John 3:4
Nicodemus saith unto him, How can a man be born when he is old? can he enter the second time into his mother’s womb, and be born?
Nicodemus saith unto him, How can a man be born when he is old? can he enter the second time into his mother’s womb, and be born?
Commentary part 2 of 2
Pioneers and periodicals
149 sources
Nicodemus takes being born again to mean a second physical birth when old, a return to the mother's womb to be born over.ST Apr 15, 1886ST Feb 13, 1893ST Nov 14, 1892 The birth required is not that, but being born anew from above, born of God and born of the Spirit.ST Jun 27, 1911ST Apr 23, 1896ST Sep 16, 1897 No one can see or enter the kingdom of God without it, whatever his rank or outward religion, because all are born sinners with a depraved nature that flesh birth can only reproduce.ST Feb 13, 1893ST Sep 17, 1894RH Mar 13, 1856ST Apr 16, 1896RH Aug 19, 1915 It cannot be gained by human will or effort, but is wrought by God through the Holy Spirit, often through the Word and baptism, and is received by repentance, faith in Christ, and surrender.ST Feb 13, 1893ST Sep 17, 1894ST Jun 27, 1911ST Oct 16, 1893ST Jun 27, 1911 It is a present moral and spiritual change to a new heart, new spirit and new life in this life, while those who held the other teaching placed the new birth at the resurrection when the just become immortal spirit.ST Nov 14, 1892RH Jul 23, 1861ST Jun 27, 1911ST Nov 14, 1892RH Jan 22, 1857
Question's Words and Setting
The question records a literal misunderstanding of being born again as a second physical birth, asking how a person can be born when old and whether he can enter a second time into his mother's womb and be born.ST Apr 15, 1886ST Feb 13, 1893ST Nov 14, 1892ST Jan 11, 1899ST Jan 18, 1905 It comes from one acquainted only with birth of the flesh, taking being born anew as an old man re-entering his mother's womb to be born, which sets up the contrast that what is born of the flesh is flesh and what is born of the Spirit is spirit.ST Feb 13, 1893ST Aug 27, 1894ST Feb 13, 1893 The change meant is not fleshly or material but spiritual, a moral change from the carnal life to the spiritual life wrought by God's Spirit through faith in Christ and necessary to see and enter the kingdom of God.ST Nov 14, 1892ST Sep 17, 1894ST Apr 23, 1896 That work of the Spirit is mysterious like the blowing of the wind, and it embraces both the spiritual character formed here and the further change needed for life in God's kingdom.ST Feb 13, 1893ST Nov 14, 1892
The question expresses surprise, puzzlement, incredulity and marveling, and failure to grasp the meaning.ST Feb 22, 1899ST Apr 23, 1896ST Apr 25, 1906ST Aug 19, 1886 It stumbles over teaching about being born from above by treating it as a physical impossibility, reflecting the difficulty of accepting what cannot be understood by ordinary experience.RH Nov 7, 1907RH Nov 7, 1907 Inability to explain how the work happens does not make it unreal, for the new birth is known by its seen results though the Spirit himself and the manner of his working cannot be seen or explained, just as the wind is known by its effects.RH Nov 7, 1907 In one telling the misunderstanding is pretended, and in another it is a scornful question that a literal living over of life is impossible.ST Aug 19, 1886
The literal answer came as he was startled and irritated by personal application exposing that outward piety, good works, respectable life and moral character could not qualify him for the kingdom in his present spiritual state.ST Apr 29, 1913ST Apr 15, 1886ST Nov 15, 1883ST Jan 11, 1883 Pride in good works and piety had led him to think his own life perfect before God though he had long seen the lack of spirituality around him, and the words exposed his unfitness.ST Apr 15, 1886 His focus was on how the new birth happens rather than seeking life, while the answer concerns neither bodily resurrection nor a nation born in a day but inward cleansing and renewal of the sinful heart by the Spirit, without which outward righteousness, strict observance and religious forms cannot avail.ST Mar 29, 1899ST Jan 11, 1877 Seeking life rather than debating a new theory changes how the Scriptures are searched, and as he submitted to the leading of the Holy Spirit he began to see the kingdom of heaven.ST Mar 29, 1899
The exchange belongs to a private nighttime interview and conversation about salvation and the soul, occasioned by a secret visit from a Pharisee and ruler of the Jews who came to inquire, brought his difficulties and questions while searching for truth, and received patient explanation that he must be born again, born of the Spirit.RH Jul 1, 1902RH Mar 25, 1902 That single-hearer conversation allowed instruction that could not have been given in the presence of the Sanhedrin and would not have been received there, and it is held up as a model of personal ministry and occasion for practical teaching.RH Jul 4, 1907 He who came secretly later spoke for a just hearing and became a humble influential disciple.ST Mar 29, 1899RH Jul 1, 1902
The word saith uses the historical present to tell a past event vividly, not to mark present time, and its present tense does not prove a present or continuing action.RH Mar 25, 1873 The verse has been confused with 1 John 3:4 on sin as transgression of the law, including claims that it refers to the Ten Commandments and that it was cited for that definition in error.ST Apr 6, 1915ST Jan 14, 1886ST Jan 5, 1915 In that confusion it has been connected with the law that says Thou shalt not covet, the last of the ten commandments in Exodus 20:3-17 spoken at Sinai and written by God on stone, as the holy and just and good law still binding whose universal transgression makes gospel preaching necessary, convicting of sin and pointing to cleansing.ST Apr 6, 1915ST Jan 14, 1886 It has likewise been connected with Christ's death for sins as transgressions of God's law, as reason for the Spirit to write that law in the heart and for grateful love to avoid sin and keep it, and with the teaching that wherever sin is found the law is present and broken and Christ is needed as Redeemer and mediator from Adam until sin and sinners are no more.ST Oct 7, 1880RH Apr 29, 1875
Though a master and leading teacher in Israel, he knew only birth of the flesh and reasoned in human terms, questioning through ordinary human reasoning what should have been known.ST Feb 13, 1893ST Feb 13, 1893ST Jun 21, 1899 He looked for a temporal kingdom, which kept him from understanding the spiritual truth being taught.ST Aug 27, 1894 The mystery cannot be comprehended through natural processes or human reason, must be received by simple faith in God's word rather than learned by reason or accomplished by human power, and no one who has not felt the transforming and renewing influences of the Spirit in his own heart can comprehend it.ST Sep 17, 1894ST Aug 19, 1886ST Jun 21, 1899 The earthly change spoken of had been manifested often in Israel, yet testimony about what is known and seen was not accepted, and the contrast with heavenly things exposed that failure.ST Aug 12, 1889
Spiritual Not Physical Birth
Nicodemus heard the requirement to be born again as a question about physical birth, about an old man entering his mother's womb a second time to be born, and answered with surprise in the most literal, material sense.ST Feb 13, 1893ST Jan 9, 1893ST Apr 23, 1896 The birth required is not a second physical birth from the mother or a return to the womb, but being born anew, born again, born from above, born of God, born of the Spirit.ST Jun 27, 1911ST Sep 16, 1897ST Aug 27, 1896 That new birth is primarily a moral change in character rather than a fleshly or material birth, yet in its full scope it ultimately includes the resurrection, when the grave cannot hold those whose character is right.ST Jun 27, 1911ST Apr 23, 1896ST Sep 16, 1897 It is not received by human descent, fleshly choice, or human law, but by receiving Christ and being begotten of God through personal faith in Christ as giver of life, and it is brought about by the Spirit of God as birth into new spiritual life.ST Sep 16, 1897ST Aug 27, 1896
That which is born of the flesh is flesh and that which is born of the Spirit is spirit, so the difference exposed is between birth of the flesh which is flesh and birth of the Spirit which is spirit, with a different birth of water and the Spirit necessary to see and enter the kingdom.ST Feb 13, 1893ST Jan 9, 1893ST Jan 16, 1893 Birth of the flesh produces only flesh, man's natural unregenerate condition of living unto self by following the lusts and desires of the natural man, which cannot please God, cannot receive the things of the Spirit because they are spiritually discerned, and does not connect a person with God and life.ST Oct 7, 1886ST Jan 16, 1893RH Oct 30, 1900 To become spiritual, render spiritual service to God, and live unto Him who died and rose again instead of living unto self, a person must be brought forth by divine power and born from above, born of water and of the Spirit.ST Jan 16, 1893RH Oct 30, 1900 That work of the Spirit is mysterious like the blowing of the wind.ST Feb 13, 1893
The new birth is a real moral and spiritual change from the carnal life to the spiritual life, wrought in a person by God's power and obtained through faith in Christ, including a change of nature from fleshly to spiritual that is necessary to enter the kingdom.ST Nov 14, 1892ST Nov 14, 1892ST Apr 23, 1896 It is a radical change of nature, heart, affections, motives and character, not a mended respectable life, gradual development, repair of human nature, or cultivation of human nature, but an entirely new start in which God gives a clean heart and brings His own nature into a person through the indwelling Holy Spirit.ST Jun 27, 1911ST Oct 31, 1911RH Oct 5, 1916 It is brought about through conversion and sanctification, enabling a life freed from sin and disobedience, and its scope encompasses both the present moral change and the other change needed for life in God's kingdom, including the change to immortality at Christ's coming and the resurrection of the righteous.ST Nov 14, 1892ST Jun 27, 1911ST Oct 31, 1911 Right living depends first on becoming right, and this change cannot be achieved through human effort or righteousness by works.ST Jun 27, 1911
It is God replacing the heart of stone with a heart of flesh, creating a clean heart and renewing a right spirit, giving a new heart and new spirit, turning from the old life to the new.ST Apr 7, 1881ST Dec 20, 1905ST Jul 8, 1889 This shows a radical change in human nature, not physical birth, by which a person is made a new creation and new creature in Christ, created unto good works in righteousness and true holiness and necessary for cleansing of sin.ST Dec 20, 1905ST Apr 19, 1905ST Jul 3, 1893 The change begins with a change of heart or mind when a person yields to God's Spirit, when the Spirit cleanses the heart and creates new affections, purposes and motives, making the person a child of God through faith in Jesus Christ and beginning a new life as an effective work done by God.ST Apr 7, 1881ST Jun 17, 1903ST Jul 3, 1893ST Jul 8, 1889 It continues until grace's work is complete or the Spirit is grieved and withdraws, and its completion includes God making His people immortal at the last day, when the body is redeemed from corruption.ST Apr 7, 1881ST Jun 17, 1903 It is done by the same power of God that raised Christ from the dead, the power in the gospel and of the eternal Spirit by which Christ offered Himself without spot, by which His children keep the righteousness of the law, and by which the power of His endless life triumphant over sin and death is lived in everyone who has faith in Him.ST Apr 19, 1905
It is birth into God's family as children of God and children of the last Adam, receiving divine life as a mother imparts life to her child, with the Spirit imparting the Spirit's own life to the child of God, which is eternal life.ST Oct 7, 1886RH Oct 30, 1900ST Dec 25, 1893ST Dec 26, 1906 Those so born become partakers of the divine nature rather than relying on natural human goodness, and bear the image of the heavenly as children of Christ, the second Adam, who becomes the Father of the redeemed race and the source of their eternal life.RH Oct 30, 1900ST Jan 1, 1894ST Aug 30, 1905 Those born from above are heavenly and spiritual, receive the things of the Spirit because they are spiritually discerned, are no longer in the flesh but in the Spirit because the Spirit of God dwells in them, can please God, are made subject to the law of God with the carnal mind destroyed and the mind of Christ given, and theirs are all the privileges, blessings and joys of that birthright, including seeing the kingdom of God.ST Oct 7, 1886RH Oct 30, 1900
Birth decides parentage: natural earthly birth makes children of the first Adam, who is earthy, natural, and of the flesh, while the new spiritual heavenly birth from above makes children of the second Adam, the Lord from heaven, spiritual and life-giving.ST Oct 7, 1886RH Oct 30, 1900ST Aug 30, 1905 Just as all the sin that ever appeared in life was already present from the first Adam from the day of natural birth, all the good and all the righteousness that ever can appear in life was already present from the last Adam from the day of being born again and comes only from him who caused the new birth, in which believers are created new creatures in Christ Jesus.RH Oct 16, 1900 In that birth believers are born from above, born of God, becoming children of the last Adam, who is both the Child born and the everlasting Father and Prince of Peace.ST Aug 30, 1905RH Oct 16, 1900
Timing and Completeness of Birth
The new birth begins in this present life when a person yields to God, and it is a present spiritual birth rather than a change to the body postponed until the resurrection.RH Jun 26, 1866ST Oct 7, 1886RH Aug 16, 1906 Nicodemus understood Jesus to be speaking of a new life to be entered in this world, for as one who believed in the resurrection he would not have been puzzled if Jesus had meant only the future resurrection, and his question about the mother's womb shows he took the words as requiring present entrance upon new life.RH Aug 16, 1906 That birth is by the Spirit from above and not a physical rebirth, giving a new heart and spirit, filling with divine life, and enabling walking in God's statutes and obedience to His judgments.ST Oct 7, 1886RH Aug 16, 1906 Converted people are still flesh and not yet spirit, but the Spirit's indwelling prepares them for resurrection to life.ST Oct 7, 1886
The new birth takes place at the resurrection of the just and not at conversion in this life, because natural birth is used in Scripture sometimes to represent conversion and sometimes to represent the resurrection.RH Jul 23, 1861 Seeing and entering the kingdom of God follows being born again, and that entering does not follow conversion but will follow the resurrection.RH Jul 23, 1861 That which is born of the flesh is flesh and that which is born of the Spirit is spirit means that converted people remain flesh, while those brought forth from the dead by the Spirit will be spirit, for God is a Spirit Being and the children of the resurrection to life will be spiritual beings.RH Jul 23, 1861 As the wind blows where it pleases and its sound is heard without its coming and going being traced, so is everyone born of the Spirit, which is not true of mortals even when converted but will be true of the immortal saints.RH Jul 23, 1861 In this reckoning two births, and only two, are necessary to enter God's kingdom, natural birth and birth of the Spirit, and the new birth of the Spirit is the resurrection to immortal life, since conversion does not give the power associated with that birth.RH Mar 13, 1856 People in the present flesh-and-blood state cannot enter God's kingdom but must be changed to incorruptible bodies, as at the resurrection, or an equivalent change.RH Jan 22, 1857
The fuller teaching holds both together, that the new birth includes the present moral change through conversion and sanctification and the future change to incorruptibility and immortality at Christ's coming.ST Nov 14, 1892ST Apr 7, 1881ST Jun 27, 1911ST Jun 17, 1903ST Oct 31, 1911 The change Jesus describes instead of a literal return to the mother's womb is a moral change from the carnal life to the spiritual life, wrought by God's Spirit and obtained through faith in Christ, in which God replaces the heart of stone with a heart of flesh, creates a clean heart and renews a right spirit, and turns a person from the old life to the new.ST Nov 14, 1892ST Apr 7, 1881 This change begins when a person yields to God's Spirit and fully accepts the Lord Jesus Christ as the one and only Saviour, with God accepting him as His child, and it continues through growth in the Christian life until grace's work is complete or the Spirit is grieved and withdraws.ST Apr 7, 1881ST May 7, 1912 It begins with a change of heart or mind, comes from above through the power of God's Spirit, is primarily a moral change in character brought about through conversion and sanctification enabling a life freed from sin and disobedience, and right living depends first on becoming right, which cannot be achieved through human effort or righteousness by works.ST Jun 27, 1911ST Jun 17, 1903ST Oct 31, 1911 Its completion includes God making His people immortal at the last day, the resurrection of the body or the changing from mortality to immortality placing God's stamp upon incorruptible character, when the grave cannot hold those whose character is right and the spiritual character formed here encompasses the other change needed for life in God's kingdom.ST Nov 14, 1892ST Apr 7, 1881ST Jun 27, 1911ST May 7, 1912
Birth is used as a figure for the comprehensive change from a sinful, mortal state to a holy, eternal one, covering conversion, baptism connected with conversion, growth in spiritual life, perfection of Christian character, and finally immortality through translation or resurrection.RH Feb 28, 1871 In Scripture birth represents two events, conversion and resurrection from the dead, and here the birth of God's children includes their rising at the first resurrection and being gathered to the heavenly city.ST Aug 22, 1878 The change wrought in a man's heart by conversion is sometimes illustrated by the figure of birth, but the new birth properly is birth into the immortal kingdom by a resurrection from the dead, or a change equivalent thereto, and the great and final change called the New Birth is distinguished from the moral change that takes place in this life through faith in Christ, which is the redemption of the body.RH Jul 2, 1857RH Apr 5, 1870 Baptism prefigures this change to immortality that must occur before people can inherit God's kingdom, for the believer is buried with the Lord and rises to walk in newness of life, which Nicodemus as teacher of Israel should have understood from Ezekiel's prophecy and similar passages.RH Jul 12, 1864RH Nov 26, 1861
The new birth is a bathing of the whole man that thoroughly purifies the moral nature once and does not need to be done again, sharing with baptism the character of a one-time initiation into privileges and duties that cannot and ought not to be repeated.ST Jun 25, 1885ST Mar 29, 1899 Stains contracted afterward in the walk of life do not undo it, for daily imperfections only need to be washed away like dust from the feet, and then the person is wholly clean again.ST Mar 29, 1899 Whether the new birth occurs before or only when a person is changed from mortality to immortality has been the subject of dispute, and the questions of being born again at conversion and whether someone who sins afterward is still a sinner and can still be a Christian have been raised but left unanswered.RH Feb 20, 1855ST
Necessity and Means of Birth
No one can see or enter the kingdom of God without being born again, born anew from above by water and the Spirit, for flesh birth produces only flesh and leaves a person unconnected with God and life.ST Feb 13, 1893ST Sep 17, 1894RH Mar 13, 1856ST Feb 14, 1906 This necessity rests on all alike, whatever rank, education, wealth, parentage, ancestry or outward religion, and it cannot be learned by human reason or accomplished by human power but must be received by simple faith in God's word.ST Feb 13, 1893ST Sep 17, 1894RH Oct 30, 1900 Entry requires two births, the natural earthly birth that makes a child of the first Adam and the heavenly spiritual birth that makes a child of the last Adam, the Lord from heaven who is a life-giving Spirit.RH Mar 13, 1856RH Oct 30, 1900 Those thus born from above become heavenly and spiritual, receive the things of the Spirit because they are spiritually discerned, are no longer in the flesh but in the Spirit because the Spirit of God dwells in them, have the carnal mind destroyed and the mind of Christ given, are made subject to the law of God, belong to Christ by having the Spirit of Christ, and inherit all the privileges, blessings and joys of the last Adam.RH Oct 30, 1900ST Feb 14, 1906
The need is universal because all are born sinners with a poisoned source of life, a depraved nature inclined to rebel, a radical defect of heart, and inherited impurity flowing down through the centuries.ST Apr 16, 1896RH Aug 19, 1915ST Jun 2, 1909RH Feb 19, 1857 No child is born morally white, for every child inherits the vices and virtues of ancestors in a stream of human life turned out of its channel sixty centuries ago when God breathed into man the breath of life, and that stream has flowed down through sin picking up impurity now poured into the veins of every child.ST Apr 3, 1884ST Jun 2, 1909 Righteousness is not hereditary and religion cannot pass by descent, so the child of a saint is born a sinner who will live and die and perish as surely as the child of the vilest sinners unless he repents and is converted to God.RH Aug 19, 1915ST Apr 3, 1884 Man has no hope for life in himself and can get no righteousness from himself, no more working himself up to be a partaker of the divine nature than a beast can work itself up into humanity, and the ultimate cause of evil lies in this evil nature rather than in environment.ST Apr 16, 1896ST Dec 19, 1916 The entire work of regeneration, conversion and renewing of heart and life must therefore be repeated in each successive generation through thorough conversion, personal acquaintance with the Lord Jesus Christ, faith, and yielding to God to become a new creature, for training, instruction and good example may lead children toward Christ but salvation belongs to God alone, and without this change the world, the flesh and the devil opposing every influence toward right would be victorious in every life.ST Apr 3, 1884ST Jun 2, 1909
A repeated physical birth would not free the sinner, for simply entering the mother's womb a second time and living life over again would only reproduce the carnal nature and would not make a person better.ST Jun 27, 1911ST Jan 17, 1900 The new birth Jesus taught is primarily a moral change of character, not a second physical birth, and right living depends first on becoming right, which cannot be achieved through human effort or righteousness by works.ST Jun 27, 1911ST Jun 27, 1911 It is not brought about by human will, power or religious systems, but by God's will and the Holy Spirit working through the Word, and it is not a result of human works, learning, civilization, success, law-keeping or reform, which do not free people from selfishness and sin.ST Jun 27, 1911ST Aug 22, 1911ST Jul 3, 1893RH Nov 26, 1903 It is God's gift of new life from above, which people receive and then live out simply and naturally, as the conscience awakens through God's Word, the person sees himself in comparison with the sinless Christ, renounces self and sin, yields fully to God, confesses sin and trusts Christ as Savior.ST Aug 22, 1911ST Jul 3, 1893RH Nov 26, 1903
That gift is wrought by the Spirit of God, making birth into new life spiritual rather than physical, mysterious in its working like the blowing of the wind which cannot be controlled or confined though its effects are seen.ST Feb 13, 1893ST Jun 27, 1911ST Aug 27, 1896 It comes when a person submits to the will of God, opens the heart to admit the Spirit as the indwelling Comforter to abide forever, is receptive before Him, and by faith grasps spiritual regeneration, believing the promise that sins are forgiven and cleansed so that God supplies the fact.ST Oct 16, 1893ST Nov 21, 1895 God's Spirit pleads with the unrepentant through His word taught and preached, through holy angels and in various ways to turn and live, and that pleading leads to the new birth, often through the Word, the gospel and the water of baptism as the sign of renouncing the world.ST Feb 13, 1893ST Sep 17, 1894ST Jun 27, 1911ST Nov 21, 1895
The whole plan of salvation set forth in this discourse is based on the love of God, for sin in the very nature of things produces death and God in love devised a plan at the sacrifice of His willing only-begotten Son by which believers should not perish but have everlasting life.ST Apr 15, 1886ST Mar 15, 1905 Eternal life is not a natural inheritance but God's gift through Jesus Christ received through the new birth, which communicates God's own life and carries in it the germ of eternal life of incorruptible parentage, not merely purity and happiness added to an immortality everyone already possesses.ST Oct 11, 1905ST Mar 4, 1886 That higher divine life belonging to the world to come is found only in Christ and is given to those otherwise perishing, so that to become a new creature through Christ as faith takes hold of God's love is to be saved and inherit the kingdom of heaven.ST Apr 15, 1886 The claim that man has a deathless soul living on by nature contradicts the need for the new birth and would make Christ's offering to bring life and immortality vain, whereas in the new birth complete obedience covers the believing sinner with righteousness, the vital power of God's Spirit transforms the heart, and the sinner by faith unites with Christ in crucifixion and death, is buried with Him in baptism, and comes forth as a new man with no condemnation, a free man living through the life of his Lord.ST Oct 11, 1905
Regeneration is a re-creation and a miracle, not merely a change in ethical conduct, wrought by the same all-power that created heaven and earth.ST Nov 21, 1895 The new spiritual life is begotten in the heart by the divine Spirit when the will is surrendered to God, and its mystery is no greater than the mystery of creation.ST Jun 23, 1914ST Jun 9, 1890 It is not a natural process or a step in ordinary progress, it lies beyond scientific discovery and natural law and must be received by faith because it is divinely revealed.RH Nov 7, 1907ST Jun 9, 1890 Though the Spirit himself and the manner of his working cannot be seen or explained, just as the wind is known by its effects, its results are often visible and often invisible, seen in the tearful eye and other signs of repentance and in love, joy, goodness and other manifest fruits, and inability to explain the work does not make it unreal, for it is known by experience and its effects even when it cannot be traced.RH Nov 7, 1907ST Apr 3, 1893ST Jun 23, 1914
Results in Character and Life
The Spirit gives a new mind, purifies the life, ennobles the character, cleanses from sin, and makes holy, because keeping a spiritual law requires becoming spiritual through being born again of water and the Spirit unto righteousness.ST Apr 29, 1913RH Feb 28, 1871 This regeneration through the Word delivers from bondage to corruption, sin and death, and prepares a blameless holy people triumphant over temptation to stand before the Father's glory as heirs of eternal life.ST Feb 24, 1898RH Nov 24, 1859 The carnal mind is not subject to God's law and cannot be, so the new heart saves from transgression and ends resistance by writing the law within, and the change comes by grace through repentance, humility, submission and practical acceptance of divine truth, not by any human remedy.ST Apr 29, 1913RH Jan 12, 1905 Those who enter the kingdom have pure, lowly, obedient, loving hearts and remain firm in faith and service.ST Apr 29, 1913
The new birth is complete transformation by the Holy Spirit, not a mended or patched respectable life, creating a new being in the image of God by communication of divine life.ST Jul 16, 1896 The mind, as God's invisible agent governing action, is taken possession of and purified from all evil to become the motive power of good, so wicked thoughts are put away, evil deeds renounced, and love, peace and humility replace anger, envy and strife.ST Jul 16, 1896ST Mar 29, 1899 Dishonesty, vice, ungovernable appetite, hatred, emulation, strife, envy, drunkenness and every other evil, whatever its form, strength or degrading depth, are driven away and cleansed as chaff before a hurricane, a tangible change full of upbuilding vitality that opens an illimitable ocean of divine power.ST Mar 29, 1899 It is Heaven's remedy for sin-sick souls, deliverance from sin through the blood of the Lamb, applicable to every age, nationality and condition, for which no human substitute or improvement of temporal conditions can stand.RH Sep 15, 1910 Man has no hope or righteousness in himself, since the source of life is poisoned with death and he can no more lift himself to partake of the divine nature than a beast can lift itself into humanity, so salvation from eternal death is God's gift, with the gift of righteousness as life set against the wages of sin as death.ST Apr 16, 1896 Through Christ's death the believing sinner is reckoned righteous without works and regarded as one with Christ, standing uncondemned, constituted righteous as he was constituted a sinner by Adam's disobedience, with old things passed away and Christ's life lived in him as Christ in him the hope of glory, his life hid with Christ in God, freed from death and passed from death unto life.ST Apr 16, 1896ST Apr 16, 1896
Its results are visible, for though the moving of the Spirit itself cannot be seen any more than wind, its effects appear in the tearful eye and other signs of repentance and in love, joy, goodness and other manifest fruits, discerned truly only by those who have the Spirit.ST Apr 3, 1893 Those born from above by the Spirit are different in nature from the world and are created in Christ for good works.ST Aug 5, 1897 The change is positive and evident, known by the one newly born, by those about him, and by the world which justly expects it, making it the test of conversion, as when the outlaw Africaner proved his change by going with Moffat to the very officials who offered a large reward for his capture living or dead.ST Jul 7, 1909 It is revealed in honesty, uprightness, faithfulness and steadfast principle.ST Nov 30, 1915 A life ruled by worry, want, discord, doubt and care is incompatible with the second birth, and mere closeness to light and instruction without a changed heart leaves covetousness unchanged, as with Judas, who had not experienced this birth and so lacked faith to stand in trial.ST Sep 3, 1894ST Feb 14, 1906
Birth from God enables true love, for love comes from God and everyone who has it is born of God and knows Him, not as fleeting passion or transient emotion but as abiding principle.ST Aug 7, 1893ST Jun 18, 1896 The one born of the Spirit enters the kingdom as a spiritual babe who is welcomed and given a prepared place, with the Father watching growth, supplying every need from His riches, providing the milk of the Word as abundant food and opportunity for vigorous exercise under watchful care.ST Oct 5, 1904 As a flesh babe gradually grows in perception of life, the spiritual being's sensibilities enlarge to the realities of the kingdom, passing from darkness of sin into ever-increasing light of eternal day, with every exercise bringing development and purest joy as foretaste of fullness to be revealed at Christ's coming.ST Oct 5, 1904 Without this real personal experience no one can see or enter the kingdom, for a person may see physically yet remain spiritually blind, and physical strength gives no spiritual life.ST Feb 24, 1914 It is continuing renewal bringing strength out of weakness and good out of evil, as the soul recognizes need of God, relies on the Spirit, and rises freed from sin to a brighter life of holiness.ST Mar 11, 1913 The change is from a life ruled by sin, vice and self to righteousness, virtue and service, bringing new hope, joy, love, peace and zeal to help others, coming through trial, conflict and self-crucifixion with blessings from above.ST Jan 3, 1905
Regeneration gives new life with power to overcome sin and live soberly, righteously and godly in this present world.RH Aug 24, 1905 The heart has a radical defect in its mainspring and is out of order like a broken watch, so it must be taken to God as to a skillful mechanic to be set right into good running order with regular motion, and only then by grace can it be kept with diligence, for the unregenerated heart cannot keep itself.RH Aug 30, 1870 One born of God turns from sin and does not consent to it.ST Nov 9, 1915 The change is of the inside spirit, not a remaking of the outside body and brain, which remain the same even if inefficient, incapable, cursed by heredity, weakened by habit, undisciplined, untrained, and still subject to disease, pain and failure, while the world outside still has storms, pestilence and famine.RH Jul 8, 1909 The Spirit does not make body, brain or world over to remove difficulties but makes over the real inner man to face and conquer them by getting good out of them, so pain and misfortune bring sweetness of spirit and renewed faith instead of bitterness and despondency, which is the peace passing understanding in a spirit quickened into life that evil cannot quench nor disaster embitter.RH Jul 8, 1909 The new nature does not immediately remove the old, and their conflict is evidence of the new birth, for without a new nature there would be no opposing will or battle; the old nature is not converted but is gradually subdued and put to death as the believer cooperates with God until it is finally destroyed, making overcomers who conquer through trial.ST Jan 3, 1905ST Oct 19, 1915
The new birth can begin in childhood, for a child can turn to Christ early, love and obey God, and grow up in Him before years of wrongdoing take hold.ST Dec 13, 1905 Though puzzling when taken physically as birth in old age, it is a simple essential gospel requirement that even children, the illiterate and the heathen can understand, or they could not be saved.ST Dec 13, 1905RH Mar 12, 1914 Some can remember the exact time and place of conversion while others cannot, and inability to name a precise date does not by itself show absence of rebirth.RH Mar 3, 1874 It can bring every child, however badly born in a disjointed and misfitting family, into spiritual life, replacing the heart for the whole race by the same power that makes of twain one new man, reconstructing divided halves that misrepresented fatherhood and motherhood, for those who had to be lost before being found and sinners before being redeemed.RH Jan 9, 1900 A person may be born again after reaching natural maturity, and some mature converts are transformed quickly into effective workers.RH Aug 21, 1913 True fatherhood and motherhood teach the experience, for children help a true Christian mother and father become better Christians than without them by giving revelations of God that make salvation possible.RH Jan 16, 1900
Scriptural Connections and Illustrations
The night conversation in John 3:1-15 lays out the entire plan of salvation as grounded in God's love, with the new birth, birth of water and the Spirit, the wind blowing where it pleases, and everlasting life for believers in the willing only-begotten Son who was given so that sinners whose sin by its very nature produces death should not perish.ST Feb 13, 1893ST Mar 15, 1905ST Feb 13, 1893 Nicodemus knew only birth of the flesh and so imagined an old man entering his mother's womb a second time, which exposes the contrast that what is born of flesh is flesh and what is born of Spirit is spirit and establishes that a different birth is necessary to see and enter the kingdom of God.ST Feb 13, 1893ST Feb 13, 1893 The events belong just before Jesus went to Samaria, for after speaking with Nicodemus Jesus and His disciples left Jerusalem and taught in Judea during the summer.ST Sep 3, 1894
The same change of heart is taught more clearly than anywhere else in Ezekiel 36:26-27, where God takes away the stony heart, gives a heart of flesh and a new spirit, and puts His Spirit within to cause walking in His statutes and keeping and doing His judgments.ST Apr 7, 1881ST Jan 25, 1905 This is the spiritual change of the new birth, in which God creates a clean heart and renews a right spirit and turns a person from the old life to the new, beginning when a person yields to God's Spirit and continuing until grace's work is complete, including making His people immortal at the last day, or until the Spirit is grieved and withdraws.ST Apr 7, 1881 As teacher in Israel Nicodemus should have understood this from Ezekiel's prophecy and similar passages, since his question showed misunderstanding of the birth as physical birth rather than birth from the dead and change to immortality that must occur before inheriting God's kingdom, which baptism prefigures.RH Jul 12, 1864
Becoming a child of Jerusalem above requires being born again, born from above, because that city is above. God's promised children are begotten by His direct power, born of the Spirit and from above, and this birth distinguishes Abraham's children of faith, citizens of the heavenly Jerusalem, from his natural descendants who are born after the flesh.RH Jan 15, 1901 The resurrected people of God are the children of the great family of heaven, with Christ as their everlasting Father and the New Jerusalem as their mother.RH Nov 12, 1857
Being born again is receiving Christ by the Holy Spirit, the direct power of the Highest, the same power by which Christ came in the flesh through the Spirit's overshadowing.ST Oct 16, 1893ST Oct 14, 1913 The Son of God became human, born of David's line, so that people might receive this second birth, become children of God and regain likeness to God, be born of the Spirit and become members of God's house.ST Apr 22, 1889RH Jun 10, 1902 That new birth makes the sinner a child of God and heir with Christ destined to share His glory, and it requires the soul to submit to God in receptiveness, for faith to grasp spiritual regeneration, and for the promise of forgiveness and cleansing to be believed, whereupon God supplies the fact.ST Oct 16, 1893ST Oct 14, 1913 The crucified and risen Saviour is thus to be born in the heart of each of the saved.RH Aug 19, 1915
The difference between the natural man and the spiritual man, the non-Christian and the Christian, is the same as between the inorganic and the organic, the dead and the living, the crystal and the organism, the stone and the plant.ST Oct 31, 1916 As dead matter cannot produce life without life reaching down from above, the natural man cannot become spiritual by his own effort or gradual development but must be born again through power from the spiritual world above.ST Oct 31, 1916 No matter how beautiful an object in the inorganic world such as onyx or diamond may be, it remains in the inorganic world unless vitalized with life from above, so even apparently beautiful non-Christian lives remain in the natural world unless vitalized with that life which is from above.ST Oct 31, 1916 Individual salvation requires this new birth because the ultimate cause of evil is in man's evil nature, not in his environment, so human schemes for the world's salvation that try to remove consequences of sin without removing sin itself deal with symptoms rather than causes, and even where they might help general welfare without curtailing individual rights they become evil when they step between the individual and personal accountability to the Creator.ST Dec 19, 1916 Evolutionary philosophy undermines and takes away this truth of a new birth from above that belongs to the whole basis of Christian faith and missions to be carried to the heathen and proclaimed, and the teaching is set aside whenever evolution is accepted in theory or practiced in life.RH Dec 30, 1902ST Sep 1, 1909 Regeneration is a change from sin to righteousness brought about by God's power, not a process taking years through gradual evolution.ST Nov 28, 1911
The new birth begins the sanctified life, and everyone who has received it keeps the Sabbath as a sign that God creates a clean heart and sanctifies the believer, since a person must be converted and born again through the transforming grace of Christ before rightly keeping the Sabbath of Jehovah and living a holy life.ST Apr 6, 1915 Through preaching of the gospel people are born into heaven's kingdom and sealed by divine agencies for eternal life, and being born into the kingdom means precious souls accepting truth and being baptized to unite with the church, shown by keeping the Sabbath and paying tithe, while God works mightily to bring about this birth as His workers pray for Him to prosper the work and for many more souls to be born in the same way.RH Jan 23, 1908ST Jan 13, 1914 Nicodemus taking the teaching as if it meant physical birth again from one's mother stands as a warning that the church had forgotten the need for conversion and genuine personal religious experience, since church membership alone cannot provide what an old person asking about entering his mother's womb a second time still lacks.RH May 8, 1900RH May 8, 1900
The Christian life has its origin in the new birth, in which God, His Son, and the Holy Spirit all act in its origin, growth, development and maturity, moulding the life and giving it tone and vigor and rounding it out in glorious perfection as the Christian submits in obedience, without which the Master is not honored and the soul is not saved.ST Nov 25, 1886 The command to be born again meets a great human need and is spoken not to Nicodemus alone but to the world, and as the subject is studied the need appears more strongly, while the message repeated time after time with increasing power and clearness reclaims sinners.ST Jul 7, 1909 By nature people are in sin and misery and spiritually dead, unable to love or obey God or restore themselves to life, and they must pass into a state of grace through birth of the Holy Spirit to become children of God and heirs of heaven.ST Jan 20, 1887 Being born again means turning from the wrong use of self to the right use, changing direction, using moral senses rightly, recognizing a higher standard for body, mind and soul, and returning from wandering and peril to the care of the shepherd of the soul.ST Jul 17, 1884 It begins a new life entirely different from the old, with Christ in the heart, coming not by imitating Christ or through human effort but as the heart is surrendered to Christ who fills and shapes the life.ST Mar 17, 1914 Failure to have experienced this birth leaves even workers for God unable to see the kingdom's principles, treating one outside their group as a rival while thinking they defend the Lord's honor.RH Feb 5, 1914
Christian love and service need doctrine and fellowship with God in Christ as their source, so the gospel teaching must not be set aside in favor of practical ethics alone.RH Jun 2, 1903
Sources