John 7:4
For there is no man that doeth any thing in secret, and he himself seeketh to be known openly. If thou do these things, shew thyself to the world.
Translations
For there is no man that does any thing in secret, and he himself seeks to be known openly. If you do these things, show yourself to the world.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
For there is no man that doeth any thing in secret, and he himself seeketh to be known openly. If thou do these things, shew thyself to the world.
For there is no man that doeth any thing in secret, and he himself seeketh to be known openly. If thou doest these things, show thyself to the world.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
For no man doeth anything in secret, and himself seeketh to be known openly. If thou doest these things, manifest thyself to the world.
for no one in secret doth anything, and himself seeketh to be in public; if thou dost these things — manifest thyself to the world;'
for no one does anything in secret and himself seeks to be [ known] in public. If thou doest these things, manifest thyself to the world:
For, no one, anything in secret, doeth, and yet is seeking, himself, to be well-known. If, these things, thou art doing, manifest thyself unto the world.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
For no one who wants to be known publicly acts in secret. Since You are doing these things, show Yourself to the world.”
For no one does anything in secret while he seeks to be known openly. If you do these things, reveal yourself to the world.”
Because no man does things secretly if he has a desire that men may have knowledge of him. If you do these things, let yourself be seen by all men.
For there is no man that doeth any thing secretely, and hee himselfe seeketh to be famous. If thou doest these things, shewe thy selfe to the worlde.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
For there is no man that doth any thing in secret, and he himself seeketh to be known openly. If thou do these things, manifest thyself to the world.
Cross-references
- John 7:10
But when his brethren were gone up, then went he also up unto the feast, not openly, but as it were in secret.
Jesus later goes to the feast privately, as urged by circumstances.
- John 7:12-13
And there was much murmuring among the people concerning him: for some said, He is a good man: others said, Nay; but he deceiveth the people.
People disputed Jesus’ identity but feared speaking openly about him.
- John 12:12-19
On the next day much people that were come to the feast, when they heard that Jesus was coming to Jerusalem,
Jesus later entered Jerusalem publicly, as his brothers had urged.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
22 sources
The verse records the unbelieving brothers of Jesus urging Him to leave Galilee for Judea at the Feast of Tabernacles to display His works to His disciples and press His claims publicly before the rulers, on the reasoning that no one seeking to be known acts in secret.Ms 26, 1904, par. 1–2Ms 14, 1900, par. 30–34Ms 31, 1889, par. 41–44 Their conditional word expresses doubt whether He was the Messiah and the Sent of God, treating His mission as a bid for worldly fame and His reserve as weakness.ST Sep 23, 189711MR 291.2–4DA 447 Their counsel came from ambition and the world's expectation of display, looking for Him to win the rulers, demonstrate power in Jerusalem, and establish a temporal kingdom exalting Israel.ST Sep 23, 18972SP 235.1–2DA 447.1–2 He pitied their ignorance and blindness yet refused their timing and demand, and because opponents in Judea sought to kill Him He went later secretly and undistinguished so hostility would not prematurely interrupt His teaching work, though He was already making Himself known by speaking in the streets, healing the sick, and doing the miracles He came to do.Ms 14, 1900, par. 30–34Ms 31, 1889, par. 41–44Ms 186, 1907, par. 26–27Ms 21, 1909, par. 7 The verse exposes the demand for public miracles and signs as the price of faith as an excuse for unbelief, of the same taunting spirit as those who reviled Him on the cross to save Himself so they would believe, and closing the eyes to clear evidence while asking for miracles leads men to reject truth and be confirmed in deception by the counterfeit miracles Satan will present.Lt 4, 1889, par. 60–6211MR 291.2–4
Brothers' Unbelieving Challenge
The saying was spoken not by friends but by Jesus' own brothers, who did not believe in Him, urging Him to leave Galilee for Judea and Jerusalem at the Feast of Tabernacles to display His works to His disciples and show Himself to the world.Ms 26, 1904, par. 1–2Ms 14, 1900, par. 30–34Ms 31, 1889, par. 41–44DA 447 They pressed Him to make His claims as Messiah publicly and to press His rights before the rulers, on the reasoning that no one who seeks to be known acts in secret.Ms 26, 1904, par. 1–2Ms 14, 1900, par. 30–34Ms 31, 1889, par. 41–442SP 235.1–2LC1 83.2 Their challenge reflected unbelief and failure to understand or reverence His divine mission.Ms 26, 1904, par. 1–2Ms 14, 1900, par. 30–34Ms 31, 1889, par. 41–44
The little word if in their speech carries doubt and unbelief, questioning whether He was the Messiah and the Sent of God.ST Sep 23, 189711MR 291.2–4DA 449.2–450.2 They treated His mission as a bid for worldly fame and His reserve as cowardice or weakness.ST Sep 23, 1897DA 447DA 449.2–450.2 What His works revealed about Him as the One sent by God did not produce faith in them.ST Sep 23, 1897DA 449.2–450.2
Their counsel came from ambition and worldly desire for display, expressing the world's expectation that one seeking recognition should act openly.ST Sep 23, 1897DA 447.1–2DA 449.2–450.2 They assumed the Messiah should demonstrate power in Jerusalem, win the support of the rulers, and establish a temporal and political kingdom that would exalt Israel.ST Sep 23, 18972SP 235.1–2DA 449.2–450.2ST May 3, 1877 Because He did not openly establish the kingdom they expected, they were disappointed and rejected Him.2SP 235.1–24RED 80.2ST May 3, 1877
They judged Him by human standards, from ignorance and blindness, failing to understand His divine mission, purpose, and the authority behind His words.Ms 26, 1904, par. 1–2Ms 14, 1900, par. 30–34DA 326.1–3 Their urging was contemptuous and ironic, pressuring Him to act according to their ideas and to live like them.Ms 14, 1900, par. 30–34Ms 31, 1889, par. 41–44Ms 2, 1896, par. 8–9 That pressure showed misunderstanding and lack of appreciation rather than reverence.Ms 26, 1904, par. 1–2DA 326.1–3Ms 2, 1896, par. 8–9
Their unbelieving rejection grieved Him and was especially painful because it came from His own.Ms 14, 1900, par. 30–34Ms 186, 1907, par. 26–27 Yet He pitied them and answered without sarcasm, refusing to answer in kind.Ms 14, 1900, par. 30–34Ms 31, 1889, par. 41–44 He refused their timing and demand and would not go openly even with members of His own family, because it was not safe, since opponents in Judea could recognize Him and sought to deprive Him of liberty and kill Him.Ms 31, 1889, par. 41–44Ms 186, 1907, par. 26–27Ms 191, 1907, par. 25–26 He went later secretly and undistinguished in the crowd so He could teach, waiting for the appointed time so that danger and hostility would not prematurely interrupt His work.Ms 186, 1907, par. 26–271RED 83.2–3Lt 191, 1900, par. 9
Demanding Signs and Faithful Witness
Christ was already making Himself known, but in a way His brothers did not recognize, by speaking to people in the streets, healing the sick, and continuing to work miracles, which were the very work He came into the world to do.Ms 21, 1909, par. 7 His brothers wanted Him to leave Galilee for Judea and Jerusalem so His disciples could see His works and He could display Himself publicly to the world.Ms 21, 1909, par. 7
Demanding public miracles and signs as the price of faith is exposed as an excuse for unbelief, recalling the taunts directed at Jesus.Lt 4, 1889, par. 60–6211MR 291.2–4 It is the same taunting spirit as those who reviled Him on the cross to save Himself and come down so they would believe, and as those now who refuse the light God sends and demand a miracle and healing of the sick if the messengers have truth.Lt 4, 1889, par. 60–62 Such speech does not come from the Lord, those who utter it do not know what spirit they are of, but are encircled by exulting evil angels deceiving them.Lt 4, 1889, par. 60–62 Their reasoning that no one seeking to be known acts in secret treats public display as the test of His claims.11MR 291.2–4
Closing the eyes to clear evidence while asking for miracles leads men to reject evident truth, believe foolish error, take false positions under Satan, and be confirmed in deception by the counterfeit miracles Satan will soon present to all who seek that kind of evidence.Lt 4, 1889, par. 60–62
His example contrasts pressure to conform with faithfulness to Scripture, for He did not act to satisfy the demand for public attention or do wrong or depart from Scripture.Lt 191, 1900, par. 9Ms 2, 1896, par. 8–9 He sometimes went privately and left places where interest or hostility could provoke an outbreak after giving instruction and warning, so a mob would not prematurely interrupt His work before its appointed time.Lt 191, 1900, par. 9 His brothers misunderstood and did not appreciate Him, yet pressed Him to act and live like them.Ms 2, 1896, par. 8–9
The warning is not to imperil the cause of God and personal influence by perverted ideas, but to follow God and heed His counsel and believe in His only begotten Son for everlasting life so that He will continue to work with the believer.Lt 73, 1900, par. 1 Christ's followers are to show His character in their daily lives.STGC 49.1–2 Love for one another is the mark that they are not of the world, and when Christ dwells in the heart His joy is theirs, putting an end to backbiting and criticism and leading believers to strengthen rather than weaken one another's hands.STGC 49.1–2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
15 sources
His own literal brothers, who did not believe He was the Messiah and Sent of God, urged Him to leave Galilee for Judea and Jerusalem at the feast to display His works openly before His disciples and the crowds.ST Oct 15, 1896ST Nov 3, 1881ST Feb 25, 1897 Their challenge was a taunt rather than faith, for their if questioned whether He was who He claimed to be and treated His unwillingness to make a public show as cowardice and weakness.ST Sep 23, 1897RH Sep 9, 1902ST Oct 15, 1896 Their counsel reasoned from a worldly point of view, assuming that anyone doing such works must want public recognition, power and glory, and it reflected disappointment that He did not set up the political kingdom they expected.ST Sep 23, 1897ST May 3, 1877RH May 4, 1911RH Sep 17, 1903 He did not accept their demand or go up openly with them, but went later in private, avoiding a popular movement and premature exposure to those in Judea who sought to kill Him because His appointed time for death had not yet come.ST Nov 3, 1881ST Feb 26, 1894 In this their treatment of Him as a stranger fulfilled the prophecy that Messiah would be estranged from His brethren, while His course showed He was carrying out His Father's work rather than seeking glory and was not governed by the world's expectations.RH Sep 9, 1902RH May 4, 1911RH Sep 17, 1903
Context and Wording
The saying belongs to the Feast of Tabernacles, one of the three annual feast days appointed by God. It was one of the lesser festivals of the seventh month, coming five days after the Day of Atonement.RH Dec 10, 1861 It falls in the last six months before the crucifixion, when Jesus lived in the shadow of the cross with His heart resting on the prophecies and promises of the Old Testament.ST Feb 15, 1883
The brethren who spoke it were Christ's literal brothers, distinct from His disciples.ST Feb 25, 1897 Even if they were sons of Joseph by a former marriage, they are still to be reckoned as His brothers.ST Feb 25, 1897
They urged Him to leave Galilee for Judea and to Jerusalem at the feast, that His disciples might see His works.ST Oct 15, 1896ST Nov 3, 1881 They wanted Him to display His works publicly before a large audience at Jerusalem so His claims would be judged.ST Nov 3, 1881ST Oct 15, 1896 Their argument was that no one who does such things and seeks to be known openly acts in secret, but shows himself to the world.ST Oct 15, 1896ST Oct 15, 1896ST Oct 15, 1896 They contrasted such open display with remaining in villages and solitary places and in quiet places.ST Oct 15, 1896ST Oct 15, 1896 Their tone in giving such direction and control suggests they felt He needed it, which supports the view that they were older than He was.ST Jun 20, 1911
He did not accept their demand or join their journey openly.ST Nov 3, 1881 He waited and went up later in private. In doing so He avoided a crowd and a popular movement that could have brought His death before its appointed time. He would not expose Himself prematurely to the hostility of those in Judea who wanted to kill Him, because His appointed time for death had not yet come.ST Nov 3, 1881ST Feb 26, 1894RH May 4, 1911
In this setting He instructed hearers by reasoning with them from the Scriptures and then calling on them to judge and decide with regard to the truth.RH Aug 9, 1864 Reason and judgment were not laid aside but were used and appealed to in order to persuade men to choose the truth.RH Aug 9, 1864 There He used the Old Testament to encourage and teach His disciples and to answer His opponents.ST Feb 15, 1883 By absolute reliance on its words in trial He proved that His teaching about the Old Testament came from His heart and deepest conviction.ST Feb 15, 1883
Unbelief and Motives
The urging to leave Galilee for Judea and put works on display before disciples and a large audience came from unbelief.ST Oct 15, 1896ST Oct 15, 1896 Even His own brothers did not believe in Him, did not believe He was the Messiah and the Sent of God, despite what His works revealed.ST Sep 23, 1897ST Oct 15, 1896ST Oct 15, 1896 Their challenge was a taunt and not an expression of faith.RH Sep 9, 1902ST Oct 15, 1896ST Oct 15, 1896 Their "if" expressed doubt, questioning whether He was the Messiah and treating His refusal to make a public show of Himself as cowardice or weakness.ST Sep 23, 1897
Their demand came from prejudice, failing to weigh that people in Judea wanted to kill Him and that the time for His death had not yet come.ST Feb 26, 1894 Their counsel reasoned from a worldly point of view and ignored His purpose and motive, so it could not explain His course of life.RH May 4, 1911RH Sep 17, 1903 It came from ambition and the worldly desire for display, assuming that anyone doing notable works wanted public recognition, power, and glory.ST Sep 23, 1897RH May 4, 1911
Their words reflected disappointment that He did not establish a political kingdom and reveal Himself as they expected the Messiah to do.ST Sep 23, 1897ST May 3, 1877 They wanted display and a temporal throne rather than His Father's work, while He was not seeking power or glory but carrying out His Father's work and not exposing Himself to danger before the appointed time.ST Sep 23, 1897RH May 4, 1911
Prophecy and Example
The challenge to stop working in secret and to show himself openly to the world by going to Judea proves unbelief on the part of his own brothers.RH Sep 9, 1902 In withholding congenial fellowship and support from his work and in treating him as a stranger and an alien to them, they fulfilled the prophecy that Messiah would become a stranger to his brethren.RH Sep 9, 1902
Their taunt assumed that anyone doing notable works wanted public recognition and urged open display, yet it ignored his purpose and motive.RH May 4, 1911RH Sep 17, 1903 He was not seeking power or glory but carrying out his Father's work, and therefore did not expose himself to danger before the appointed time.RH May 4, 1911 His course of life could not be explained by reasoning from a worldly point of view and was not governed by the world's expectations, so he did not follow their advice.RH May 4, 1911RH Sep 17, 1903
Sources