Translations
Who is this that darkens counsel by words without knowledge?
King James Version, Webster Bible, Revised Version, Darby Translation
Who is this that darkeneth counsel by words without knowledge?
KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, American Standard Version
Who is this that darkeneth counsel
By words without knowledge?Who [is] this — darkening counsel, By words without knowledge?
Who is it that darkeneth counsel, by words, without knowledge?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“ Who is this who obscures My counsel
by words without knowledge?“ Who is this who darkens counsel
by words without knowledge?Who is this who makes the purpose of God dark by words without knowledge?
Who is this that darkeneth the counsell by wordes without knowledge?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Who is this that wrappeth up sentences in unskillful words?
Cross-references
- Isaiah 55:8-9
For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways, saith the LORD.
God’s thoughts and ways are higher than human understanding.
- Job 40:4
Behold, I am vile; what shall I answer thee? I will lay mine hand upon my mouth.
Both call for silent humility instead of many words.
- Job 38:19-21
Where is the way where light dwelleth? and as for darkness, where is the place thereof,
God questions Job’s knowledge of where light and darkness dwell.
- Job 38:31-38
Canst thou bind the sweet influences of Pleiades, or loose the bands of Orion?
God questions Job about the heavens and the ordering of the earth.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
8 sources
To darken counsel is to speak words without knowledge that cloud understanding of God's counsel instead of giving sound guidance.CT 380.3Ms 105, 1893, par. 1–2Lt 55, 1897, par. 31–32MH 431.2–31T 329.3–330.2 The setting among the questions of Job 38 shows human wisdom to be limited, for many mysteries of God in nature lie beyond finite grasp.MH 431.2–3 Those mysteries are not given for people to solve but to turn attention to the depth of God and call for faith, so that people may keep searching and learning while there always remains more beyond comprehension.MH 431.2–3 The same darkening occurs when theology is made up of human speculation and dressed in learned terms, seeking intellectual prestige rather than truth that feeds mind and soul.CT 380.3MH 442.3 Such learned speculation obscures rather than teaches when it fails to give food for mind and soul.CT 380.3MH 442.3 The scribes and Pharisees did this by misinterpreting and distorting the words of Christ, and thereby turned people away from the path of life and righteousness.Ms 105, 1893, par. 1–2 The same is true of a person who through prejudice makes confident but uninformed claims, misleading others and opposing those united in keeping God's commandments and holding the testimony of Jesus.1T 329.3–330.2 Truth is also obscured by excess of words, for when a speaker adds at length to what has already been clearly said the extra words weaken rather than strengthen the impression and leave the matter less clear.Lt 39a, 1887, par. 1–5 Divine counsel is clouded when those seeking to know duty commit explanation to others and ask fellow human beings to tell them what to do, instead of seeking wisdom and understanding duty through personal communion with God and His own light and guidance.Lt 55, 1897, par. 31–326MR 381.1–382.1 Those who would labor with God must hold direct communion with Him, ask His guidance in everything undertaken, and seek wisdom from Him by coming in consecrated and humble faith so that He speaks His mysteries to them personally.6MR 381.1–382.1 Then hearts burn within as Christ draws near to commune as He did with Enoch, so that instead of words without knowledge they receive Christ who is the true light that lights every person.6MR 381.1–382.1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
42 sources
To darken counsel by words without knowledge is to obscure sound understanding and hide the truth rather than clarify it, especially by piling up many words where knowledge is lacking.ST Apr 18, 1878ST Feb 27, 1879ST Dec 5, 1878RH Sep 29, 1910RH Apr 24, 1879 God himself speaks these words to Job from the whirlwind after the long discussion with his friends, opening his answer with rebuke that startles his afflicted servant into silence and calls him to stand and answer like a man.ST Jul 3, 1893RH Jan 6, 1916ST Sep 22, 1914ST Aug 24, 1915RH Apr 4, 1912 The questions that follow about the laying of the earth's foundations and the governing of nature expose that man was not present at creation and cannot control what God alone knows and governs, showing how small man is beside God's infinite power and wisdom.ST Apr 18, 1878ST Jun 30, 1909ST Aug 29, 1911ST Jul 22, 1908RH May 28, 1857 By pointing to his mighty works in the common and familiar things around Job, God reveals himself through nature and leads Job from merely hearing of him to seeing him, repenting in dust and ashes and learning to trust his will even where he cannot understand it.ST Jun 30, 1909ST Jul 31, 1879ST Jun 24, 1913ST Apr 10, 1893RH Jan 9, 1872 So multiplying words in affliction and attempting to explain God's ways and government by human reasoning and speculation only clouds good counsel and belittles God, while true wisdom comes from laying the hand on the mouth in silence, humbly trusting his word and waiting because his ways are true and just.RH Jun 30, 1904RH Sep 29, 1910ST Jun 3, 1886
Setting of the Rebuke
God himself speaks to Job out of the whirlwind and from the storm-cloud after the prolonged discussion with his friends and after Elihu's speeches.ST Jul 3, 1893ST Sep 22, 1914RH Apr 4, 1912ST The voice comes at Job's home in the land of Uz, showing that God had been listening to all that was spoken.RH Apr 4, 1912 He comes down to Job in answer to Job's challenge and repeated prayer for the Almighty to answer, rather than Job going up to God's throne.RH Apr 4, 1912 The verse falls within that account of Jehovah speaking to Job and rebuking him.RH Jan 6, 1916
The verse opens the Lord's answer and a long series of questions about the laying of the earth's foundations and the governance of natural forces and processes.ST Jul 3, 1893ST Sep 22, 1914ST Sep 24, 1894ST Jul 31, 1879 By those questions God calls Job's attention to the majesty and power of the Infinite as contrasted with the weakness of the human, answering in the same strain by showing that their governance belongs to divine power beyond human understanding.ST Jul 3, 1893ST Sep 22, 1914 They contain some of the sublimest utterances ever put into human language, suggesting thought and research far beyond the general education and learning of that time.ST Sep 22, 1914 They are therefore to be pondered with more than usual care, while God also brings Job's attention to familiar things he could not explain, speaking to his understanding while revealing wonders.ST Sep 22, 1914ST Jul 22, 1908
That speech about the laying of the earth's foundations includes the earliest recorded use of music, when the morning stars sang together and the sons of God shouted for joy.ST Sep 24, 1894 In it God points to the foundations of the earth and to His mighty works in creation to show His might and greatness.ST Jun 30, 1909ST Jul 31, 1879 The material world He made is thus presented as evidence of His glory.ST Jul 31, 1879
The rebuke is directed to Job himself as God's impatient and afflicted servant, who at times had been almost peevish at what his friends said.ST Sep 22, 1914ST Aug 24, 1915ST Jun 24, 1913 It charges him with clouding right counsel by speaking without knowledge, speaking unwisely and uttering things that brought darkness, and misreading the meaning God was writing in his sufferings.ST Aug 24, 1915 His words have obscured God's purposes because he speaks beyond what he knows.RH May 28, 1857 It exposes him as guilty, startles him into silence, and calls him to stand like a man and answer when God questions him.ST Aug 24, 1915RH Apr 4, 1912
Sense of Darkening Counsel
To darken counsel by words without knowledge is to obscure sound understanding and hide the truth rather than to clarify or reveal it, confusing the mind instead of offering sound sense or argument.ST Apr 18, 1878ST Feb 27, 1879ST Feb 17, 1914RH Aug 30, 1906 Speaking without enough knowledge to judge leaves the speaker unable to answer what God alone can know, since he was not present when the foundations were laid, and such speech therefore obscures rather than explains.ST Apr 18, 1878 Words without knowledge darken counsel when they confuse the distinction between the promise and the commandment within a covenant.ST Feb 27, 1879 Many words without knowledge can darken wisdom and muddle truth, so that efforts meant to explain a clear meaning instead obscure it.ST Dec 5, 1878 Presenting unsupported claims and faulty reasoning as a demonstrated conclusion is darkening counsel, as is quoted teaching about the origin of evil and disease that obscures understanding rather than revealing truth despite its appearance of explanation.RH Aug 30, 1906
Piling up and multiplying many words without knowledge clouds good counsel and hides meaning.RH Sep 29, 1910RH Apr 24, 1879RH Mar 13, 1856 Fluency alone gives a speaker no power, since words are too common to carry weight, while good thoughts gladly received need only the words required to convey them.RH Apr 24, 1879 Sentences should be built so closely that removing any word would destroy the meaning or spoil the form, and such compact speech gains power, durability, and pleasantness that lets writings last for centuries.RH Apr 24, 1879 Multiplying words in affliction darkens counsel by ignorance, requiring the sufferer to sense his own insignificance, lay his hand upon his mouth in silence, learn humility and perfect trust and faith, and wait because the Father knows the need and thorn and shadow, the unseen snare, what will keep him nearest and what he could not bear, while his ways are true and just and will bring infinite compensation.RH Sep 29, 1910 All who endeavor to prove the change of the Sabbath darken counsel by multiplying words without knowledge, and the fallacies of their arguments show the weakness of their cause.RH Mar 13, 1856
Calling something an explanation does not make it understood when the difficulty is left unresolved, for such explanations darken counsel by leaving the matter obscure.ST Apr 5, 1883 In the great controversy between good and evil, human words, actions, and even thoughts are observed and can either illuminate the issues or cast a shadow over them by darkening counsel.ST Feb 17, 1914
God's Wisdom, Human Ignorance
The questions that follow the rebuke expose ignorance of creation and the natural world, for no human teacher was present when the Word laid the foundations of the earth.ST Apr 18, 1878ST Aug 29, 1911RH May 28, 1857 None can answer what God alone can know, and the challenge shows how little man can know or control beside Him who alone has wisdom and power to govern the earth, humble the proud, and judge righteously.ST Apr 18, 1878ST Aug 29, 1911RH May 28, 1857 Even men of greatest intellect and the most profound scholars cannot understand or answer the questions God asks about nature.
God points to His mighty works in creation and to the commonest and most familiar things around Job to display infinite power and wisdom.ST Jun 30, 1909ST Jul 22, 1908ST Jul 31, 1879ST Jun 24, 1913 By that contrast man is seen to be exceedingly small and utterly unworthy and of small account.ST Jun 30, 1909 Since material things are comprehended only in a measure, God's moral dealings with men and His great purposes where eternal life itself is at stake can be understood still less, exposing the folly of questioning His providence without understanding it.ST Jun 30, 1909ST Jul 22, 1908 The material world He made thus stands as evidence of His might and greatness and glory, while familiar things He could not explain are brought before Job's understanding along with revealed wonders.ST Jul 22, 1908ST Jul 31, 1879ST Jun 24, 1913
He does not directly answer the arguments but reveals a solution through the evidence of nature.ST Apr 10, 1893 The natural world is made to proclaim His character and perfection and to show His goodness, love, and tender care.ST Apr 10, 1893RH Jan 9, 1872 Its grand and terrible forces, its beauty and sublimity, arouse the emotions and reach the moral and religious nature of man.RH Jan 9, 1872
The questions were not asked to be answered but to call attention to the deep mysteries of God. They teach that human wisdom is limited, that many things in the surroundings of daily life are beyond the comprehension of finite minds, and that His judgments, purposes, and wisdom are past finding out and unsearchable. He is to be acknowledged more from what He does not reveal of Himself than from what is open to limited comprehension.
The rebuke therefore exposes deniers and skeptics who claim knowledge enough to judge yet speak without knowing enough to judge the matter.ST Apr 18, 1878 It exposes those who refuse to believe in God because with finite minds they cannot comprehend the infinite power by which He reveals Himself. Such speech darkens counsel because it obscures truth rather than explaining it.ST Apr 18, 1878
This dramatic presentation of divine glory, greatness, infinity, and eternity gives deeper meaning to Christ's gentleness, patience, and kindness.ST Mar 25, 1880 The Lord's words lead Job to see God's power and wisdom, from which His goodness can be inferred.ST Jun 30, 1909ST Apr 10, 1893 Job moves from having heard of God to seeing Him, truly repents and humbles himself in dust and ashes, prays for those who misjudged him, and learns to trust and submit to God's will whatever comes even though he cannot understand it.ST Jun 30, 1909ST Jun 24, 1913ST Apr 10, 1893
Warnings and Applications
Multiplying words in affliction darkens counsel by ignorance, for the sufferer must sense his own insignificance and learn humility and perfect trust and faith and cease such speaking.RH Sep 29, 1910 Silence is required because the Father knows what the sufferer does not know, the need and thorn and shadow, the unseen snare, what will keep him nearest and what he could not bear.RH Sep 29, 1910 His ways are true and just and will bring infinite compensation, so the sufferer must lay his hand upon his mouth and wait in perfect trust.RH Sep 29, 1910
Attempts to explain God's ways and mysteries by human reasoning, and ingenious speculation about providence and his government without knowledge, only obscure understanding, confuse the mind, and belittle God.RH Jun 30, 1904ST Jun 3, 1886 Practical wisdom comes instead from simple trust in his word and from recognizing him and conforming to his revealed will.RH Jun 30, 1904ST Jun 3, 1886 Treating his word contemptuously as though it could be made to say whatever one wishes darkens his counsel, for his expressed thoughts are far above human thoughts, yet his words are righteous, straightforward, and plain to those who understand and seek knowledge.ST Mar 27, 1907 Twisting his plain words to make them mean something other than what they say darkens counsel, including the claim that the death he declared as sin's penalty cannot mean actual death.ST May 24, 1883
Confusing the distinction between the promise and the commandment within a covenant darkens counsel by obscuring sound understanding.ST Feb 27, 1879 Arguments against keeping the letter of his law darken the subject and undermine the authority of his written word.ST Jan 16, 1879 Using philosophical speculation and superstition to confuse the plain biblical account of human life and death darkens counsel.RH Jul 21, 1868 Creating difficulties where the Bible presents none, and controversy and learned explanations that obscure plain biblical truth and make simple teachings difficult to see, darken counsel without knowledge.ST Jan 8, 1885RH Oct 15, 1861
Presenting unsupported claims and faulty reasoning as a demonstrated conclusion, and speech that confuses rather than offers sound sense, darken counsel by words without knowledge.ST Aug 10, 1882 Turning attention from God and the Bible to human opinions while exalting human power, merit, and learning hides his glory.ST Nov 10, 1898 Studying heathen philosophy and trying to build Christianity on it replaces the life-giving gospel with its shadow and form so its power to save is lost.ST Oct 10, 1900 Hiding the truth through arguments that sound like distinctions but lack knowledge darkens counsel, as in sophistry that obscures the shared purpose of the Roman and Spanish Inquisitions by emphasizing their different religious and civil justifications.ST Sep 10, 1896 Quoted teaching about the origin of evil and disease that obscures understanding rather than revealing truth darkens counsel despite its appearance of explanation.RH Aug 30, 1906
Claiming that the fourth commandment points forward to Christ darkens counsel without knowledge, for the Sabbath commandment is a memorial of creation, not a type of redemption.ST Jul 15, 1880 Arguing against the Lord's Sabbath while rejecting the clear path of Scripture darkens sound counsel with ignorant words in an attempt to avoid the cross of obedience.RH Sep 30, 1852 Ministers who oppose the seventh-day Sabbath by arguing that those keeping Saturday are really keeping the first day while those keeping Sunday are really keeping the seventh day obscure God's counsel, turn things upside down, and put darkness for light.RH Mar 20, 1856 In contrast God's people walk in the light of the fire he has kindled, ever rejoicing in the truth.RH Mar 20, 1856 All who endeavor to prove the change of the Sabbath darken counsel by multiplying words without knowledge, and the fallacies of their arguments show the weakness of their cause.RH Mar 13, 1856
Calling Sunday the Sabbath and using Bible texts about the seventh day to support Sunday observance hides God's counsel and perverts his word. Claiming that people cannot know which day God commands them to keep hides his counsel because it is irrelevant and obscures the duty to observe his appointed day rather than one of their own choosing.ST Aug 30, 1905 Calling the first day more honorable than the seventh day he called honorable, blessed, sanctified, and commanded to be kept holy darkens counsel by words without knowledge.RH Jan 8, 1875 Though he knew he made light on the first day, he did not set that day apart but chose, honored, and set apart the seventh day.RH Jan 8, 1875 Passing by what he gave about its blessing, sanctifying, commanding, reproving violation, and promising observance to set up another day as its rival with reasons he never gave that conflict with his reasons is presumption and folly continuing since Satan deceived the race to aspire to be as gods.RH Jan 8, 1875
Sources