel experimentation on helpless people is not from God but is earthly, sensual and devilish, whereas God-given wisdom is peaceable, gentle, open to reason, merciful and fruitful.ST Feb 15, 1899
Wisdom that does not come from God as earthly, sensual and devilish characterizes the cruelty, deceit, immorality and idolatry of those living without knowledge of God.RH Sep 26, 1871 The same earthly, sensual and devilish wisdom marks swinish natures so gross, selfish and swinish that they see no more value in priceless pearls of truth than in worthless clay, acting as Satan's agents to hinder the work, consume ministers' time, lower spiritual truths of the Gospel to worldly things, and needing to be reached in some other way than by feeding them pearls of spiritual truth.ST Jul 17, 1901
Sources