Job 4:7
Remember, I pray thee, who ever perished, being innocent? or where were the righteous cut off?
Translations
Remember, I pray you, who ever perished, being innocent? or where were the righteous cut off?
Remember, I pray thee, who ever perished, being innocent? or where were the righteous cut off?
Remember, I pray thee, who ever perished, being innocent?
Or where were the righteous cut off?Remember, I pray thee, who ever perished, being innocent? or where were the righteous cut off;
Remember, I pray thee, who ever perished, being innocent? or where were the upright cut off?
Remember, I pray thee, who ever perished, being innocent?
Or where were the upright cut off?Remember, I pray thee, Who, being innocent, hath perished? And where have the upright been cut off?
Remember, I pray thee, who that was innocent has perished? and where were the upright cut off?
Remember, I pray thee, who, being innocent, hath perished, or when, the upright, have been cut off.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Consider now, I plead:
Who, being innocent, has ever perished?
Or where have the upright been destroyed?“ Remember, now, who ever perished, being innocent?
Or where were the upright cut off?Have you ever seen destruction come to an upright man? or when were the god-fearing ever cut off?
Remember, I pray thee: who euer perished, being an innocent? or where were the vpright destroyed?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Remember, I pray thee, who ever perished being innocent? or when were the just destroyed?
Cross-references
- Jeremiah 12:1
Righteous art thou, O LORD, when I plead with thee: yet let me talk with thee of thy judgments: Wherefore doth the way of the wicked prosper? wherefore are all they happy that deal very treacherously?
questions why wicked prosper
- Job 12:6
The tabernacles of robbers prosper, and they that provoke God are secure; into whose hand God bringeth abundantly.
Job's opposite answer that robbers prosper
- Psalms 73:3
For I was envious at the foolish, when I saw the prosperity of the wicked.
wicked also prosper
- Psalms 37:7
Rest in the LORD, and wait patiently for him: fret not thyself because of him who prospereth in his way, because of the man who bringeth wicked devices to pass.
wicked prosper despite evil devices
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Pioneers and periodicals
13 sources
Eliphaz speaks the question in his speech in the debate with Job over the cause of his afflictions.ST May 13, 1889RH Dec 30, 1915ST He lays down the rule that the innocent never perish and the righteous are never cut off, making prosperity sure proof of divine favor and adversity sure proof of divine displeasure, and by it implies that Job's loss of property and children and his bodily affliction must point to secret and open sin and departure from righteousness.RH Dec 8, 1904ST Aug 24, 1915ST Jun 17, 1913 As a general principle that evildoers reap what they sow and that evil will at last be punished and good rewarded, the saying is true in itself, yet it rests on only limited observation.ST Mar 27, 1893RH Mar 21, 1912 Eliphaz misapplied it to Job, for suffering does not prove a person is under God's displeasure, poverty does not prove guilt, and financial prosperity alone cannot prove right principles or divine approval, since the tents of robbers prosper while God often tries His children in the fire of affliction for their good and for the good of those who live after.ST May 13, 1889ST Jun 17, 1913ST Mar 27, 1893ST Sep 21, 1904ST Aug 24, 1904 The book was written to expose this argument from prosperity, so that later readers would not reject the Messiah because His poverty and life of toil and sorrow supposedly proved He could not be Emmanuel, for in the end God's way alone will be vindicated as the only way of real prosperity.RH Dec 8, 1904ST Jun 16, 1909
Speaker and Claim
The question belongs to Eliphaz in his speech within the debate between Job and his three friends concerning Job's afflictions.ST May 13, 1889RH Dec 30, 1915STST Sep 21, 1904 It asks whether anyone ever perished while being innocent and where the righteous were ever cut off, as part of an argument that affliction proves the sufferer has sinned.ST May 13, 1889ST Aug 24, 1915ST Aug 24, 1904 That principle was wrongly applied to Job, whom God had not condemned, and the words are not reliable as a true account of God or of Job unless supported by inspired Scripture, so they are not to be treated as an unquestionable rule.ST May 13, 1889ST Sep 21, 1904 The speech to which the question belongs teaches not to despise God's chastening.RH Dec 30, 1915
It lays down the friends' rule that the innocent never perish and the righteous are never cut off, making prosperity sure evidence of divine favor and adversity sure proof of divine displeasure.RH Dec 8, 1904ST Aug 24, 1915ST Jun 17, 1913ST Mar 27, 1893 Eliphaz uses it to imply that Job's suffering must point to sin and to charge him with departure from righteousness, forfeiture of God's favor, and secret and open sins.RH Dec 8, 1904ST Aug 24, 1915ST Jun 17, 1913ST Jun 16, 1909 He treats Job's loss of property and of sons and daughters and his bodily affliction as direct judgment from God, while asserting that those who plow iniquity and sow trouble reap the same and perish by the breath of God and are consumed by His anger.RH Dec 8, 1904ST Jun 16, 1909ST Aug 24, 1904 The friends thus question Job's innocence and insist the innocent do not perish, declaring his sufferings to be because of sin and reflecting only limited observation and human misunderstanding of God's purposes and dealings with His children.ST Aug 24, 1915ST Jun 17, 1913ST Mar 27, 1893ST Jun 16, 1909ST Aug 24, 1904
Its language of perishing and being cut off shows that man is mortal and corruptible, subject to perishing and being cut off, in contrast to God who alone possesses immortality.ST Sep 18, 1884
Truth and Error
As a general rule that the innocent do not perish and the righteous are not cut off, while those who sow trouble reap it and perish under God, the saying is true in itself, with evil at last punished and good rewarded.ST Mar 27, 1893RH Mar 21, 1912 The friends' use of it against Job reflected only limited observation.ST Mar 27, 1893 It was misapplied to Job by charging that his calamities came from terrible wickedness in his past life, though he had been counted good and very righteous, as if God knows and makes no mistakes.RH Mar 21, 1912 In fact God had not condemned Job.ST May 13, 1889 Suffering does not prove that a person is under God's displeasure.ST May 13, 1889ST Mar 27, 1893
God Himself declared the friends wrong for treating suffering as proof of guilt.ST Aug 24, 1904 The words of Eliphaz are therefore not reliable as a true account of God or of Job unless supported by inspired Scripture, and must not be taken as an unquestionable rule that the innocent never perish or the righteous are never cut off.ST Sep 21, 1904 Poverty and suffering do not prove guilt.ST Aug 24, 1904 The tents of robbers prosper and those who provoke God are secure.RH Dec 8, 1904
God does often bless His children with temporal prosperity, yet wicked men also acquire large wealth.RH Dec 8, 1904 Financial prosperity alone therefore cannot render a true verdict.RH Dec 8, 1904 It cannot prove right principles, nor divinely approved methods, nor disobedience to be right.RH Dec 8, 1904
The question where the righteous have been cut off affirms that the righteous are not taken before completing the time and work God has appointed for them.RH Apr 17, 1866 They die when God wills, after fulfilling their allotted course.RH Apr 17, 1866 The speech also teaches not to despise God's chastening.RH Dec 30, 1915
Purpose and Application
The book of Job was written to expose the argument from prosperity, that prosperity is sure evidence of divine favor and adversity is sure proof of divine displeasure.RH Dec 8, 1904 Financial prosperity alone cannot render a true verdict, for God does often bless His children with temporal prosperity yet wicked men also acquire large wealth, and the tents of robbers prosper while those who provoke God are secure, so it cannot prove right principles, divinely approved methods, or disobedience to be right.RH Dec 8, 1904 It was written to give light so later readers would not reject the Messiah because His poverty and life of toil and sorrow supposedly proved He could not be Emmanuel, God with us.RH Dec 8, 1904 In the end God's way alone will be vindicated as the only way of real prosperity.RH Dec 8, 1904
God was disciplining and trying Job and bringing him through the fire of affliction not simply for his own good but for the good of those who should live after.ST Jun 17, 1913ST Jun 16, 1909 The questioning displays the great problems of overruling providence, sin and suffering.ST Jun 17, 1913 It belongs to painful conversations that, with the continued pain of boils, led almost to despair.ST Jun 16, 1909
The verse exposes human misunderstanding of God's purposes and dealings with His children and proneness to misjudge others in the same way by thinking prosperity is evidence of God's favor.ST Jun 17, 1913ST Jun 16, 1909 The unjust accusation that affliction must come from secret and open sins helped unsettle the sufferer.ST Aug 24, 1915ST Jun 16, 1909 Meant to goad to desperation, it charged that calamity resulted from terrible wickedness in past life though counted good and very righteous, as if God knows and makes no mistakes.ST Jun 16, 1909RH Mar 21, 1912
Sources