Job 40:2
Shall he that contendeth with the Almighty instruct him? he that reproveth God, let him answer it.
Translations
Shall he that contends with the Almighty instruct him? he that reproves God, let him answer it.
King James Version, Webster Bible
Shall he that contendeth with the Almighty instruct him? he that reproveth God, let him answer it.
Shall he that contendeth with the Almighty instruct him?
He that reproveth God, let him answer it.Shall he that cavilleth contend with the Almighty? he that argueth with God, let him answer it.
Shall he that cavilleth contend with the Almighty?
He that argueth with God, let him answer it.Is the striver with the Mighty instructed? The reprover of God, let him answer it.
Shall he that will contend with the Almighty instruct [ him]? he that reproveth God, let him answer it.
Shall a reprover contend, with the Almighty? He that disputeth with GOD, let him answer it!
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“Will the faultfinder contend with the Almighty?
Let him who argues with God give an answer.”“Shall he who argues contend with the Almighty?
He who argues with God, let him answer it.”Will he who is protesting give teaching to the Ruler of all? Let him who has arguments to put forward against God give an answer.
Girde vp now thy loynes like a man: I will demaunde of thee, and declare thou vnto me.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Shall he that contendeth with God be so easily silenced? surely he that reproveth God, ought to answer him.
Cross-references
- Job 42:1-6
Then Job answered the LORD, and said,
Job answers God’s rebuke, repenting and acknowledging his limited understanding.
- Job 38:1-4
Then the LORD answered Job out of the whirlwind, and said,
God questions Job to reveal human limits and display his power and wisdom.
- Job 40:8
Wilt thou also disannul my judgment? wilt thou condemn me, that thou mayest be righteous?
God asks whether Job will condemn him in order to establish his own righteousness.
- Isaiah 40:13-14
Who hath directed the Spirit of the LORD, or being his counsellor hath taught him?
No one can counsel or instruct God, whose understanding is unsearchable.
- Job 38:4-11
Where wast thou when I laid the foundations of the earth? declare, if thou hast understanding.
God questions Job about creating the earth and setting limits for the sea.
- Romans 11:34
For who hath known the mind of the Lord? or who hath been his counsellor?
Both ask who can instruct or counsel the Almighty.
- Psalms 94:9
He that planted the ear, shall he not hear? he that formed the eye, shall he not see?
Both affirm that the Maker hears and sees.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
3 sources
Finite man is not qualified to instruct God, to contend with Him, to rightly challenge Him, to reprove Him, to sit in judgment on His plans, or to arraign Him to pass sentence on His works, but he who does so must answer to Him.Ms 236, 1902, par. 2–4MH 431.2–3RH Sep 25, 1900 This is because man was made last and took no part in creating the world or anything that has the breath of life.Ms 236, 1902, par. 2–4 Man was created after the image of God and Christ, and must therefore reject men's fallacies about God.Ms 236, 1902, par. 2–4
God's questions expose human limits and call people to recognize that many of His works and purposes are beyond their understanding.MH 431.2–3 God is infinitely wise and just and good and holds supervision over the universe, yet men know hardly anything of His mysteries.RH Sep 25, 1900 His plan for the redemption of the human race is not comprehended even by the wisest of earth, and beyond the utmost of human thinking and reasoning lies an infinity that will take all eternity to unfold.RH Sep 25, 1900
Those who think themselves competent to weigh and measure the counsels of divine wisdom do not know even the A B C of higher education, and though they discern only a little of God's marvelous power they take the glory that belongs to the Creator.RH Sep 25, 1900 Man must become a fool in his own estimation and show becoming humility.RH Sep 25, 1900 If the veil were removed and the greatness of God's plans were seen, every mouth would cease its boasting.RH Sep 25, 1900
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
15 sources
Jehovah speaks these words out of the storm to Job in rebuke, answering his desire for God to manifest Himself and speak with him as a man.RH Jan 6, 1916ST Jun 30, 1909ST Jul 22, 1908ST He confronts Job while Job is still defending himself and disputing with God, challenging him that one who contends with the Almighty cannot instruct Him and one who reproves God must answer for it.RH Apr 4, 1912ST Jun 30, 1909RH May 15, 1856 He presses the challenge by questions about creation and common things before Job, to show His infinite power, wisdom, goodness and tender care, and by contrast how exceedingly small, powerless and ignorant man is.RH Apr 4, 1912ST Jun 30, 1909ST Jul 22, 1908 If man can only partly comprehend material things, he can understand far less of God's moral dealings and His plan of redemption, so finite man is not qualified to sit in judgment on His plans, but must humble himself, repent, and trust and submit to the divine will even when he cannot understand it.RH Sep 25, 1900RH Jan 6, 1916RH Apr 4, 1912ST Jun 30, 1909ST Jun 24, 1913 To change God's way, plan or law to suit human judgment is to reprove God as though He had failed to choose what is best, as when men hold to eternal torture against His plain statements that the wicked shall die, perish and be consumed, and it is Christ's own question calling all who fight against the Almighty and condemn Him to make themselves righteous to answer for presuming to instruct Him.ST Jan 17, 1900RH May 15, 1856RH Jan 25, 1912ST Feb 4, 1903ST Dec 14, 1904
Setting and Plain Sense
The verse belongs to the fourth division of the book of Job, the speeches of the Lord out of the storm-cloud, coming after the prologue, the debate between Job and his three friends, and the speeches of Elihu.ST It is part of Jehovah speaking to Job in rebuke, in His answer beginning in chapter 38 and continuing in chapters 38 to 41, in which God condescends to speak to His servant in answer to Job's request that the Almighty speak to him as a man.RH Jan 6, 1916ST Jun 30, 1909ST Jul 22, 1908 It confronts Job while he is still defending himself as guilty of no open sin and desiring God to manifest Himself, in persistent self-justification stirred by his friends' false accusations, following Elihu's unanswered argument that Job is not great while God is everything.ST Jun 30, 1909 The verse challenges Job, who has been disputing with God, to answer whether he can instruct or correct the Almighty: he who contends with the Almighty cannot instruct Him, and he who reproves God must answer for it.RH Apr 4, 1912RH May 15, 1856
God presses the challenge through questions about creation and creatures, His mighty works in creation and many common things constantly before Job which he cannot understand, to show His infinite power and wisdom and also His goodness, love and tender care, and by contrast how exceedingly small, powerless and ignorant Job is.RH Apr 4, 1912ST Jun 30, 1909ST Jul 22, 1908ST Apr 10, 1893 He does not directly answer Job's arguments but reveals Himself through the works of nature.ST Apr 10, 1893 If Job can only partly comprehend material things, he can understand far less of God's moral dealings with men and His great purposes where eternal life itself is at stake.ST Jun 30, 1909 Finite man is not qualified to instruct God, reprove Him, sit in judgment on His plans, or arraign Him to pass sentence on His works, for beyond the utmost of human thinking lies an infinity concerning God's supervision of the universe and His plan for redemption that the wisest of earth do not comprehend and that will take all eternity to unfold.RH Sep 25, 1900ST Jun 30, 1909
The questions expose Job's ignorance and folly in questioning God's providences, humble his pride, show him how little he knows and how great God's power is, and lead him to see God in a new way while speaking to his understanding and disclosing wonderful revelations.ST Jul 22, 1908ST Jun 24, 1913ST Feb 5, 1880 Faced with the challenge Job admits his lowliness and vileness, acknowledges he has no answer, stops speaking, learns God is infinitely wise, just and good while he is utterly unworthy and of small account, and repents and humbles himself in dust and ashes.RH Jan 6, 1916RH Apr 4, 1912ST Jun 30, 1909ST Feb 5, 1880 God's sermon through nature, accompanied by the Spirit, restores him to patience and submission, teaching him to trust God whatever may come, submitting to the divine will even though he cannot understand it.ST Jun 24, 1913ST Feb 5, 1880ST Apr 10, 1893 Nature in this reveals only God's wisdom and power and not the mercy sinners need for salvation.ST Feb 5, 1880
Doctrinal Warning and Application
No one who strives against the Almighty is able to teach Him, for He framed the worlds by His word and in wisdom made them all, originating every law of nature, and having formed the ear He hears and having formed the eye He sees.ST Jan 22, 1894 All the fullness of the Deity dwelt bodily in Christ, who is the embodiment of all wisdom, whose words and works furnish food for the most unlearned and thought for the mightiest mind, refining character, uplifting the soul, and joining man to heaven.ST Jan 22, 1894 Those who imagine themselves fit to weigh and measure the counsels of divine wisdom have not yet learned even the ABC of higher education, and while perceiving only a little of God's marvelous power they take to themselves the glory that belongs to the Creator.RH Sep 25, 1900 Man must become a fool in his own esteem and manifest fitting humility, for were the veil lifted and the greatness of God's plans beheld, every mouth would stop its boasting.RH Sep 25, 1900
To alter God's way, plan, or law to fit human judgment is to reprove God, as if He had failed to choose what is best.ST Feb 4, 1903 To refuse the means of instruction He has appointed therefore lays personal responsibility under the warning that he who reproves God must answer for it.RH May 15, 1856ST Feb 4, 1903 To uphold eternal torment by denying as untrue His plain declarations that the wicked shall die, perish, be consumed soul and body, be brought to an utter end, be destroyed and come to an end, and be left as ashes, is to reprove and reproach God.RH Jan 25, 1912ST Dec 14, 1904 Whoever takes that position must answer it to Him.RH Jan 25, 1912ST Dec 14, 1904
The question is Christ's own question to Job, and He could with godlike dignity have rightly directed it against His persecutors at His trial.ST Jan 17, 1900 It meets human beings who fight against the Almighty and find fault with God, summoning them to answer for presuming to instruct Him and for setting aside His judgment and condemning Him in order to make themselves righteous.ST Jan 17, 1900 Though He possessed power to doom His enemies to death for every indignity inflicted by beings He had created, love for His Father and His pledge from the foundation of the world to become the sin-bearer to save all who come to Him in faith moved Him to endure their cruelty patiently and without complaint rather than utter this rebuke.ST Jan 17, 1900
Sources