James5:3

Hoarded gold and silver become cankered and corroded, exposing earthly riches as uncertain and soon passing away when they are kept unused instead of serving God. Their rust stands as registered evidence against their owners for neglected opportunities to help others, robbery, fraud and covetous extortion. That stored treasure will eat like fire and bring consuming judgment upon those who stretched economy into meanness merely to increase riches. It is wealth heaped by greed and oppression, by withholding wages from laborers and grinding down the hireling while living in luxury, whose cries come up into the ears of the Lord of Sabaoth who records every injustice. Wealth is the Lord's entrusted goods to advance His cause, bless the poor and support His work, so professed believers who cling to earthly treasure and give only a little will weep and howl when their hoarded property is swept away and no longer accepted.

Words and Imagery

Gold and silver kept back for self are pictured as cankered, corroded and decayed, uncertain and soon passing away. They are like moth-eaten goods put into a bag with holes, giving no lasting security. This exposes the worthlessness of riches held in mansions, farms, buildings, cattle or bank stock when they are not used to serve God and save others and to advance His work and bring souls to Christ. Holding to the world in this way for honor, position, business and daily bread is selling the soul for a little worldly gain instead of receiving eternal riches. Ambition, avarice and gain without godliness cloud the eye so the loss is not seen, clinging to such treasure stops progress heavenward, holds the affections to earth, starves and dwarfs the soul for want of spiritual food, and puts the world between the soul and God.

Their rust becoming a witness means hoarded wealth stands as registered evidence against its owners. It witnesses to unused abilities and neglected chances to help others and to put entrusted money to its appointed use and benefit. It is evidence of guilt for doing wrong to a neighbor by dishonest practices, robbery, fraud, covetous extortion, injustice and oppression of the poor, and keeping back the hire of laborers. Such unlawful gain is registered in heaven, and bringing it into God's treasury to make compromise with God does not make it pure but deceives the giver's own soul. Wealth gained through injustice, withheld wages, or hoarding while the needy are neglected thus brings just retribution and condemnation in God's judgment in the last days.

Eating flesh as fire means the stored treasure brings consuming judgment. Its corrosion is pictured as fire consuming the rich, and the judgment stored up will shortly consume its owners. The Lord turns to such hoarders in anger and wrath, forsakes them, and has no further use for them. It harms the soul like an eating canker when economy, though right in itself, is stretched into close, penurious meanness merely to add to heaped-up treasures. This displeases God especially when those called to speak the truth and watch for souls waste precious time worth far more than the little saved instead of acting as faithful stewards and making right disposal of the Lord's goods, and unless they do so their treasures will consume them like fire. Treasure hoarded through covetousness without good purpose or generosity and at the cost of faithful service to God, and substance selfishly retained while only a little is given now and then to ease conscience, brings this fiery end.

Heaping treasure together for the last days means storing wealth for destruction rather than safety. What is piled up is a curse and snare rather than a blessing when it draws the heart away from heavenly treasure. Those who love neither God nor truth and who live in pleasure and wantonness only nourish the heart as in a day of slaughter. Men of the world rushing on to ruin heap up these treasures of gold and silver through many schemes and confederacies and new devices brought in to make of no effect the counsel of God. Those heaped treasures will be consumed by the fires of the last days, in contrast to eternal treasure to be gained by believers using their abilities aright.

Setting of Injustice

The verse belongs to a picture of wealth gained by fraud, including wages kept back by fraud from laborers who reaped the fields, grinding down the hireling, dishonest practices, oppression of the poor, wrong done to a neighbor, and taking advantage of others wherever possible to increase gain. It is covetousness that loves neither God nor people, using entrusted gifts for self and for pleasure and self-gratification while shutting the eyes to perishing fellow beings who could be given homes, food and clothing. Bringing means so gained into God's treasury to make compromise with God does not make it pure but deceives the giver's own soul.

The rich heap colossal fortunes by greed, oppression, extortion and robbery, grasping all they can get, paying laborers as little as possible while charging as much as possible, and locking up thousands where they do no good so that entrusted capital brings no increase. They live in pleasure, wantonness and luxury, selfishly spending on self while the needy are neglected. Such hoarding wastes capital, cherishes covetousness which is idolatry, and leaves owners in continual worry and fear of losing it.

The cries of defrauded laborers, starving humanity and the suffering poor come up before God and enter into the ears of the Lord of Sabaoth. No cry of suffering is unheard by Him, for He marks every act of oppression, records every act and every injustice, registers every dollar entrusted by Him and squandered on self, and in the last great day oppressors will stand face to face with their deeds of oppression and injustice when every case stands in review before God. Means gained by fraud will then be a swift witness against its owners, and the worldly rich will be the poorest and most to be pitied before the judgment throne.

This greed and oppression will prevail just before Christ's second coming, contrasting luxury with the poor and ragged, including luxurious living and extravagant dress. What the verse pictures exists in the world today, with rich men heaping treasure together by every species of oppression and extortion and piling up colossal fortunes while defrauded laborers and starving humanity cry out.

Coming Judgment

Hoarding brings coming misery and condemnation, causing the rich to weep and howl over unlawful gain gotten by wronging a neighbor, dishonest practices, oppression of the poor, and keeping back the hire of laborers by fraud. Corroded wealth heaped for the last days stands registered in heaven as evidence against its owners, and its rust eats their flesh as fire while living in pleasure and wantonness only nourishes the heart as in a day of slaughter. Storing money to increase gain is covetousness that loves neither God nor people, spending on self for pleasure and self-gratification while shutting the eyes to perishing fellow beings who could be given homes, food and clothing, grasping all that can be gotten, paying laborers as little as possible while charging as much as possible, and locking up thousands where they do no good so entrusted capital brings no increase. This condition exists in the world today, God has a controversy with such users of His gifts, and at the judgment when the books are opened they will have a fearful account to settle and meet His vengeance for condemning and killing the just. The depiction of the misery of the rich who have done wickedly is to be repeated as a warning and appeal, and bringing such means into the treasury to make compromise does not make it pure but deceives the giver's own soul.

Hoarded property will be swept away and destroyed, for treasures of gold and silver heaped through many schemes and confederacies and new devices to make of no effect divine counsel are stored only to be consumed by the fires of the last days. Wealth and property gathered in the cities can be destroyed by judgment with a touch of the hand, and that loss stands as a witness against those who stored it up. Riches gained through breaking the law and hoarded for earthly advantage become corrupt and testify against their owners, and grand houses are laid in ruins while costly property is consumed by calamities and fires and possessions of lawbreakers are not protected. In the last-day judgment and final crisis those riches are swept away and scattered, leaving the rich destitute.

As the work closes and truth goes forth in mighty power, hoarded means will no longer be wanted and will be of no further use to the cause. Clinging fast to earthly treasure, farms, cattle, gold and silver instead of using means to advance the cause when opportunity is given shows love for the world greater than love for truth, for fellow men, and for God, and giving a little now and then to ease conscience while selfishly retaining substance is not sacrifice. The rust as witness and as fire eating flesh means turning in anger and wrath, forsaking hoarders and having no further use for them, and letting them go. When they then bring riches and lay them at the feet of servants begging acceptance, God will not accept them because they withheld help when the needy suffered and good could have been done, and holding perishable substance forfeits treasure in heaven that comes by selling and giving to those in need.

In the final crisis the rich lament as their gold and silver are scattered and their earthly gains vanish, having sought earthly riches rather than becoming rich toward God. Their regret is for losing their wealth, not for sin or neglect of other people and the needy.

Faithful Stewardship Required

Wealth is the Lord's goods entrusted to men, with the power to get wealth and with rain and sunlight and fruit given by Him, to be used to advance His cause, bless the world, help the poor and needy, bring souls to Christ, and support workers and mission fields, not kept for selfish gain or luxury. Clinging to earthly treasure in farms and cattle and gold and silver instead of using means when opportunity is given shows love for the world greater than love for truth and fellow men and God, and giving a little now and then to ease conscience while selfishly retaining substance is not sacrifice. Hoarding through injustice and oppression while people suffer leaves gold and silver corrupted, and the corrosion stands as evidence in judgment and as fire consuming the owners. Money stored for the last days while refusing earlier opportunities to do good will be of no use when the work closes and truth goes forth in mighty power, and riches offered only then will not be accepted, for holding perishable substance forfeits treasure in heaven.

Locking up thousands where they do no good wastes entrusted capital so it brings no increase and leaves owners living in continual worry and fear of loss. Money is to be put into circulation to benefit and bless others so it will benefit still others, and by such blessing it steadily increases and multiplies. Unselfish work increases intelligence and knowledge of God, for giving brings return. Storing up money to increase gain while selfishly spending on self for pleasure and self-gratification, grasping all that can be gotten and shutting the eyes to perishing fellow beings who could be given homes and food and clothing, is covetousness that loves neither God nor people. When locked away and put to no use, money fails to accomplish its appointed work.

Economy is right, but stretching economy into stingy meanness merely to add to heaped treasures displeases God. Saving becomes sinful when practiced for the sole purpose of increasing riches without good purpose or generosity, and goods so held will shortly eat their owners as fire and testify against them in judgment. This applies especially to those looking for the Lord's coming who waste precious time worth far more than the little saved instead of speaking truth, watching for souls, and rendering faithful service. What is held is the Lord's goods and must be disposed of rightly as faithful stewards.

Hoarding strengthens the soul-corroding sin of covetousness, which is idolatry, turning wealth kept for self rather than used to do good into spiritual injury like an eating canker. Continually giving to benevolent purposes counters that sin, while growing in benevolence with increasing riches makes money a means of helping others. Hoarded wealth is not merely useless but a curse and in this life a snare to the soul, drawing the affections away from heavenly treasure. In the great day its rust stands as witness to unused talents and neglected opportunities and condemns its possessor.

God asks a return of His own in tithes and offerings, so withholding robs God and must be made right by restitution and pardon. Selfish use of His money, especially spending extravagantly on self while others lack food and basic necessities, makes hoarders accountable for robbing both fellow people and God.

Warnings to Believers

The warning falls with particular force on wealthy people who profess present truth and look for the Lord's coming yet cling fast to earthly treasure — farms, cattle, gold and silver — instead of using their means to advance God's cause when opportunity is given. Such clinging shows love for the world greater than love for truth, for fellow men, and for God, and giving a little now and then merely to ease conscience while selfishly retaining substance is no true sacrifice for God. Their corroded wealth stands as registered evidence against them for unused ability and neglected help to the needy, and the rust eating like fire means the Lord turns to such hoarders in anger and wrath, forsakes them, and has no further use for them. As the work closes and truth goes forth in mighty power their money and property will no longer be wanted for the cause, and when they then bring their riches and lay them at the feet of God's servants begging acceptance, God will not accept them because they withheld help when the needy suffered and good could have been done. Holding perishable substance in this way forfeits treasure in heaven and brings coming misery and judgment, contrasting earthly hoarding with laying up heavenly treasure by selling and giving to those in need.

The same condemnation rests on Sabbath-keepers who gain riches by fraud and oppression, by keeping back the hire of laborers who reaped the fields, by grinding down the hireling in his wages, and by taking advantage of others wherever possible to add to treasure. God is not in riches so obtained, for Satan often has more to do with acquiring such property than God, and the same guilt lies on believers who take advantage even of poor and distressed brethren, exacting more than the real worth of things and more than they themselves would pay, showing no consideration for a brother's distress instead of making allowance with compassion. Every selfish act and every covetous extortion will bring its reward in a fearful account unto destruction, so those who have taken a dishonest course must work fast to redeem the time by a very different course of mercy. Kindly acts that spare the poor and distressed are approved by God and will not lose their reward.

The verse exposes wealth wasted on costly jewels and display, extravagant dress, luxurious living, and costly homes, furnishings and buildings, while the poor go hungry and naked and laborers and famine-stricken people lack food and support. Such extravagance violates justice and integrity, dishonors God, and leaves those who have felt no touch of want guilty before Him, with their selfish use of His money making them accountable for robbing both their fellow people and God. Their hoarded and misspent means will testify against them and bring judgment, and the poor will rise in judgment against those who spent means to gratify pride and ambition instead of helping them. Luxurious living and extravagant dress are signs of the last days, marking misuse of time and means that should have served godly purposes with self-denial and care for others.

Men who lay snares for the drunkard and build themselves up from his property, living in luxury while those they have robbed live in poverty and degradation, are storing up condemnation for the last days. God will require ruinous gain at the hand of everyone who helps speed a soul on to ruin for gain, and the same reckoning falls on pleasure-lovers who spend thousands to please and amuse themselves while the world is full of distress and poverty. Means raised for God's appointed work but diverted from its proper channel likewise becomes a severe fraudulent witness against the untrustworthy handlers who proved unfaithful in handling it. Such diverting stands recorded as a fraudulent transaction known by God, and every dollar of principal and interest should be placed where designed, for this state of things will bring a terrible reaction.

In the setting described the warning applies to a world where rejecters of God's law oppress others and oppose those who obey it because of religious faith, and where people in cities gather property that God can destroy with a touch of His hand. The corrosion of hoarded riches is evidence of guilt that will bring judgment as fire consuming flesh, and wealth and property stored for the last days can be swept away so that loss itself stands as witness against those who stored it. The grand houses the rich build for themselves and take pride in will be laid in ruins by the Lord, and no human ingenuity can prevent it. Those who take pride in scheming to obtain money to exalt self and gain worldly honor will reach the limit of mercy, when He will no longer bear with them in their lordly presumption, for such men are a curse to humanity.